Tuesday, April 28, 2009

AI8 recap, Finalists x 5 (04/28/09)

So, a little on last week’s eliminations. Glad to see Lil go. She had underwhelmed me for long enough. Real sad to see Anoop go, especially when I heard this week would be the Standards from the Rat Pack era. Anoop could’ve killed a song this week. But I also think that he may have been relieved to go home after all the time he spent in the bottom 3. I wish Matt would’ve gone last week, just to show the judges that they wasted their save on a guy who the voting public turned down twice already.

Again, this week was Rat Pack standards and Jamie Foxx was the guest mentor. Have you seen “Ray?” Jamie was unbelievable in that movie. We have “Dreamgirls” on the shelf but haven’t watched it yet. Jamie was also in a little known movie called “Shade” about poker and a con. Jamie’s a classically trained musician (that can act and do stand up too), but his mentoring was a bit odd at times. My wife Kristin can’t stand his song that’s out on the radio right now (“Blame It”).

And as a side note, I’m so glad that it was only 5 singers and 5 songs tonight. Usually at this point, they have the singers sing 2 songs.

01 – Kris, The Way You Look Tonight
So, I love this song. There are many, many versions of it out there, but my favorite one is the one featured on the “Father of the Bride” soundtrack. I don’t even know who sang it, but it’s my favorite arrangement. It was also featured in “My Best Friend’s Wedding,” under a Tony Bennett cover, but my favorite song on that soundtrack is the “I Say A Little Prayer” song that the cast did at the rehearsal dinner. Especially the part with the lobster and his claws in the background. This song (The Way You Look Tonight) is definitely a wedding-type song. Pretty typical for a first dance or father-daughter dance (it was my wife Kristin’s dance with her dad). Kris did a good job with it tonight. He played it straight but it was still unique, which is hard to do since this song has been done so many times. Randy thought it was his best performance to date, which I disagree with. I thought Kris was best and most memorable last week. Kara called him truly a dark horse. Paula called him a contemporary crooner and Simon called it a little bit wet. Didn’t really understand what he meant by that, but I guess he was just trying to say that he liked it, but just not as much as the other 3. Kris is probably safe tomorrow night.

02 – Allison, Someone To Watch Over Me
It’s Allison’s birthday today (she turned 17) and when Ryan mentioned that, she gave the “raise the roof” motion. Do people still do that? I mean, seriously? I’ll break out the “raise the roof,” but it’s purely in jest. Who started that gesture? It had to be someone in sports. I remember Emmitt Smith doing it, but I thought it was in response to the signal that the football referees do to reset the play clock. And when I do “raise the roof” it’s never with two hands. I’ll only do it with one hand, which shows how committed to the motion I am (I’m not). Hmm. Back to Allison. Vocally, my wife Kristin thinks it should be Adam and Allison in the finals, but realistically it will probably be Adam and Danny. But it’s close between Allison and Danny vocally. Randy mentioned that she looks like Brittany Murphy (is he reading this recap?). And I’ll add she looks like the Brittany Murphy as Tai Fraiser in “Clueless.” Kara said something but did it in her “girlfriend” voice that bugs the heck out of me. Paula said something scripted. Does she have a teleprompter? Does she write her comments down before they even sing? Simon called it a great performance, but has a horrible feeling that she’s in trouble tonight. I think Simon is pulling the old reverse psychology trickeroo. When he pans someone, people tend to vote for that person. We’ll see if it works. She still may be in the bottom 2 tomorrow though.

03 – Matt, My Funny Valentine
Every time I hear this song I think of Michelle Pfeiffer draped over a piano singing this in “The Fabulous Baker Boys.” She did all of her own vocals in that movie, as well as her stint in “Grease 2.” As bad as “Grease 2” was in comparison to the original, I would still watch it if it was on TV. I even have the soundtrack. It had some campy songs, but a few weren’t bad. Speaking of bad, Matt was bad tonight. Jamie’s suggestion of making the song a key lower turned into off key for the beginning. He was pitchy too and my wife Kristin calls him a one-trick pony, as all Matt likes to do is riff. His phrasing and accent seemed like he was trying to sing the song like a Rat Packer, maybe even Sammy Davis, Jr. Randy called it a little pitchy and that it didn’t all come together. Kara didn’t think he was emotionally connected to the song. Paula did the predictable thing and praised him so that she could hear the crowd on her side. She is so predictable. Simon then went on to disagree with Randy and say it was the only believable authentic song tonight. I see Simon working here. He’s using the reverse psychology again. If he agrees with Randy and Kara, it may give Matt pity votes. Well played, Cowell. Well played. Matt is going home tomorrow night.

