Wednesday, February 27, 2008

AI7 recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 10 (02/27)

Let’s get right into it. Same theme (‘70s) for the gals and they also share something that America might be surprised to know.

01 – Carly Smithson, Crazy On You (Heart)

Her surprise is that even though she owns a tattoo bar with her husband, she also works at an Irish bar around the corner. Hair looked better for her tonight, but that tattoo is downright sinister. I’m really not a fan of Carly’s. I think she has a real good voice, but her singing posture and the way she holds the mic just bugs me. I can’t put my finger on it, but there’s just something insincere about her. Maybe it’s because she previously had a record deal (but the label went belly up) or that she’s not American (Green Card marriage, anyone?). Randy said it was good towards the end. Paula called her an amazing singer. Simon called it much better than last week, but she really hasn’t connected with the right song yet. And added when she does, she’ll blow everyone away. Looking at the competition, she’s safe tomorrow night and probably into the final 12.

02 – Syesha Mercado, Me and Mr. Jones (Billy Paul)

She obviously changed the gender on this one. Syesha’s been in commercials in Miami. Doesn’t surprise me. She’s gorgeous and has that signature big hair. Song was okay, but she finished it big. Wore a nice understated black dress and colorful scarf as a headband. She really can model/act if this doesn’t work out. But she could be the triple threat too, because she can sing. Randy said it wasn’t a great song choice and wished she picked a song that would’ve showcased her big voice. Paula said it fell off pitch for the lower notes. Simon called it a bit indulgent. She didn’t kill it tonight, but I think she’s still safe tomorrow night. And into the top 12 too.

03 – Brooke White, You’re So Vain (Carly Simon)

Brooke surprised us with the fact that she went to beauty school, but didn’t finish, making her, yes, a beauty school dropout. She came out with a guitar and the first thing my wife thought of was when Lili Taylor was singing “Joe Lies” at the graduation party in “Say Anything…” Funny thing about “Say Anything…” is that I was just talking about that movie. Did you realize that Chynna Phillips (from Wilson Phillips and married to Billy “the AWOL” Baldwin) was Joe’s girlfriend? I thought Brooke was good tonight. Better than last week. Sitting with the guitar saved us from her uncomfortable dancing. Not as bad as Jason Yeager, but uncomfortable nonetheless. And I’m usually a “less is more” kind of guy when it comes to makeup, but Brooke looks better with some makeup. And you probably know this but no one really knows who this song is really about. Carly Simon has been very secretive about it over the years. There are rumors that it’s about Warren Beatty, Mick Jagger, Cat Stevens, Kris Kristofferson, William Donaldson or James Taylor. Randy called it a great song choice. Paula called it the perfect song choice because it suited her. Simon absolutely loved it. I think this gets her to next week, but she’ll have to bring it again to make it to the final 12.

04 – Ramiele Malubay, Don’t Leave Me This Way (Thelma Houston)

Her surprise was that she grew up doing Polynesian dance. The USA Today guy compares her speaking voice to Paris Bennett. Believe me, there is no comparison. I don’t see Ramiele saying, “then kew.” Ramiele has a real ‘80s look to her with her haircut and I almost expected her to be wearing on oversize belt. And leg warmers. And singing “Physical.” I thought she was okay tonight. Not great, but I still think she’s one of the better gals. Randy said it was rough for him. Paula said she powered through but didn’t get to perform her magic. Simon said he’s heard this song so many times and he won’t remember it so well. But he did say he thought she was in the top 3 singers in the competition. I hope Ramiele is safe tomorrow. I think she will be. And I think she should cruise to the top 12 and go pretty deep. David Archuleta should win, but she could be top 4 or 5. I think her goal is to beat Jasmine Trias’ top 3 finish.

05 – Kristy Lee Cook, You’re No Good (Linda Ronstadt)

Kristy’s surprise is that she’s a tomboy and loves to fish, play softball, camp and ride horses. I think she looks a bit like Kristy Swanson too (you know, Buffy the Vampire Slayer; the movie, not the TV show, which was played by Sarah Michelle Gellar). Kristy came out in a Raiderette uniform tonight. Looked pretty good in it too, although did anyone else notice her lollipop red tongue? Randy called it a 100% improvement from last week. Paula said she was back, the song choice was good and she mentioned something about a pocket. I really haven’t figured out what she means when she mentions the pocket. Simon called it a huge improvement, but didn’t really know what type of singer she was. He suggested country and said that she’s got real potential, which is Simon-speak for “you’re hot.” She did mention that she was sick last week and said she was on 5 antibiotics for the flu. C’mon, FIVE antibiotics? If that were true, she’d be 1) bacteria resistant to all antibiotics now and 2) had diarrhea or 3) a yeast infection. I think Kristy will survive tomorrow but will have to step up to keep going on.

06 – Amanda Overmyer, Carry On My Wayward Son (Kansas)

Amanda came out looking like Cruella DeVille tonight. Last week she reminded me of Elvira, this week, 101 Dalmations. What’s up for next week? Ursula, the sea witch from “The Little Mermaid?” Amanda’s got a gravelly voice, but it didn’t match the song tonight. Came off as shouting and was not good at all. Randy said it wasn’t the right song choice because there was way too much melody (whatever that means). Paula said she’s got some moves and that she should just do what feels right. Simon said it felt contrived, indulgent, not natural and even called it an ugly song. But when they flashed to her family in the audience, her mom is hot. Like Bo Bice’s mom hot. So Amanda can stay. But she probably won’t. I think she’s in the bottom 3 and may be gone tomorrow night.

