Tuesday, April 29, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 5 (04/29)

Neil Diamond week, which reminds me of that lame movie “Saving Silverman” that starred Jason Biggs (from the “American Pie” trilogy; yes, they made three of them), Jack Black, Steve Zahn (Lenny from “That Thing You Do!”) and Amanda Peet. The 3 guys play Neil Diamond fanatics and play in a cover band that only plays Neil Diamond covers. Lame movie because Jason Biggs will forever be known as the guy from “American Pie.”

01, 06 – Jason Castro, Forever in Blue Jeans & September Morn

So, someone on this list referred to Jason Castro as the “dumbest person in America.” It’s hard for me to argue with that. Well, his second song was better than his first, but that’s not saying much. He just doesn’t have that strong of a voice. He has a nice voice for certain types of songs, but overall he’s difficult to listen to. And his facial ticks are making him hard to watch too. Not exactly the best combo for a supposed American Idol. Randy didn’t dig his first one and called the second one just okay. Paula called both songs safe, but she totally flubbed the segment after the first round of songs. She commented on Jason’s second song even though he hadn’t even sung it yet. Paula is on something every week, be it alcohol or prescription medication and she really needs to be off this show. I think the show’s producers think that she means so much to the show and that it may not be as good without her. But this is the seventh season and although her name is what got it off the ground (honestly, who knew who Randy and Simon were?), if there was a smart, witty, intelligent woman that sat in between Randy and Simon and actually partook in some witty repartee with Simon, I think the show would be much, much better. Simon needs a foil to match his comments and Paula clearly isn’t it. Either she had comments that she needed to say that the producers gave her or she took notes from the rehearsal and just said those. Either way, it’s not that hard to comment on the 5 songs that were just sung. How confusing to a sane, sober person is it to do that? Simon hated his first song and said that the judges don’t recognize Jason anymore. He struggled through both songs. Jason should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow night and given his #1 spot, he may be gone tomorrow.

You know I can’t resist this (and most of you were probably thinking I’d lead with this), but I’m so happy that I don’t have to hear Carly Hennessy/Smithson sing and talk ever again. I did find someone who hates Carly more than I do. It’s hard to believe but that person exists out there. I also had someone comment to me that she thinks Carly “Irish-es up” her accent. I don’t know why I feel better that a person who doesn’t have to carry a green card is going to win, but I do. Seriously though, how do you feel if you’re Carly if you got voted off in a week where 2 people (Jason and Brooke) were complete train wrecks? Jason for his lame song and Brooke for starting again. That would tell me that I’m not very popular because people with “lesser” songs made it through on the fan votes.

02, 07 – David Cook, I’m Alive & All I Really Need Is You

David picked a few of the lesser known Diamond songs. He sped up the first one and really made the second one contemporary. The second one left my wife Kristin saying that she would download that song right now. I think David really knows how to make the songs work for him. He had an AC on his jacket and guitar and I’m assuming it’s for “Adam Cook,” which is his brother who is suffering from brain cancer. Kudos to both David and even Ryan Seacrest for not drawing unnecessary attention to it. Randy said he rocked the house. Paula said something scripted and Simon said the first song was okay, but the second one was brilliant. I see a finals of the two Davids with neither having a negligible advantage.

03, 08 – Brooke White, I’m A Believer & I Am I Said

I’m A Believer was a nightmare. Brooke’s not an upbeat song gal. She’s not a happy singer. Unless she did that song for the kids she used to nanny because they liked Shrek, I saw no merit in the first song. She looks like a fish out of water when she tries to dance to upbeat songs. The judges criticized David Cook for potentially being lost without his guitar, but Brooke would not be in the finals if she wasn’t able to play an instrument while she sang. I think the use of instruments is a good thing and a fortunate one for Brooke. Brooke’s second song was much better than the first, but that’s not saying much because the first one pretty much sucked. Randy called it a nice job. Paula looked drunk or on drugs when she commented on Brooke. Simon, after calling her first song a nightmare, said this is the Brooke we like. I still think Brooke is in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

04, 09 – David Archuleta, Sweet Caroline & America

So this first song really reminds me of “Beautiful Girls” when the gang sings the song at the bar. That movie was pretty good, with a stellar ensemble cast (Matt Dillon, Timothy Hutton, Uma Thurman, Lauren Holly, Michael Rappaport, Natalie Portman, Mira Sorvino, Rosie O’Donnell and the underappreciated Annabeth Gish). David’s second song was a bit disappointing, but I think it went over well with the crowd. So the words to “America” are a little intriguing. They could be seen as a positive interpretation of the history of immigration to the United States. But it could also be interpreted as a slight to the non-Americans who were just eliminated (Michael and Carly). It’s probably not the latter, but I like to get my digs in when I can. Randy called both performances good. Paula called it the absolutely perfect song. My wife Kristin didn’t agree with it because it seemed a bit Broadway, but it was probably a wise choice because Kristy Lee Cook played the Up With America card before and it worked for her. Simon echoed Paula’s sentiments when he said it was a smart choice. David should cruise the finals against David Cook and I think that would be one heck of a finale.

05, 10 – Syesha Mercado, Hello Again & I Thank The Lord For The Night

I think Syesha was smart to straighten her hair and “let it down,” both figuratively and literally. It’s like she’s a completely different person now. Both in style and confidence. It’s like she underwent a metamorphosis. I thought she looked a bit like Tatyana Ali (the little sister in “The Fresh Prince of Bel Air”). She’s really done a 180 since the beginning of the finals. It’s kinda like how Vonzell Solomon came on at the end and finished third to Carrie Underwood and Bo Bice in season four. My wife Kristin thought she did a good job with the first song, although she wished David Archuleta would’ve sung it. And Syesha showed so much personality (that was lacking previously) in the second song. Unfortunately, Syesha may not have enough fans to continue much longer. Unless people notice her change for the better, she’ll be a victim of popularity like Carly was. Randy said she finally realized who she is as a singer. Paula called her Brooke to start. Did anyone catch that? Simon thinks she’s going to be in trouble tomorrow night, but he might have been doing that to get people to vote for her. It’s the old reverse-logic trick.