04 – Danny, Come Rain or Come Shine
Jamie was a bit weird in his commentary for Danny. He was getting all up in his grill while he was singing. Evidently it worked though because Danny knocked it out of the park. He finally ended a song with a big note! It was a bit boring at the start, but he ended with a bang. The performance reminded me of Sugar Ray Leonard in this heyday, when he’d do nothing for the first 2 ½ minutes of a round, then end with a flurry of harmless punches at the end of the round to “steal” it on the judges’ cards. Randy said he could have an album of songs like that. Kara liked his swagger and said it was the most creative he’s been with a melody so far. Paula called him stellar. Simon liked his swagger and confidence up there. I hope this means that Danny is about to hit his stride. He started out so fast but came back to the pack in the middle and was surpassed by Adam in the process. I hope Danny picks it up and gives Adam a run for the money. I still think Adam is head and shoulders above everyone else, but I’d like to see Danny right there with him.

05 – Adam, Feeling Good
What’s interesting about this song is that A.J. Tabaldo and Leslie Hunt both sang this song in the second week of season 6 of AI and both were eliminated that week. But, Brian Melo and Natalie Gauci both sang this song on their respective international Idols (Canadian and Australian, respectively) and both went on to win their respective competitions. How many times did I use respective(ly) in that last sentence? Tonight Adam showed his incredible range and incredible control once again. This did feel a bit like a Broadway performance, but I don’t mind anymore. Adam’s amazing. I just wonder if he’s killing the other competitors in votes every week. We know he’s never been in the bottom 3 (neither has Danny), but I’d like to know what the vote counts have been. Randy called him a little (a little?) theatrical tonight, but in the zone. Kara fawned over him again. Simon said something about Adam being in it to win it. Adam should be safe tomorrow and I have a feeling it will be Adam, Danny and Kris as the final 3.

Bottom 2: Matt, Allison
Out: Matt

I now have to mention a little bit about Dancing With The Stars. Is it me or does Julianne Hough’s boyfriend/dance partner Chuck Wicks look like a dead ringer for Matt Leinart? And Lil Kim is so short that all she looks like is boobs and butt. No torso. I think Melissa (from the Bachelor) looks like The Nanny. Good thing she doesn’t have her annoying voice and laugh. Is it weird that Shawn Johnson looks like Sabrina Bryan? And that they both danced with Mark Ballas? People like Gilles Marini (I don’t), but I think he’ll be in the finals with Lil Kim and Shawn Johnson. Although Melissa has a chance if she isn’t hurt that bad (ribs). I’m so glad that Chelsie Hightower is on the show after her run at So You Think You Can Dance last year. And I can’t wait for SYTYCD to start again on May 21 (after AI is over).

And thanks to those who mentioned Susan Boyle from “Britain’s Got Talent” to me. Do yourself a favor and YouTube it. Or go to this link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9lp0IWv8QZY
It’s only been viewed over 47 million times so far...

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

AI8 recap, Finalists x 7A (04/21/09)

Thanks to Mike Rico who wrote the recap last week, although he didn’t quite identify himself, other than saying the Ura Family was down in San Diego (you had to put 2 and 2 together to get that it was him writing). Credit is due to Mike for another great recap and a big thanks for filling in once again.

To recap what happened last week, we saw the performances on TV down in San Diego, but didn’t see the results show on Wednesday night. Had to hunt down the story on Thursday morning. When we told my father-in-law that Matt got voted off, but they saved him, he asked simply, “why?” My feelings exactly. America doesn’t like or get Matt. They didn’t vote him through in his semi-final. He had to be brought back by the judges, then put through by the judges (and not a popular vote). Now they save him again? Can’t they just let him and his Justin Timberlake wannabe self go away?