07 – Alaina Whitaker, Hopelessly Devoted To You (Olivia Newton-John)

Her surprise is that she can’t have her food touching on her plate. I’ve actually encountered this before. There was a guy who was a friend of a co-worker at the Bulls that was the same way. We’d go to a soul food restaurant west of the United Center and he’d have to have everything separate. Chicken, collared greens, mashed potatoes, etc. It was a sight to see. Alaina’s problem was that this is such a classic song that the changes she made to it did nothing for me. She’s a cute girl though. I think she’s a card carrying member of the Sexy Gap Tooth Society, along with Madonna, David Letterman, Lauren Hutton, Michael Strahan and Shannon Meyer. Randy said the verses were really rough. Paula said she forgets how young and mature Alaina is and that she did a real good job. Can’t remember if she mentioned a pocket here though. Simon said he likes her, but she was old fashioned tonight. Called her a dark horse. I think she was bottom 4 tonight though and has a chance to be out tomorrow.

08 – Alexandrea Lushington, If You Leave Me Now (Chicago)

I love Chicago, but it’s mostly their newer stuff from Chicago 16 on. I think their album “Greatest Hits 1982-1989” really covered all that I knew and liked about them. This song was hard because Peter Cetera has such a distinctive voice that it’s hard for someone else to sing it. Much like Journey and Steve Perry (and Randy Jackson, I guess) has their own sound. I loved Cetera when he went solo too, especially with the Karate Kid, Part II song (Glory of Love) and the duet with Amy Grant (The Next Time I Fall). So it was all wrong for Alexandrea tonight. Even her sk8r4life outfit was odd. I like her, but she didn’t represent very well tonight. Randy called it a boring choice and it was so safe for her. Paula said she did her own arrangement. Simon said the song was absolutely stuck in its own time period and couldn’t be updated. I hope Alexandrea makes it through, but she may be in the bottom two tomorrow night.

09 – Kady Malloy, Magic Man (Heart)

Her surprise is that she sings opera. But does she sing it like Adam Sandler’s Opera Man? That’s the real question. I think Kady looks a bit like Anna Nicole Smith. But this song tonight was a complete mess. She was totally off the tune from the get go. But her Zen-garden top was kinda cool. Randy said she never found the pitch. Paula said when she powered it sounded great. Simon said he was very frustrated with her because she’s great on tape but then it doesn’t translate to the stage. I think that she’ll be better off as a reporter like Kimberly Caldwell or Matt Rogers. Kady should be in the bottom 4 and possibly be gone tomorrow.

10 – Asia’h Epperson, All By Myself (Eric Carmen/Celine Dion)

Her surprise is that she grew up cheerleading. Can’t wait to see her spirit fingers and jazz hands. You could tell she was sick tonight because it was almost like she was saving her voice (or it could be that her sickness made her lose control on the lower notes) for the big notes. I thought she ended well though. Randy said she gets the award for the highest degree of difficulty. Paula said she brought it home. Simon said she wasn’t a good enough singer to pull this song off and that she should know her limitations. I think that she would’ve done better had she not been sick. I really like Asia’h. She looked great with the straight hair tonight too. I think she’s safe to the final 12.

Bottom four – Kady, Amanda, Alaina, Alexandrea

Top two – Carly, Brooke

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

AI7 recap, Semi-finalists, Guys x 10 (02/26)

So it’s ‘70s Classics tonight. Interesting. And the contestants tell you something that you might not have known about them.

At the outset, two things struck me tonight. One, that the band director (Ricky Minor) looks a lot like former NBA head coach and current assistant coach Alvin Gentry. Two, that Simon kept doing the half-antlers during all of his comments. That reminds me of a drinking game we used to play when I was younger (way younger, as I’ve got my 20th high school reunion this year!). Don’t know if any of you remember it, but it was called “Thumper.” You’d sit in a circle and everyone had a “sign.” You could do the antlers or thumb your nose or flip the bird, etc. You’d start the game and someone would do their sign and someone else’s sign. That person then had to do their sign then someone else’s. You’d proceed until someone messed up and they’d have to drink. Pretty sophisticated stuff, I know. I was pretty good at this game (meaning I hardly ever messed up). Not that I should be that proud of it. But then again, it was survival for me, as I’m a lightweight and couldn’t drink much anyway. You could also play this game with sounds instead of signs, which, when drinking was involved, could add to the difficulty factor. But don’t get me wrong, I wasn’t much of a drinker then, nor am I now. It may have to do with the fact that I get the “Asian Beer Rash” when I drink. Many of you on this list know of that phenomenon. Basically I turn beet red when I drink. That usually discourages an underage kid from drinking, especially if his mother knows that happens. J

01 – Michael Johns, Go Your Own Way (Fleetwood Mac)

The Aussie said he is an avid tennis player. Easy, Pat Cash. Remember him with those sweet checkered headbands he used to wear? Michael did okay with this song. He has a good voice (but then again, just about everyone in the semis has a good voice), but this definitely wasn’t his strongest performance. I think Michael’s mic technique will start to bug me soon. And he hops a lot, like someone gave him a hotfoot or something. Randy said it wasn’t his best, but he liked it and he has a good tone. Paula said he was charismatic and charming and got the whole crowd working. Simon said it was okay and he was coasting along. The ladies love Aussies, so Michael should be safe Thursday night. Actually I think he’s a lock for the final 12.

02 – Jason Castro, I Just Want To Be Your Everything (Andy Gibb)

His secret is that he’s horrible at interviews. And his blooper tape proved it. The ladies love him though. I guess playing the guitar is his thing, as he did it again this week. My wife Kristin asked if it reminded me of Johnny Bravo (Greg Brady). I said no, but I’ll bet the girls would love to rip his shirt off! I actually liked him better this week than last week. But people loved him last week for some reason. Randy said it’s all cool with the guitar, but his vocals weren’t great. Paula wants to see him without his guitar next week. Simon called the song horrible and that it didn’t suit his voice. Regardless, I think Jason’s safe Thursday night and also into the final 12.

