Tuesday, March 29, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 10 (03/29)

Whew! Was that a collective sigh when Mikalah finally got the boot last week or what? If you ask me, it was 3 weeks too late, as she should’ve been gone before the finals started and Amanda should’ve been in the final 12. But that’s just rehashing old news.

We finally figured out how to get the recap done quicker. We now let Jared stay up and watch with us. The kid loves music. He has a routine that we (him and I) do. He hammers on the piano and I play his kid’s drum set. When we stop, we bow and he says “thank you very much.” I’m trying to get him to add, “you’re too kind.” We’ll see how that works out. Jared hasn’t quite grasped the whole concept of commercials yet though. Every time they come on he asks where American Idol went.

This week’s theme is “songs from the ‘90s,” which is okay for me, but I can’t wait until they do the ‘80s, if they ever do.

01 – Bo Bice, Remedy (Black Crowes)
Bo came out rockin, as usual, this time with a big cow print cowboy hat and a reddish-orange velour shirt. It’s funny because his hat was pretty low on his forehead and Jared kept saying, “can’t see.” He did his usual rocker, run around with the mic stand performance. Walked across the judges’ table this time and put the cow hat on Paula’s head. I’m warming up to Bo. Like him better than Constantine now. Didn’t really know this song that he sang, but he’s cool with me. Randy said that he’s glad he’s back rockin’ it and he’d love to see a rocker win. And that the performance was hot. Paula adores him and said he did an awesome job. Simon said that he didn’t like the song and that it was something that you’d see at a wedding. Bo should be safe until about the final 5 or so.

02 – Jessica Sierra, didn’t know the song title (LeAnn Rimes)
Jessica mentioned the Dixie Chicks in her intro and it made me think that she looks like one of them. The short, chubby one. I didn’t really know this LeAnn Rimes song. She should’ve picked the Con Air song. That would’ve been better. She wore a lavender blazer but her hair was WAY too flat. Had jeans on that had bleach marks on them. I had a pair of jeans in college that had an actual acid bleach spot on them. I was wearing them in a Chem lab and a guy next to me spilled his beaker on my pants. Burned a hole right through them. Had to go to the health center for some cream (it was Cowell Health Center, not BALCO) to rub on it. No major damage, but it did add some flair to my wardrobe. And it was that first Chemistry class, combined with a Physics class my first semester at Cal that convinced me that I wasn’t digging the science classes to go into pharmacy. Little did I know that I’d eventually become a pharmaceutical rep, but stranger things have happened. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite song choice, but that she sang it well. The song didn’t feature any big notes that she could’ve hit. Paula said the song didn’t showcase her vocals. Simon said that she doesn’t have the likeability factor like some of the others. I’m split on Jessica because I think Simon is right. If she doesn’t blow you away with a song (like she did last week with the Bonnie Tyler song), she doesn’t have the following to keep her around. She may be on the bubble tomorrow night.

03 – Anwar Robinson, I Believe I Can Fly (R. Kelly)
This song reminds me of “Space Jam.” That Michael Jordan movie. It also reminds me of that statutory rapist (allegedly) R. Kelly. Kelly is a Chicago guy and I think that he actually used to live down the street from me. I had heard that his house was an old church that he converted into a huge house. I think it was down Sheffield a bit, by a Carolina BBQ place called Brother Jimmy’s. I hear that Brother Jimmy’s isn’t there anymore, which is a shame because the ribs there were awesome. I think that I took just about everyone who came to town there. This song also reminds me of Glen Rice. Remember when he had that unbelievable stretch with the Hornets when no one could guard him? Was MVP of the All-Star game. I saw a feature on him and he said that he would sing that song before every game to get himself pumped up. Then he got traded to the Lakers for Eddie Jones and he disappeared. Got hurt and never was the same. Glen Rice also reminds me of Michigan hoops when he used to wear those long lycra undershorts that almost went down to his knee, but wore the John Stockton short shorts over them. Still can’t believe they won it in ’89 with Steve Fisher as their coach. He took the team over when Bill Frieder took the Arizona State job before the tournament started and they canned him and handed the keys over to Fisher. Anyway, back to Anwar. I’m losing my love for him. My wife thinks he’s too nasal-sounding now. And this song choice. Done way too much. It’s so trite. It’s almost as though this was too predicable of a song choice. I was disappointed. I guess it’s because I’m just tired of this song. Although Anwar reminds my wife of a ‘70s cartoon character. He really could’ve fit into the Fat Albert cast. Especially with those bell bottom pants he always wears. I’m not hating on him yet, but he’s not my favorite anymore. Randy (complete with the shirt with 3 buttons on the neck) said that his “lower register was pitchy” and that he “hits the high notes to the crowd on his side.” My wife concurred. Paula said that she has never heard such an incredible and original rendition of that song. Simon said that Randy was spot on. The first half of the song was not good enough. I think Anwar is safe, but I don’t think he’s going to win now. He’s really laid an egg the last 3 weeks.

04 – Nadia Turner, I’m The Only One (Melissa Etheridge)
Nadia’s such a rocker. She must’ve been surprised to be in the bottom 2 last week. But then again, I thought her performance was awful. It’s almost as though she thought that she was safe and decided to just have fun with the Cyndi Lauper song. It goes to show you that you have to perform every single week now. Now that Mikalah is gone just about anyone can go now. It’s that close. She definitely got back to her roots here and sang a song that matched her. Cool outfit, as usual. Funky belt. Gold all over the place. Randy said that she isn’t the greatest singer, but a great performer. How do you take that backhanded compliment? Paula said that she was miles better than last week. Simon said it was a 1000% improvement over last week but that she should be slightly nervous about that song because it was not a great melodic song. I think she’ll be okay tomorrow night, but needs to step it up again like earlier in the competition.

05 – Constantine Maroulis, I Can’t Make You Love Me (Bonnie Raitt)
Couldn’t remember who sang this song, but my wife remembered that (Sistah) Robi Kahakalau sang it. It was funny because in the intro they were asking each contestant what they remembered about the ‘90s and Constantine mentioned the Seattle grunge scene. Then he comes out singing this Bonnie Raitt ballad. Talk about your non sequitur. I thought the song was okay. He showcased his vocals, but it was so subdued and if felt as though the audience gave him a reluctant standing O. What bothers me about Constantine is the cheesy glances that he always gives to the camera. It used to be the opening of one side of his jacket, but he’s cut that out. Now it’s those darn glances. And the nose wrinkle too. That bugs. The judges, however, loved him. Randy said it was his best vocal performance. Paula said that she was glad to hear the male version of that song and that it was his best vocal performance (you know, she should go first so that she doesn’t copy Randy all the time). Simon said that the thinks he did better than Bo tonight. It looks as if Constantine will be around for awhile, so I better get used to those facial expressions…

06 – Nikko Smith, Can We Talk (Tevin Campbell)
Boy, what ever happened to Tevin Campbell? Looking back, this was his only real hit. But it was a good one. Back in the early ‘90s I was big into the R&B crooners like (as previously stated) New Edition and Boyz II Men, but also lesser knowns like Hi-Five and Riff, who sang in the movie “Lean On Me.” Funny story. I was in an interview for an alumni scholarship for UCLA and they asked me what I thought about the actions of Joe Clark and I said, “do you mean, Jack Clark? Because I love Jack the Ripper.” Needless to say, I didn’t get that scholarship and made a better decision to go to Cal… Anyways, I always say, “if I didn’t see it on SportsCenter, it didn’t really happen…” Is it me, or did Tevin Campbell look like Tyus Edney? Back to Nikko. Paula, again, was the only one standing during his performance. Nikko was good tonight though. Wore a black tee and a white leather jacket, both of which were air brushed on. A little different than the black on black on black he’s been wearing recently. Nikko’s really proven himself in this competition since given a second chance. Randy called him most improved and that he blew it out (that’s a good thing). Paula said that he makes her proud to sit where she is sitting (I think that’s a good thing). Simon called him a breath of fresh air, but then kinda dogged him saying that it was just like the original. But it really wasn’t he changed it up quite a bit. I was a fan of the song and also of Nikko’s performance. I’m hoping he lasts a lot longer in this competition.

07 – Anthony Fedorov, Something About The Way You Look Tonight (Elton John)
Anthony changed it up a bit tonight. No glasses, a lime green shirt (which made him look pasty, by the way), big belt. Shirt was cool though. Double buttons instead of single ones and huge cuffs. A different color might have had a better effect though. He was a bit pitchy with the song though, but he did try to let go and not be so cautious in his singing. Randy called it a’ight. Paula said he did a great job. Because she did not expound on that, it meant she thought he sucked. Simon called it, in parts, excruciating. I wouldn’t go that far, but I really think Anthony is in jeopardy tomorrow night.