And to get back to San Diego, if you have kids under 10, LegoLand is the way to go. They have a ton of rides now (3 roller coasters) and attractions. The food is unbelievable for an amusement park. The things they made out of Legos around the park defy logic. It’s less crowded than Disneyland because there aren’t any teenagers and the adults are with kids. Throw in Sea World, the Zoo and Wild Animal Park and, as my son Jared says, “San Diego rocks.”

So this week is Disco Week, but it’s also “Turn Off the TV Week” at my son Jared’s school (he’s in 1st grade). So he’s agreed to not watch TV at all this week. And so did my wife Kristin and I … until the kids go to sleep! We’ve got so much TV to make up from last week. I’m so into The Celebrity Apprentice right now. And the Haney Project where Tiger’s coach Hank Haney is trying to fix Charles Barkley’s major hitch in his swing. But on the positive side, we’ve been able to do more things with Jared and Kacey instead of watching TV. We’ve played a Pokemon dice game, which is akin to Yahtzee. And tonight we made jigsaw puzzles. But now onto the recap…

01 – Lil Rounds, I’m Every Woman (Chaka Khan)
Lil has a bad habit of trying to emulate each performer to honor them and this week she looked a bit like Donna Summer. But the problem with that is that she comes off as a copycat and unoriginal, which is what you’re not supposed to do on this silly, contrived competition. I don’t know if she doesn’t know how to make a song her own or if she is blatantly trying to do what she is doing. Regardless, I’m done with her. She can’t take criticism. She makes a sour face when getting the judges’ comments. It’s like she thinks she’s a better singer than she is. She definitely knows how to sing, but it seems like she doesn’t know music. Like in “Days of Thunder” when Tom Cruise’s character knew how to drive, but didn’t know anything about cars. Or my wife Kristin likens it to the difference between a cook and a chef. Anyone can follow a recipe, but only chefs can add their own panache to a recipe to make it memorable. Randy said she can definitely sing, but she didn’t show them anything. Kara said everyone’s been waiting for her to sing a Chaka Khan song, but it wasn’t worth the wait. Simon said he was glad she had fun up there because it will be the last time we see her up on that stage. She had no originality. She should go tomorrow night.

02 – Kris Allen, She Works Hard For The Money (Donna Summer)
I don’t dig Kris every week, but this version worked for me. It had a Jack Johnson feel (a la “Upside Down” on the Curious George soundtrack; have I told you that the last adult movie that me and my wife Kristin went to together, sans the kids, was Ocean’s Twelve? You realize they’ve had an Ocean’s Thirteen out since…). My wife Kristin chimed in with this was finally a memorable performance for Kris. Although he had the luxury of going after Lil. This performance reminded me of the old trick apartment hunters do. They take you out to see a ton of crappy apartments and the last one is okay. But you think it looks better than it is because it’s so much better than the junk they’ve shown you all day. Although I do think Kris’ performance was better than that average apartment. But Lil’s was every bit as crappy as those dives that the hunters show you. Kara said he took a risk with the arrangement and it paid off. Paula said it had a Santana feel to it and then made some comment about him taking a chance by singing a woman’s song. Miss Short Term Memory (which was a great old skit by Tom Hanks in the Saturday Night Live’s of the ‘80s) conveniently forgot that Danny and Anoop also sang women’s songs (Mariah Carey’s “Hero” and Monica’s “Angel of Mine”; both in the same week too). Simon called it a complete polar opposite of Lil’s song. It was original, well thought out and not karaoke. Randy called him ready for the big time. Kris should make the final four (along with Adam, Danny and Allison). He’s safe tomorrow.

03 – Danny Gokey, September (Earth, Wind and Fire)
So shouts go out to Peter and Kelly Kim, as Kelly is a huge EWF fan (like my wife Kristin) and they got married on the “21st night of September.” I really like Danny and his dancing doesn’t bother me much. It’s way better than Taylor Hicks’ dancing. It’s genuine and not contrived. He can dance. Almost. But his voice is really spot on. I think it’s going to be between Danny and Adam, but Adam should win in a landslide. Randy didn’t think there was enough in the melody for Danny, but said that he turned it into something that worked. Kara thought Disco Week for Danny was like asking Simon to wear a plaid shirt (Simon wore what looked like a V-neck undershirt tonight). And she also said his pitch was right on. Paula called his voice sexy. Simon said he didn’t get star power from his performance. Danny should be safe tomorrow.

