Tuesday, April 26, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 6 (04/26)

So, Anwar is gone. I was not really broken up about it. I liked Anwar, but he really peaked too early. He’d been really average for quite awhile now.

Tonight’s theme: any song from the turn of the millennium on (or basically the last 5 years). Could be a dangerous theme, as anything goes tonight, as long as it’s recent.

Because there are only 6 left, they take some time to do some bios in the towns that the prospective Idols grew up in.

01 – Carrie (Checotah, OK), some Martina McBride song
Small town in Oklahoma that only has one stop light. Real country feel for her tonight, in the song and outfit. Still had the sway going. Straight hair. Kinda shaky at the start, but I’m not too familiar with the song so I don’t know if she changed it up or made it her own. Carrie’s been kinda shaky the last few weeks. I wouldn’t be surprised to see her in the bottom 3 tomorrow night. Randy said that he was glad to see her return to her (country) roots but he said her performance was pitch-wise under the whole song. Paula said the song threw away her vocals, but celebrated her style. Simon chose not to comment on the performance (probably because he thought it wasn’t good), but chose to say that he doesn’t understand country music (he’s from England), but thinks Carrie’s fans will still love her.

02 – Bo (Helena, AL), I Don’t Wanna Be (Gavin DeGraw)
Bo has his own house in Alabama and they interviewed his girlfriend, who has hair about the same length as his. He dressed like Lenny Kravitz, complete with a loud skateboarder pull over and those bad Lenny shades. But I’m not complaining, I loved this song, which is the theme song for one of my current favorite shows, “One Tree Hill.” (You expected a long, tedious tangent on One Tree Hill here right? Well, I’ll spare you this time :)) Bo really knows how to perform and really does a number on that mic stand. Great performance tonight. Before the performance there was a Clay Aiken sighting in the crowd. First time he’s been in the audience. And he now has a debit card with his picture on it. Jim Rome went on for a whole segment on how manly it would be to have a Clay Aiken debit card. They should give those out as a hazing ritual when rushing a fraternity house. Randy called him an honest and true rock star. Paula said the song totally describes him. Simon said his confidence was back but the only downside was wearing the bad Lenny Kravitz sunglasses (what about the whole outfit?). When I saw the outfit I expected him to sing that Lenny Kravitz jam that is the theme song for Alias. Man, I almost forgot to mention how hot Bo’s mom is. Looks like a cross between Bo Derek and Rebecca DeMornay.

03 – Vonzell (Fort Myers, FL), Turn To You (Christina Aguilera)
You may remember that Vonzell was a mail carrier in Florida, but they also showed her doing some karate and breaking a board. This was a tough song and I thought that she had a rough start. She hit the big notes, but overall I thought that she was out of key quite a bit. And at the end it looked like she forgot the words and only sang the chorus. But maybe that was how it was supposed to be. We found out after the performance that she doesn’t talk on Tuesdays. She only writes notes when responding to someone. Quirky, but I like that. Like a pitcher who won’t wash his uniform if he’s on a winning streak. I really think Vonzell is pretty; like a young, pre-crack, pre-Bobby Brown Whitney Houston. After watching it back with my wife, she didn’t think Vonzell was out of key, but just didn’t project her voice at the beginning. Randy called it a difficult song to sing, but she SANG it. And he welcomed her to the Dawg Pound. What a thrill for her. Paula said she nailed the song and that she connects with the audience. That she projects a magic before she hits the bridge. Something metaphysical like that. Simon called her flat at the beginning. I’m hoping that Vonzell is gaining some support because she can sang.

04 – Anthony (Trevose, PA), I Surrender (Celine Dion)
As you know, he’s from the Ukraine and his parents played a tape of the first time that he sang, when he was like 1 ½. Brought tears to their eyes because of the tracheotomy thing. Anthony really looked foreign in his childhood pics, but not so much anymore. He wore a nice pinstripe suit tonight. It was definitely his best performance to date. It’s what my wife expected from him from the beginning of the show. Then we found out that he’s been wanting to sing this Celine Dion song for weeks now. I don’t know what to think about that. A guy wanting to sing a Celine Dion song. Because he knows the words, we’re wondering if that has something to do with his comfort level on stage. He must be a slow learner of songs because when he has to sing a song that he’s not familiar with, he seems to struggle and seem out of his element. He was very much in control of his performance tonight. I’ll go out on a limb and say he was in the top 3 tonight. Forgot to mention that Anthony was introduced by Ava, the daughter of Heather Locklear. Heather Locklear is pretty hot still, although I’ve heard that she’s about as smart as a box of rocks (which is funny because there were a few signs for Bo saying “Bo Rocks My Socks” or “Bo Rox My Sox”). When I was growing up there were 2 Heathers, Heather Locklear and Heather Thomas. One was on TJ Hooker and the other was on the Fall Guy. Can’t remember which was which, but I do remember that Heather Thomas had that poster of her in the pink bikini. Donald Hiura had that poster up in his room. His older brothers had the Farrah Fawcett brown bikini poster up in their room. Back to the judges. Randy said that it started a little rough for him but he hit the high notes. Paula said his vocals built up with the song and it was his best performance. Simon called him a very brave man (presumably for singing a chick’s song) then did his “Simon thing” of degrading him, then complimenting him. He said he hated it personally, but he nailed it for his fans. Very Simon-ish. As funny as it sounds, this may have been Anthony’s best performance and she still may be gone tomorrow night.