08 – Carrie Underwood, some country song (Martina McBride)
Didn’t know the title of the song, but boy can Carrie sing country. What a voice! is what my wife said after her performance. And that she is very likeable. Good hair this week. Last week was such a shock. I can’t believe that I didn’t liken her to Sandy being made up at the end of Grease. Looked just like her, especially the hair. Now Sandy wore black with tight black pants. Did they actually have lycra in the ‘50s? Or was it called something else? Randy called it a great performance and the best vocal of the night. Paula said that she loves it when she sings country. Simon said that she has something different. The “it” factor. Carrie was very good tonight, as she has been throughout most of the competition. I’m jumping on her bandwagon now. I was always a fan of hers, but now I’m riding shotgun on the wagon.

09 – Scott Savol, One Last Cry (Brian McKnight)
I’m a huge Brian McKnight fan too. His first hits (One Last Cry and After the Love) were great. I think his first album was his best. He also had a song on there called “Never Felt This Way” that would be a great first dance song for those of you yet to get married… I had a buddy at the Bulls who claimed that he was going to have Brian sing that live at his wedding for his first dance. Don’t think it happened, but it was a nice thought. It seems as though all of McKnight’s CDs after the first had only 1 or 2 good songs on them, which means, I guess, that only a Greatest Hits CD would be worth purchasing. Doesn’t surprise me Scott did this song. He’s got a nice falsetto (my wife’s observation), but was a little pitchy at the beginning. Scott always does the reach to the camera, which I notice, but it doesn’t bug me as much as Constantine’s antics do. He always does the finger point to the temple too. Just observations, not complaints. Randy called it an ambitious song (which, as we know, means he didn’t pull it off) and he ended it well. Paula said she was vibin’ wit it. Simon called it karaoke-ish. My wife calls him the haku-jin (Caucasian) Ruben. Scott may be on the bubble tomorrow.

10 – Vonzell Solomon, I Have Nothing (Whitney Houston)
First off, my son has a crush on Vonzell. He actually remembers her name. She’s a pretty girl, so I guess he’s got good taste already. Vonzell came out with long, curly hair and a black prom dress. She sang the song exactly how Whitney would on stage. Not moving much, just raising the arms for effect every now and then. Pretty much a copy of a Whitney performance, but don’t take that the wrong way. Vonzell has a huge voice and it matched the song. She didn’t really sing it any different than Whitney, but then again, as we learned last year, you can’t sing a Whitney song different because Whitney sings it the way it should be sung. I’m just glad it was this song and not “I Wanna Dance With Somebody.” By the way, that Bodyguard soundtrack is good. In addition to the Whitney songs, there are a few good songs by Lisa Stansfield and S.O.U.L. S.Y.S.T.E.M. Randy called it a great performance. It was sharp in some spots, but he says she keeps getting better every week. Paula said America is falling in love with her. Simon said he was worried about her doing a Whitney song, but she pulled it off.

To sum up the night. Top 3 performances: Carrie, Vonzell, Nikko. Bottom 3: Anthony, Jessica, Anwar. Don’t know how the voting will go, but it won’t surprise me to see those bottom 3 in there and maybe Scott or Nadia.

Wednesday, March 23, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 11 (03/22)

Nothing much from last week. Did get some ideas of whom Vonzell looks like, but I’ll get to them when I get to her in the recap. B Gwyn wonders why they brought back Nikko and not Amanda. My thoughts are that since Mario opted out, they wanted a guy to make it and even 6 and 6 again. They said that he had the second lowest votes (Travis had the lowest among the guys). Amanda, I think, had the second lowest among the girls. Bryan is such a pharma guy. He argued that you can’t compare the votes that Nikko got on his night to those that Amanda got on her night. He called it analogous to those who compare across clinical trials. If it’s not a head-to-head study, you simply cannot make a comparison. Some of you pharma people will appreciate that. BUT, I don’t think that Amanda was even an option because of their insistence of keeping it 6 guys and 6 girls in the final 12. Hear me now and believe me later, I would’ve rather seen Amanda back in the competition, as would a number of guys out there.

01 – Anthony Fedorov, I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me) (Aretha Franklin with George Michael)
Anthony comes out in an homage to Ryan Seacrest: t-shirt and blazer. Nothing like sucking up to the host. What is this that I’ve heard about George Michael? They did a documentary on him so that he could tell his story, then he’s going to retire into oblivion? Thanks George. Skip the movie and just go. Your Wham! days are over. Although I did like that “Freedom” video when they shot it in China. And what was up with his butt? Remember those SNL skits with the guy focusing on his butt? Ladies, help me out on this one. Was his butt that nice? And George Michael is such a common name. Same name guy also does “The Sports Machine,” a highlights show usually shown on Sunday nights. He would set up a clip with some meaningless banter then push some oversized button to start the clip. In the day and age of ESPN, ESPN2, ESPN Classic, ESPNEWS and ESPN U, “The Sports Machine” is really antiquated. Back to Anthony. Good voice, nice kid. A little goofy. I won’t be heartbroken when he’s out. It may be this week. I think he’s vulnerable every week from here in. Randy said it was a good song choice and he had fun with it. Said “he’s back.” Paula said he came back strong (I guess that means he sucked last week?). Simon called it an okay performance and said it was a sexy routine that didn’t work. He likened it to Randy appearing on Baywatch. But Randy may have been on Baywatch. Didn’t they have an episode where they had to get a beached whale back to sea?

02 – Carrie Underwood, Alone (Heart)
I love me some Carrie Underwood. Kudos to the make over department. Carrie came out with big hair, like she stuck her finger in the light socket. Reminiscent of the Heatmeister in Rudolph’s Shiny New Year. She turned a new leaf and didn’t look so wholesome anymore. I’m not complaining. Carrie looked the part tonight, especially for singing the Ann & Nancy Wilson, Heart song. You know, I looked up Heart’s Greatest Hits and they all sound the same. “What About Love.” “Never.” “These Dreams.” “Alone.” They all sound the same. Carrie is a little large, but definitely in charge. But what bugs me about her is that after every performance, Seacrest is always touching her, in a dirty old man sort of way. Randy said “WOW” and called it one of her best performances and that she finally came alive. Paula said that she took a risk doing the Heart song, but did it well. Simon called her the favorite to win it all and predicted that she will sell more records than any other previous American Idol. I voted for Carrie tonight.

03 – Scott Savol, Against All Odds (Phil Collins)
Jessica sang this song the first week of the competition. Scott came out with his baseball cap cocked off center and threw if off at a strategically placed part in the song. Had the smoke tinted glasses on and tossed them aside at another juncture. All of this was for effect, which sort of bugs me, but not to the extent that it did last year when George Huff flung things into the crowd. It was a bad decision to ditch the glasses because then we had to look at his cold blooded killer eyes for the last part of the song. Regardless, I still think Scott’s got a sweet voice and I hope he stays around. Randy said he worked it out. Paula said he’s getting better week after week. Simon said it was good that it was only a 3 minute song or else it may have been a total striptease. He said it was a good performance, but the vocals were not fantastic. I disagree with that. Scott was good and consistent again tonight. The problem is, consistent may not be good enough for him pretty soon in the competition. I think he’s also on the fence every night from here on out.

04 – Bo Bice, Time In A Bottle (Jim Croce)
Bo was really subdued with this song choice tonight. Started out by sitting on the stage. He did get up throughout the song though, which was better than last year when Fantasia did her whole Summertime thing sprawled across the floor (which totally bugged me and still does to this day. I need to put that behind me. I really do.). Bo’s ending of the song was kinda weak. I know it’s a ballad, but usually you’re supposed to end your songs with a bang and not a whimper. I think I’m just being picky. I thought Bo was good tonight and I think that he’ll be in the Final Four, if not win it all. I’ll just never vote for him. He wore a black shirt with an almost Aloha print on it. It was like Reyn Spooner meets Ted Baker. Pretty cool look though. Randy called it subdued, but showed his range and his sensitive side. Paula called him a gift to the 60 million people watching. Simon said that when he watches him, it’s like he’s not even a part of the competition, which is a compliment. I agree with Simon. First off, the dude looks like he’s 40. And he’s very accomplished. He’s growing on me and I don’t wish him ill will. He’s definitely safe and should go deep into the competition.