So bottom 2 – Jason & Brooke

Top 3 – Syesha and the 2 Davids

And onto what I remember from last night’s DWTS:

  • Kristi Yamaguchi is so good that she is being judged unfairly by the judges. I think they’re holding her to a higher standard and giving higher scores to other contestants who are clearly inferior.
  • Kristi did a cool, contemporary Cha Cha Cha and Len docked her. How can she get 10s from the other 2 judges and an 8 from him? At least give her a 9 if not a 10.
  • Jason Taylor did the Paso Doble to the theme for Monday Night Football. That was awesome. His Paso was nowhere near Apollo Anton Ohno’s but I really think that he and Edyta must mate for the good of mankind. Either their kids will be the best looking kids on the planet or the worst looking. There would be no in between.
  • Marissa is getting a lot better. She is nowhere close to Kristi (and her scores shouldn’t even be in the same zip code), but she’s come a long way. I like her partner Tony more this season than last when he was with Jane Seymour and I don’t know why that is.
  • Mario’s partner Karina has too much spray on tan every week. It’s like that episode on Friends when Ross kept messing up and instead of getting a 2 in the front and a 2 on the back, he got a 4 on the front. You know that episode…
  • Mario has the “dancer butt,” especially in the white pants on his second number. And he also looks a bit like Chris Tucker.
  • Shannon Elizabeth and Derek Hough are definitely an item. He was trying to play the drill sergeant on her and her comment was something like, “you won’t like it when you go home alone tonight…”
  • I really can’t stand Cristian de la Fuente, but I really felt for him last night when he cramped up in his arm and couldn’t continue the routine. He was in obvious pain and just wanted to get out of there. He usually has that cheesy smile on his face and that was completely gone.
  • More stars I’d like to see:
  • A Food Network Star (Rachel Ray, Emeril Lagasse, Bobby Flay, Tyler Florence, Giada de Laurentiis, Sandra Lee)
  • A HGTV person like Candice Olson.
  • A WNBA star (Lisa Leslie, Sue Bird, Stacy Dales, Swin Cash)
  • A track and field person (Michael Johnson)

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 6 (04/22)

Andrew Lloyd Webber night. My initial thoughts were that Simon is going to hate this because everything will sound cabaret and I don’t think he gets Broadway music. His challenge for the singers was to make it sound memorable, yet contemporary. They flew the final 6 to Las Vegas to The Venetian to work with Lord Andrew on his Phantom of the Opera set. His only directive to the contestants was to try to make the songs work for them, not vice versa.

01, 07 – Syesha, One Rock & Roll Too Many (Starlight Express)

So Syesha gets the “jinx” spot. There was an analysis done and out of the 69 finals episodes, 20 singers in the #1 spot have been eliminated, (seven more than would be expected based on statistical probability).

http://www.whatnottosing.com/library/editorials.asp?id=18

I thought Syesha was okay tonight and this was definitely more up her alley, but I think that I should like her more than I do. I think I was high on her after the auditions, but she’s never really knocked it out of the park. She looked great tonight in her form-fitting red dress and was very Michelle Pfeiffer, a la The Fabulous Baker Boys. Although with her hair down, she looked a bit like either Nia Long (Will Smith’s girlfriend/wife in “The Fresh Prince”) or Robin Givens. I think these Broadway songs suit her voice. Making it on Broadway and not American Idol isn’t the worst thing in the world. Randy called it her best performance. Paula said it wasn’t surprising and that she was in her happy place. Simon called it very sexy, it was her strongest so far and she was more comfortable in this area. Syesha may live another week, given some of the other performances. I think she’s still in the bottom 3 though. I don’t think her recent strong performances will overshadow the eggs she laid in the beginning of the competition.

02, 08 – Jason, Memory (Cats)

How bad was this performance this late in the competition? He was flat and my wife Kristin thought he murdered the song. She again stated that she couldn’t listen to a whole CD of this guy. The movie Cats reminds me of that show in the mid ‘90s called “The Single Guy” starring Jonathan Silverman (Weekend at Bernie’s with Andrew McCarthy). He got his girlfriend tickets to Cats, but it had been out so long that she thought he was joking, but he wasn’t. He then proceeded to say he was joking and made her guess what he did get her. They made it into a game show type thing. She guessed all these outrageous things like dinner at a place that you can’t get reservations, a show that had been sold out for months and transportation in an antique car and, of course, he said yes to all of them. So the rest of the episode had him killing himself to fulfill the date. Hmm. Guess you had to see it to truly appreciate it. If I ever find that episode on You Tube, I’ll forward it to you all. Trust me, it was funny… Randy said vocally it was a train wreck. Paula called it a very wise choice (huh?). Always hitting it right on the nose, Paula. Simon called it the longest 2 minutes of his life and said it was miserable throughout. Jason will most certainly be in the bottom 3 tomorrow, but he may not go.

03, 09 – Brooke, You Must Love Me (Evita)

I think the intro doomed Brooke on this one. Oops. Can I start over again? I think the intro jinxed Brooke on this one. Andrew said she had no idea what the song was about and proceeded to interpret it for her. I think she put so much energy into remembering those lyrics and expressing what he said that she lost the lyric. I don’t think that’s ever happened on AI before. There have been missed, skipped or wrong lyrics sung, but NEVER had someone started over again. Luckily for her it was at the beginning of the song. I really don’t know how Brooke did with this song because I was SO thrown back that she stopped and started again. Randy said it wasn’t great but that she believed what she was singing. Paula had a hard time finding her words (maybe she didn’t want to start and stop) and eventually said that you should never start and stop, but then mumbled something about not overacting. Simon thought that the beginning completely threw her, but that’s why he loves live TV. My wife Kristin and I still like the tone in Brooke’s voice and still think that her performance was better than Jason’s, but Brooke should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow and there will be tears. Many, many tears.