05 – Constantine (New York, NY), You Remind Me (Nickelback)
Found out he was born in Brookyn to a very Greek Orthodox family. Mother is Constance (hence his name?). Brother Athan. I mistook his brother who has been in the audience for his father. He’s scary looking nonetheless. One of my good friends (Billy Mellis) is Greek and when I was in Chicago his older brother Foti was working at Northwestern in the athletic department and he would take me around to some of his Greek get togethers. The Greeks are like the Japanese in many ways. Very strong sense of family. Strong community ties to the church and festivals. I tagged along to a few of the church festivals around Chicago that first summer. One thing that still bugs me to this day was that there was this set of sisters that all the Greek guys liked. I actually didn’t think they were that hot, but whatever. I met them a few different times and every time they would say “it’s so nice to meet you.” What bugged me was that they had met me like 3 or 4 different times. Now I don’t want to sound arrogant like I’m some memorable guy that you wouldn’t forget, but I was the only Asian guy at those things. The only one. Among Greek people eating dolmas, gyros and drinking Ouzo. And another thing about the Greeks. I love it how they always name the first children after the grandparents. There was one family in Watsonville that had like 5 Annas and 3 Georges. They had to be known as 8th grade Anna and 5th grade Anna, etc. Back to Constantine. My wife yelled “stop looking at the camera” once during the song. And he gave his patented camera kicks (twice!). This song was putrid. He was all over the place vocally. It was like he didn’t commit 100% to this song and was just trying to be positive during it and did all kinds of extracurricular stuff, but really just wanted it to be over. He had all kinds of false hype and over amped the song totally. I’m not a fan of his and this song did nothing to bring me to his side. Randy said he was high on the performance, but low on the vocals. Paula said it wasn’t her favorite song, but he makes it through each genre without any difficulty. Simon called it a very bad imitation of the original. And said that going back to the rocker didn’t feel real. Maybe he isn’t a rocker, but just a cheesy lounge singer. He should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow, but mark my words, he won’t be.

06 – Scott (Shaker Heights, OH), Dance With My Father Again (Luther Vandross)
Boy, his bio was difficult to watch. They were trying to sell you on his “average Joe,” “thought he was going to be a priest” appeal. Scottie wore a huge grey pinstripe blazer with six (6) buttons. That’s a big coat. Okay. I don’t get this song. Tamyra Gray sang this a few years back and it was perfect. Can someone tell me how it is that Luther sings this song? Isn’t it a song meant to be sung by a woman? Am I deaf? Aren’t the words about dancing with her father? Does anyone else have a problem with a guy singing this song? Scott was very pitchy on this song. It was only 5 or 6 notes, but they were big ones. Randy called it his weakest performance in weeks. Paula said the song didn’t do him justice. Simon just said to pack his suitcase. Scott should be in the bottom 3 and out tomorrow night, but stranger things have happened.

Has anyone heard what’s going on with Paula? I saw the cover of People (but didn’t read the article) and it mentioned her surgeries, her pain, her grief. And then the story came out that she had a romantic relationship with Corey Clark, the dude from a few years back that was kicked off the show because he beat up his sister and assaulted some cops in the process. I hated that guy. He sang in a falsetto so high that it was like he got kicked in the nuts right before he went on stage. Supposedly she told him to keep their relationship quiet and in return she’d fund his singing career. Anyway, don’t know what is true or not, but she’s definitely an interesting one right now. I hope the article explains why she claps like she does…

Top 3 tonight: Bo, Vonzell, Anthony

Bottom 3 tomorrow: Scott, Constantine, Carrie, but Vonzell or Anthony could easily be there too.

Tuesday, April 19, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 7 (04/19)

So a little clean up on last week. Okay, Kate Beckinsale was the lead opposite Ben Affleck in “Pearl Harbor.” Jennifer Garner was in the movie, but in a lesser role. Never saw the movie. Don’t know if I will. Tough movie to see, as the event had quite a negative impact on the Japanese, not to mention the Americans of Japanese decent.