03 – Luke Menard, Killer Queen (Queen)

His secret is that he toured with an a cappella group called “Chapter Six.” And he said singing a cappella is not like having a band behind you. Um, yeah. I got that. Luke, take a drink for overstating the obvious. I thought Luke looked like the father from “Field of Dreams” and Tony Romo, but Sarah Royalty Tredo said he’s a dead ringer for Orlando Bloom. I see that too. Thanks, Sarah! And Seacrest called him “Dawson’s Creek” at the end of his song. I see that too. Definitely Dawson-hair, but just darker. I thought this was very Broadway and he also gave a lot of smoldering looks into the camera, a la Constantine. Randy said the degree of difficulty was there because it was a tough song and all and all it was pretty good. Paula called him great vocally. Simon thought it was a mistake because it lacked charisma and personality and it came off as whiny. When we watched it back, my wife Kristin couldn’t help but think it sounded like some kids song. About a half hour later she figured it out. You parents may recognize it, but it sounds like a song from the “Little People” videos. One that Sonya Lee (the Asian-looking one) sings. I think Luke is in trouble Thursday night. Definitely bottom 4 and maybe off the show.

04 – Robbie Carrico, Hot Blooded (Foreigner)

Robbie likes to drag race cars. How nice. So the faux rocker does a lite rock version of Hot Blooded. This is a high energy song and Robbie just doesn’t do it for me. Plus he reminds me of Seth Green, so I can’t shake that either. Robbie reminds me of his character Kenny “Special K” Fisher in “Can’t Hardly Wait.” Do you realize that Seth Green also played Patrick Dempsey’s little brother in “Can’t Buy Me Love?” I just saw the modern day remake of that movie called “Love Don’t Cost a Thing” with Nick Cannon and Christina Milian. Exact same plot, just updated (ie, she wrecked her mom’s Escalade instead of spilling wine on her mom’s leather outfit). I still prefer the original, but this wasn’t a wasted movie out of the Netflix queue. Randy said it was just okay and that the rock thing just isn’t his thing. Paula said he played it a little safe. Simon told him not to get defensive over their opinions of him and that actually the vocals were okay tonight. Robbie should be in the bottom 4 and possibly in the bottom 2. If he squeaks by on Thursday, he’ll definitely be gone next week.

05 – Danny Noriega, Superstar (The Carpenters)

Danny’s secret was that he was in a punk rock band (that sucked and they only played one gig). My wife Kristin thought he was flat and pitchy and that he’s really a better singer than he portrayed tonight. I still do like Danny though. Votefortheworst.com has adopted Danny as their poster boy. Randy said there were problems with his vocals tonight and that he could’ve sped it up a little and that he lost control of the song. Paula said he has amazing vocal skills, but he just needs to perform. Simon said it was better than last week but that he was over concentrating on the song. But what he likes about Danny is that he stands out in the crowd and he’s interesting and looks good on camera. Danny reminds us of Ross the Intern on Jay Leno, if any of you have seen that bit. Over the top, but in a way that works for both of them because it’s who they are. Danny may be in the bottom 4 on Thursday. I do hope he stays a bit longer though.

06 – David Hernandez, Papa Was A Rollin’ Stone (The Temptations)

His surprise was that he was a gymnast as a youngster. He doesn’t have the strongest voice, but this sure was a nice performance. Probably my 2nd or 3rd favorite of the night (way behind David Archuleta’s). He controlled the performance and hit some great notes. You could tell he believed in what he as doing up there. Randy said that was the David Hernandez they fell in love with and that he put it down. Paula said his voice was so pure (has she heard David Archuleta?) and that some notes were amazing tonight. Simon called it the best vocal of the night so far, which is like saying Janet is the sanest of the Jacksons. It’s all relative since the first half of the show was average at best. I’m glad David did well tonight. He should be safe on Thursday, but he’ll have to impress again next week to make the final 12.

07 – Jason Yeager, Long Train Running (The Doobie Brothers)

Jason mentions that he plays multiple instruments (piano, drums and guitar) and the proceeds to sing with playing anything. Maybe playing an instrument would slow down his horrific dancing. Um, white man’s overbite alert! He reminded me of Kevin James in “Hitch.” I kept waiting for Will Smith to come up and say, “this is your home base. Keep it here.” My wife Kristin thinks he has a nice voice, but I think he’s just a bad performer. He’s got a cheesy smile and weird points into the crowd. But that actually might work in theater, where cheesiness could blend with the acting. And I know I’ve said Jason looks like Chet, the older brother, in “Weird Science,” but I think he also looks a tad like the pre-HGH (allegedly) Roger Clemens. Randy called him pitchy and karaoke. Paula said she liked seeing the fun side of him, but the song choice didn’t have many notes in it so he couldn’t show off his range. Simon said the simple truth was that it was awkward and ordinary. I agree. He’s almost assuredly gone on Thursday night.

08 – Chikezie, I Believe To My Soul (Donny Hathaway)

Chikezie’s secret is his name is pronounced differently than he’s accepting it pronounced right now. He accepts the incorrect pronunciation because it’s just easier. Like a guy who used to work for TAP. His name was Steve Isaki (ee-saw-kee) but everyone would pronounce it (eye-saw-kee) and it quickly became “ice hockey” which then morphed into his nickname being “Puck.” Anyway, Chikezie is a Nigerian name for something that I scribbled down but can’t read right now. And it’s too late to back to the TiVo to figure it out. Sorry. Chikezie came out dressed like Boyz II Men and did much better than last week. In the words of my wife Kristin, “he let go.” Randy said Chikezie is back and that he was blazin’. Paula called it brilliant and fun. Simon said he looked better and sounded better. Just a little aside, but until Elliott Yamin sang his praises two years ago, I had no idea who Donny Hathaway was. Chikezie should be safe on Thursday.

