Tuesday, April 27, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 6 (04/27/10)

Tim is gone! Although I didn’t see it. Seriously, 24 minutes over? I set my DVR for 10 minutes past. 24? Ridiculous. My DVR cut out as they started talking to Elton John. Didn’t get to see Tim go, but I hear they didn’t have him sing again.

Did anyone else notice how horrible some of the acts sounded live? Thought the Black Eyed Peas sounded rough.

This week is Shania Twain week. She sure has aged, but it’s nice to see that she hasn’t enhanced herself to keep her from aging (or maybe she has but it’s not overly noticeable to me). She reminds me a bit of Jaclyn Smith. So this is kinda country week, but Shania was such a crossover artist that maybe the contestants are getting a free pass this week. And I’m definitely getting a free pass, as usually when they get down to 6, the contestants sing 2 songs each. What a treat to only hear 6 songs!

01 – Lee, You’re Still The One
Can’t emphasize enough how much I enjoy listening to Lee’s voice. He can sing any song and it will sound different because of that voice. Randy thought he did a pretty good job. Ellen echoed my take by saying every song he sings, he makes it his own (referring to his voice). Kara thinks he’s come a long way since the start of the show and Simon thought it was absolutely the perfect song out of Shania’s catalog for him. I liked Lee tonight and think he should be safe tomorrow.

02 – Michael, It Only Hurts When I’m Breathing
I didn’t know this song, but in the Idol Chatter recaps it says it’s from the movie Up. I know Up was a pretty good movie and did well with the critics, but I didn’t really like it that much. I had no idea what it was about but it was more serious (and scary) than I imagined. My kids hated it. Add to the fact that we paid for it to be in 3D and it wasn’t in 3D and I was really put off. When Big Mike sings, it always reminds me of the scene in “Coming to America” when the big bodyguard sings at Eddie Murphy’s wedding ceremony a cappella. You just don’t expect that voice to come out of that big guy. And my wife Kristin always mentions Nell Carter when he sings. Randy thinks he hit his zone. Ellen thought it felt like Luther Vandross. Kara likes how he always connects to his songs. Simon called it “wet,” which didn’t make a whole lot of sense. And I think Big Mike’s wife owns stock in a sparkly eye shadow company. Regardless of the judges comments, I think Mike is in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

03 – Casey, Don’t
Didn’t know this song. Thought Casey did a good job with it, but I wasn’t wowed like some of the judges were. Randy thought it was one of the best Casey James performances. Ellen thought it was his best to date. Simon thought it was his best performance so far and suggested he give Shania a big kiss, which he did. Way to hook him up, Simon! I thought it was good, but not great. Seems like he’ll be safe tomorrow. But who knows?

04 – Crystal, No One Needs To Know
This performance went country to the opposite extreme. Instead of crossing over, Crystal went Emmet Otter’s Jug Band on us. Does anyone remember Emmet Otter’s Jug Band Christmas? Came out in 1977, right about the same time we got cable in Watsonville. I remember it being on HBO. I may get that for our kids next Christmas! I also remember “Not Necessarily The News” and the “sniglets” for some reason. I thought this was an okay song, but it clearly meant something to her (her boyfriend was in the audience). I’m guessing the lyrics suggest that she’s ready to get married but her boyfriend isn’t. She’s planning things, but no one needs to know right now. Interesting… Randy was glad that someone did an actual country version of a Shania song. Ellen said it was not her favorite performance, but likened it to your least favorite color of the rainbow (which I guess is still good). Kara said it is impossible for Crystal to not be good. Simon got to the point (which the others danced around) and said “we didn’t like Crystal tonight.” Crystal may be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. I just hope she gets through this week. It was one of her weakest weeks, but she’s still the best in the competition. How sad would it be if she got voted off tomorrow and the judges don’t have the save left because they wasted it on Big Mike? I hope that doesn’t happen…

05 – Aaron, You’ve Got A Way
I was like, I know this song. And my wife Kristin said you better remember it. It’s on our wedding video! I honestly didn’t know this was a Shania Twain song. But I do love this song. My kids started watching our wedding video a few years back (and we’d get the questions like, “why aren’t we in the video?”). And they also don’t recognize their uncle Kevin (Kristin’s younger brother). He’s a drummer and has dreds down to his butt now. In our wedding video he has short black hair. He kinda looks a bit like Troy Polamalu now. Anyway, Aaron sang it well, except for 1, maybe a few, sour notes. Randy thought this was in his wheelhouse. Ellen thought the emotion and depth were there. Kara noted that he changed a line about making love. And Aaron explained that he was singing to his mother (and that made my wife Kristin cry a little). Simon thought it was sincere and believable. Here comes a shocker. I think Aaron’s gone tomorrow. A country singer getting booted on country week. Believe it.