If you’ve watched American Idol live, you no doubt have seen those awful Old Navy Tunic commercials. They slay me. That white girl is working SO hard to keep up. It’s flowing so naturally to the other two, but she’s like counting steps and forcing movements. She’s like Vanilla Ice trying to keep up with the brothas in “Ice Ice Baby.” Word to your mutha.

So the theme tonight is “’70s Dance Numbers.” And promises to be the most energetic of all the AIs. With the dance-ability of the remaining competitors, I’m not holding my breath.

01 – Constantine, Nights on Broadway (The Bee Gees)
Nice ‘70s outfit. Black shirt with black pants under a white blazer. But wore some eye shadow and that was a tad frightening. Kinda looked like Ozzy Osbourne. Did the Bo “use the whole mic stand” during the performance. I’ll give Constantine this. He’s a very good vocalist. And I think that he’s going to win. Or at least be in the final 2. Like Fantasia last year, I will not vote for Constantine because he’s got plenty of fans to vote him through every week. And when they flash on his family, is it me or does his dad look like the lead singer from Talking Heads? Or the dad from “That ‘70s Show?” Randy said it was a good song choice, but it was “a’ight,” but not “oh my god.” Paula retorted with “everything about you for the last 3 weeks has been oh my god.” Right song. Right theatrics. Great stage presence. I’m going out on a limb here, but I think Paula likes Constantine. Simon likened him to a singing waiter in Spain. Okay. Let’s move on.

02 – Carrie, MacArthur Park (Donna Summer)
Big hair again for Carrie tonight. Along with some eyeshadow along the lines of Constantine’s. Wore a pink dress with flowers on it that reminded me of a bad bridesmaid dress. You know, from the wedding with the insecure bride that has to put her bridesmaids in hideous rags so that all the attention will be on her. Not familiar with the song, but Carrie has such a strong voice. She does do the “Carrie Sway” most every week though. A bit boring in her stage presence, but you can’t deny that voice. Randy said it was official: welcome to the Dawg Pound. Called her vocals unbelievable. Paula said “wow” on that last note. Quipped that Simon turned 53 while she held that note. Simon said she sang it very well, but called her “Barbie meets the Stepford Wives.” Said she’s too young to dress that old. Leave that to Paula. Touche. Simon should talk. He looked like he was wearing a grey Nike Dri-Fit shirt. Like the ones that the trainers wear at 24-Hour Fitness.

03 – Scott, Everlasting Love (Carl Carlton)
Don’t have much to say about Scott really. Sang it pretty well. He definitely looks “softer” with glasses. Although I liked the tinted ones better because it hid his eyes more. Got a comment from a guy (not naming names as to protect his identity) who watches the show that Scott looks like Barrett Robbins. I know some of you won’t know who that is, but he’s the former Raiders center who went AWOL on the eve of the Super Bowl and was recently shot by the police. Randy said he picked just the right song that fit his voice. Paula said he had fun with it and was on pitch for the most part. Simon called him an ordinary guy doing quite well, but equates his performances to karaoke. He’s got no love for Scott. I think Scott’s in trouble this week. He’ll probably be in the bottom 3 every week now until he gets eliminated.

04 – Anthony, Don’t Take Away The Music (Tavares)
Wore a brown shirt with the cuffs unbuttoned. Almost like he’s trying to dress like Ryan Seacrest. Anthony, I know you don’t have much of a fashion sense, but to have Seacrest as your model is not a good move. At least the brown didn’t make him look as pale as when he wore that lime green a few weeks back. He really reminds me of a huskier Clay Aiken. I’m really not a fan of Anthony’s voice anymore. And he dances way too much up there. But he has looked more confident up there lately. Randy started with “So dude…” but said that he didn’t fall his week. Paula called it soothing and in the right range. Simon called it pleasant and safe. I wasn’t too impressed. I think he’ll be in the bottom 3.

05 – Vonzell, I’m Every Woman (Chaka Khan)
Boy does she have a big voice. She needs one to match that booty. I’m a bit younger, so I remember this as a Whitney Houston-The Bodyguard song. Vonzell does Whitney well. Didn’t dance too much tonight, which is a good thing. She reminds my wife of a younger version of the mother on “Fresh Prince.” The first one though, not the second one. Isn’t that funny how shows change characters on you (mostly because of contractual issues) and the go on like nothing happened? Like when the oldest daughter on “Roseanne” was changed? But then she came back. The replacement daughter is now on “Scrubs.” I love that show, but my wife hates it. Don’t blame her. It’s sophomoric humor, at best. Vonzell’s hair tonight looked something Eva Longoria’s character (Gabrielle) from “Desperate Housewives” would wear. I have to tell you, I love that show, but didn’t watch it from the get go because of that title. It seemed like it would be over the top, tongue in cheek. If they’d have named it something else, I probably would’ve watched it earlier. How can you turn down Teri Hatcher, Eva Longoria and Felicity Huffman? Although they make Felicity Huffman’s character look so frazzled at times (well, she does have 4 boys). She was a main character in “Sports Night” one of my favorite shows of all time. It only ran 2 seasons and I never watched it live (probably part of the reason it got cancelled) but I saw it in its (I think I got that one grammatically correct) entirety on ReplayTV (via Comedy Central) and now own it on DVD. Great show. Back to Vonzell. She was wonderful tonight. She really can sing, but I think she lacks a following. Final four is the best case scenario for her. She will get a recording deal though. Randy said she chose the song with the highest degree of difficulty, but worked it out. Paula stood up and danced to the entire song. Said she rocked the house. Simon called her right on the edge vocally, but her personality would push her over the top to make it work.