04 – Allison Iraheta, Hot Stuff (Donna Summer)
What was up with Allison’s Catwoman outfit tonight? She actually reminds me a bit of Brittany Murphy. This competition is perfect for Allison because she always changes the song she’s singing up to make it a rock song/ballad. I can’t believe she’s only 17 (or is it 16?). She’s got a huge voice, but I don’t think she has a following. She should be in the top 3 (after Adam and Danny), but her lack of votes means that she’ll probably top out at 4, maybe 5. Randy didn’t like the arrangement, but said she’s one of the best singers in the competition. Kara thought the slowness of the song at the beginning worked against her, but the vocals were great. Paula loved that she never compromises herself in her song choices. Simon thought she was the underdog in Disco Week and said that it was a brilliant performance. Allison should be safe tomorrow night, but you can never tell with her.

05 – Adam Lambert, If I Can’t Have You (Yvonne Elliman, from the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack)
What can I say that hasn’t already been said about Adam? He brings it every week. He blows the competition away every week. It’s like he’s making a mockery of this competition because he’s so much better and more original than everyone else every single week. He’s Michael Jordan better than everyone else. I doubt Adam’s been compared to MJ much in his past, but he’s that much better. He’s Tiger Woods better than everyone else. Randy said he’s ready right now. Kara said he’s brilliant and called this his most memorable performance (which I disagree with; I think “Track of My Tears” was his most memorable so far). Paula babbled something. I don’t listen to her much anymore. Simon thought he was going to sing something from Donna Summer for sure (which 3 others did!). He said it was original, we’ll remember it and his vocals were immaculate. Other than that he was just okay.  Adam thanked Michael Orland (the pianist and arranger for AI) for helping him with that song (which was cool that he acknowledged him). Adam’s safe.

06 – Matt Giraud, Stayin’ Alive (The Bee Gees)
I’ve said my piece about Matt already. I think it would be fitting that they save him, but he gets voted out the next week. Randy said he didn’t like the song choice or arrangement, but he really can sing. Kara liked that he brought the mood back to disco and called it a solid performance. Paula made some bowling analogy and said this was a strike. Seriously, who writes her stuff? Simon called it desperate and not original. Unfortunately, this is a recipe for a Matt save because every time the judges pan him, he’s safe. We’ll see tomorrow. He should be in the bottom 3 with Lil and probably Anoop. I’m hoping Matt goes tomorrow.

07 – Anoop Desai, Dim All The Lights (Donna Summer)
Did you dig Anoop’s mustache that he grew for this week? I don’t dig the preppy look that they keep trotting him out with every week, that’s for sure. Still, I love me some Anoop. Started out as a ballad (a la “Flashdance”), then moved a little more up tempo (how can he not dance and do his tired singing motions in Disco Week?). I thought his gesticulations were more under control this week than earlier in the competition. Anoop really can go tomorrow or next week. If he finishes better than 5th, he really would’ve overstayed his welcome. Nice kid. Good voice, but no where near as talented as Adam, Danny, Allison or Kris. Randy didn’t like the arrangement. Kara thought it was a great song choice. Paula made some comment about real men knowing how to wear pink (for the record, I wore a pink shirt out in the field today; shoot me now, Paula’s on my side…). Simon called it mediocre at best and his worst performance so far. And I say no way to that. There is no way that was worse than his “Beat It” disaster. My son Jared still imitates that performance, but he does it because it was funny to him. Anoop will probably be in the bottom 3 tomorrow and may actually go. I think it would be a week too soon, but his departure is imminent anyway.


I did like how they scrapped the intros to try to make it on time, but my TiVo cut out as Anoop was singing in the recap. How can they not keep this show on time? This was never a problem in past seasons.

Bottom 3: Lil, Matt, Anoop
Top 2: Adam, Kris
Gone: Lil & Matt

AI8 recap, Finalists x 7 (04/14/09) by Mike Rico

Hi folks

The Family Ura is on vacation as they tour San Diego and its local attractions. Hopefully, they remembered to bring their passports to LegoLand. If not, I hear it’s easy to break out of customs.