09 – David Cook, All Right Now (Free/Stanfurd Band)

David’s secret is that he’s a word nerd. I think his secret is that he’s a thinner, blonder Jack Black. So, I hate this song. I hate the Stanfurd Band (as do most of their fans) and this is their de facto fight song. How ironic is it that the Stanfurd Band is a bunch of alcoholic druggies that don’t march or do formations and the Cal Band wears traditional uniforms and prides itself on their marching and formations? Well, David Cook doesn’t have to answer questions about the authenticity of HIS rock. He really makes Robbie Carrico look bad on the rocker scale. This song really matched his voice, and I like him, but he’s got the Chris Sligh thing going on. He’s older and I think he’s putting a lot of thought into how to win this competition and is very calculating in his song choices. It’s hard to explain, but he’s not the breath of fresh air that David Archuleta is. I think David’s very talented though and should definitely be in the top 12. Randy called him a real rocker. Paula called him the real deal and dropped her word for the season, “relevant,” on him. Simon called him solid and believable but said he has no personality. Which prompted David to spar with him saying that he didn’t have to win Simon over, but the fans. Simon got his nose pushed out of shape for his comeuppance and had to try to save face. Way to check your ego at the door, Simon. David’s safe on Thursday.

10 – David Archuleta, Imagine (John Lennon)

His secret was that he attended the finale for Season One when he was 11 and they have tape of him singing in a lobby for Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarini. He had an amazing voice then and Kelly totally reacted to him. The word on the street is that David (among others) isn’t really undiscovered talent. He won the 2003 Star Search title (beating fellow semi-finalist Alexandrea Lushington in the process). And reading some things on the Net, his mother is from Honduras, which may explain his mixed-background looks. I think he actually looks like fellow recapper Mike Rico’s younger brother Todd, when Todd was a kid. Anyway, it’s no secret that I love David Archuleta. His voice is so pure. He made my wife Kristin cry tonight with this performance. He may not win it all (because the best singer doesn’t always win this competition), but he’s already won a recording contract with someone when this is over. That much is for sure. Randy said yo dog, that was the best vocals he’s every heard on this show. Paula said he was ridiculous and that was one of the most moving performances she’s ever heard. Simon said the song choice was risky, but it worked out and that he’s going to be very hard to beat. I can’t see David losing this competition or being in the bottom two until the finals, when there are only 2 left.

Bottom four: Jason Yeager, Luke Menard, Robbie Carrico, Danny Noriega

Top four: David Archuleta, David Cook, David Hernandez, Chikezie

Thursday, February 21, 2008

AI7, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 12 (02/20)

I hope this new font does away with those missing characters in the e-mails that I send out.

So I really hate this ‘60s theme. And can Ryan Seacrest get any more annoying when he over EMPHASIZES certain words?

Let’s get right into it, because it’s late…

01 – Kristy Lee Cook, Selma, OR (Rescue Me)

So she trains horses back in Oregon and the story goes that she sold her best barrel horse to have enough money to go to audition. I don’t know how true that really is because I was reading somewhere that she actually signed with a record label in 2001. She’s been described as a blonde Brooke Shields, although I think she may look like a younger Kyra Sedgwick. She’s eye candy, but nothing special. Pleasant voice, but it was probably because I was listening with my eyes instead of my ears. Randy said it wasn’t her best and she had some pitch problems. Paula said it was tough because she’s been sick and she was the first one on stage. Simon said the song didn’t suit her and that she didn’t belt it out. Called the performance robotic. I hope she makes it through, but she could be on the bubble tomorrow night.

02 – Joanne Borgella, Hoboken, NJ (I Say A Little Prayer)

In her bio she says she’s a plus size model. Or, as I like to call her, a mini-Mandisa. She was the one who go through last with that girl Cardin. I have to tell you, whenever I hear this song I think of the Rupert Everett version in “My Best Friend’s Wedding.” So this one didn’t hold a torch to Rupert’s. That scene in the restaurant always cracks me up. Especially when the guy in the lobster outfit is waving his hands, er, claws to the beat of the song. And his intro to set up the song kills me too. Randy said it was pretty good but also shaky in parts. Paula said it was nerve racking and she liked it but didn’t love it. Simon didn’t like it at all. Called it a cabaret version. I get the feeling someone pissed in his Cheerios this morning. Joanne may be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

03 – Alaina Whitaker, Tulsa, OK (More Today Than Yesterday)

I think she looks like cross between Carrie Underwood and Bevin from One Tree Hill. Bevin Prince is her real name and she also played one of Sharpay’s friends in High School Musical 2. Yes, if you’re new to these recaps, I love me some high school programs, although my sister-in-law can’t seem to get me to start watching DeGrassi High. Alaina changed this song up a bit and she can definitely sing. She wore a pretty funky top though. One that I could see Lucy Liu wear on Cashmere Mafia (which I’ve come to like now too). Randy called it the year of the young ones (Alaina turns 17 tomorrow). Paula said it was a feel good song and she nailed it. Simon thinks she’s very good (read: he thinks she’s hot). He hated the song, but sees her sailing through after that performance. She should be safe tomorrow.