06 – Siobhan, Any Man Of Mine
What was Siobhan wearing tonight? Didn’t really dig the floral dress/mini and that leather upper lederhosen thing going on. And my wife Kristin hated her spider necklace (she’s afraid of bugs). Randy loved it, especially the whole punk-country thing. Kara said she’s back. Simon doesn’t like country, but liked that song. I still believe Siobhan is safe tomorrow, especially since they gave her the pimp (last) spot.

Overall, I love Shania Twain, but I never like country week. I’m sort of glad they did it with only the final 6 so that I didn’t have to endure more country than necessary. I was a bit bored by the whole week. I’m hoping it picks up next week (and that Crystal is safe!).

Bottom 3: Aaron, Big Mike, Casey

Off: Aaron

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 7 (04/20/10)

So I was partly right last week. Andrew off and Katie in bottom 3. Missed Big Mike being in bottom 3 and Tim not. Totally fine with both of those being voted off. Now to get Tim and Big Mike off…

Songs of Inspiration week with Alicia Keys as the mentor. How good looking is Alicia Keys? And she looks so different with her different hair styles. Her intro showed like 7 different looks. She’s a little like pre-whack job Whitney in her chameleon-like appearances. Alicia reminds me a little bit of the older sister in the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air (Hilary, played by Karyn Parsons). What ever happened to her? She was in “Class Act” with Kid n Play (although they weren’t Kid and Play in that movie) and “Major Payne” with Damon Wayans, but not much on her bio after that. And of course we’re hit over the head that tomorrow night is an elimination and Idol Gives Back. Set your DVRs to go long, as Seacrest thinks they might. They went over tonight too. Luckily I was watching it live.

01 – Casey James, Don’t Stop (Fleetwood Mac)
So last week I got a note from Connie Carrillo that she was watching AI with her anti AI husband and when Casey came on, he asked “why is he singing like Goat Boy (from Saturday Night Live)?” Lovely. I mentioned to my wife Kristin tonight that he really sounds like Huey Lewis (and sang “Power of Love” a few weeks ago) and she quickly replied with, Huey Lewis with a fast vibrato. And she even added that at the end of the song he sang “baaaaaaaack.” Dude can’t get a break around here! I said stop kidding… Anyway, Randy thought it was good, but not his best. Ellen thought the guitar playing was good but he’s been consistently good, but not great. Kara thought this was just “jam band,” and he made himself like everyone else. Simon thought it was a lazy song choice, with zero emotion and no originality. Casey could be in trouble for the first time tomorrow night.

02 – Lee DeWyze, The Boxer (Simon & Garfunkel)
I didn’t know this song, but my wife Kristin did and she kept doing this exploding sound during the la la la part and it startled me! I thought she was having a Tourette’s outburst. Regardless of me knowing this song or not, I thought Lee was really good tonight. Randy called him (Lee) a great artist. Ellen thought it was a beautiful song choice. Kara thought he had a moment tonight and complimented him on connecting with the song. Simon joked that even though they were only 2 singers in, it was the best of the night. He called it sincere, emotional and inspirational and mentioned that it could have been written a week ago. My wife Kristin kept waiting for one of the judges to say that he made the song “current,” and Simon didn’t disappoint. I think Lee should be safe tomorrow night.