06 – Anwar, September (Earth, Wind and Fire)
I have to preface this by saying EWF is my wife’s favorite group. We saw them in concert in Chicago at the United Center with Barry White. That was a great time. Anwar had on a black velvet jacket along with his patented bell bottoms. Crowd was really into from the start. Sang it okay, but I thought it really had a wedding singer feel to it. And I like Anwar. Randy said it was another good Anwar performance and praised his energy at the end. Paula said he had fun with it and was in the moment. Simon called the ending good but then I got called away by Jared (we didn’t let him stay up tonight and he had trouble getting to sleep) and couldn’t hear the rest of his comments. I think Anwar could be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

07 – Bo, Vehicle (The Ides of March)
Was this really considered a “dance” song? It was more like background music for a ‘70s show. Or a contemporary movie that is a movie about a ‘70s show, like “Starsky and Hutch” or “Charlie’s Angels.” The thing that I like about Bo is his attitude. Last week when Seacrest asked him how it would be if he was gone, he didn’t really care. His reply was, “what’s the worst thing that happens? I go back home and play gigs again? Which is what I love to do.” For that, I like Bo. Randy said Bo Bice is back. Paula said the competition is back on. Simon called it his only authentically good performance. I thought it was good. But whatever.

I think the bottom 3 tomorrow should be Scott, Anthony and Anwar. I think it has the possibility of being Scott, Anthony and Vonzell or Bo.

Tuesday, April 12, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 8 (04/12)

So, Nikko’s gone. I’m disappointed, but not heartbroken. Poor Nikko never had a strong following. Being voted off before the finals showed that. I don’t think that he was going to win it all, but I wish that he could’ve stayed around to sing a few more songs. How Anthony and Scott avoided being booted I’ll never know. Anthony not even being in the bottom 3 was a crime too.

This week’s theme was a song from the year that the contestant was born. Interesting. I guess they’re running out of ideas. Maybe next week they’ll play the Name Game. You know, the singer’s first name has to start with the same initial as the contestant’s last name. Wouldn’t that be clever? Not.

A little fashion police for the judges. Randy was wearing a light blue shirt that looked like a faux police uniform, a la Dennis Rodman. Or Olden Polynice, former NBAer, who was busted for impersonating a cop. Olden Polynice was responsible for some of the Bulls championships, as it was he that was traded for Scottie Pippen in that 1987 draft, which also brought Horace Grant and BJ Armstrong to the Bulls. Paula wore a sparkly top that was black on one side, but then also red, green and yellow on the other. She looked like the flag for (formerly) East Germany. Simon wore a powder blue, tight top that showed his man boobs, again. Don’t remember what Seacrest wore, as I try to erase him from my memory immediately, if not sooner.

01 – Nadia (’77), When I Dream (Mac Davis)
The BIG hair was back. Much better all up like Freddie from “A Different World” than that mohawk a few weeks back. Wore a red top and short skirt. Very Ally McBeal-ish. Speaking of Ally McBeal, has anyone seen that new show “Grey’s Anatomy?” Great show. Main character, Meredith Grey is very Ally McBeal, but in surgical scrubs. Played by Ellen Pompeo, who was Luke Wilson’s love interest in that classic “Old School.” She looks like she could be sisters with Christina Applegate and Paula Devicq (Kirsten on Party of Five). The show centers around four first-year surgical interns at a hospital in Seattle. Sandra Oh (Sideways, Arli$$) and Katherine Heigl (My Father the Hero, Roswell) are two of the other characters. Patrick Dempsey plays her semi-love interest. Funny thing about Patrick Dempsey. You may remember him as Ronald Miller in “Can’t Buy Me Love.” In real life, to quote the movie, “he went from totally geek to totally sheik.” He also played the goofy kid in “Loverboy” and now he’s the hunk in “Grey’s Anatomy” and also played Reese Witherspoon’s jilted lover in “Sweet Home Alabama.” I think the other attending surgeon was the guy who Renee Raddick (Ally McBeal’s roommate, until she went nuts in real life and was inexplicably dropped from the show) put in the hospital when she was defending herself from his advances on a date. Anyway, back to Nadia. She doesn’t have the greatest voice, but has good stage presence. Randy didn’t even know what song it was. Okay performance, but it was rough pitch-wise for him. Paula said she looked outrageously stunning. Simon called her the equivalent of “musical wallpaper.” Basically it was a performance that you wouldn’t remember. He thought the song choice was appalling. She could be on the bubble tomorrow night.