04 – Amanda Overmyer, Mulberry, IN (Baby Please Don’t Go)

Elvira alert! Amanda’s only 23, but she looks older. Maybe it’s her gravelly voice? She’s a hard core rocker though. She makes last year’s resident rocker, Gina Glocksen, look like Spandau Ballet. This song was on the Blue Chips soundtrack, but done by John Mellencamp. Anyways, Randy loved the bluesy rock version that Amanda did. Paula loves everything she does. Simon said he really likes her. Called her genuinely authentic and that she stands out in the crowd. But he didn’t recognize the song, which is odd because it was part of the British Invasion… Amanda should be safe tomorrow.

05 – Amy Davis, Lowell, IN (Where The Boys Are)

She’s a trade show model, but she reminds me of that Victoria’s Secret model, Frederique van der Wal. Must be the eyes. Her song was vanilla, boring and forgettable, but then again, it was okay because I think I was listening with my eyes again. Randy said it wasn’t great, she had pitch problems and mentioned something about scooping that I really couldn’t understand. Paula said the camera loves her (which really means she sucked), but it was lackluster and the nerves got to her. Simon said she looked great but didn’t sound great. He said it was a boring arrangement that didn’t work without a country twang. I think Amy’s in big trouble tomorrow night.

06 – Brooke White, Mesa, AZ (Happy Together)

So Brooke is a nanny and this was the same song that David Cook did last night. Brooke’s got a nice husky, folky sound to her voice. But she looks like she needs SP500 when she ventures outdoors though. She’s got a real natural, simple beauty to her. Randy thought it started rough, but then on the back part she got her slaying on (which confused Simon). Paula likes her originality. Simon thought she chose the right song but wants her to be less nice. It’s kinda weird though because he’s kinda flirting with her but she’s married and her husband was in the audience. I think she’s safe tomorrow.

07 – Alexandrea Lushington, Douglasville, GA (Spinning Wheel)

I don’t know who Alexandrea looks like. I wanna say Roxie Roker from The Jeffersons, but I may not be remembering her right. Or the comedienne, Adele Givens. Alexandrea gives a spirited performance to this song though. I like her. Randy said she blew the doors off. Paula said she took control of the entrance and whole performance. She also said she could hear that version on the radio today. Simon didn’t get it. Said the vocals weren’t great and called Paula on her “go to” radio comment. I still think Alexandrea is good for tomorrow night.

08 – Kady Malloy, Houston, TX (Groovy Kind of Love)

Kady’s so tan I think she looks like a surfer girl, but I don’t know where she’s surfing in Houston. Her song sounded like it could’ve been in a Disney movie. Take that for what it’s worth. I remember Phil Collins’ version of this song in the early ‘90s. Kady’s a pretty girl, but she makes some weird looking faces when she’s contemplating things at times. And she also kinds reminds me of the chubby Bush daughter. Randy thought the song was okay but it was too restrained and controlled. Paula wanted to see more life in her (like in her intro when she was imitating Britney Spears!). Simon thought it was like the night of the living dead. Then the judges proceeded to try to offer suggestions to her while I think she just wanted to get off the stage. Poor girl. I think she wasn’t horrible and should be safe tomorrow.

09 – Asia’h Epperson, Joplin, MO (Piece Of My Heart)

Asia’h’s been through quite a bit as her father passed away 2 days before her audition. She did a good job with this song. Randy loved it. Paula liked how she had fun up there and it had some good moments. Simon called it his favorite of the night because she has a good voice and she let go. She’s definitely safe for tomorrow.

10 – Ramiele Malubay, Miramar, FL (You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me)

She’s a sushi girl back in Florida. She’s got a pretty common Asian look. One that I could probably see at either Straits Café on Santana Row or at the 4. You pick. In the beginning this song always sounds to me like Hopelessly Devoted to You from Grease. This little girl has a big voice though. She mentioned Jasmine Trias in her audition. She puts Jasmine to shame. I think Ramiele is my favorite girl, along with Syesha. Randy said she took her time and built up the song. She made it very classy. Paula called her a force to be reckoned with. Simon admitted that he didn’t like her at first (it was probably because she said if Jasmine Trias can make it, so can she), but told her that she outsung every single person so far tonight. She should be safe tomorrow and I’ll say she should make it to the final 12.

11 – Syesha Mercado, Sarasota, FL (Tobacco Road)

I like Syesha. I think she has the whole package. Looks, voice and stage presence. Randy said she has a powerful voice and he really liked it. Paula called her consistent and joyful. Simon said it wasn’t her best, but she was probably one of the most talented of the girls. I think that’s a fair assessment. She should cruise to the final 12, along with Ramiele.

12 – Carly Smithson, San Diego, CA via Ireland (The Shadow of Your Smile)

She owns a tattoo shop in SD now and cops to the fact that she was signed to a record deal at the age of 15. Is it fair to have people who had records out before compete in this competition? Carly definitely has a big voice, but she needs a total makeover. Her hair is bad. I think there’s something wrong with her teeth too. Randy loved her, saying that’s what this show is all about and it was the best vocal so far this season. Paula called her the lucky coin in the pocket, as she’s old reliable. Not sure I’m following that analogy, but then again, does Paula ever make sense? Simon said he didn’t get it and that there is so much hype to Carly and he doesn’t see it. I’m not a big fan of hers either, but she does have a good voice.

So that’s it for now. I think:

Top 3 – Syesha, Ramiele, Asia’h

Bottom 3 – Amy, Joanne, Kady/Alaina

Seeing the girls tonight really made me feel like a guy’s gonna win this year.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

AI7, Semi-finalists, Guys x 12 (02/19)

So, they go with a theme night right out of the box (songs from the ‘60s). Usually they let the semi-finalists sing whatever they want, which I think is more fair, but whatever. Seacrest calls this bunch the “best talent ever,” which 1) they say every year and 2) will be trumped by next year’s crop.