03 – Tim Urban, Better Days (Goo Goo Dolls)
My wife Kristin thought Tim was extremely pitchy tonight. And one thing that she’s noticed is that when the former Idols come back, they get to wear those ear thingys that allows them to hear their voice better and usually cuts down on the pitchyness. What’s the downside of letting the contestants use them? They get better songs and less pitchy? Where’s the downside there? My wife Kristin (who was on a roll tonight) said Tim could be wearing those ear thingys and we wouldn’t know because he rocks that ‘70s haircut over the ears. Does he hang out with Eric, Kelso & Fez? But the sad part is, even if he was wearing those ear thingys he was still pitchy tonight. Randy thought it was just okay karaoke. Ellen called him the Soup of the Day and sometimes she likes it, but today she didn’t. Kara didn’t think the execution was the best tonight. Simon thought it was a let down from the last few weeks. My wife Kristin can’t believe the judges didn’t call him out for being pitchy. I actually think the judges aren’t being overly critical of Tim right now because I think they think the voters become more sympathetic to him when he’s judged harshly. My wife Kristin also called him this season’s Sanjaya. Ouch. Tim should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

04 – Aaron Kelly, I Believe I Can Fly (R. Kelly)
There’s a joke here somewhere. Young kid singing an R. Kelly song… When I think of this song, I think of 2 things. Space Jam and Glen Rice. Glen Rice used to sing this song before every game while he was with the Charlotte Hornets. He averaged 26.8 points per game that year (1996-97) and was the NBA All-Star Game MVP. And he looks like a taller version of Tony Gwynn. Back to Aaron. He’s got a real nice tone to his voice but I have a feeling that he’s too inexperienced (vocally) to succeed in this competition. His singing, tone and stage presence have improved tremendously throughout, but I have the feeling he doesn’t know music well enough to change things up and make songs original. Regardless of that deficiency, he will probably make a pretty good commercial artist though, as you don’t have to change things up and sing covers of songs. He’ll sing whatever original songs he has and will sing them well. Randy thought he picked a giant song and did okay with it. Ellen thought it was a tough song but he handled it well. Kara thought he got there by the end of the song. Simon would have turned the song off if he heard it on the radio, but said because Aaron was singing it (and everyone likes Aaron), it sounded better than it actually was. I think Aaron is safe tomorrow, but his ceiling is top 4.

05 – Siobhan Magnus, When You Believe (Whitney Houston/Mariah Carey duet)
I have to tell you, I was so distracted by Siobhan’s dress/outfit tonight. She looked like a fairy or a cast member from A Midsummer’s Night Dream. Beautiful dress, but the butterflies on the straps and the laces up her calves were a bit overwhelming. But that’s Siobhan. And that’s what I like about her. She’s not afraid to take on a Whitney song. Or a Mariah song. Or (gulp) a Whitney/Mariah duet. Siobhan did an admirable job with the song, but comparing to the original, it probably fell a bit short. Randy thought she picked the toughest song and did just okay. Ellen called it a confirmation of why she’s on the show. Kara thought it was sung technically well, but it sounded too much like a musical. Simon didn’t like the arrangement and mistook her butterflies for leaves. I think Siobhan might be in trouble tomorrow night. Probably not off, but maybe in the bottom 3.

06 – Michael Lynche, Hero (Chad Kroeger)
I didn’t know this song, but when he said he was singing “Hero,” I was wondering if it was Mariah Carey’s version or Enrique Iglesias’ and I was wrong on both accounts. I actually thought the song sounded like Seal’s “A Kiss from a Rose.” Anyway, wearing black tonight, Big Mike looked like the Michelin Man. He’s so enormous. Randy thought he held his own. Ellen said great job. It was not Kara’s favorite song and in parts it was unrecognizable to her. Simon thought he sang it well, but it felt artificial to him. I haven’t been on Mike’s bandwagon for quite sometime and I’m not boarding now. I think he’s in trouble tomorrow and won’t be saved it he goes.

07 – Crystal Bowersox, People Get Ready (Curtis Mayfield)
Wow. Crystal started a cappella and kept going. The only thing that bothered us was her mic stand. Then we found out at the end of the song that the mic stand was an antique that she’s used every performance until Idol. Crystal was in another world tonight. And she broke down and cried on the last notes of the song. She said later that it was because she saw her dad in the crowd and it was his first time at the show. Randy gave her a standing O. Ellen said she’s never looked so beautiful. Kara thanked her for singing without an instrument and said she took it to another level. Simon said she sang it fantastically and that she was in a different class tonight. And in the final recap of the singers, they showed Crystal singing the last words of the song and not crying. Lazy producers cut that from the rehearsals. I feel cheated somehow. Crystal should win this thing, but the best singer doesn’t always win. She’s already showed enough to have a successful career after this regardless.