05 – Nikko Smith, Incomplete (Sisqo)
I gotta tell you, I’m really not familiar with this song. Isn’t this the guy who sang the “Thong Song?” So Nikko loses points in my book for singing a song (no matter how good a song it is) from someone who also sang a song about thongs. And this wasn’t a song about the ones that go on your feet. Nikko’s style is impeccable. He always wears black. Tonight a black suit, with a black fedora and he added a black overcoat tonight. Silver tie, but mostly all black. I thought it was good, but not great. Better than last week when he only had a few days to prepare since he got called back mid week. Randy said the real Nikko Smith showed up. I have no idea what he meant by that. Paula called it brilliant and it showcased his beautiful voice. It’s (I think I used “it’s” correctly that time. Its my wife’s pet peeve that I don’t use the apostrophe correctly all the time. And yes, I left it out on purpose in that last sentence) funny, but I got a call from Sarah Royalty about Nikko’s performance, which is funny in itself because she lives in Chicago now and sees the show live, three hours before most of us do out on the West coast. But she was so compelled to call me because of how Paula reacted during Nikko’s performance. Did anyone else notice how, when they panned the crowd, Paula was going nuts, standing up and cheering, but NO ONE else was? Since she tipped me on it, I saw it and had a nice chuckle. Poor Sarah used to text message me during the performances in year’s past but now has to call and speak in generalities, so as to not upset my tape-delayed viewing. That reminds me of the first season when Kelly Clarkson won. We were watching at my in-law’s house and my sister-in-law went on the Net to check e-mail or get a recipe or something and the start up page was MSN or Yahoo or something that gave headline stories. She didn’t realize what she was reading when she blurted out “Kelly Clarkson is the new American Idol.” It’s funny because they were like 5 minutes from announcing it PST. We were like, thanks Kor. Although I was happy with the result. Justin bugs the heck out of me. I think I need to let that go too. Simon said that this was, give or take a few notes, by far his best performance. I like Nikko, but he’s not in the top four. He may be on the fence every night now too. Especially since he may not have a strong fan base, evidenced by the fact that he was eliminated once already…

06 – Vonzell Solomon, Best of My Love (The Emotions)
Okay, I got a Mary J. Blige from Adele. Mary J. is too harsh looking for Vonzell. Although I loved Mary J.’s first album (What’s The 411?). “Reminisce.” “Real Love.” “You Remind Me.” “Sweet Thing.” I also got an Iman crossed with Grace Jones from June. Interesting, but neither is as cute as Vonzell. Finally, I came up with who she reminds me of. Gabrielle Union. Although Gabrielle has a rounder face. You may know her from “Bring It On” or “Deliver Us From Eva” or “Bad Boys II.” Local girl from Pleasanton. Went to Nebraska (she was born in Omaha), transferred to Cuesta College (down in San Luis Obispo) and ended up at UCLA. Is married to former NFL player Chris Howard. Is a big fan of New Edition. See what you can learn from bios on IMDB.com (the Internet Movie DataBase)? Vonzell came out in a pink tank and grey capri pants (TAP marketing, please work on getting black or teal pants next time). She worked the stage pretty well. Fun song for her. Randy said Vonzell’s back. Paula said her vocals really came out. Simon said that this will be the first time in the competition that people will remember her. Funny how that coincides with the fact that I finally put a finger on whom I think she looks like. I hope Vonzell stays longer.

07 – Constantine Maroulis, I Think I Love You (The Partridge Family)
This was really a #1 song? Does it really count if it’s a make believe group that sings it? Did the Brady Bunch hit #1 with “It’s A Sunshine Day?” Or “We Can Make the World A Whole Lot Brighter?” Or that classic “Time to Change” when Peter’s voice is cracking? I actually owned this CD at some point in my life. Don’t think this won’t show up as a White Elephant gift this Christmas… Constantine “rocked” this song up quite a bit. I just think that the competition can only support one rocker and that one is Bo. Constantine will hang around for awhile, but there is no way he should win this thing. He’s like Joshua Gracin from a few years ago. I think he lasted longer than he should’ve, but I’m glad that he didn’t win it all. Randy called it and interesting song choice, but he went over the top with it. Paula said he has the best sense of showmanship of the group and says he probably has an amazing female fan base. Simon said it was like ordering a guard dog for your home and getting a poodle with a leather jacket. Translation: don’t rock up the Partridge Family. Constantine can leave at any time for all I’m concerned.

08 – Nadia Turner, Time After Time (Cyndi Lauper)
I was looking forward to her singing this after she introduced it. I loved Cyndi Lauper, but not for “Girls Just Want To Have Fun” and “She Bop.” By the way, “Girls Just Want To Have Fun” was a classic ‘80s movie. Did you realize that Helen Hunt, Jonathan Silverman and Shannen Doherty were also in that movie (of course, SJP was the main character). Cyndi Lauper was great with the ballads. “All Through the Night.” “True Colors.” “I Drove All Night.” “Change of Heart.” “Time After Time” was great too, but then Nadia went and butchered it. Nadia came out with a mohawk. Yes, a mohawk, like that guy in “Say Anything” that Lloyd and Diane drive home after the graduation party because he’s too drunk to drive and can’t remember where he lives. It was a SERIOUS ‘80s look. If Samuel L. Jackson saw her in “Pulp Fiction,” he’d say, “what’s up, Flock of Seagulls?” June said that all she needed was a Bob Mackie dress and she would’ve duplicated Cher’s appearance at the Oscars. Nadia had fun with the song. Started on the podium behind the judges, but she just didn’t pull it off. I don’t know if I was expecting to hear Cyndi’s unique voice with the song, but Nadia was not good tonight. She’s one of my 2 favorite girls, but I think that she may be in jeopardy tomorrow night. In past years, at this point in the competition (11 left) that performance would’ve been okay because there were still people who were worse. But the competition is so good now that one bad song choice or off night may get you booted. I’m hoping that she makes it through to redeem herself. Randy called her a star on that stage all the time (which means it wasn’t good, but he didn’t want to kill her). Paula said she rocked it, but she was not a fan of her song choice. Simon called it an over the top cruise ship cabaret performance and it was her weakest song by a mile. I agree. I cross my fingers that she makes it through.

09 – Mikalah Gordon, Love Will Lead You Back (Taylor Dayne)
How can she pick this song? Last week I professed my sincere adoration of Taylor Dayne and now Mikalah “sings” one of her songs. Is there anything more wrong than that? Mikalah was brutal tonight. Her hair was nice. That’s about the only thing nice I can say about her. She had some peacock feather thing around her neck that looked like a mask that you’d wear to a masquerade ball. If she’s not gone tomorrow night, I’ll be disappointed. Randy said he missed the young, fun Mikalah and that she was pitchy. Paula said earlier that she sounded like a young Taylor Dayne and wanted her to be careful to not try to emulate her. Simon called it complete and utter mess. That was putting it lightly. But you’re probably asking yourself, “how does Jason REALLY feel about Mikalah?”

10 – Anwar Robinson, Ain’t Nobody (Rufus, featuring Chaka Khan)
Good performance, but not great. Sounded like the music was louder than his voice. He, too, used the riser behind the judges. I think it would’ve been funny if he sang a Milli Vanilli song, like “Blame It On the Rain” or “Girl You Know It’s True.” Did they ever have a #1 Billboard hit? And if they did, did they have to give their #1 spot to the #2 after the whole lip-syncing scandal went down? That’s like Mike Greenwell asking for his MVP trophy now that Jose Canseco admitted he won the award with the “help” of steroids. Randy called it another ambitious song choice (which means he didn’t like it), but he always brings it home well. Paula called it an incredible job. Simon called his performance inconsistent and risky to take on a song like that. I voted for Anwar tonight, partly because he’s my favorite to win it all.

11- Jessica Sierra, Total Eclipse of the Heard (Bonnie Tyler)
How great was this song in the ‘80s? How many times does she say “turn around” in this song? About 20 times. If you really listen to the lyrics of this song, they are powerful. I’d say that Bonnie Tyler was a one-hit wonder, but she did have “Holding Out For A Hero” that graced the “Footloose” soundtrack. Don’t get me started on “Footloose.” We just saw that movie on cable the other day. Believe me, you either love the movie or you hate it with a passion. Personally, I love the movie. It was hokey, yes. It took itself WAY too serious, I know that. But you can’t deny the fact that Kevin Bacon was in it. And the splendiferous soundtrack. Kenny Loggins (Footloose and I’m Free), Denise Williams (Let’s Hear It For The Boy), Ann Wilson/Mike Reno (Almost Paradise), Bonnie Tyler (Holding Out For A Hero, played during the Tractor Chicken scene), Shalamar (Dancing In The Sheets). And for the 15th anniversary soundtrack, they added Foreigner (Waiting For A Girl Like You), John Cougar Mellancamp (Hurts So Good) and Quiet Riot (Bang Your Head). Saw this production at the Chicago Theater. Just love it. I was worried when Jessica sang this because Bonnie Tyler has such a distinctive voice and Jessica really didn’t change it much, but the judges liked it. She wore a very interesting top tonight. See thru on the lower half. Kinda Diana DiGarmo-ish, which is not a good look. By the way, Jessica reminds me of “Miami” a character in ESPN’s original series “Tilt” about poker. Randy called it a brilliant performance. Paula said she closed the show right on top. Simon said that everyone has been saying the guys are dominating but Jessica and Carrie outsang everyone tonight. I concur. I voted for Jessica tonight.