Can I say that Ryan Seacrest is very, very, very lucky. He’s a twit by all accounts. No one likes him. Yet he’s mega famous for hosting this show. This show could run itself. Really anyone could introduce the contestants and feign a witty repartee with the judges. He just happened to get the golden ticket. Life’s funny that way.

Such is the same for Paula Abdul. She’s the one that they chose from the beginning. And, at first, her name carried her and added recognition to the show, since NO ONE knew who Randy or Simon was. But I can’t understand what she’s saying half the time. Or understand the point she is trying to make. As a matter of fact, tonight my wife Kristin pointed out on more than one occasion that the end of her sentence didn’t match how she began. I wish she were wittier. Or funnier. Something. Simon deserves an equal when it comes to put downs and banter back and forth. Paula is not a worthy (or is it wordy?) opponent. Not by a mile.

01 – David Hernandez, Glendale, AZ (Midnight Hour)

He reminds me a bit of last year’s contestant Rudy Cardenas. And a little like David Segura (from back home). His beginning was good, but then he faltered a bit in the middle and end. Overall has a nice voice and good control though. Randy said way to start it off. Paula called his vocals brilliant and said he had a perfect vibrato (which is different than most contestants who have a fast vibrato). Simon said it was better than he thought it would be, but told him to loosen up. I think he was okay. Middle of the road. Should be safe Thursday night.

02 – Chikezie, Inglewood, CA (More Today Than Yesterday)

The first male contestant to go by one name. Interesting. Have you ever played the name game? The one where you say a person/celebrity/sports figure and the next person has to say a person with the first initial in the first name from the first initial of the previous person’s last name? So, if I said Jason Kidd, you’d have to say someone with a first name starting with “K,” like Kevin Durant. Then you could said David Beckham, etc. We were playing once with sports personalities and someone said, let’s say, Willie Parker. I said, “Pele. Game over,” and walked out the door. Get it? Because Pele didn’t have a last name, much like Chikezie… Okay, stupid story. How about the suit Gary Coleman, er, Chikezie was wearing? It looked like it was out of Willie Wonka’s closet. My buddy Dante and I had a running joke that if we ever won the Excalibur Guild award at work (which entitles you to walk across the stage at our National Sales Meeting), we’d buy NBA Draft suits. You know those suits that the rookies wear on the night they get drafted. The 7 button, loud color, sometimes with pinstripes deals? Well, a broken clock is right twice a day and Dante and I finally did win the Excalibur award, but we tempered our enthusiasm and settled on just buying a new tie. Back to Chikezie. Randy called him an old fashioned singer and wanted him to make it fresh. Paula called him a throwback and loved his infectious smile. Simon hated the whole performance and called it corny and cheesy. I kind of agree with Simon, which is why I’m rocking the tie next month and not the new suit… I think Chikezie could be in trouble on Thursday.

03 – David Cook, Blue Springs, MO (Happy Together)

It’s funny, my wife Kristin and I have done 180s (or according to Jason Kidd, 360s) on David. I liked David in the auditions, but not so much now. She didn’t warm to him and now thinks he’s got a Daughtry-like feel to him. I think he worked the mike stand adequately tonight but I really thought he did a karaoke version of this song and totally played to the camera too much. Randy said he started weird but made it a rock joint, and added that “dawg, it was good.” Paula called it “worthy” of just praise. She was trying to be clever because Simon called his audition “a bit worthy” or “wordy” but he doesn’t remember the context in which he said it. Simon said he shouted a bit in the middle, but it was good and almost made it believable. I think David will be safe.

04 – Jason Yeager, Grand Prairie, TX (Moon River)

Jason’s son looks like Matt Damon and I think Jason looks a bit like Chet from Weird Science (Bill Paxton), which also makes him look like Ryan Leaf. He missed a note at the beginning of the song but has a nice voice. Song didn’t suit him though and that may be his downfall. Randy thought he lost his concentration a bit in the middle of the song. Paula said it reminded her of her first ballet recital. Simon thought it was much older and said it had a cruise ship feel to it. I agree. Jason’s on thin ice on Thursday.

05 – Robbie Carrico, Melbourne, FL (One)

He’s the boy bander turned rocker. He was in a band called Boyz N Girlz United and here a website dedicated to him (http://www.angelfire.com/me3/robbiecarrico/). Gotta love angelfire and those free webpages people created on that server. Robbie sure has changed his look, coming out with the long hair, beard, ‘do rag and prison issue grey jumpsuit. Randy said it moved him. Paula called it the perfect song for him. Simon said it was the only performance so far that was a current performance. I’m torn on Robbie. I think he’s a’ight, but he looks a bit like Seth Green and he’s no David Archuleta…

06 – David Archuleta, Murray, UT (Shop Around)

My wife Kristin said this is hot (but not like how Paris Hilton says it) and that it gave her chills. He’s got a silky smooth voice which belies his 17 years. It’s funny though, the USA Today guy didn’t like him. I thought he was head and shoulders better than everyone else and has a confidence when he’s singing, but a naivety and “aw shucks” personality when he’s not. Almost like Melinda from last year, but less obvious and more believable. I really think he’s awed by the crowds and judges. Without even hearing the girls, I’m proclaiming him to be the favorite. Randy is a big fan and said he was born with this gift of song. Paula called it a bold song choice and that he has a confident older soul. Simon simply said when you’ve got it, you’ve got it and David’s got it. I agree.

07 – Danny Noriega, Azusa, CA (Jailhouse Rock)

Came out in a nice Reservoir Dogs outfit (Mr. Pink anyone?). He really can sing, but this song didn’t really showcase his range. Randy said he knows how to have a good time. Paula called it very warm (he said he wanted to do something hot in his intro) and a safe song choice. Simon said it was verging on grotesque. I wouldn’t go that far, but I think it’s hard to have 18 year olds try to pick a song from the ‘60s that they might not be familiar with and have them try to make it their own. I think Danny’s safe on Thursday though.