Bottom 3: Tim, Michael, Casey

Off tomorrow: Tim

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 9A (04/13/10)

So they saved Big Mike last week. Shocking. I can’t believe that they used the save so early on. What if Crystal or Lee or Siobhan or Casey get booted in the next few weeks? I’m just not a fan of Michael’s. And what was up with all the instrumental accompaniments last week? A didgeridoo? Huh? I guess Ellen was able to get away with playing it on her show because she’s so manly… It really would be funny if Seacrest wore one of her outfits for one of the shows. But then that would be funny and that would go against all that is Seacrest.

So now instead of a Finalists x 8, you get a Finalists x 9A. And a double (ohhh) elimination tomorrow. Elvis Presley night tonight as the contestants go to Vegas and on the set of “Viva Elvis,” a Cirque du Soleil show at the ARIA hotel. Adam Lambert was the mentor this week, making him the first former contestant to be a mentor.

01 – Crystal Bowersox, Saved
She asked Adam if she should go with the acoustic or electric guitar and he recommended the electric. Crystal had a good time with this tonight, although she looked like a misguided girl scout, with a brown leather vest, floral print pants and a guitar strap that looked like a badge sash. And missing teeth and dreds. I was bummed that she went first tonight, as the first performance almost always gets lost in the shuffle at the end of the night. Randy liked her energy and called it dope (was he in “Bell Biv Devoe” too because I think they were the last people to utter that word). Ellen thought it was fantastic. Kara called it another solid performance and liked that it was up tempo. Simon liked that it didn’t fall into the karaoke trap that the Elvis theme will bring. Crystal is the only singer (and maybe Siobhan, although she’s been in a little rut lately) that I look forward to every week. I’d be shocked if she didn’t win this thing, but I’ve been wrong before. She’s safe tomorrow.

02 – Andrew Garcia, Hound Dog
Adam’s advice was that it was too boring and to make it more up tempo. Andrew came out with no guitar and also with no advice taken to heart. He didn’t change it up and kept it boring and dreary throughout. He sang behind the judges again this week, which really annoys me. The stage isn’t big enough to sing on it? You have to go into the crowd or behind the judges? Maybe he just didn’t want to sing and look at the disinterested faces of the judges. Randy called it not good karaoke. Ellen thought he pulled it off (pulled what off?). Kara didn’t think he owned it and used the mike as his crutch. Simon called it lazy and thought his coolness has been sucked out of him. What can I say? Andrew’s been horrible and the only reason he’s still around is because he has such a huge Internet/You Tube/Facebook following. The problem is that there are so many others that aren’t good either that he slides through every week. Andrew deserves to be gone tomorrow.

03 – Tim Urban, Can’t Help Falling In Love
Boy has this song been covered a lot. My two favorite versions are Corey Hart’s (from 1987) and Like the Tins (a folk version, on the “Some Kind of Wonderful” soundtrack; which is funny because I said Turban looks like Eric Stoltz from this same movie). Before the song, Seacrest was in the audience with his mom, who looked strangely like Cindy McCain and had a First Lady-like outfit on to boot. We let our kids stay up tonight since they don’t have school tomorrow and my wife Kristin was out at Bunko. Jared said that Tim looks like Luke Skywalker. Tim did his song with a guitar on a stool behind the judges table. Another singer behind the judges. I really wonder if the contestants conspire and do things together (like all the musical accompaniments and singing behind the judges)? I dozed off during this song (kidding). But it was a bit dreary. Tim reminds me of Jason Castro, minus the talent. Randy actually liked it. Ellen compared Tim to taking shots of tequila. Kara called it her favorite Tim performance ever (which cleverly wasn’t saying much). Simon said he went from zero to hero in 2 weeks. I actually don’t think Tim is getting better, he’s just not as bad as he’s been. As “good” as he was tonight, he still should be in the bottom tomorrow, if not one of the two gone.

04 – Lee DeWyze, A Little Less Conversation
Adam’s advice was to smile more and connect with the audience, as he’s not in the studio; he needs to perform. I’ve really come to like Lee over the course of the show. His voice is awesome. And he chose to sing on a stool, but in front of the judges (style points in my book). Real good performance tonight. I think he’s becoming a bit more comfortable in front of the audience and the judges. Randy said he’s definitely in the zone. Ellen said he made the song current. Kara said she’s never seen him go for it vocally like he did tonight. Simon called him on the money. Lee should be safe tomorrow. I like him to go to the final four, if not farther.