02 – Bo Bice (’75), Freebird (Lynyrd Skynyrd)
Bo did the whole “carry the mic stand during the performance” thing again. Song started really slow at the beginning. Almost put me to sleep. I was really getting disinterested, but then he ended it well. We let Jared stay up tonight to watch and he said that the liked that song. Oh no, I’m raising a rocker son! June, stay away from my son. I don’t need him going to Def Leppard and Whitesnake concerts when they’re in their 70s and still touring. Unless, of course, his Auntie June will accompany him with Jake Ryan… Randy said that he loved that song and that it was excellent. Paula said “see you at the finals.” I think that’s jumping the gun a bit. Simon disagreed with them. Couldn’t hear what else he said, but I really think that Constantine has surpassed him as the token rocker in the group. Bo hasn’t done it for me in the last few weeks and that “gendre” comment last week was disappointing. I don’t think he’ll be in the bottom 3 tomorrow, but his time will come.

03 - Anwar Robinson (’79), I’ll Never Love This Way Again (Dionne Warwick)
Okay, I’ve got this nitpicky thing about Anwar. After you hear it, you’ll think that I’m weird for noticing this. But then you’ll catch yourself looking. So here’s the deal. I used to think that Anwar had a funny eye. You know, a wandering eye. But then I finally realized that his eyes are so slanted at the edges that you can’t see the whites of his eyes (the whites closest to his ears). So it looks like his eyes are off-center. I don’t know if it’s because his pupils are too big or that his eye sockets are formed funny, but it really used to bug me. Actually it still bugs me, but not in a bad way. I’m just glad I figured it out. You know, if Anwar was in the Revolutionary War, he’d have never been fired upon. Had his bell bottom jeans on again and a shirt open down to his naval, like he was on Miami Vice or something. I really thought his performance was good tonight. Randy gave him his props and said that he is the best technical singer. Paula called him consistently pleasing to the ear. Simon called it one of his better performances in awhile. Although he’s not my favorite to win anymore, I think that he should make the final 4.

04 – Anthony Fedorov (’85), Every Time You Go Away (Paul Young)
Finally a song from the ‘80s and it has to be this one? They flashed on Hall and Oates in the crowd and said that Scott would be singing one of their songs later in the show. Is it me or does Darryl Hall look like Dennis Leary? Has anyone seen them in the same room together? And how goofy does John Oates look without his mustache? They had that Rock ‘n’ Soul, Part I, but they never had a Part II. I think that it’s very presumptuous to have a part I. You just don’t call your shot that there will be a 2 or a sequel like that. It’s like the forces of the universe came together to punish them to not come out with a part II. Like the Mel Brooks movie “History of the World, Part I.” There were actually previews for Part II (Hitler on Ice!), but the movie was never made. The way to do it is call it “Rock ‘n’ Soul” and IF you have a second one, call it “Rock ‘n’ Soul, Part II.” Take for example the Scream trilogy. Kevin Williamson knew that he wanted to make 3 movies, but he didn’t call the first one Scream 1. I can appreciate subtleties like that. Back to Anthony. I felt like the music was kinda drowning him out at times. And he was dancing around, but it wasn’t working for me because the song is such a downer. Really didn’t compare to the original. However, the judges loved it. Randy said that he did his thing. Paula called him much better than last week, which isn’t saying much, but then again, does Paula really say anything of substance? Ever? Simon thought that he was very good tonight. I still think that he should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. I’m basing it on cumulative performances.

05 – Vonzell Solomon (’84), Let’s Hear It For The Boy (Deniece Williams)
When I heard this song choice, I was thinking “oh no, there is going to be dancing.” And there was. This was my worst nightmare for Vonzell because I like her and I just don’t want to subject the voting public to her dancing again. I think that she can get away with this right now, but once Scott, Anthony and Nadia are gone, there will be no room for ill-advised “Elaine” dancing. That can definitely be a deal breaker. Vonzell wore a sparkly top (maybe she went shopping with Paula?) and a denim skirt that was a lot too tight. Poor girl couldn’t move in that thing. I was thinking how bad would it be for her to fall on her face when she was trying to navigate those stairs? Would that affect the voting? Randy called it another great performance. Paula called her such a bright light and that she was adorable up there. And noted that she even sang the song an octave higher than Deniece. Simon called it a very good choice of song. I honestly thought it was a safe choice. Didn’t really stretch her vocally, but I think she had fun with it. I’m hoping that Vonzell is safe tomorrow night.