This week is Movie Week and who better to sit in this week than 90’s phenomenon, Quentin Tarantino. Back from a Season 3 appearance, QT is super geeky and difficult to watch talk sometimes, but I have to say, I went ape poop over Pulp Fiction when it first came out. I saw it seven times in the theater the first month. An all-time favorite of mine… I do think AI went overboard in his introduction by calling him a legend and saying he changed the course of cinema… I guess it’s true to a certain extent as crappy wanna-be Tarantino movies backfilled theaters for years after. Anyway, the wonderful 1-2 punch of Reservoir Dogs & Pulp Fiction was an amazing start to his career.



In this format, he didn’t really bring much to the table for the singers, at least from what I could tell in the intros… Another programming note: In the interest of time constraints, the producers decided to have only two judges comment on each singer. Heck of a good idea, time constraints or not, but they still ran over a bit. Luckily, we didn’t miss any performances like last week.



This week I went on to the AI web site to explore a bit. It was interesting to see the favorite/influences of our remaining contestants- including their favorite AI contestants from the past. Turns out nearly everyone’s fave is either Kelly or Fantasia. I’ve cut and pasted here…



1 Allison Iraheta - I Don’t Want To Miss A Thing/Armageddon

Favorite Male Artist: Michael Jackson

Favorite Female Artist: Pink

Favorite Idol thus far: Fantasia Barrino, Carly Smithson



Allison is my favorite of the singers we have left. She can sing a song like no other 16 year old and you know I like the chain-smoking, whiskey-gargling voices. Week in and week out, she turns in very good performances even though the judges seem to be more preoccupied with her hair and clothes. After her great performance last week, Simon was forced to acknowledge her presence in the competition. Tonight, she tries on Aerosmith…



Paula says Allison shares a quality as one of her favorites, Adam Lambert: she’s authentic. She called her remarkable and talented. Simon said she is the girls’ only hope. (He’s talking to you, Lil Rounds.) Says Allison is getting stronger and more confident in the competition.



Not my favorite performance from her, but I think it has more to do with the song. Outside “Sweet Emotion” Aerosmith is meh to me. I still chuckle when I’m reminded of the Saturday Night Live skit where it’s a commercial selling their greatest hits album including “Crazy”, “Amazing”, “Crazy Amazing”, “Crazy Amazing Crazy”, etc. – the point being their songs all sounded the same in the ‘90s…The judges point out how difficult it is to sing this song, especially for a 16 year old, and it’s good to see her receive some love from Simon.



2 Anoop Desai – Everything I Do/Robin Hood

Favorite Male Artist: Ne-Yo

Favorite Female Artist: Lauren Hill

Favorite Idol thus far: Kelly Clarkson



Jason pegged it early in that Anoop is enjoyable to watch when he slows it down to sing ballads, but has an issue with the up tempo songs. As it’s been said by the judges (not Randy, who was encouraging him), he’s not very believable singing those. I’m very glad Anoop is still around and he sings the first of two Bryan Adams songs we will hear on movie week- Bryan Adams was to movies in the 90s what Kenny Loggins was to movies in the 80s.



Randy remarked that the last couple of weeks he has found his zone. Thought he did a real good job. Kara said he’s found his niche: taking pop songs and adding his own soulful vibe. She felt connected to his performance tonight.



Anoop is one of the best balladeers that Idol has ever had. He does seem to be a one trick pony, but he’s very good and very smooth with the crooning. Now if they could stop dressing him like a cheesy high school kid…





3 Adam Lambert - Born To Be Wild/Easy Rider

Favorite Male Artist: Michael Jackson, Freddie Mercury, Lenny Kravitz, David Bowie

Favorite Female Artist: Pink, Katy Perry, Christina Aguilera, Lady Gaga, Beyonce, Goldfrapp, Madonna

Favorite Idol thus far: Fantasia Barrino



Not a fan of Adam, but have to admit that he is charismatic and delivers rock star performances- he gets the live audience in a tizzy every week. I’m not on board with his out-there performances, such as his Johnny Cash live from Marrakech performance, but very much liked his Elvis sings Smokey on Motown week. He sings a song from the only movie that I’ve seen from this list, Easy Rider…



Paula said the reason that he shakes up the competition is because he dares to dance in the path of greatness. (Who wrote that crap for you, Paula?) Simon said that vocally, Adam was incredible, but the downside of the performance compared to the Rocky Horror Picture Show in parts. He ended his critique by saying last week was better.