Overall, it was a good night (except for Mikalah). If she does get ousted tomorrow, the competition then turns serious because everyone is good and somewhat Idol-worthy. Some are more worthy than others, but assuming Mikalah is gone tomorrow, every cut will be hard after her.

Wednesday, March 16, 2005

AI4 recap, Finalists x 12 (03/15)

This one will be late, because it’s 10:30pm and I still have not watched it in it’s entirety yet.

A few notes on since we last checked in.

Mario is gone and Nikko is back. Supposedly Mario voluntarily withdrew, but there are conflicting reports as to why. I’ve heard that he already has a record deal lined up and that would violate his American Idol contract. He’s not saying exactly why he quit, but it’s a shocker nonetheless. In his defense, once you’re a finalist, you might as well wear that shirt that reads “Property of American Idol,” because you are pretty much at their mercy. The first few seasons, that was fine and dandy. Most were unknowns that needed this as their break. But I think what this entails is a huge promotional tour with concert dates that will eat up a year or so of your time. Mario has always been kinda cocky and a loner, just wanting to make it on his own. He’s no spring chicken either (I think he was in his late 20s), so maybe he figured a year of his life/career at this point would be counter-productive. I’ll miss him, because he was one of my favorites to win, but he wasn’t my #1, so I can live with him gone. And I’m glad Nikko’s back. But I would’ve rather had Amanda back (but that goes without saying).

I’m glad that they are not having the contestants sing after they get eliminated. That’s really pouring salt in the wounds, if you think about it. They were basically saying, the song you sang last night didn’t get you enough votes, so why don’t you sing it again. I guess it was first done to honor the contestant’s work on the show, but at this point in the competition, I’m glad it’s gone.

And I’m glad that they don’t have the families in the red room anymore. How annoying was that? Seeing the families boo Simon when he was being brutally honest?

On to tonight, where the theme is the ‘60s. Any song written or sung in the ‘60s, regardless of genre, is fair game. New stage tonight too. Huge stage.

01 – Jessica Sierra, Shop Around (Smokey Robinson)
Also done by Captain and Tennille in the ‘70s. Jessica reminds me of a chubby Taylor Dayne. I loved Taylor Dayne in the ‘80s. Get her Greatest Hits (Say A Prayer, Tell It To My Heart, I’ll Always Love You, With Every Beat of My Heart, Love Will Lead You Back, Don’t Rush Me, Prove Your Love, just to name a few). A lot of love and heart and love and heart in those titles. Anyway, Jessica’s got a big voice, to go along with her big bones. Wore a red top that looked like stretchy material, although maybe that’s just how it fit her… She missed a few notes, but was pretty okay. Randy said she was a little pitchy and just okay. Paula is still a huge fan of her voice. Simon called it very boring and an uninspiring performance. I still think she’ll be okay tomorrow. She’s in my top 3 girls still left in the competition (behind Nadia and Carrie, and way behind Amanda).

02 – Anwar Robinson, A House Is Not A Home (Burt Bacharach)
Anwar comes out in a black version of Jerry Seinfeld’s “puffy shirt.” Remember that episode where Kramer’s girlfriend a “soft talker” and Jerry agrees to wear her shirt on a national TV show and Bryant Gumbel makes fun of him? “But I don’t want to wear a puffy shirt…” Classic. And Anwar also has a long black coat on that has enough buttons on it that it looks like something Napoleon wore. Other than that, I loved him. We think Tamyra sang this song and someone may have sung it last year when Burt was a guest judge. He does a good job with it. Not my favorite performance of his, but I hope better things are on the horizon. Randy called it a safe performance. Paula said he dressed in style and that he is flawless. Simon said he was more serious tonight and likes the fun side of him better. Anwar should be safe tomorrow night and is my favorite to win it all.

03 – Mikalah Gordon, Son of a Preacher Man (Dusty Springfield)
Looks like Mikalah got her eyebrows waxed for tonight. Very interesting outfit. She wore a short blouse and low rise pants that showed her midriff. Not the best fashion choice for her. We’ve already discussed that she needs to say no more at the dinner table. Fun song for her, she just doesn’t have that great of a singing voice. It’s been bandied around that she is a younger and just as annoying version of Fran Drescher (the Nanny). I think an annoying Minnie Driver could now be viewed as a compliment! One of my wife’s co-workers went into a whole foray about how the Coffee Talk ladies were probably going ga-ga over her last week because she sang a “Bah-brah” song. And my former (I use that word because I was told not to use “old” anymore by another “former” manager) manager’s manager Mike P. says that Mikalah probably has a big following in New York, New Jersey and South Florida. Randy called it rough for him. Paula said it wasn’t her favorite performance, but was glad she got her fun back. Simon said her confidence exceeded her ability tonight. Tonight? How about always? Her ability is NEVER higher than her confidence. I hope Mikalah is gone tomorrow, or soon. That being said, I will stop doing these things if she is voted off tomorrow night…

04 – Constantine Maroulis, You’ve Made Me So Very Happy (Blood Sweat & Tears)
No leather jacket today. Constantine actually sang tonight and didn’t try to “rocker” it up. Good voice, but I thought it sounded a bit Broadway. I did hear that he was in an off-Broadway production of Rent though. He seemed to scream less tonight. Did a decent job. I think he’ll be around for a few more weeks. Randy called it his best performance so far. Paula called his last note great. Simon said if the competition was Smoldering Idol, he’d win hands down. I was high on Constantine, then over him, and now I’m coming back to liking him. If he sticks around, I’ll be okay with it.

05 – Lindsey Cardinale, Knock on Wood (Eddie Floyd)
Lindsey was a bit flat tonight and she really can’t dance to save her life. Looks real uncomfortable up on the stage when she has to move around. Maybe she should sing more ballads so that she can just sit on a stool. She’s reduced to doing those knee bends that Jennifer Hudson used to do last year. Lindsey. Pretty girl. Husky voice. Not as talented as the others in the competition. Randy said he didn’t know. Paula asked her how she thought she did (which means it was horrible). Simon made some bad put down. I like Lindsey but she’s just been skating by. If you’re on Survivor, flying under the radar is a good thing. If you’re on American Idol, you want to be memorable. I can’t remember any song she’s sung so far. That is not an American Idol.

06 – Anthony Fedorov, Breaking Up Is Hard To Do (Neil Sedaka)
Every time Anthony sings now, I think about Clay Aiken and compare him to Clay. Clay would’ve killed this song. Anthony did not. My wife said that Clay had an old voice and that she likes Anthony because he has a much younger sounding voice. I like Anthony too, but that trachea thing bugs me a bit. I’m really cognizant of it now when he sings. Like that person who has a mole on their face with a hair in it. You just can’t stop focusing on it. Or the person with the bad comb-over. It’s like a magnet. Randy called it a below average performance in a bad hotel. Paula said it wasn’t bad, just not up to his par performance. Simon likened to when someone tries to sing at a Christmas office party and fails. I didn’t think it was that bad. I think Anthony will be safe tomorrow, but he’s not in my top 2 guys.

07 – Nadia Turner, You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me (Dusty Springfield)
Slowed it down. Wore an aqua-ish dress where the skirt was attached to her left wrist. Nadia’s like Tamyra, but she doesn’t have as strong a voice nor the range. But Tamyra is amazing, so the last statement is by no means a put down. Nadia is my co-favorite girl along with Carrie. She did a great job with this song, although it did remind me of the Stockard Channing (Rizzo) song in Grease (There Are Worse Things I Could Do). Randy gave her props for being the first one to bring it tonight. Paula was excited for her because she’s in it to win (um, aren’t they all?). Simon said that in a competition full of hamburgers, Nadia is a steak. She’s a filet mignon, as far as I’m concerned.