05 – Aaron Kelly, Blue Suede Shoes
I really like Aaron (and my daughter Kacey likes him too), but I just didn’t get it tonight. He has a great voice and nice control (especially in the second part of the song), but there was a disconnect for me. It wasn’t authentic or believable for me. Randy said the half time fit his voice better. Ellen didn’t think he got all the way there. Kara said it was out of his comfort zone and she liked it. Simon thought it was karaoke and out of a high school concert. I agree with Simon. Still, I don’t think it’s Aaron’s time to go yet.

06 – Siobhan Magnus, Suspicious Minds
Siobhan’s outfit was incredible tonight. She had a Sheena Easton hairdo, but reminded me of a female version of Jon Cryer’s character “Duckie” in “Pretty in Pink.” Her white outfit looked a little like the outfit that got red wine spilled on it in “Can’t Buy Me Love.” Her white outfit also had lightning bolts on it, which made me think of the “Greased Lightning” dream sequence in “Grease” too. Just odd, but that’s Siobhan. Randy liked the Supremes-ish intro, but though it came alive in the second part. Ellen also liked the second part better. Kara was getting confused with the 2 voices of Siobhan. Simon thought the first part was terrible and that she was very erratic. I actually liked the first part, but didn’t like what she did in the second half (slowing it down). Made it different, but I thought it lacked continuity. Regardless, I still like Siobhan but I think she’s lost some of her mojo the last few weeks. She should be safe tomorrow.

07 – Michael Lynche, In The Ghetto
How about the shot at Brian Dunkleman that Seacrest took? He was announcing that next week will be Idol Gives Back and that it would be shot at 2 different locations and Dunkleman would be at the Pasadena site. Psyche. Big Mike (lucky to be back) chose this song at Siobhan’s suggestion. Didn’t know it was pronounced “get-toe.” Randy thought it was hot. Ellen was glad they saved him. Kara said he sang it well. Simon said it was a million times better than last week. I’m guessing Michael will be safe tomorrow, but he could go at any time now.

08 – Katie Stevens, Baby What You Want Me To Do
Katie had so much bling going on that I thought she raided a Claire’s. I thought she did okay, but she really bugs me. She’s another case of her not being all that great, but she’s not as bad as some of the others. I think top 5 is her ceiling and she should probably go before that. Randy liked her getting all sassy. Ellen said it was a very horny song (she had 5 horn players up on stage with her). Kara snapped her fingers and said she showed us judges. Simon called it loud and annoying. Ditto. Have you seen that Bud Light commercial where the guy is fawning over the new Bud Light cans and his girlfriend asks him what he likes about her and he can’t come up with anything (other than he likes all of her teeth). Then he asks her the same thing and she says he’s her soulmate and he says “ditto.” Well, this ditto was different than that one, but it’s just such a funny commercial. I think Katie might be in trouble tomorrow.

09 – Casey James, Lawdy Miss Clawdy
Didn’t really know this song. Thought Casey did well with it. He’s safe for the next few weeks, guaranteed. Randy didn’t think he saw anything different, but it was a solid performance. Ellen noted how comfortable he was in the sea of women (he performed the song stage right surrounded by the crowd). Kara thought it fell short of brilliance. Simon thought it was a wasted opportunity on a forgettable song. I was tired by the time this song came along (the perils of going first and last!). I know Casey will be safe tomorrow.

Bottom 3: Andrew, Tim, Katie

Two off: Andrew, Tim

Friday, April 09, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 9 (04/06/10)

Hello all

Mike Rico subbing for Jason today as our fearless recapper has been feeling under the weather… Rest up and get well, J...I felt last week was a big week for the show as it was the first time that everyone put a good show for the most part. I think it was a credit to both Usher, who gave great advice to the contestants on how to perform to the audience and also the theme of last week, which was R&B/Soul. I think this is a comfortable genre for many of the contestants and most of them found their groove.



The theme this week honors the partnership of John Lennon and Paul McCartney. Paul videotaped a message to the contestants that was a bit strange in an old man sort of way… My big memory of John Lennon, unfortunately, was Howard Cosell announcing on Monday Night Football that he had been shot…



AI did a Beatles tribute over two weeks a couple of years ago- I remember recapping one of those weeks. Some of the same songs will be performed this week. On the lighter side, the contestants will be describing their peers as we get another look into their personalities.