06 – Scott Savol (’76), She’s Gone (Hall and Oates)
BIG denim shirt. How many denim trees did they have to cut down to make that shirt? Just kidding. I know that denim is a form of cotton. So, how many cotton fields did they have to pick to make that shirt and pants combo? I’m really not a fan of the “jeans on jeans” look, but if it works for you, you go. Kinda rough in the beginning. But Paula was standing during the song. I guess that since Nikko is gone, she has to give her standing O’s to someone else. Randy started with “so listen…” Nothing good ever comes after those 2 words with him. He said the low notes were rough, but the chorus was good. Paula called it nerve wracking (probably since Hall & Oates were in the audience) but he did awesome. Simon called him a nice guy, HOWEVER there were more bum notes than good notes and it was not good on the whole. I agree. Scottie the Body can go at any time now. I think he should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

07 – Carrie Underwood (’83), Love Is A Battlefield (Pat Benetar)
This song totally reminded me of “13 Going on 30” with Jennifer Garner. Man that movie was funny. I know that the whole “younger person in an older body” movie has been done ad nauseum, but I really don’t get tired of it. And I don’t get tired of Jennifer Garner either. Do you realize that she’s really come out of nowhere to where she is now? She played second or third fiddle to Jennifer Love Hewitt in “Time of Your Life” and played one of the twin sisters, along with Marla Sokoloff (you may remember her as Lynette’s nanny in “Desperate Housewives”), in the epic “Dude, Where’s My Car?” She gained some momentum starring opposite Ben Affleck in “Pearl Harbor,” but BAM she hit it big with “Alias.” The show is a cheap rip off of La Femme Nikita, but it’s still pretty good. And she’s good looking, but not so hot that she’s unattainable. I mean, she IS dating Ben Affleck. Maybe he got used to the nickname “Bennifer” and had to date another Jennifer. Garner is actually a bit boyish, in a soccer girl/Sporty Spice kind of way. Back to Carrie, who is not boyish in any way. I always worry about singing rock songs because there can always be the temptation to scream and shout instead of sing. It was a risky song, but she did okay with it. Straight hair and heavy mascara. I hope she’s okay tomorrow night. Randy said that it was pitchy a bit and that she messed up the words. Paula said she rocked it. Simon called her a kitten that wants to be like a tiger. She is still my favorite to win it all though. I don’t think that the talent is such that this performance will kill her. Because I said that, she’ll probably be in the bottom 3 tomorrow night.

08 – Constantine Maroulis (’75), Bohemian Rhapsody (Queen)
Vanessa Olivarez, who was the first finalist voted off in Season 2, sang this in her audition. And, of course, this song was made popular again with its inclusion in “Wayne’s World.” Although Constantine’s version didn’t quite resemble that one. He did a pretty good job with this. I’m still not a fan of his, but I think that he will make it to the final 2 now. Randy gave his showmanship a 10 and his singing a 7. Paula said that he is now the one to beat. Simon called it astounding. He really has improved and found his comfort zone in this competition. I’m not on his bandwagon, but I know plenty of people who are. I won’t name names, but she’s one of my wife’s sisters. Oh wait, she only has one sister. J Constantine will absolutely be safe tomorrow night.

So that’s it for tonight. I voted for Anwar, Vonzell and Carrie.

If you’re new to the recaps, you can view all of the previous ones at http://airecaps.blogspot.com

Tuesday, April 05, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 9 (04/05)

Jessica gone from last week. A little bit of a shocker, but not really. She didn’t perform all that well and I don’t think that she had the following to get her through a rough spot. Like last year, Jasmine had a few rough weeks, but her following got her through. If Jessica didn’t dazzle, she was vulnerable. And that showed last week.

More news from The Smoking Gun. This about Scott Savol’s past. (Sorry, took out the website because it made the page look funny). Kristin’s co-worker Bryan calls him Sling Blade.

On to tonight. Musicals! is the theme. I’m not a hard core musicals fan, but I did enjoy watching them growing up. Mostly musicals that were made into movies. Among my favorites, The Music Man, Guys and Dolls, Singin’ in the Rain, My Fair Lady and West Side Story. I recently saw “Miss Saigon” in Hawaii and it was a beautiful musical but it really bugged me that they sang all of their lines. I don’t mind a musical that has dialogue, then BOOM, someone breaks into a song. I’m cool with that because that’s what musicals are all about. But singing all the dialogue? I couldn’t get with that. At all. I was hoping that I’d hear a song from one of the movies that I mentioned above, but only West Side Story hit the radar. Then I got to thinking that a lot of the songs in musicals aren’t great songs. They are really simply dialogue put into song. So “Gee, Officer Krupke!” from West Side Story or “Rain in Spain” from My Fair Lady may not have really played all that well tonight.