08 – Bo Bice, Spinning Wheel (Blood Sweat & Tears)
Bo sure knows how to sing using that mic stand. Bo went out into the crowd (a la Fantasia). I tell you, Bo knows how to perform and he gets it. He gets that he doesn’t have to perform for the judges (which is what some of the singers do). The judges comment on you, but they’re not the ones voting. Bo gives a great performance for the audience and the viewers. As long as Bo sings songs that I know or can get with, I’m on his bandwagon. He’s in my top 2 guys (behind Anwar). Although he did have an open shirt today and he either had a medallion or a tattoo on his chest. But it was blurred out. I actually thought it was a tuft of hair that he had shaved in the shape of something. Had to do a double take. Randy said “way to get it done” and I think there was a dog in there somewhere. Paula called him a superstar. Simon said it looks like he’s been doing it for 20 years. Well, he does look that old…

09 – Vonzell Solomon, Anyone Who Had A Heart (Dionne Warwick)
This song title reminds me of the “About Last Night…” soundtrack. There was a song on there by John Waite called “If Anybody Had A Heart.” Great soundtrack. A couple of Sheena Easton songs. Just a wonderful movie too. It’s funny, but this was the first movie for Elizabeth Perkins. One of her more memorable roles, but she looked horrible because she really is pretty. Like in Big or Indian Summer or even The Flintstones. Loved her in “He Said, She Said,” with … Kevin Bacon. And how great was Rob Lowe in About Last Night? And his career? Had a pretty good run (Outsiders, Oxford Blues, St Elmo’s Fire, Youngblood, About Last Night…). Then the sex tape. But he recovered quite nicely from that. I think Wayne’s World & Tommy Boy revived his career. The West Wing was good for him and even got him a few more TV shows (The Lyon’s Den and Dr Vegas). Back to Vonzell. She was wearing a salmon/peach (?) colored prom dress. Very pretty girl, as a matter of fact, we let Jared stay up and watch tonight (that’s part of the reason this is so late, as he had a hard time getting to sleep tonight) and he told his mommy that she (Vonzell) was very pretty. She really looks like someone, but I can’t put my finger on it. Please, anyone, let me know who you think she looks like. Randy called it an ambitious song choice (which, as we know, means they didn’t pull it off). Paula said she looked lovely tonight (although that dress showed her hips a little too much). Simon called her “in the middle” and needs to do something great to stay in the competition. I agree wholeheartedly.

10 – Scott Savol, Ain’t Too Proud To Beg (The Temptations)
Scott, my man, came out in a suede suit. Like one that one of the basketball players would wear on Draft Night. You know, those loud, usually pinstripe deals that have a minimum of 6 buttons on them. If I win Excalibur this year, I will give serious thought to buying an NBA Draft Night suit to walk across the stage next year in Vegas… I love Scott’s voice. I hope that he stays in this competition. The only bummer was that they didn’t have a “family and friends” shot for him after his performance. Randy said it was good and it was mostly in tune (backhanded compliment). Paula called it fun. Simon said he was surprised and that he did good. I think Scott is on the fence every week from here on out just because he may not have a huge following. I like him though.

11 – Carrie Underwood, When Will I Be Loved (Everly Brothers)
Straightened her hair, which looked good. Wore a little more make up tonight, which was a good thing. Usually I’m a less is more kind of guy, but more was good on Carrie tonight. More was not good on Mikalah tonight. Carrie is a bit stiff on stage too, but not to the extent of Lindsey. Carrie still has such a big voice. I’m a fan of hers. Randy said that she has one of the better voices in the competition but has not been showing it lately. Paula called her performance safe and boring. Simon disagreed and said there are 3 people who know what they are and she is one of them (I’m guessing the other 2 are Bo and Nadia?). I hope Carrie goes far in this competition. Or I hope they bring Amanda back. Either one will do. It’s funny but a lot of guys were upset that Amanda was voted off, but most of the guys that were upset were probably ones that don’t vote. That’ll get you every time. Gotta vote if you want to keep people around. I should talk. I didn’t vote tonight.

12 – Nikko Smith, I Want You Back (Jackson 5)
Poor Nikko only probably 3 days to prepare for this. My wife calls him Urkel. My buddy Jeff works as a trainer down on the Warner Bros lot and he used to train Jaleel White. And he trained Bob Sagat. Almost golfed with Jose Canseco the other day. He trains a guy who is on a show that knows Jose. That would’ve been cool. He heard Jose hits it a mile but can’t keep it on the short grass. That’s like me, except for the hitting it a mile thing. Nikko was definitely better than Travis in the whole “sing while you dance” thing. I hope that Nikko makes it through to next week so that he can have a whole week to prepare for the next show. He was not great tonight, but good given the time constraints. Randy was glad to have him back. Paula said he did his own thing. Simon thought he was horrible. I like him. Oh baby, baby, I want him back.

If I would’ve voted tonight, I would’ve voted for Anwar, Nadia, Bo, Scott and Carrie.

Tuesday, March 08, 2005

AI4 recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 8 (03/08)

I think it was a first last night that I got all the songs right and also the correct artists.

And by the way, I’m a Scorpio.

Let’s get to it.

01 – Amanda Avila (Gemini), River Deep Mountain High (Tina Turner)
It seemed as though she was having trouble with her mic. Like it was too sensitive and it was registering all the time that she tapped the mic when she was singing. Really upbeat song though and had the crowd going. She looked wonderful tonight, as always. Put it this way. I’m voting for her every night unless she’s embarrassingly horrible. And she was adequate tonight. Not even resembling horrible. I was the same way with Jasmine last year. I voted for her regardless, until the talent differential was clearly evident. I’m not ashamed to admit that. Randy said it was good, nice and okay. Paula said it was good and she’s sure that Amanda has enough fans out there to put her into the finals (ya think?). Simon said that she looked great, but didn’t come close to the Tina Turner version. He called her an average singer, but a good performer. I’ve said it before and will say it again. She’s Christina Christian all over again. But she’s a stronger singer than Christina. If Amanda is voted off tomorrow night, I will stop writing these things.

02 – Janay Castine (Libra), Dreaming of You (Selena)
That was Selena, the one who was tragically murdered by an obsessed fan and portrayed by Jennifer Lopez in one of her first roles, not Celena Rae. She was horrible tonight. She changed her game plan tonight. Going for a slower, less contemporary hip-hop song. I appreciated the change, but not the execution. She was WAY flat (even my tone deaf ears could hear that). She seriously shakes when she performs and she sounds like a goat. Randy called her pitchy and only 5 or 6 notes were in tune. Paula called the song choice ambitious (have you noticed when they say “ambitious,” it usually means they didn’t pull it off?), but pitchy. Simon clowned her by going with the whole astrology theme and saw in her future a suitcase and plane travel. The problem with the judges ganging up on a performer is that sometimes they get pity votes (see last year: JPL and Finchy). By the way, my wife played Bunco tonight and had to watch it TiVo-ed and she said that she could’ve done without seeing that performance tonight. My feelings exactly. If she’s not gone tomorrow night, I will stop writing these things (just kidding, because crazier things have happened when America votes).

03 – Carrie Underwood (Pisces)
Sorry, wasn’t familiar with the song (was it Because You Love Me?). She was had this peach-colored top on that sparkly things over her bosom and around the bottom. I actually thought she was only wearing a bra because the top looked flesh-colored. She’s got a very strong voice, but was a bit off tonight. She is such a pretty girl that she needs a serious makeover. If they can work with Kimberly Locke, they can make her Miss America. Randy said it wasn’t her best. The performance was a bit pitchy and she seemed scared. But he’s still a fan of her voice. Paula wishes that she would get back to the happy-go-lucky girl they saw in Hollywood, but the vocals are still there. Simon said she was looking a bit old-fashioned and is waiting for her to connect with a good song. But he did say that she sounds fantastic in whatever she sings. I think she’ll make it through to the finals.

04 – Vonzell Solomon (Pisces), Respect (Aretha Franklin)
Interesting. She came out with a white cowboy had and white cowboy boots with tassels. Didn’t really fit the song. She had fun with the performance though and she still reminds me of Vivica A. Fox. By the way, is there another Vivica Fox that she has to add the middle initial? A friend asked last week when submitting a pick for my golf pool, is there another Jose Olazabal that he has to include the Maria? Randy said she was having fun and he saw glimpse of what could be great. Paula called her great and likes that she takes risks. Simon said it was an okay performance, but that the outfit didn’t fit the song. Then she admitted that she’s alone out in California and her daddy brought her the hat and boots and she wanted to wear them. So, she gets a pass from me. Just no more Alicia Keys songs, Vonzell.