01 Aaron Kelly; The Long and Winding Road



First up is Aaron. We learn tonight that young Aaron is a wannabe jedi and loves to speak Yoda. Loves to speak Yoda, Aaron does. Everyone calls him their little brother. Tonight, he sings the slow-tempo The Long and Winding Road…



Ellen says it’s a big song to take on. A long and winding song at that… Simon asks him why he sang the song and Aaron, giving a long and winding answer, compares the song to his journey on Idol. Simon followed up by calling it very old fashioned. Kara says that while he’s been good, he needs to try for great and try something up-tempo next week.



Funny that he seems like such a kid in the puff pieces while he always tackles songs that are mature or complex in theme. This was a boring performance IMO by Aaron, who has started to grow on me these past weeks. He usually makes good song choices and he definitely knows what types of songs he wants to sing. It didn’t work tonight, but he should be safe.



02 Katie Stevens; Let It Be

While Aaron is everyone’s little brother, Katie is the little sister. She’s described as energetic and fun and she is known around camp for her “All the Single Ladies” dance. Tonight she sings one of their most popular songs.



Randy calls it her best performance ever. Ellen says it was amazing, an example of changing the song just enough and not too much. Simon says she took his advice and paid off- she was better because it sounded more country.



I’ve liked Katie throughout and thought she gets picked on a little too much by the judges. She’s almost a novelty act, though; a voice so mature in a teenager. I think she fits well in R&B and disagree with Simon wanting her to sing country… Tonight is sort of her breakthrough night, which is not surprising as she sings a song that is about 40 years old, which is a good way to describe myself and Jason… Hopefully, this can lead to bigger and better things for Katie.





03 Andrew Garcia; Can’t Buy Me Love

We see Andrew as crazy and goofy. Big Mike calls him his PIC – Partner-In-Crime while Lee calls him his buddy and feels like he’s one of his friends from back home.



Randy says it was a solid performance, but a little corny for him. Ellen says she loved it; a perfect choice for him. Simon says the band overpowered Andrew and it was a bad arrangement. He also agreed that it was corny. Kara says she wants to love it, but wants to see more from him.



Andrew had been getting progressively worse until last week where he turned the tide with a very good performance. I didn’t know until my niece told me, but Andrew already had a nice following before American Idol on Youtube, so he has kind of a built-in fan base. This may explain why he is still on the show at this point… Tonight was just okay for me and I agreed with most of the judges in that it didn’t work even though it was somewhat entertaining. When it’s good, it’s great for Andrew- everything else is disappointing so far.





04 Michael Lynche; Eleanor Rigby

It is unanimous from the contestants that Big Mike is the big ol’ teddy bear. Katie had a funny line when she recalled being on the same plane out to Los Angeles- when Michael walked into the cabin, she told her mom, “the Incredible Hulk is boarding our plane.” An interesting tidbit is that he was part of a performing family that called themselves “The Lynche Mob”.



Randy says that it didn’t all work, but has shown enough artistry in the competition that he has the license to do what he wants. Ellen says Mike has so many sides to him and he thought it was incredible. Simon says he didn’t love it as much as the others. He thought it was theatrical and something you would hear in musicals. Kara says that his vocals were on fire and he was committed.



I love Big Mike the personality, but haven’t connected with his music for whatever reason. I know he’s been singing great, but the songs and performances don’t do it for me. Tonight was another example… I like the Beatles’ version of this song and I like Big Mike so it should be all good on paper, right? Still, I couldn’t get into it… Interesting to know that he performed in a family band as a kid. Between that and performing arts school, Mike is definitely at ease with himself in the spotlight.



05 Crystal Bowersox; Come Together

Crystal is known as Mamasox to the other contestants. Not just because she’s a mom, but she’s also kind and the nurturing type. She sings a crowd pleaser tonight.



Ellen remarks that she struggles for new ways to tell her how great she is- she loved it. Simon says her performance tonight is one that he can hear on the radio. Randy calls it a solid performance, but not her best performance. Kara says it’s one of her favorite performances, because she was sexy and playful and Kara thinks she’s been a little too serious in her past performances.