04, 10 – David A., Think Of Me (Phantom of the Opera)

Andrew had two pieces of advice for David. Open your eyes and open your eyes. I thought the second one was going to be don’t lick your lips, but if these are the only criticisms of David, I’m fine with that. My wife Kristin loved this version. He really changed the tempo of this song and delivered it well. My wife Kristin called it beautiful, and second only to his “Imagine” performance. Randy said it was the bomb and that he’s the one to beat. Paula called it absolutely perfect and he took a risk but changed it into a pop ballad. Simon called it pleasant but one of his weakest live performances. And called it forgettable. I thought my wife Kristin was going to rush the set after those comments! I’ve said it before and will say it again, David Archuleta is a star. He’s likeable. He’s got an unbelievable voice. He’s got a pleasant voice to listen to. I think he should win it all, but he’ll be successful even if he doesn’t win.

05, 11 – Carly, Jesus Christ Superstar (Jesus Christ Superstar)

Have I mentioned that I can’t stand her? I’d make fun of her flying carpet dress, but the fact that it covered up her sinister tattoos made the outfit palatable for me. I’m admittedly biased here. I don’t think there will ever be anything that she sings that I’ll like. My wife Kristin didn’t like this performance either, which has more credibility because she is at least a little more objective when it comes to Carly than I am. Randy said it wasn’t the best but definitely good. Paula said it was so unexpected (huh?). Simon called it shouty in the middle but it was one of his favorites of the night. Then she went over to Ricky Minor and got a shirt that said “Simon Loves Me (This Week).” How contrived was that? THAT is why I can’t stand her. I think it’s between her and Syesha for bottom 3 tomorrow, with only the Davids being safe.

06, 12 – David C., Music of the Night (Phantom of the Opera)

The biggest surprise of the night is that David Cook played it straight this week. He didn’t try to rock up or grunge out an Andrew Lloyd Webber song. He just used this week to show off his musical talents. And it totally worked. This was 180 degrees from the show 2 weeks ago. Which reminds me of a story that my manager told me. She was watching Extra and they did a feature on how David’s brother has brain cancer. Did anyone notice the pale looking guy (that looked a bit like Kevin “Chicken Little” Covais) sitting next to Teri Hatcher right behind the judges last week? That was David Cook’s brother. He is in such a weakened state that his doctor would not allow him to fly commercial out to see David perform live (because it could upset his medical condition). Friends and family chartered a medical jet for him to attend the show, which I think was a surprise to David. He was very emotional after the performance, which led me to believe it was because the judges gave him such kudos, especially after being panned the week before. But it was because of his brother being there and more power to David for not bringing it to the attention of the public. I really respect and admire that. Randy said it was an amazing performance. Paula called him so well rounded (finally something that made sense from her!). Simon said he liked the grittier David, but he made the most of the week. I think this week really showed a lot of David. I, too, like the rocked up covers that he does, but he worked it out this week and this may be a week that people look back on and say this is why he won (or why he made the finals).

Bottom 3 – Jason, Brooke, Syesha/Carly

Top 2 – the Davids

DWTS bullet points:

· How good is Kristi Yamaguchi? Her level of dancing is so much higher than the rest of the contestants. I know that she has an advantage over the others because she can learn routines faster because of her skating background, but she really is a joy to watch. And her partner Mark must be having fun too. He can totally challenge her and it will work out.

· So Shannon and Derek were caught smooching on the beach after one of their shoots. Told ya something was going on.

· Do you ever notice how out of breath Shannon is after her dances? That’s another advantage Kristi has! But my boss thinks that Shannon’s part of the young Hollywood that doesn’t eat and smokes, which makes a bad cardiovascular combination.

· My wife Kristin always sees Marlee Matlin’s body and says, “I can’t believe she had 4 kids!”

· Cristian de la Fuente bugs me. Maybe it’s the cheesy smile or the fact that he thinks he’s better than he is, but it’s definitely something.

· The Hairspray chick is doing much better than in the beginning. But she still looks like Ricki Lake.

· Edyta was wearing something close to nothing last night (not that I’m complaining).

· Mario is getting better, but his partner Karina bothers me.

· Here is my wish list of future Stars to participate:

· Kelly Ripa – if Cameron can work and do this, she can too

· Danica Patrick – Helio did it and won it all

· Erin Andrews – sideline reporter for ESPN

· Michael Jordan – he’d have the Emmitt Smith thing going

· Charles Barkley – I guarantee he’ll be better than Clyde Drexler

· Courtney Thorne-Smith – Why not go to Melrose Place? They already tapped 90210, although Tori Spelling and David Austin Green are still out there

· Danica McKeller – Winnie Cooper; she needs to be back in the spotlight

· John Cusack – this was my wife Kristin’s suggestion, but that would mean that Joan Cusack and Jeremy Pivin would also have to be on the show

This is just off the top of my head. I’ll think of more later…

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 7 (04/15)

Ah, Mariah Carey week. My initial thoughts were that this was going to be a tough night. Mariah has such a great voice (and five-octave range) that it would be hard to duplicate her songs. Obviously the contestants will have to change it up so that they won’t pale in comparison. And she’s got 18 #1 singles, which pushed her past Elvis Presley as the #1 solo artist with the most #1s, and only second to The Beatles who hold 21 #1s.

I really enjoyed her first album “Mariah Carey” as “Vision of Love” is one of my personal favorites of hers. I think her public image took a hit in the late ‘90s. And did she get a boob job? I mean, she’s huge. And she’s not shy about dressing to let you know she’s huge. Didn’t she date Derek Jeter at some point awhile back?

Back to the show. What’s going on with Seacrest’s hair? He’s got a double part, almost mohawk like. Actually, he looks like Jack Jack from The Incredibles.