05 – Nadia Turner (Capricorn), Try a Little Tenderness (Otis Redding)
Nadia is growing on me. She’s way more talented than Amanda, but she’s quickly becoming my 2nd favorite behind Amanda. She’s pulled into a tie with Carrie. Nadia came out in a black tank top and a black mini-poodle skirt (is that possible?). She’s got a real cool fashion sense. She does remind me of Holly Robinson-Peete, back when she was just Holly Robinson, minus the twins, circa 21 Jump Street. Remember that show? With Johnny Depp, Peter DeLuise, Richard Grieco (for a few seasons) and Dustin Nguyen? Did they really look like high schoolers? Then again, the O.C. was just made fun of in a recent episode of “Will and Grace” for having 25 year old high school students with 35 year old parents. And only David Silver and Donna Martin looked like teenagers in 90210. So I guess it’s not that much of a stretch. Nadia also reminds me a bit of Joie Lee, Spike’s sister. Her filmography includes just about every Spike Lee joint. Kinda like John Turturro, but he gets other work. How funny was his character in “He Got Game?” Anyway, Nadia gave an unbelievable performance of this song. It was a tad better than Duckie’s lip-synch in “Pretty in Pink.” I think one of the more underrated performances in that movie was Annie Potts’. Andrew “Dice” Clay made a cameo in that movie too, as the bouncer at the club who would never let the Duck Man in. Randy loves watching her perform and digs her outfits. Says she has that star potential. Paula said she has a knack for picking the right song for her, although my wife would disagree and say that ANY song is good for her. She makes it her own and has her own unique style. Paula said she is the whole package and has the X factor (which Randy corrected to call it the “it” factor). Simon called it amazing and reminded her of a young (and stick thin) Tina Turner. She took a risk and it will pay off with a trip to the finals. Again, I’m becoming a huge fan of Nadia’s.

06 – Lindsey Cardinale (Aquarius), I Don’t Want To Miss A Thing (Aerosmith, Armageddon soundtrack)
First off, I have to qualify the fact that I loved this movie (yes, I know it was sappy and predictable and had Ben Affleck in it, but sue me). And I loved this song in this movie. So Lindsey had me at “I could spend my life…” She wasn’t great with this song, but given what has just been written, I was okay with it. She came out with a teal top and some funky black Capri-type pants. Made her look like I Dream of Jeannie. She did show off her husky voice again, but it didn’t really match the song all that well. Randy said that she came back and the husky tone has returned. Not the bomb, but good. Paula said she’s a fan of her voice, but not a fan of the songs that she picks. Simon called her the musical equivalent of Seacrest. Look the part, but leave them disappointed. Then Seacrest threw water on him and ran back to the stage to stay out of harms way. I voted for Lindsey tonight, but won’t be crushed if she doesn’t make through.

07 – Mikalah Gordon (Capricorn), Somewhere (Barbra Streisand, West Side Story soundtrack)
Mikalah now officially bugs me. She’s too young. She’s kooky, then she acts all grown up. Being wacky was way too much for me, but being reserved is just a façade. No grey area with her. She came out with some kind of black leotard thing that was probably meant to be slimming, but it really wasn’t. This song was okay, but considering LaToya London brought the house down with it last year, Mikalah’s version was quite “ambitious.” Randy called it a very interesting song choice. Shaky at the beginning, pitchy in parts but nailed a few high notes. But her called her fearless; a risk taker. Paula said she tackled a tough song and was shaky at the start but nailed it at the end. Simon called the first part hideous and the last part was fine. He thinks she went into an aging machine and is not fun anymore. All of her songs have been safe. I agree that she needs to show more personality in her song choices, but then again, I’m not a fan of her personality, so I hope she’s gone soon. Mikalah and Janay are just too young for this competition.

08 – Jessica Sierra (Scorpio), (The Boys Are) Back In Town (various country artists)
Jessica came out in a green velvet thing that surely accentuated her, um, things that set girls apart from boys. It reminded me of something out of Camelot, like what Lady Guenevere would wear. Did a good job with the song. She said in her pre-song thing that she didn’t make the cut last year, but tried out again and is now in the top 16. She’ll be in the top 12 for sure. Randy likes her blues, soul, country, rock sound and calls her in control. Paula said she found her niche. Simon said that with that outfit, she couldn’t have picked a better song title. Easy Simon, this is a family show. She’s good. She’ll be through to the finals.

I voted once for everyone except Janay and Mikalah. I think Janay, Mikalah and Lindsey are on the bubble. Vonzell too maybe.

It’s amazing how much stronger the guys are than the girls. The way they set it up this year with exactly 6 guys and 6 girls making it to the final 12 will hurt some of the guys, as it could easily be 8 guys and 4 girls.

Until next week…

Monday, March 07, 2005

AI4 recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 8 (03/07)

A few thoughts on the “boot the four that suck show.” How is Janay still in this competition? She is JPL, Finchy and Leah LaBelle all rolled up into one. Joe Murena gave the “not enough exposure” excuse that Simon attacked before the singers started. Simon correctly recalled that Kelly Clarkson got no run before she took the competition by the throat and made it her own. I was sorry to see David go, but he was bound to the get the boot. Celena just wasn’t that good. Aloha deserved to have one more performance (over Janay), but I’m not heartbroken that she’s gone. See, aloha does mean goodbye. At this point in the competition, you’ve got to sing well. A bad song choice will do you in.

Going in, I had a feeling that this show would be pretty good because 1) the guys, as a group, are way stronger than the girls and b) everyone left can sing and/or perform.

01 – Scott Savol (Taurus), I Can’t Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Honey Bunch) (The Four Tops)
First off, why did they give all the singers’ Zodiac signs? Was that not ridiculous? Scott comes out in the smoke tinted shades again, which is a good thing because he’s got some crazy eyes sometimes. Scott sang the song with some subtle theatrics thrown in. He was making the gestures, but not really. Like he was too cool to really do them, so he kinda half did them. Gesticulations aside, I really like Scott’s voice. He’s just a big Pillsbury Doughboy up there. He had some nice runs during the song. I’ve told a few people that I like Scott, but I think that I may like him more than I should because I’m amazed at the voice that comes out of that body. Randy said that he had fun with the song and he finally saw the personality again that was first shown in his audition in Cleveland. Paula loved the little choreography. Simon said that he should stick to something that he’s good at … singing and leave the dancing behind. Personally the dancing didn’t bother me. I’m still amazed at that voice. I voted for Scott tonight, but think he may be on the bubble on Wednesday. Being on the bubble is nothing to be ashamed of in that all 8 are pretty strong and two HAVE to go.

02 – Bo Bice (Scorpio), I’ll Be (Edwin McCain)
Finally, a song that I recognized and liked from Bo. I love Edwin McCain. As some of you may know (from past recaps), “I Could Not Ask For More” was the song that Kristin and I danced to at our wedding. We got that song from the “Message in a Bottle” soundtrack. Good movie, except for the ending. Sorry. Hope I didn’t give anything away there. I’m actually a Kevin Costner fan. Partly because I choose to remember him by his successes (American Flyers, The Untouchables, No Way Out, Bull Durham, Field of Dreams, JFK, The Bodyguard, Tin Cup, For Love of the Game, Message in a Bottle) and forgive him/forget about his truly bad choices (Waterworld, The Postman, Revenge, Thirteen Days, 3000 Miles to Graceland). Kristin and I saw Edwin McCain live at a VH1 party at the Sundance Film Festival (thanks TAP). Also saw Sammy Hagar there (sans the long hair, which was weird) and Liev Schreiber (Cotton Weary from the Scream movies). Any way, Bo was good … again. I think I’m one of the only people that isn’t really digging him. Partly because I don’t know all the songs he sings. Partly because I think he looks and performs like a young Joe Cocker. I’m not ANTI-Bo, just not over-the-top PRO-Bo like some people are. It doesn’t really matter to me who wins this thing because I’m only going to buy CDs of the people that I like anyway. Randy said it was not his best and was shaky at the start but he still likes him. Paula called it a consistent slam dunk. Simon called it absolutely 100% the right kind of song for him. He said the competition is his to lose at this point. We’ll see once they have to do the theme nights. I did not vote for Bo tonight because I guarantee he’s safe on Wednesday.

03 – Anthony Fedorov (Taurus), I’ve Got You (Marc Anthony)
I had to look that song up. I couldn’t figure out if it was Marc Anthony. Or Enrique Iglesias. Or Ricky Martin. Or Menudo. Or William Hung. I really think Anthony is a good kid and a great story (trachea thing), although TAPer James Snodgrass wishes he’d break out more turtlenecks because he thinks his trachea is going to blow during one of his performances. Anthony came out with a blazer that looked like someone threw paint on. Kinda stylish, kinda not. Randy said that he got the power back in his voice and was finally back. Paula said it was the best they’ve seen of him so far and that he was brilliant. Simon said he was a nice guy but was confused with the song choice. Seemed out of place saying he’s got as much Latin flair as a polar bear. I was thinking the same thing. Has anyone heard the comedian Henry Cho? Asian guy from Knoxville, TN? Same thing. Asian guy with a Southern accent. It just doesn’t fit. I didn’t vote for Anthony, but think he’s okay for Wednesday night.