Like most everyone else, I look forward to Crystal’s performances every week. She rarely disappoints and she has another enjoyable performance, though it’s obvious she is having some voice issues because of a bug going around. The judges don’t even mention it as she has built up more than enough good faith in the competition… Bizarrely, the song started off with a didgeridoo. After the song, my wife kicked in with some didgeridoo 411 last night and informed me that in Australia, women are forbidden to play the didgeridoo. I don’t know the gender politics behind this, but apparently Ellen played the didgeridoo on her show and she was overwhelmed with emails and tweets about this no-no. Crystal was in compliance tonight by having a male play it and thankfully, this is the end of my “And Didgeridoo You Know” public service announcement.



06 Tim Urban; With All My Lovin’

This intro is all about Tim’s permanent smile and that Tim is an all around, happy person. Boring…



Kara says that his best performances are with guitar and it showed tonight. Ellen thought it was his second best performance since Hallelujah. Simon agreed he did really well with that song and he made it sound current. Suited his voice…



Tim is a guy that we fast forward at our house if he doesn’t bring it in the first 15 seconds. That said, I loved his Hallelujah performance and I liked this one as it was a perfect match for this upbeat song. Definitely in his wheelhouse. Tim is a nice enough guy, but I’m ready for him to go over the others at this point.



07 Casey James; Jealous Guy

Mike calls Casey the playboy of the group. They also talk about his golden, free-flowing locks and a very boisterous and distinctive laugh that can be heard across a room. Tonight, he sings a song I am not familiar with…



Ellen calls his performance heartfelt and his best performance to date. She said she was moved by it. Kara says he finally showed vulnerability. Very tasteful on acoustic and showed more depth and range. Simon says it was the best performance of the night.



It’s been a slow-rolling train, but Casey has won me over the last few weeks. He’s picked great songs as Kara has prodded her protégé to open up in his performances in her critiques and it’s paying off. He’s got a bluesy vibe and he does best in this element. I really like his performance tonight and he is picking up steam at the right time.



08 Siobhan Magnus; Across the Universe

This was a fun piece as Siobhan was called amazing and then amazingly weird. She was also called “the most interesting person I’ve ever met” by one of her peers (I forget who) which leads me to conclude that Siobhan doesn’t always drink beer, but when she does, it’s Dos Equis.



Randy called it sleepy, but he liked to see the tender side. The Dawg still loves her. Simon says she came back strong from last week, which he called a disaster. He likes that she is unpredictable.



After Mamasox, Siobhan is the most anticipated singer on the show each week for me. I’m always on board with her decisions, even though some work out better than others. Tonight, she sings a song that I remember well, but not too well. I agree with Randy, it was muy sleepy. She’ll gets a pass from me and I’ll hope for something better next week.



09 Lee DeWyze; Hey Jude

Turns out that Lee is the resident worrywart. “Dude, they hate me” he tells the gang each week and that he’ll be the one going home. The others also crack jokes about Lee and Andrew being BFFs and they end the piece by showing Lee & Andrew turning out the lights for bed like they are Bert & Ernie… Lee ends the party tonight by singing one of the Beatles’ all-time classics.



Kara says there were good moments and not good moments, but she likes the newfound confidence and it shows. Randy says another hot look for Lee and Ellen says she loved it. Simon says he didn’t like the bagpipes and though it was gimmicky.



I like Lee and I expect very good performances from him. During the song a guy with bagpipes walks down the stairs doing his thing and accompanies Lee on stage. This was contrived and Ellen made light of this random bagpipe sighting when she told Lee that it was great that he didn’t break stride on stage even though Mr. Bagpipes became separated from his parade. Ellen is money... Overall, not one of Lee’s best, but an enjoyable version at the least…



No really bad performances this week, just ones that were a bit off or uninspiring. Most of the fat has been trimmed off, so the cuts are going to start to hurt soon.



Deserved Bottom 3: Andrew Garcia, Aaron Kelly, Tim Urban



Actual Bottom 3: Katie Stevens, Andrew Garcia, Tim Urban



I think Tim goes home tonight although it was one of his better performances. Maybe wishful thinking on my part…



Enjoy the rest of the season with Jason. In case this is my last recap, it’s been a pleasure filling in for J over the years and I’m happy he let me do it. Thanks to everyone who has sent me emails along the way – they were appreciated. J



Rico out!