01 – David Archuleta, When You Believe

So this was a duet with Whitney Houston for the movie “The Prince of Egypt.” It’s funny because my wife Kristin and I thought this was from “The Preacher’s Wife,” but that song was “I Believe in You and Me.” Then we realized that this song is on our wedding video. We love this song. And we actually saw “The Prince of Egypt” in the theaters, kind of. We went to see it at an 11pm showing on a weekend that we came back from Chicago and ended up both falling asleep during it. I don’t think we’ve ever seen the complete movie. Anyway, my wife Kristin liked David’s performance a lot, as did I. Randy was worried about this week for the guys, but he gave his standard, “if you can sing, you can sing anything” line. Paula said it must’ve felt great for Mariah to hear David’s interpretation of the song (thanks for putting words into her mouth, Paula). Simon said it was very, very good and that he performed it very well. The USA Today guy thought David’s performance was 5th or 6th out of the 7. I don’t know how I can read his blog anymore after that blatant hating of David. He must drink Haterade and root for the Florida Hators. David should be safe tomorrow night and should battle the other David (Cook) in the finale.

02 – Carly Hennessy, Without You

So there’s stuff around the net professing that it would be interesting to see how Carly handles “meeting” Mariah because supposedly they met 7 years ago when Carly was making her album that sold 378 copies. In the intro, Carly says, “nice to meet you” and Mariah responds with, “I’ve been wanting to meet you.” Now I can understand Mariah not remembering Carly, but how can Carly make like it was the first time they ever met? Okay enough of this stuff. Carly made the song her own, which was a good thing because there is no way she could outsing Mariah. She reminds me of Heart up there sometimes when she’s belting out the big notes. Randy said she was pretty good. Paula liked that she showed vocal restraint. Simon said she didn’t pull it off. He claims she’s capable, but she’s still wound up and it was an okay version. I think Carly will be in the bottom 3 again this week. Hopefully we can stick a fork in her tomorrow night.

03 – Syesha Mercado, Fantasy

I admit that I didn’t really know this song, but Syesha really let go tonight. And she looked like Diana Ross in that gold dress. I think this is what they’ve been waiting to see in her and probably what they thought they’d have seen in Carly the song before. Randy called it the toughest song to sing of the night but she did a good job. Paula thought it was extremely smart to pick a song that not many people knew (I guess so that there wouldn’t be a comparison to the original). Simon called it very good technically, but thought that at this point in the competition she shouldn’t have picked a song that no one knows. It’s like a red flag goes up when Paula says something and he refutes it right away. Regardless of her performance tonight, I still think she’s in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

04 – Brooke White, Hero

The way that Brooke always sings with a piano or guitar I half expect her to sing “Smelly Cat” one of these nights. She changed this song up a bit (smartly), but she started losing it at the end. All in all though, my wife Kristin thinks she’s got a nice tone to her voice. Randy liked the whole singer/songwriter vibe. Paula said every ounce of her is totally authentic. Simon said her voice wasn’t strong enough to carry that song. Then he tried to make some analogy of a hamburger without meat. I think the analogy would’ve been better by saying the performance was like a plain hamburger with no condiments. By process of elimination, Brooke could be on the bubble for the bottom 3 tomorrow night.

05 – Kristy Lee Cook, Forever

Why is it that every time I hear Kristy sing, I feel like I should be standing in the audience at a county fair? Or watching a beauty pageant on TV? I didn’t really know this song, but she picked the right one. She country-ed it up a bit and pulled it off (for her). Randy said it wasn’t amazing, but she hit the note at the end. Paula was blown away. Simon said she managed with what she could and called it whiny at times. My wife Kristin thinks it boils down to the fact that he’s just not a fan of country music. I thought she was fine, but she’ll probably be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. And this is the point in the competition where Seacrest will put the contestants in two groups of three and say the 7th person is safe. He’ll then proceed to ask the 7th person to go to the group of 3 that are also safe. The top 3 will be who the crowd thinks is the bottom 3 and there will be shock and audible displeasure when the bottom 3 is revealed. George Huff was the first person he did this to and he went over to LaToya, Jennifer Hudson and Fantasia, thinking Jasmine, Diana DiGarmo and John Stephens were the bottom 3. The following year, Bo Bice simply sat down in the middle of the stage, refusing to make a choice. I hope that happens again tomorrow night.

06 – David Cook, Always Be My Baby

Every time David changes a song up like this it reminds me of the DWTS band because they always do songs but you can’t tell right away what the song is. That’s part of the fun in watching DWTS (along with all the hot female celebrity and pro dancers wearing next to nothing with spray on tans and glitter), trying to figure out what the song is. There usually comes a point where you say to yourself, “hey, I know that song.” My wife Kristin thinks David has a very contemporary voice. I would buy a CD of his if he just did rocked up covers of ‘80s songs. And he bugged me last week, but he totally redeemed himself in my eyes this week. I still liked “Hello” better, but this one was pretty “out of the box” creative. Randy said he’s ready to make an album right now, stood up and said it was the most brilliant performance yet. Paula said that could be on a movie soundtrack right now (which is great because I’m sure David wants to be the sellout Kenny Loggins/Smash Mouth of this era). Simon said that it was a breath of fresh air after being trapped in karaoke hell. It was original, daring and stood out by a mile. David’s back and is David Archuleta’s only competition, in my humble opinion.

07 – Jason Castro, I Don’t Wanna Cry

I’m not a fan of Jason’s and would never want to listen to a complete CD of his, but he does have a nice voice for Hawaiian music. My wife Kristin thinks that he restrains his voice too much. Randy didn’t really love it and likened it to being at a luau with Jason singing in the background. Paula said she’d love to be at that luau and Simon said it wasn’t the best vocal of the night but it was a cool version. I think Jason’s okay for tomorrow night, but don’t think he’ll make it past 3rd, if he even gets that far.

Bottom 3 – Carly, Brooke, Syesha

Top 2 – David A., David C.