Seacrest wearing a loud sweater over an untucked Oxford type shirt. Just looked plain sloppy. Randy’s wearing these shirts that have a mad collar. Three neck buttons and the buttons for the collar aren’t at the front/base of the neck like normal shirts. They are mid way up the enormous collar a few inches back. Hard to explain, but if you saw the shirt, you may understand what I’m talking about. Kind of a cool look, but I think you’ve got to have some girth to pull it off. Simon boring black shirt as usual and Paula was wearing a skull and crossbones ring. And she can’t clap. But we know this. June wonders if she gets a manicure before the show and has to clap that way? At least that would explain why she claps so retardedly.

01 – Scott Savol, The Impossible Dream (Man of La Mancha)
Scottie the Body. If you saw the story above, it may have affected his preparation for this week. Scott came out in a black four-button suit with a blue shirt underneath. Almost looked like he stole the look from Nikko. But it was like a 60 short. Scottie was flat tonight. Didn’t really do it for me. He’s missed notes before, but usually gave a pretty good performance. Not tonight. But, on the bright side, they did have some people in his “friends” section. Or at least they flashed the graphic over some random people in the audience. Either one will do. Randy called it a tough song. He was shaky but ended with a bang. Paula said that she likes it because he picks songs that fit his life. Simon called it ordinarily extraordinary. I think Scott is on the bubble tomorrow night.

02 – Constantine Maroulis, My Funny Valentine (Babes In Arms)
This really was Constantine’s week to shine. He’s really a Broadway, cabaret-type singer. Like that guy last year that Randy called a sheep in Rocker’s clothing. Rock is his front, but he’s really a showtune-type of guy. I think that Constantine has a good shot to win this thing because of his female following, but more than that, he’ll headline some shows after this. He really is a pretty good singer. I just can’t get past the preening to the camera. He’s like a fly: always gravitating to the red light of the camera. He constantly knows with camera is on him and broods into it. Nauseates me, but others love it. I guess. This song is interesting. I think it’s normally sung by a woman, which is odd because he also sang a Bonnie Raitt song last week. I remember this song from that forgettable movie “The Fabulous Baker Boys,” which starred brothers Beau and Jeff Bridges, along with the sultry Michelle Pfeiffer. Michelle sang this song in the movie and I actually had this soundtrack. I used to get soundtracks with scores on them because for the few times I actually dragged my butt down to the library in college, I would bring a Walkman and listen to music while I read. Listening to music without lyrics made it easier for me to concentrate on the material. Another great soundtrack that is only a score is “Hoosiers.” I don’t think they make in a CD, but I about wore out that tape! Back to Constantine. He’s got a great theatrical voice, although tonight his last note started very sour. He ended up saving it, but it’s such a stark contrast to the other singers, who usually start slow and shaky, then save the performance with a huge last note. Constantine reminds me of a young Montgomery Burns (from the Simpsons). “Smithers, sing this song for me…” Randy said that he’s really a showtune guy and doesn’t buy the rocker thing. Paula called it remarkable and said he was a role model for guys to get into musicals. Simon gave him a 7 for vocals and 9 ½ for pouting. Called it the best pouting performance ever on AI. That Simon is such a cut up. Constantine should be safe tomorrow night and I think that he may be in the final 4, if not the final 2 (not on merit, mind you, but based on his following).

03 – Carrie Underwood, Hello, Young Lovers (The King and I)
Carrie came out in a dress that looked like she was in “Peggy Sue Got Married.” She really needs a fashion consultant. If she had Nadia’s style, she’d be money. My wife thinks she has the strongest voice in the competition and thinks it’s her competition to lose. I really like Carrie and the song wasn’t great, but she sang it well. Randy was impressed because he didn’t like the song choice, but his mantra has always been, “sing the song that you’re given.” Or something like that. Said she was in control throughout the song. Paula called her simply stunning and that she gave an elegant performance. Called her vocals a well-oiled machine. Simon said she sang the song well but criticized her for being old fashioned. Which is a bit unfair because musicals are old fashioned. When was the last musical that was made into a movie? Well, besides “From Justin to Kelly” that is. This really was a hard theme night and hopefully your favorites will get through to do better on a better theme night.