Adam does his thing again and lights the crowd afire. He’s too theatrical for my taste, but he’s got skills. Despite my feelings towards his arrangements, I like the way he carries himself and he is in another league as a performer.





4 Matt Giraud – Have You Really Loved a Woman, Don Juan DeMarco

Favorite Male Artist: Billy Joel

Favorite Female Artist: KT Kunstall

Favorite Idol thus far: Michael Johns



Bluesy Matt grew a little bit on me last week with his performance of “Part Time Lover”. That was a great match for him and I enjoyed a BM performance for the first time. That was only a start, however- I’ll wait for two good ones in a row from him before I officially change the universal meaning of BM to Bluesy Matt.



Randy said it was interesting tonight…Started off good, but it got rough in patches. He said he can’t do all the riffs that he usually does to a song with a simple melody like this. Kara basically expanded on Randy’s point that all his runs detracted from the melody of a beautiful song like this one.



Yes, the true meaning of BM still stands (or flushes)… Bluesy Matt can’t help himself and even Kara, an advocate of his, tells him his up and downs were too much. He’ll be there in the bottom 3 tonight…



5 Danny Gokey - Endless Love/The Blue Lagoon

Favorite Male Artist: Michael Jackson

Favorite Female Artist: Lauren Hill

Favorite Idol thus far: Kelly Clarkson is the most memorable. I'm not sure who my favorite is.



Like most everyone, I enjoy hearing Danny sing… I find comfort in his name; didn’t everyone go to junior high or play Little League with a Danny Gokey? Like Tarantino, Danny started off like gangbusters and his star has faded a little, but the reality is he’s performed well every week. I look forward to his performance this week as Danny sings without his trademark wood shop goggles.



Paula said she thought the key should have been lower in the beginning, but midway through, the song picked up and was it great to the end; a beautiful rendition. Simon said he can’t fault the way he sang the song, but was disappointed with the choice of harp and the traditional, straightforward delivery. He was bored. He compared it to the David Cook version of another Lionel Ritchie song, which David completely reworked.



Like Simon, I was expecting more, but such are expectations for Danny who has been great all season long. The song does works better as a duet as well…



6 Kris Allen - Falling Slowly, Once

Favorite Male Artist: Jamie Cullum

Favorite Female Artist: Kelly Clarkson

Favorite Idol thus far: Kelly Clarkson



I don’t like Kris and his lightweight pop style. I’m sure he’s cool with it as he is popular in the most important demographics in AI, young girls and young ladies. And maybe cougars and pumas, as well, and other jungle cats that are code for old and horny women. He’s got two jungle cats in the judge’s panel that are drinking his Kool-Aid from their commercially conspicuous Coke glasses. This sounds like I’m being a hater, so I’ll stop here…



Randy said I don’t know; it never quite caught on for him…It was pitchy from note one.

Kara said it’s difficult to pick an obscure song, but for her it was one of his best moments in the competition.



More of the same from Kris; that’s great for many and ugghh for the rest. I thought people got too excited about his performance of “Ain’t No Sunshine” from a couple of weeks back, when clearly Christina Christian sang the better rendition of this song back in season one. Okay, it’s official; I’m a hater. Let the haters hate!!!