Now, on to the DWTS semi-recap (this format took way too long, so it’s back to bullet points next week):

Mario – He looks a lot like Chris Webber (my mom pointed that out). He danced the Samba last night and got some inspiration from Stevie Wonder, who looks like Barry Bonds now. His partner Karina called him “Poopie” in their rehearsals. Karina wore this yellow dress that looked like the end result of the chicken guy at the graduation party in “Say Anything…” which was played by Eric Stoltz, by the way. (Score, with Carrie Ann’s score first, Len’s second and Bruno’s third) 9-9-9=27

Priscilla Presley – She and her partner Louis van Amstel danced the Rumba last night. Louis (prounounced “Louie”) looks like an odd mix of Harry Hamlin and Craig Sheffer (“A River Runs Through It,” “The Program,” “Some Kind of Wonderful,” Keith Scott on “One Tree Hill”). Priscilla (at age 62) did the splits during this routine. That was amazing. This dance was so slow though that it reminded me of an act out of Cirque du Soleil, one where two guys were balancing each other. I forgot the name of the act, but they used to perform at Bulls games back in the day. 7-7-7=21

Marissa – Her partner Tony bugs me. Don’t know why. Maybe because he looks like a character out of “Good Fellas?” Marissa reminds me of the girl on “Bosom Buddies.” Wendie Jo Sperber was her name, I think. Can you believe Tom Hanks was on that show? How often do you think Peter Scolari looks back at that show and says, “it could’ve been me with those back to back Oscars?” They did the Samba and got 8-8-8=24.

Cristian – He bugs me too. He’s always got this cheesy smile on his face and he thinks that he’s better than he is. Did an okay Rumba with his partner (and 2 time champ, Cheryl Burke) and got 7-8-8=23.

Marlee Matlin – Did the Samba with her partner that looks like Lou Diamond Phillips (LDP to his close friends). She was really off last night though, which stands to reason because of her lack of hearing. She lost her timing a bit and had a few stumbles. The judges criticized her but also commended her for doing so well. I don’t think she took that very well because, although they don’t mean to do it, I think Marlee finds it patronizing when they give her an out because of her deafness. 7-7-8=22. I hope she doesn’t go home.

Kristi Yamaguchi – She did an elegant Rumba with her partner Mark Ballas. And we finally saw her 2 cute Hapa daughters (and her husband, hockey player Bret Hedican). I guess it was okay doing the sensual Rumba because after witnessing the practice, Bret didn’t highstick Mark into the boards! 9-10-10=29. She’s the obvious front runner in this competition and the only thing that will do her in is if people don’t vote for her.

Shannon Elizabeth – Her poor partner Derek got hospitalized with a neck injury last week and this week he went to the hospital for food poisoning! Another dancer (Jonathan who had the unrhythmic Monica Seles earlier this season) would’ve stepping in had Derek not been able to dance. They did a Samba and Shannon is really out of shape. They panned her though saying she didn’t have enough hip action. 8-8-7=22. I think there might be something going on between these two.

Jason Taylor – He did a graceful Rumba with his partner Edyta. He is amazingly graceful for such a manly athlete. His “lines” are unbelievable. They were a bit disappointed that they didn’t get any 10s this week, but I think it was a bit of a make up call for last week when they got two 10s, but he slipped a few times. I hope that Jason incorporates some of his ballroom dancing into his sack dance next season. 9-9-9=27. He’s Kristi’s main competition based on ability and fan voting.

Wednesday, April 09, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 8 (04/08)

It’s inspiration week, which I would think would be tough to judge, because how can you criticize what inspires someone? But I’m sure Simon (or Randy) will find a way (and Paula won’t).

01 – Michael Johns, Dream On (Aerosmith)

Michael looked like a crusty old jazz musician tonight (okay actually it was last night, as I’m doing this recap a day late; but bear with me), with his short sleeve tux shirt, vest and bandana/ascot. Is that ascot thing a good look? I’m not digging it at all. Randy said it was a pretty good song choice, but he had pitch problems. And he mentioned something about the competition being about “undiscovered talent” which is laughable given all of the people who previously had record deals in the past and on the current show (namely Carly and Kristy Lee Cook; and David Archuleta to an extent, as he did win Star Search back in 2003). Paula couldn’t disagree more. I honestly think she just disagrees to get the crowd on her side, which is sad. Simon called it a good performance, but said he doesn’t like an impersonation of a rock star. I think Michael will last longer in the competition but can’t match the Davids. He’ll peak at top 4 or 5.

02 – Syesha Mercado, I Believe (Fantasia)

First off, I’ll readily admit that I wasn’t, nor am I currently a fan of Fantasia’s. But she also sang this song very well. Rule 1A of picking songs (after don’t pick a Whitney Houston song) should be don’t pick a song from a previous American Idol. That doomed season 5 contestant Lisa Tucker when she sang a Kelly Clarkson song. Syesha has a better than average voice, but she picks songs that she sings well, but not close to the original. I’m actually really down on her because if she hasn’t learned to pick different songs by now, she gets what she deserves. Randy said she took on another tiger and it was okay, but he didn’t feel like she found a connection with the song. Paula said she flipped the song a little and said it was one of her shining moments (which further validates that Paula is on crack; and what was up with her dress tonight? Her boobs were fighting to get out of there…) Simon said that she (technically) sang the song well, but of course it was going to be compared to the original and he didn’t see the wave of emotion that should be attached to that song. I think Syesha is in trouble tomorrow night. Definitely bottom 3. But I’ll have her stay another week if it means Carly is gone. Because Carly can sing her way back in and Syesha can’t.

03 – Jason Castro, Somewhere Over the Rainbow (Israel Kamakawiwo’ole)

Or Braddah Iz, is he’s also known as. Jason came out with the ukulele tonight, which was cool. Iz paired this song with “What A Wonderful World” and you may also remember it on some American Express commercials. I’m not a huge fan of Jason’s, but this song was right up his alley. He has a great voice for Hawaiian music. Randy said that Jason Castro is back in the hunt (which is a point well taken because he’s had a lapse in recent weeks). Paula said he has a definitive sound. This is important because her word of the night was “definitive.” Simon called it fantastic. Jason should be safe tomorrow night, but I don’t think he’s a contender for winning it all. I think he will top out at top 3 or 4.