04 – Vonzell Solomon, People (Funny Girl)
If Mikalah was still in the competition, would she have battled Vonzell for the rights to this song? I mean, it was from Babs. Vonzell has such a big voice. I think that she is in the top 3 girls left in the competition. Definitely top 3. Pretty girl. Can sing a ton. Just can’t dance. As long as she sings like she did the last few weeks, dancing shouldn’t be a problem. Randy said that she keeps getting better every week and that she was brilliant and a girl just may win this thing. Paula called it a bold song choice, but she sang it in the same key as Barbra and hit the high note that Babs even couldn’t hit. Simon called it good, but not great. Said it was clinical and cold. I think Simon had wax in his ears tonight. I hope that Vonzell makes it through. I think that she’ll be in the final 4, but won’t beat Carrie. And I was being facetious above because I know there are only 3 girls left. But she’s a solid #2 behind Carrie and miles ahead of Nadia.

05 – Anthony Fedorov, Climb Ev’ry Mountain (The Sound of Music)
I’m really done with Anthony. Good story. Nice kid. But I really hope he’s gone tomorrow night. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not even remotely close to the outrage and frustration that I felt last year when JPL and Finchy were still in the competition. I think Anthony is confused right now because he’s trying to change things up, but it’s not working for him. His wardrobe is atrocious. Tonight he came out in white pants and a light blue shirt that looked like he was dressed by Ryan Seacrest. And vocally he was flat tonight. I know that Anthony has quite a following so he may be okay tomorrow. Randy said he didn’t like it at all. He was sharp and flat all through the song. Paula said it was interesting and she liked how he changed the song up. Simon called it hideous. I really think that Anthony and Scott should be in the bottom 2 tomorrow night, but stranger things have happened.

06 – Nikko Smith, One Hand, One Heart (West Side Story)
This song is especially special to me and Kristin because her father sang this song for us at our wedding. Not exactly the way Nikko sang it tonight, but it was memorable for us nonetheless. Nikko is a dapper guy. Really can dress the part. Black pants and vest tonight with a brown polka dot tie. Black fedora with a brown band. He’s really got a cool sense of style. Did a real good job with this song. My wife said he “Brian McKnight-ed” the song, as he does with all his songs. I like it. He’s winning me over. I’m really glad now that he’s back in the competition and forget Mario. I mean, who’s Mario anyway? Has he faded into the distance yet? I was once worried that Nikko doesn’t have a following, but I think that people are jumping on his bandwagon now. I have. Randy loves it because he keeps it contemporary. Paula calls him the Comeback Kid and loves that he brings an R&B flair to the competition. Simon said that he hits the big notes at the end of each song, but called the first part out of tune. I hope Nikko is safe tomorrow night.

07 – Anwar Robinson, If Ever I Would Leave You (Camelot)
Finally the old Anwar that we liked. He really has been shaky the last few weeks. Actually he hasn’t sung well since the semi-finals. He had his confidence back tonight. Long jacket, again. Scarf, again. Pretty good performance. Randy said welcome back. He’s one of the best singers and has one of the best voices. Paula called him the technically best singer and that his smile melts the audience. Simon said he seemed very comfortable up there. I think that Anwar should be good tomorrow night (after being in the bottom 2 last week). I think the final 4 should be Carrie, Vonzell, Bo or Constantine and Nikko or Anwar.

08 – Bo Bice, Corner of the Sky (Pippin)
This was an odd song choice for me. Couldn’t he have done “Pinball Wizard” from Tommy? Or something from Hair? Kristin had the call of the night when she referred to his shirt as a “fruit roll up.” On top of leather pants, mind you. Didn’t know the song. Thought he was okay. Randy said once again he was consistently great. Paula called him a winner. Simon said that he’s had 2 bad weeks and needs to pick himself up next week. I think Bo is safe, but that performance would put him in the bottom 3 tomorrow night.

09 – Nadia Turner, As Long As He Needs Me (Oliver!)
Nadia definitely had the most style in this competition. She looked very Diana Ross-ish in her long white dress tonight. Song matched her voice very well and she was very sultry tonight. I think they were rushing to get through because the judges comments were very short, although Simon got in that she was the strongest she’s been in weeks but asked to not have Ryan pick the themes anymore. She may be safe tomorrow night because she did give a pretty good performance, but she’s been in the bottom 3 for 2 weeks in a row now.

Overall, it was a tough theme night. Most of the kids had never heard the songs before they picked them. They’re all too young to even experience many of the musicals. Difficult, yes, but not really unfair. These theme nights are meant to have the cream rise to the top and do away with inferior competition. Although just because you can’t sing a certain theme shouldn’t preclude you from being an American Idol. That first year when they had the Big Band theme, Kelly Clarkson did swimmingly with it, but I don’t think that she’s releasing a Big Band CD anytime soon. I guess on difficult theme nights, you just hope to do well enough to make it to the next week and hope there’s a theme better suited for you.

Top 4 performances tonight: Carrie, Vonzell, Nikko, Anwar (I voted for those 4 tonight).

Bottom 3 performances: Scott, Anthony, Bo

I think it’s either Scott or Anthony tomorrow night. It’ll be interesting to see who the third of the bottom 3 is.