08 – Luke Menard, Crawfordsville, IN (Everybody’s Talkin’)

I thought at first this guy looked like the dad in Field of Dreams but then the thought turned to Tony Romo, current quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys and ex-boyfriend of both Carrie Underwood and Jessica Simpson. It was funny how the media blamed Jessica Simpson for the fall of the Cowboys this year. Dan Patrick coined her Yoko Romo! My wife Kristin thought he withheld on this song and was too reserved. Randy said it was pitchy, consistently sharp. Paula didn’t feel it was the best song choice. Simon called it forgettable. I think he’s in trouble on Thursday night. He’ll probably be in the bottom 3. I hope he makes it through to redeem himself.

09 – Colton Berry, Staunton, VA (Suspicious Minds)

I thought he looked like William Zabka from Karate Kid fame but then he said that he gets Ellen DeGeneres a lot. What a tough person to look like! But at least he owns it. Randy said he did a pretty good job. Paula said it was nice to see a different side of him. Simon said it was okay and not quite as bad as the other Elvis song. I think Colton’s safe for Thursday, but won’t make it to the final 12.

10 – Garrett Haley, Elida, ID (Breaking Up Is Hard To Do)

This poor kid is overmatched. He was nasal and pitchy and was really the only one that didn’t look like he belonged tonight. When they did the closeups he looked and even sounded like a girl. Like he could be Barbara Mandrell’s daughter. Yes, he does look like Leif Garrett. And Peter Frampton. Randy said he didn’t do anything with the song. Paula said the slow tempo brought the performance down. Simon called it boring and whiny. He’s definitely in the bottom 3 and should be put out of his misery.

11 – Jason Castro, Rockwall, TX (Daydream)

Dude’s got pretty eyes, which I bet the chicks dig. Nice voice, but I didn’t think it was that great of a song choice. Randy liked the accent but said he had pitch problems. Paula said it blew her away and it was the right song choice. Simon called it in the top 2 performances and that he “gets it.” I thought it was better than most, but not really deserving of that much praise. Jason’s definitely safe on Thursday.

12 – Michael Johns, Buckhead, GA by way of Australia (Light My Fire)

I now think Michael looks like a cross between Tim Daly (Wings, Private Practice) and Ian Michael Black. He did okay with this song, but my wife Kristin thinks he’s better than this song. Randy likes him because he throws all caution to the wind. Paula called it an excellent way to end the night. Simon called him the most consistent contestant and that he has the natural charisma of a lead singer, which is high praise from him. I think he’s safe for Thursday and into the top 12.

Top 3 – David Archuleta, Michael Johns and Jason Castro

Bottom 3 – Garrett Haley, Luke Menard, Jason Yeager/Chikezie

These guys are definitely the strongest guys the competition has ever had. And the shortest. Ryan Seacrest actually looks tall compared to some of them.

And Dancing With The Stars just announced their 12 new celebs which include Kristi Yamaguchi, Penn Gillette, Adam Carolla, Marlee Matlin, Monica Seles, Jason Taylor, Shannon Elizabeth and Priscilla Presley. I love that show.

Saturday, February 16, 2008

AI7 recap, The Auditions/Hollywood/Final 24

I’m baaaaaaaaaaack. I have to admit, I didn’t get to see all of the auditions (which isn’t necessarily a bad thing). This is going to sound real lame, but I actually missed the first audition because I didn’t set my TiVo to record it. You see, we switched TiVos since the last season ended. And when you don’t already have a show set to record, you have to wait for it to come up on the scheduler again (I’m anxiously awaiting the return of “Burn Notice” on USA). The scheduler only goes two weeks out so I totally forgot to add AI back to the priority list.

So, what’s new in the Ura household? Three words. Korean Soap Operas. Although I think the Koreans refer to them as “dramas” and not “soap operas.” So these things are huge in Hawaii. And they’ve made their way to California. My mother-in-law broke her foot last year and one of Kristin’s aunties sent some of the Korean Dramas to help her pass the time. Well, she got hooked. And so did my father-in-law. They watch until all hours of the night. My wife and sister-in-law thought they were crazy. Until winter break a few months ago. My sister-in-law got hooked. And so did my wife. If you’ve never seen a Korean Drama, they all loosely follow the same skeleton plot. Here are some of the basic “rules” for the dramas:

There is always a love triangle of some sort.

The rich guy always falls for the poor girl (or vice versa), to the disapproval of his/her mother.

There is usually some sort of serious illness that is never fully explained.

If you fall, you automatically get hospitalized.

Amnesia is a common theme.

There is usually a father who is a gambling drunk.

There is always an over the top guy who thinks he’s funny, but isn’t.

The music is very well done to fit the flow of the show, and the songs will stay in your head forever.

When one episode is done, you must continue watching another one. Even if it’s 3:00AM.

Whenever two people need to talk, they go to a restaurant and do it over tea.

Anyway, my wife limits herself to starting these shows on business trips because she’s an insomniac on the road and is up anyway. It takes over her life when she’s watching them. Usually these dramas take place over what we’d consider one season. Instead of shows continuing season after season like the popular ones do in the US, these shows last about 20 episodes. It’s nice closure for those watching the DVDs.

My in-laws have learned some basic Korean phrases now. And they know the actors and actresses by name now. Yes, it’s scary. I’d get hooked but every time I try to watch one, I fall asleep. We just got a new TV for our bedroom (because I felt bad that my wife had to read the subtitles on our old 20” set, circa 1995) so that my wife could read the subtitles better but when my head hits the pillow, it’s only a matter of time before I’m nodding off and missing things.