7 Lil Rounds - The Rose/The Rose

Favorite Male Artist: Anthony Hamilton

Favorite Female Artist: Alicia Keys

Favorite Idol thus far: Fantasia Barrino



Oh, Lil Rounds, what has happened to you? Where did it go so terribly wrong? Lil is the type of singer that I usually get behind in AI. She seems like a sweet person who can sing well with the R&B/Soul flavor. That’s in my wheelhouse. Plus, she’s the type of girl that The Commodores were singing about in “Brickhouse”. Even in the intro, there was a connection between Tarantino and her that didn’t exist for him and the other contestants. I definitely think there was a rooting interest there… Until now, as it’s been said succinctly by Kara and Simon, Lil has come up empty in the artistry category, which is mostly what this show is about… Can the great QT reignite her star like he did for John Travolta? Please do…She picks a poem of a song in The Rose to sing tonight…



Paula said could not have picked a more beautiful lyric and compliments the songwriter, but doesn’t say anything about Lil’s performance. Uh-oh…Simon said he thought Lil is getting this all completely wrong. He says the song was too soft for her, too middle of the road. Says there was some nice moments, but Simon goes reverse Dennis Green by saying she’s not the artist who he thought she was. Lil wants to interject and then Simon lets her say her piece.



Lil complains that they wanted her to be an artist, so she took a Bette Midler song and gave it her treatment. (On a side note, this season’s contestants has been a mouthy one as a whole from Anoop, Megan & Scott and others pushing back during their crits.) What Lil says is true, but the problem was she didn’t deliver. I think if she had pulled it off it could have been a pivotal moment for her and one of those electrifying moments on AI that happen once every one or couple of seasons. It had a chance to be special, but she just didn’t execute well. Unfortunately, it’s not working out for Lil and it’s not for a lack of chances…



A middle of the road affair for Movie Week. We’re getting towards the end, so the cuts will soon start to be painful. But there’s still some fat to trim… Hmmm, that reminds me, I think I’ll have to break out the BBQ this weekend for the first time this year…



Deserved Bottom 3: Lil, Bluesy Matt, Kris

Actual Bottom 3: Lil, Bluesy Matt, Anoop

Person going home: Bluesy Matt



So long, have a great rest of the week!

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

AI8 recap, Finalists x 8 (04/07/09)

Ah, the “Songs From The Year You Were Born” week on American Idol. Do the contestants look forward to this like the Top Chef contestants look forward to “Restaurant Wars” week or how the Big Break contestants look forward to the “break the glass pane” contest?

01 – Danny (1980), Stand By Me (Mickey Gilley)
So this is cheating a bit, but not to the extent of Megan’s version of “Rockin’ Robin” on Michael Jackson week. I got Mickey Gilley mixed up with Mel Tillis in my mind, which is funny because you’d have never known that had I not written about it. Mickey Gilley’s club “Gilley’s” was featured in that John Travolta, post-Saturday Night Fever hit “Urban Cowboy.” I mistook him for Mel Tillis, who has a trademark stutter, which goes away when he sings. Anywho, back to Danny. Thought he did a good music version of this song. I’d have loved it if the contestants had to dress like the fashion in that year too. It would’ve been funny to see Danny come out in one of those Thriller jackets with one glove (although that look wasn’t in 1980). I guess he did kind of come out with the semi-Members Only jacket and skinny tie. Randy didn’t love the arrangement, but loved the song. Kara thought he turned it on its head (in a good way). Simon thought the beginning was good, the middle lazy and the end great. Danny should be safe tomorrow night, but the lead off spot is bad in this competition, as unless it was really unbelievable, it’s easy to forget any song in that spot.

02 – Kris (1985), All She Wants To Do Is Dance (Don Henley)
I don’t like it when the contestants perform off stage on the mini-mosh pit area. I think it’s a contrived look and don’t like it. This was a weird arrangement of the song. Kara likened it to jazz, funk homework that he might have been given in music school. She thought he lost his youth in the song. Paula thought he changed it up (which he did; it just didn’t work out that great) and called him one of the most likeable contestants. Simon called him likeable, but he called the song indulgent, boring and forgettable. He called Kris a guitarist who wanted to sing, instead of a singer. Randy thought they lost Kris in that song. Kris is allowed a week reprieve since he’s been so good the last few. Not his best performance, but he has a big enough following to get past this week.