04 – Nikko Smith (Taurus), Georgia On My Mind (Ray Charles)
Let me say this. Nikko is a suave cat. He dresses in black on black on black and just looks smoove. Throw a fedora on and it’s all good. My wife was just relieved that he didn’t sing Stevie Wonder again. Nikko gave a great performance. Started off a little shaky, but he really knows how to work a crowd and end a performance well. Seacrest gave him a bad time singing about “Georgia” when he’s from St. Louis, but whatever Seacrest. Let the boy sing. Randy said it was very ambitious to sing Ray (especially with the movie and all the attention it’s getting) and he started rough, but ended great and showed range. Paula called it wonderful and can’t imagine the final 12 without him. Simon said that he needed to do that. Said the vocals weren’t great through the whole song, but people will remember the last note. I voted for Nikko tonight. He’s really been pretty good throughout the competition so far. And the kid can sing. I wonder if he can pick it at short though?

05 – Travis Tucker (Aries), Every Little Step (Bobby Brown)
Oh boy. I really like Travis but he needed a mulligan tonight. He’s still pretty stylish, although tonight’s outfit (grey pinstripes w/ suspenders) looked like Michael Jackson’s get up in “Say, Say, Say.” Remember that video with Paul McCartney when they were traveling salesmen hawking their elixirs? Good times. Poor Travis has pigeon-holed himself. He HAS to dance with every song now after last week’s performance. And the dancing throws his vocals off. He’s a good performer, but I think America is looking for a stronger, purer voice. Is it me or does Travis look like he has a dip in all the time? My wife thinks that he’ll ultimately get a modeling or acting gig out of this. I said before that he looks like Steve Smith, but he’s got a little Chris Webber in him too. No one probably knows these guys, but he looks a bit like Joe Branch (former Northwestern hoops player and Bulls intern) and Marquise Kately (current Cal player). Travis’ performance tonight had a little bit of everything. Usher moonwalk. Snake. Beat box. I was hoping that he’d do the caterpillar. Maybe up rock a little, then break it down, do a butterfly, transition to a head spin and back to a back spin and end in a relaxed, hand behind head, legs crossed pose. That would’ve been sweet. But I should’ve known he wasn’t going to do that because he didn’t have his Nike windbreaker on and they didn’t lay down the linoleum square for him to “break” on. Randy gave him an “A” for the performance, but a “D” for his pitch. Paula called him pretty special and that he’s different and unique to the competition and the competition needs that. Simon called the performance appalling. Called it a theme park performance (for which my wife said he offended all the theme park performers out there. My response was they are performing at a theme park for a reason.). Simon called him a dancer first and a vocalist second. I agree. I think Travis is vulnerable tomorrow night. I really like the guy, but I did not vote for him tonight.

06 – Mario Vazquez (Gemini), How Can You Mend A Broken Heart? (Al Green)
I had to look for the title of this one. It’s been in like a million movies or TV shows. I found it on the “Notting Hill” soundtrack. I think it was also on Ally McBeal (one of my favorite shows ever, well, at least the first few seasons). That show was just so funny and quirky. Then they lost cast members and tried to force new ones on us. Lucy Liu and Portia de Rossi were good additions. Everyone else from the fourth season on (it only lasted 5 seasons), save Robert Downey, Jr, was a complete miss. The only good thing to come out of those last fateful seasons was that Josh Groban was on. The last episode of the fourth season was supposed to be a wedding (presumably between Ally and Downey, Jr’s character) but he had that little problem in the hotel room that pre-empted it. That fifth season was painful to watch. They had already let Billy and Georgia go. John Cage was taking sabbaticals. Ling left midway through the season. Ally found out she had a biological daughter. Actually I’m glad it’s done. They really wrecked it and the last season had no semblance of what originally made it good and funny. Bygones. Back to Mario. No hat tonight. Came out in a camel hair blazer, which set off all kinds of “Are you ready for some football?” thoughts, as it reminded me of the Monday Night Football blazers. Did a great job with the song. Incredible control. Although he reminds my wife of Justin Guarini, except he’s real. Justin always had a put on, fake feel to him. Randy called it a very ambitious song choice and he needs to be in the final 12. Paula said she got goose bumps and he had nice transitions during the song. Simon said he has a charm about him. He thinks there are better singers in the competition, but overall he’s very strong. I voted for Mario tonight. He should be safe on Wednesday.

07 – Constantine Maroulis (Virgo), Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic (The Police)
Really pitchy at the beginning, but then I realized that’s just how he sings. Came out in a tux blazer, with Bogart lapels. I think they were olive color. Interesting look. Definitely less screaming this time, but that probably had to do with the song choice. Constantine gave a shout out to his band, Pray for the Soul of Betty during one of the interludes. I like Constantine, but I’m done with him. He should be exiting on Wednesday. Randy liked him tonight, said he was in tune and that he has the personality and star potential for the competition. At this point, my wife almost gagged, as she was put off by the way he takes compliments. Paula said his charisma was shining through. Simon called it a bad impersonation of Sting. As far as I’m concerned, Pray for the Soul of Betty, you can have your lead singer back on Wednesday night.

08 – Anwar Robinson (Taurus), What a Wonderful World (Louis Armstrong)
Anwar took this classic song and jazzed it up quite wonderfully. My wife thinks that he has a distinct advantage in this competition because of his musical background. He understands music theory and can make ANY song his own. Because (like it or not) that’s what AI is all about. You take a simple song and make it your own. If you take a stylized song and try to further stylize it, you lose. See the girls and Alicia Keys last week. Anwar was wonderful tonight. His control was excellent. Forget that fact that I think that he looks like Keenan McCardell. My mom thinks he looks a bit like Andre Miller. Any way you slice it, he’s a winner. He’s been so strong every performance so far. I think that he is now my favorite to win it all. Or Janay Castine. Take your pick. Randy gave it up and said it was the best vocal performance all season so far. Paula dug deep for this analogy. She called his voice truly his instrument and it’s the entire orchestra. What? Does she write fortune cookie lines in her spare time? She also said that he breaths new life into old songs. Simon said that he’s everything a music teacher should be. And he called him very genuine. And he suggested that he and Paula get married and have kids because then they’d be the nicest kids in the world. I voted for Anwar tonight. He should be safe on Wednesday too.

So that’s it. It was a pretty good night. I think that Travis and Constantine are going to be gone, although it wouldn’t surprise me if Anthony or Scott didn’t make it either. My final four for the guys is Anwar, Mario, Nikko and Bo.

We’ll see. By the way, I can’t believe I took the time to write down everyone’s sign.

Tuesday, March 01, 2005

AI4 recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 10 (03/01)

Missed the first half again. Jared, our son, is great, but he still doesn’t completely grasp the concept that he needs to be sound asleep by 8:00 on Tuesday nights for Daddy to watch AI uninterrupted. He’s working on it though.

01 – Aloha Mischeaux, You Don’t Know My Name (Alicia Keys)
I don’t really know Alicia Keys’ songs all that well, but I do know that she’s pretty hot and also sings songs that are hard to 1) imitate and 2) even harder to rearrange to make it your own. I did catch her duet with Jamie Foxx at the Grammy’s though. As talented as Alicia Keys is, Jamie Foxx can hold his own. I did hear that he was trained in music in college. He’s a very talented comedian. Got his start on “In Living Color.” Didn’t go much for a few years, then played some cool roles. Like Willie Beamen in “Any Given Sunday.” Drew rave reviews for his portrayal of Bundini Brown, Muhammad Ali’s spiritual advisor in “Ali.” Of course, you’ve all heard of his Oscar (and Golden Globe) winning performance of Ray Charles in “Ray.” He also gave a nice little performance in “Shade,” an overlooked con movie about poker with a decent cast (Sylvester Stallone, Gabriel Byrne, Melanie Griffith, Stuart Townsend, Thandie Newton). Brother-in-law grabbed that for me for a stocking stuffer. DVD has some cool card tricks on it. And I love to play Hold ‘Em. I just wish I was a better player… Back to Aloha. Came out in a pink shawl and pink flower in her hair. That’s her thing, kinda like Jasmine from last year. But somehow I don’t think they have community centers rented out with telephones set up for “volunteers” to come down to vote for her all night in St Louis like they did for Jazzy in Honolulu last year. Aloha seems fun, but I’m really not digging her yet. Randy said it was not her best performance. She was pitchy and all over the place (fallout from picking an Alicia Keys song). Paula said it was a tough song to pick. Simon said the song gave her no chance to show her originality and that she seemed “affected.” I hate that word and the way the judges use it. First off, the kids have no idea what it means. Heck, I don’t really even know what they mean. There was that kid in the auditions who was turned down, but his singing coach made it that they called “affected.” And last year there was a girl in the auditions that Paula called “affected.” Oh well, Aloha was not good tonight. Will Aloha mean goodbye? We’ll see tomorrow night.