04 – Kristy Lee Cook, Anyway (Martina McBride)

Have I mentioned that Kristy is a tall drink of water? Loved the sparkly gold top and white pants that she had on tonight. Didn’t really know the song, but I think it was passable, although I’m usually listening with my eyes more than my ears when she sings. Randy said he loved it, although it was pitchy in parts. Randy was very anti tonight. Paula said she outdid herself and it was her best by far. Simon called it very good indeed and she looked like a star tonight (which could be the Kiss of Death from Simon). Sometimes when he’s complimentary, it works against the contestant. She has been in the bottom 3 for 3 of the 4 weeks so far. It won’t surprise me if she’s there again tomorrow night, but based on this performance, I don’t think it’s her time to go yet, but it will be soon.

05 – David Cook, Innocent (Our Lady Peace)

David came out with this funky white jacket with all these buttons on it. I didn’t know the song, but he ended it with “give back” on the palm of his hand. I really thought this performance was very (to take a term from Simon) indulgent and I felt like David was full of himself tonight. He’d been playing it so cool up to now. Great song choices and positive reactions, but tonight I think he got a little big headed and tried to take some liberties. I thought it was rehearsed and didn’t work. Randy said it wasn’t one of his strongest weeks. Paula branched off and said that he was so well defined (which counts as a definitive in my book) as the whole package. Simon said he didn’t like it and called it a teensy weensy bit pompous. I couldn’t agree more. But David will be safe tomorrow. He’s earned this offweek. I still think it’s between him and David Archuleta for the title.

06 – Carly Smithson, The Show Must Go On (Queen)

What was Carly wearing tonight? A jazzercise top from the ‘80s? I thought she was going to sing “Physical” by Olivia Newton-John. Either that or I thought she might have been wrestler in GLOW (Gorgeous Ladies Of Wresting) that debuted in the ‘80s. Randy said it started good but was pitchy in the middle. Paula said her voice is perfect but she wasn’t engaged by her tonight. Simon said she looked good, but that it was an unusual choice of song. She oversang it and lost control of it. And that it was out of kilter for the evening. He even called it an angry performance. If you hadn’t noticed, (to put it lightly) I’m not a huge fan of Carly’s. I think she could be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. And if she is, I hope she’s gone. Because she does have an amazing voice and she can sing her way back into the competition. And I think it would be fabulous for a singer who had a $2 million push by MCA and only sold 378 records to finish 8th in a competition of supposed “undiscovered talent.” That 378 records is on par with Ron Artest’s rap album. And way below Kevin Federline’s effort. Think about that for a moment.

07 – David Archuleta, Angels (Robbie Williams)

My only (slight) complaint about David is that he’s always talking about the “message” the song gives that he’s singing. And I think that may come from his “stage dad.” But I still love David Archuleta. Randy said that the runs at the end was the hottest moment of the season for him. Paula reacted to the crowd and called it fantastic. Simon said it was the best song choice of the night and he’s glad he did the song because it’s one of the best pop songs ever written. I guess it’s been a hit everywhere but the U.S. Although Jessica Simpson did cover it in 2004. Again, maybe that’s why it hasn’t been a hit in the U.S. This kid is so likeable I don’t see him being in the bottom 3 ever. Ideally he’ll win it all, but that hasn’t always happened on AI.

08 – Brooke White, You’ve Got A Friend (Carole King)

I really didn’t know this song. I kept thinking that it was going to sound like the Randy Newman song in “Toy Story” which, as I found out later, was “You’ve Got A Friend In Me.” So I’m trying to follow this song and it’s nothing like I remember from “Toy Story,” mostly because it’s not the same song! Maybe I don’t get fashion, but I thought Brooke’s dress looked like some bad bathroom wallpaper from the ‘70s. And Brooke gave her “thank you” that annoys me so much at the end of her song. I always chuckle when I hear that. Randy said it wasn’t her best, but he wasn’t mad at her. Paula finished strong by calling her definitive. Simon said it was pleasant, but not original. And Brooke was holding back tears up on the stage. I think the songs that she sings really touch her and she’s so emotional up there most of the time, which is cool, I guess. She should be fine tomorrow night, but who knows.

Bottom 3 – Syesha, Carly, Michael

Top 2 – David A. and Jason

And now, what some of you have been waiting for, my long awaited Dancing With The Stars recap. This won’t be a full-blown recap, but rather bullet points as observations.

  • Kristi Yamaguchi is an amazing dancer, which is equally amazing because she isn’t very outgoing or overly expressive in her interviews. She’s technically a superb dancer and her figure skating background has come in handy (especially with hand placement, etc).
  • Her partner, Mark Ballas, reminds me of the kid in “American Pie” (Thomas Ian Nicholas). He was also in “Rookie of the Year” (Pitcher’s got a big butt. Pitcher’s got a big butt…)
  • Jason Taylor continues to amaze me. Although he had a couple of obvious gaffes in his Viennese waltz and still got two 10s from Bruno and Carrie Ann. I think they just did that so that it wouldn’t look like Kristi was running away with it (which she is; she’s gotten 27s three weeks in a row and had a 29 this week).
  • Julianne Hough is an amazing choreographer. She won the last 2 seasons with Apolo Anton Ohno and Helio Castroneves but got paired with Adam Carolla this season. And although he can’t dance a lick, they survived 3 weeks before ultimately bowing out this week. And she’s only 19. And cute as a button. I’ll miss her on the show.
  • Her brother Derek and partner Shannon Elizabeth have great chemistry. I think something may be going on there. He was paired with Jenny Garth last season and there definitely was nothing going on there! He looked so young that they kept making it a big deal that she couldn’t look at him and take him seriously!
  • Priscilla Presley looks kinda scary with all of the facelifts that she’s had. You can’t tell if she’s smiling or not. And I think she may have aged gracefully had she let it happen naturally. But I could be wrong.
  • Steve Guttenberg was almost too nice and happy to be on the show. But I loved him in all the “Police Academy” movies and “Cocoon,” not to mention the “Three Men and a Baby” movies.
  • Marlee Matlin is still in. It’s unheard of (pun intended).
  • R&B star Mario (I’m ashamed to admit this, but I know him from his role as Myles in “Step Up”) is okay, but he reminds me of Floyd Merriweather, but a better dancer. And Karina had both of them. I think Mario’s into her a bit too. Don’t know if she’s still dating Mario Lopez or not.