03 – Lil (1984), What’s Love Got To Do With It (Tina Turner)
We found out that Lil is her real name and not an abbreviation or nickname/stage name. Lil is a very, very good singer that doesn’t know how to choose her songs. Or change her songs. She’s been very disappointing so far. Much like Ramiele Malubay last season. So much promise, but no delivery. She really reminds me of Syesha Mercado in her song choices. Although Syesha would sing songs too big for her. Lil just hasn’t found a song that suits her yet. And because of that, I’m tired of her. She can go anytime now. My wife Kristin added that Lil sings songs as if emulating the original singer and she doesn’t change it up. But I countered with she totally changed up the Michael Jackson song “The Way You Make Me Feel.” She was singing “the way you makin’ me feel.” Completely different… Paula knows she’s a brilliant vocalist, but it’s becoming beautiful karaoke. Simon didn’t like the 2nd or 3rd rate Tina Turner copycat performance. Simon thinks that the show has lost Lil and that she’s getting the wrong advise or making bad decisions. Kara said this is when you leap from being a singer to an artist and Lil hasn’t made that jump yet. I think she should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

04 – Anoop (1986), True Colors (Cyndi Lauper)
This was a great song choice for Anoop. He needs to stop doing the upbeat songs because his dancing becomes almost a parody, which is not a good thing. I thought Anoop was good tonight, but that doesn’t preclude him from going tomorrow. I think he’s likeable enough to make it through tomorrow though. Randy liked how he pulled it back and gave my wife Kristin’s favorite pet peeve phrase, “you can actually sing.” Kara said he controlled the song, instead of it controlling him. She liked his interpretation with a little soul. Paula said something canned, per usual. Simon called him a yo-yo, going from bad to good in a matter of a week. I think Anoop should be safe, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he went home tomorrow.

05 – Scott (1985), The Search Is Over (Survivor)
I could just tell Scott was uncomfortable up on stage without his piano. Who knew that he could play the guitar. I actually didn’t enjoy Scott at all tonight. My wife Kristin appreciated the fact that he went for all the big notes (even though he didn’t hit all of them). Hopefully Scott makes it through so that he can get back behind the piano next week. Kara thought he had some good moments, but some bad ones too. Simon encouraged him to go back to the piano next week and also to not listen to Paula’s advice anymore. Scott should be safe tomorrow, but he could be in the bottom 3.

06 – Allison (1992), I Can’t Make You Love Me (Bonnie Raitt)
I really like Allison, but evidently, no one else does. I think that she has a great voice, but doesn’t have a following. If it was talent alone, she’d be right up there with Adam. Maybe Latinos don’t vote or watch AI? Whatever it is, it’s unfortunate. Allison has some Kelly Clarkson mannerisms up on stage, but I think she looks more like Bethany Joy Galeotti (Haley James Scott on “One Tree Hill”). Paula commended her for using the same arrangement, but making it her own. Simon called her very good, but wished she could be more likeable. Randy likened her to Kelly Clarkson in that they both sing their faces off. Kara said something involving talent. I think she should be safe performance-wise, but she could be in the bottom 3 because of the votes. If that happens, I think the judges will save her, but she’d probably get voted off the next week anyway.

07 – Matt (1985), Part Time Lover (Stevie Wonder)
Real good version. Saw a friend of his wearing a Giraud Squad t-shirt in the crowd. Running short on time, so the judges gave short feedback. Randy said that vocally it was one of the best of the night. Kara called it incredible on every level. Paula gave him a standing O. Simon called it well done and way better than last week. I think Matt’s safe, but the last time the judges liked him, he was in the bottom 2!

08 – Adam, Mad World (Tears for Fears)
Stupid AI went way over tonight and my TiVo didn’t catch this performance. The USA Today guy who writes “Idol Chatter,” (http://blogs.usatoday.com/idolchatter/) loved it. Said he liked it better than his “The Tracks of My Tears” song, which also rocked. Just found the song on YouTube and it was very good (although the video was not in high quality). Simon gave him a standing ovation. Although the final spot is usually the “pimp spot,” lately it hasn’t gone over so well because the show has been running late just about every week so there is no time for comments. Maybe adding that 4th judge wasn’t so smart after all. They should’ve added Kara but cut Paula. There is no way Adam goes home tomorrow. He’s breezing into the finals.

Top 3: Adam (I think), Allison, Danny

Bottom 3: Lil, Scott, Kris

Bottom 3 vote getters: Scott, Lil, Allison

I’ll be gone next week for Spring Break (LegoLand & San Diego here we come!), but Mike Rico will be stepping in again (thanks Mike).

As always, comments back are appreciated.