So that’s it for now. That and I’ve had a recent revelation about the people who drive certain cars. Have you noticed that probably 50-75% of the Lexus RX350s are Asian women? And I’m willing to bet that of that 50-75%, 90% of those also drove an Acura Integra in the ‘90s. Just an observation.

So, like always, if you’re not watching the show this season and want to taken off the distribution list, please let me know. No hard feelings.

Now, onto the final 24. I’ll put little blurbs about them. There was nothing really remarkable about the auditions, except for the fact that there some decent singers that they didn’t let through to Hollywood. But that happens every year.

The few that stood out that didn’t make it were that kid Josiah who dismissed the band and sang “Stand By Me” a cappella. I’m so glad he didn’t make it through. Honestly, how could he have gone on after treating the band that way? And the Abstinence girl Amy Flynn. Cute girl, but in her own little world. Kinda glad she didn’t make it through.

Alaina Whitaker (16) Tulsa, OK – don’t remember her. Cute girl though.

Alexandrea Lushington (16) Atlanta, GA – don’t remember her either.

Amanda Overmyer (23) Mulberry, IN – She’s the nurse/rocker chick. My she looks older than 23. Interesting voice, but I think she’s going to be limited in what she can sing. You really have to be a versatile singer to win this competition, which really isn’t that fair, but it’s how it’s set up.

Amy Jean Davis (25) Cedar Lake, IN – Don’t remember her.

Asia’h Epperson (19) Joplin, MO – This is not all that favorable, but she reminds me of Wanda Sykes, but better looking (which isn’t that hard to do).

Brooke White (24) Van Nuys, CA/Mesa, AZ – Very earthy girl. Beautiful blue eyes to contrast her pale skin. Interesting voice. She was a mess when they announced the top 24.

Carly Smithson (24) Dublin, Ireland – Wait a minute, can a foreigner win “American” Idol? She’s an interesting one. Would’ve gone to Hollywood a few years back but had Visa problems. Nice voice. Flat hair though.

Chikezie Eze (22) Inglewood, CA – Don’t remember him (do you see a common theme here?). Kinda looks like Marques Johnson.

Colton David Berry (17) Staunton, VA – He was the last one through and sat there with Kyle Ensley (the Chicken Little with a better voice guy). I actually liked Kyle. He was weird, but cool and true to himself. Did a decent job with the Josh Groban song. Colton reminds me of Billy Zabka, of Karate Kid/Cobra Kai fame. Zabka also played the bad guy in “Just One of the Guys,” that movie where the girl played a guy to prove a point about a journalism story. Joyce Hyser was her name and she really did nothing after that movie. Anyway, this guy kinda gives me the creeps. Don’t know why.

Danny Norriega (18) Azusa, CA – Or is it Dani? I actually thought he was a chick when I saw him in his Hollywood audition because he was wearing those tapered jeans. Nice voice though.

David Archuleta (17) Salt Lake City, UT – Wow this kid has an awesome voice. My family thinks he’s already the front runner to win it all. He’s young, but doesn’t have a boy band sound. And he seems like an unaffected, nice kid. I’m already pulling for him.

David Cook (25) Tulsa, OK – Another rocker dude. I like him. I think he’ll be this year’s Chris Sligh. The guy who doesn’t buy into the hype of the show. Knows it’s a competition and will be calculating in his song choices. My wife says he reminds her of Jack Black (I’m sure he’ll love that comparison!).

David Hernandez (24) Phoenix, AZ – I thought his first Hollywood song was great. Good looking guy. May contend for Mike Rico’s first Mexican-American Idol.

Garrett Haley (17) Elida, OH – Is this Leif Garrett’s son? Don’t remember him, but his look is unforgettable.

Jason Castro (20) Rowlett, TX – Don’t remember him singing. Love the dreads. Unless you’re close enough to get a whiff of them…

Jason Yeager (28) Grand Prairie, TX – Don’t remember him, other than he cried when he got through.

Joanne Borgella (25) Hoboken, NJ – She was the last girl through and sat with Cardin McKinney. My wife thinks Joanne had the stronger voice. Cardin looks like a young Zoe from Cashmere Mafia (Frances O’Connor, who not so famously played Brendan Fraser’s love interest in that forgettable movie “Bedazzled”).

Kady Malloy (18) Houston, TX – Very cute girl. Don’t remember her though.

Kristy Lee Cook (24) Selma, OR – Another cutie. Looks better with curly hair. When she had the straight hair, she looked like Mariel Hemingway.

Luke Menard (29) Crawfordsville, IN – No recollection.

Michael Johns (29) Los Angeles, CA – Isn’t he too, a foreigner (Australian)? Do I sound xenophobic? A foreigner can’t win OUR “American” Idol! I really like this guy’s voice, although he does look a bit like Ian Michael Black, from “Ed” and also all those Celebrity Poker Showdowns on Bravo.

Ramiele Malubay (20) Miramar, FL – The big voice in the tiny package. She might have rubbed some people the wrong way when she proclaimed that if Jasmine Trias can make it, so can she. Her full name is Ramiele Macrowon Malubay. Can you get any more Pinay? I like her though.

Robbie Carrico (26) Melbourne, FL – Another rocker dude. I liked his voice and his presentation.

Syesha Mercado (21) Miami, FL – If she keeps her head on straight (and keeps her voice), she’s a serious threat to win this thing too. She looks like a model with her hair and looks. Strong voice. She may be my favorite for the girls.

That’s it. I’ll try to bang these things out starting next week. I may miss a few weeks here and there but I’m sure Mike Rico will step up to pinch hit as he did last year. Thanks again, Mike.