That’s if for now, but I’ll mention something about DWTS every week from now on.

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 9 (04/01)

First off, thanks again to Mike Rico for filling in for the last two weeks. I have to admit, I haven’t even watched the last 2 shows yet. It’s been that crazy around here. We’ve made up some other shows, but since Mike’s recaps filled us in and our time was limited, we haven’t watched them yet!

And last week was madness at the House of the Mouse. So we knew it would be packed because it was Spring Break, but we had no idea that it would be as bad as it was. We’ve been there at busy times before (President’s Week last year) but last week was like we’ve never seen before. Ninety minute plus waits for Space Mountain and Soaring Over California. Fast passes running out by early afternoon. I think we waited an hour and a half for Monsters, Inc. Yes, Monsters Inc. The Dumbo line curled around to where the stationary Dumbo is (up by the Casey Jr train). There were so many people from Oregon there, all wearing their U of O and OSU gear. And a lot of people from Arizona too (wearing Cardinals gear, which I thought was odd). But my son (who is just tall enough for roller coasters now) had enough courage to try Space Mountain (thanks to his “date” with his Auntie Koren) and he fell in love with the ride! We were absolutely beat after the trip, but the kids had a blast, so it’s all worth it.

My wife is out of town for work tonight but I’m not as busy or flustered as in the past. My 2 year old daughter Kacey gave me a little trouble, but she’s asleep now. She was crying because she didn’t have a certain toy in her room (not even in her crib). I had to bring that in and then she was fine. And my 5 year old son Jared usually goes to sleep at 8:30-ish, but he got himself ready for bed by 8:00 tonight. Brushed his teeth and got into bed all by himself. Why, you may ask? Well, seems as though he lost his first tooth today and he has an acquaintance (I’m trying not to implicate anyone here) that gets $20 a tooth. Unfortunately he won’t be getting that much, so his zeal for the Tooth Fairy may wane as his other teeth fall out. I think $2 for the first tooth and $1 each for subsequent ones is more than reasonable. Although I told him that he should put his tooth under his acquaintance’s pillow, but he didn’t seem to go for that one.

So, on to American Idol. It’s not only Country Night, but it’s Dolly Parton night. Her credentials are amazing. Over 3000 songs written. Twenty-five #1s. Over 100 plastic surgeries. Why does everyone who has plastic surgery end up looking like The Joker? Or Joan Collins? I have to admit that I don’t know many of Dolly Parton’s songs, so I can’t tell you if they changed it up or if they sang it better/worse than the original. As I imagined, she was not a great mentor, as she really didn’t want to critique the contestants. I think one of the best mentors was Barry Manilow. Dolly was nice, but useless to the singers.

01 – Brooke White, Jolene

Of course, she was sitting and playing the guitar, but also had a violin player and some dude sitting on something (was it a bongo?) and banging away during the song. It was kind of an odd arrangement of instrumentals. Randy said the song suited her voice, but that she rushed the music at times. Paula called her consistent and praised her for putting her heart and soul into the song. And said she had an emotional connection to the song. Simon said it lacked any emotion. I thought the words to the song were pretty cool, but I really don’t know if she was good or not tonight. I think she’s better than the bottom 3, but don’t think she blew anyone away.

02 – David Cook, Little Sparrow

David had a mini-interview before his song with Ryan and I think they did it so that he could address his arrangements in previous songs. This show is so popular now that if a singer “samples” a version from another artist, it runs rampant on the internet. That happened to Chris Daughtry a few years back when he did a version of a song that Fuel did and he accepted the accolades without acknowledging Fuel. And that totally bothered me at the time. AI has a habit of retroactively addressing things that come out in the media. It’s funny because they don’t really tell you what came out, but rather address it through the back door. I guess I’m okay with that, but whatever. David copped to copying arrangements from other artists and put a positive spin on it by saying the artists were pleased that he used their version. On to the actual performance now. Randy said that he made his own arrangement and it was hot. Paula liked his haircut. Simon said it wasn’t as good as last week, but he did well. I thought it was fine. David is cruising now. It looks as though he’s made up some ground on the other David (Archuleta).

03 – Ramiele Malubay, Do I Ever Cross Your Mind

Ramiele seemed a bit ahead of the music tonight. Almost like she just wanted to the get song over with. I’m actually very disappointed in her because she has a wonderful voice, but her performance skills are lacking. She seems very bland and boring most of the time. Not that I was ever really on her bandwagon, but I’m totally off it now. Randy was not jumping up and down, but he wasn’t mad at her either. Gave her a 6 ½ out of 10. Paula said she really connected with the audience. Simon said it was cute and she sang it well, but it was forgettable and something you’d see on a cruise ship. I think Ramiele is in the bottom 3 tomorrow and possibly off the show.

04 – Jason Castro, Travelin’ Thru

Dolly tried to make a lame joke about his dreadlocks and called him funky looking. I thought he was better tonight, but I’m really not a fan of his. Randy said it started rough, but he worked it out. Paula called it one his strongest performances. Simon, of course, didn’t like it at all. I was surprised to see Jason in the bottom 3 last week. Granted I didn’t hear him sing the night before, but I thought his popularity was greater than that. My guess is that he’s not in the bottom 3 again any time soon, as last week was a wake up call to his fans to make sure they call in to keep him on the show. I’ve never heard this song and thought it was a’ight. He’ll be safe tomorrow night.

05 – Carly Henne, er Smithson, Here You Come Again

I think it was Reginald VelJohnson (the father from “Family Matters” and the Sgt that bonds w/ Bruce Willis in “Die Hard”) playing guitar on the stage as Carly was singing. I’ve never heard this song, but it sounded like some other ‘80s song that I can’t put my finger on. I won’t doubt the fact that Carly has an awesome voice, but as the USA Today blogger calls her, she’s this year’s glory note queen. This is not new news, but I just can’t stand her. Be it she’s not American or that she had a major record deal previously. Or that she conveniently changed her name before the show because she’s known around Hollywood as Carly Hennessy. Pick any one of them and that’s why I hope she doesn’t win. Actually I hope she doesn’t get another record deal out of this (but she will). Do I need to let this go? Or do some of you feel the same way? Randy called it one of the best performances of the night. Paula called her glorious. Simon said it was good, not great and criticized her wardrobe. What’s the saying, you can dress up a pig, but she’s still a pig? Maybe she just need to sing in the background like in “Singin’ In The Rain.” Or maybe she’s got a face for radio. I think Carly’s safe tomorrow, but I can’t see her surpassing either David. She may be the highest female finisher though. It’s close between her and Brooke, who seems to have quite a following now.

06 – David Archuleta, Smoky Mountain Memories

David rocked the argyle sweater with the Member’s Only jacket tonight. I love how wardrobe and makeup tries to make someone look different by throwing some gel in the hair and messing it up. David is so straight laced that his hair just looks like someone ran his hand through it. Randy said David was back tonight and said it was the best performance of the night. Paula said he has an amazing tone and used glorious again. Simon called it absolutely right on the money. It seems as though the coronation of David Archuleta was a bit premature. I still love the kid and hope he wins. Maybe his faltering a bit early on will help him in the end, as it’s hard to keep that level following “Imagine” throughout the whole competition. And there was a report that his “stage dad” will keep him from winning, as people will be reluctant to vote for him. We’ll see. If he’s the American Idol or not, I think he’s going to be successful in this business. Obviously I think he’s safe tomorrow night.

07 – Kristy Lee Cook, Coat of Many Colors

Kristy is a bit of a paradox because she’s this “tall drink of water” that is a total tomboy. I’ll pass along a friend’s Look-a-likes later, but he had her looking like Kelly Preston, which I totally see. I remember her in “Secret Admirer” with C. Thomas Howell and Lori Loughlin and “Space Camp” with Lea Thompson in the mid ‘80s. Then she had her ‘90s run of “Jerry Maguire” and “For Love of the Game.” I actually read “For Love of the Game” before it was a movie and, like in most cases, the book was much better. Back to Kristy. Dolly Parton, being country, was right up her alley. Randy said this was in her wheelhouse. Paula said she looked stunning. Simon said last week was better and it was pleasant, but forgettable. I actually thought Kristy would’ve been gone by now but I guess she’s been making it through by the skin of her teeth. I don’t mind her sticking around because I know she’s not going to outlast either David. I wouldn’t mind her outlasting Carly though. It seems that Kristy will be safe tomorrow, but wouldn’t it be ironic if she goes on Country Night?

08 – Syesha Mercado, I Will Always Love You

Vanna White cameo! With her hair up like it was, Syesha looked like Thelma from “Good Times.” This song is always so strange because after Whitney sang it like she did, I can’t imagine Dolly’s version. I YouTube’d it and Dolly sang it in “The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas” to Burt Reynolds, but it just pales in comparison to Whitney’s version. Dolly actually sings it very well, but I can’t hear it any other way than the way Whitney arranged it. And is it okay to say that I liked “The Bodyguard?” It was rumoured that Princess Diana was going to star in the sequel to this movie with Kevin Costner reprising his role as Frank Farmer, but it never got past the final draft stage and she was subsequently killed in the infamous car crash before the film could progress any further (like how I put the extra “u” in rumoured because she’s British?). Anyway, per usual, no one can sing a Whitney song better than the original, nor can anyone change it up to sound any better. AI just need to put a kibosh on Whitney songs because obviously the contestants don’t know any better. But it’s been 7 seasons, they should have a clue by now. Randy said she took on the biggest tiger of the night, but it was hard for him to hear anyone else sing that song. Paula said she looked beautiful and she has a velvety tone (not glorious?). Simon called it good, but not a fantastic version. I think Syesha will be in the bottom 3 again tomorrow, as she’s struggling to find a fan base.

09 – Michael Johns, It’s All Wrong but It’s All Right

Michael came out with an ascot tonight, a la “My Fair Lady” or “Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.” Don’t know if I dug that or not. I thought it was a bit over the top, but Randy said he brings it up a notch every week. Paula called him a star. Then Simon got cut off by my TiVo. I think Michael may be on the bubble tomorrow night.

Bottom 3 – Ramiele, Syesha, Michael

Top 3 – David Cook, David Archuleta, Brooke

And a last note on my favorite show, Dancing With The Stars. Can I tell you how much I love this show? I wish I’d have watched it from the get go. I will be absolutely shocked if Kristi Yamaguchi doesn’t win this year. Although she does have the advantage of figure skating. Her “lines” and showmanship from skating give her a leg up on her competitors. Jason Taylor is amazingly graceful for a dude who is 1) a football player and 2) 6’6” and 240 pounds. He and his partner, Edyta could be the best looking couple on the face of the earth. Deaf actress Marlee Matlin is on the show. Yes, you read that correctly. DEAF actress Marlee Matlin. And she’s good. It’s amazing. Julianne Hough will not win this season (she’s won the last 2 seasons with Apolo Anton Ohno and Helio Castroneves) because she has Adam Carolla as her partner, but she continues to be the best choreographer out there. Which is amazing in itself because she’s only 19. Her brother Derek and Shannon Elizabeth are pretty good too. Steve Guttenburg just got eliminated, but he was such a good sport and came off as the nicest guy on earth. All this and DWTS has the best hosts out there in Tom Bergeron and Samantha Harris. And the judges are even awesome. Carrie Ann Inaba is Paula, but relevant and insightful. She knows when to coddle and when to constructively criticize. And the repartee between Tom and Len Goodman is 180 degrees from the forced jabs that Seacrest and Simon throw at each other. But no, a DWTS recap is not coming, but you may get more of it in these AI recaps, if you’ll indulge me…