02 – Lindsey Cardinale
I have no idea what song she sang, let alone the artist whose song it was. It was a fun song. The AI website now lists the songs that the contestants sing. But not until the day after they sing them. So I can tell you “after the recap” what was sung, but then it really doesn’t matter at that point. Lindsey is a pretty girl, but this song had no range (I think that I can say that) and was limiting vocally. But I think that she needed this song to make her feel good about herself in the competition, because she did not do well last week. She wore jeans and a top that kinda made her look pregnant, but not DeGarmo-like. Randy said it was good and better than last week. Paula wants her to stretch herself a little and show off that low, sexy voice, but was glad she picked an up tempo song. Simon didn’t like the song and said that he didn’t even remember what she sang last week, which is a bad thing. He thinks she can be better than she was and is in danger of not being noticed, which will eventually get her voted off the show. I voted for Lindsey tonight because, given the rest of the performances tonight, she was in the top 5. Plus, she said her hometown of Ponchatoula, LA is known for their strawberries, as my hometown of Watsonville is. We’re kindred spirits in that respect. For those of you who thought Watsonville was the “Artichoke Capital of the World,” that distinction goes to CASTROVILLE, not Watsonville.

03 – Jessica Sierra, With A Broken Wing? (some country singer)
Again, another unidentifiable song for me. In her intro, she said that she was definitely a country girl and would like to live on a farm. Maybe she can swap places with Carrie Underwood. Jessica’s outfit was um, interesting. It looked like she was wearing blue drapes, cut down to be a blouse. And white pants. She looked like she should be in the Color Guard. I really liked her performance though. Randy liked her big voice and said that she did a lot better than last week (which is funny because I liked her performance last week). Paula said that she was glad that she did her own version of that song (I can’t believe that she didn’t say “you made it your own”). Simon called it the best vocal performance of the competition for the girls so far. I guess he liked it. I voted for Jessica tonight. I’m really not a C&W fan, but she was pretty good. And if she gets voted off soon, she may still be able to make USA’s Country Star show…

04 – Mikalah Gordon
I don’t know what song she sang, but she sang it very well. She totally toned it down tonight. Although my cousin Stacy called her an annoying version of Minnie Driver. I don’t know what to think of Minnie Driver. The first time I saw her was in “Circle of Friends” with Chris O’Donnell, when she had to gain a bunch of weight to play the part. She was cool in “Grosse Point Blank” and even dated Matt Damon (or was it Tom Brady? Has anyone ever seen them in the same room?) during “Good Will Hunting.” It seems as though she lost the weight from the first movie, but not in the face. She’s got a big face. Like Rocky Dennis in “Mask.” Back to Mikalah. Real cool performance. Sophisticated. Dressed nice. I think she really took Simon’s comments from last week to heart and re-did her image. It worked tonight. Randy gave her mad props, especially to attack a song like that. Paula called her subdued and she nailed it. Simon called it a joy to watch and listen to and it was not a bit annoying. I voted for her tonight. We’ll see how she bounces back next week. Does she keep it toned down or revert back to the borderline annoying teenager?

05 – Celena Rae, When the Lights Go Down? (Faith Hill?)
Not really that familiar with this song, but I’m guessing this was the title because she sang those words like 20 times. It was like George Harrison’s “I Got My Mind Set On You.” Celena came out with some bad earrings that looked like hair extensions, but dangling from her ears. And I thought she was screaming at times. Randy called it okay and a’ight, but not great. Paula said she didn’t click with the song. Simon said there’s a fine line between being a pop star and singing in a hotel and that the performance was of the latter. I agree. I’ve never connected with Celena either. She looks like someone. Kinda Jennifer Love Hewitt, but not really. Remember when FOX was going to have the “Summer of Love” when they spun her off “Party of Five” with “Time of Your Life” where she was trying to look for her biological father? She was ready to make it big, then faded away. She had “Can’t Hardly Wait” and “I Know What You Did Last Summer” but then really nothing. I just saw a “Celebrity Poker Showdown” and Lacey Chabert (Claudia from PO5) was playing and it’s hard to believe, but she’s grown into a looker that’s even better looking than Love. The funny part is that Lacey played Hewitt’s part in “Not Another Teen Movie” which was a parody of numerous movies. Or does Celena look like a younger Sigourney Weaver? Or a younger Lesley Ann Warren? Any way you slice it, Celena should not be in the final 6.

06 – Nadia Turner
Um, didn’t know this song either. I don’t think Nadia and I have the same songs in our iPods (I mean, if I had an iPod). She still went with the fun white tank top and red skirt. But she looked like she had WWF (well, WWE now since the World Wildlife Fund sued and made them change to the World Wrestling Entertainment) boots on. Did an okay performance, but it was not as good as last week’s. Randy said that she uses what she’s got (translation?) and doesn’t have the best voice (which she probably disagrees with) but can perform. Paula credited her for taking risks. Simon said it was a strange song choice, almost as if she was forced to sing that song and made the best of it. He went on to say it made her sound older and cabaret. I did not vote for Nadia tonight, but think she’s safe tomorrow night.

07 – Amanda Avila, Turn the Beat Around (Vickie Sue Robinson)
This was the song that Carmen Rasmussen from season 2 sang. You know the girl that had all the zits on her face that looked like a constellation? It was a very upbeat song, but I had trouble hearing her vocals at times. I liked it, but then again, I can’t help but to think of Phoebe Cates (as Linda Barrett) in “Fast Times at Ridgemont High” when I see her. Randy said the song showed her range. Paula said she raised her game and picked the right song. Simon said that it’s so loud in the studio that he couldn’t hear if she was in tune all song, but overall the performance was good. I voted for Phoe, er, Amanda tonight. Shocker.

08 – Janay Castine
I have no idea what this song was and I don’t want to embarrass myself by taking a stab at it. This was just a bad song choice by a girl who is in over her head. She came out in a tie dye half shirt and put on a club performance that really was not good at all. And I think she has colored contacts in. I’m really not a fan of colored contacts. Randy really gave it to her and said, flat out, that it was not very good. Paula said it wasn’t bad, but disconnected. Simon said she’s not experienced enough of a singer to be in the competition. She should be gone tomorrow night. I will be shocked and disappointed if she is not.

09 – Carrie Underwood, Piece of My Heart (Janis Joplin)
Carrie has accepted the “Farm Girl” label with open arms. Why run from the truth? I thought she was a bit stiff in her on stage performance, but thought the vocals were good. I wasn’t down with the denim on denim look though. She needs a makeover to get her a bit more mainstream in her fashion. It was funny, after her performance, Seacrest put his arm around her and she hugged back and it took him by surprise. Was he surprised because he actually had female contact? Then I thought about it and thought it was a bit creepy, since she’s only 21. The judges didn’t really go for the performance. Randy said it was hard to emulate Janis. Paula said it was not her favorite performance. Simon said it was reminiscent of a cover band. But he’s torn because they really like her. I thought she was good tonight and I think she’ll make it through and hope that she can do even better next week. I voted for her.

10 – Vonzell Solomon, A Woman’s Worth? (Alicia Keys)
Was that the song? All of Alicia Keys’ songs sound the same to me. Alicia Keys is becoming the Whitney Houston of this season. Girls keep choosing the songs, failing to realize that they can’t sing them better than Alicia did. Vonzell did a good job though and the crowd was into it. She came out in black with some gold choker/necklace/Nefertiti type thing around her neck, but it looked kinda cool. And it matched her gold belt too. Vonzell seems so fun and I’m a fan of hers … as long as she doesn’t start “Elaine” dancing. Randy liked it. Paula said it started off good and it was ambitious to sing Alicia Keys. Simon said she overcooked the performance and that sometimes, less is more. Regardless, I voted for Vonzell tonight.

Overall tonight’s performances were disappointing. The guys killed it on Monday. I think that the final 6 should be Carrie, Vonzell, Amanda, Jessica, Nadia and Mikalah. I think that Aloha, Janay, Celena and Lindsey are on the bubble tomorrow night.

This cut should be okay (the people voted off will probably deserve it). Next week will get tougher. Then the final 12 will be brutal because I’m guessing that all 12 will be worthy of being the American Idol. It will come down to song choice. There will be no free weeks once the finals start. It will be very interesting to see how “niche singers” (Bo=rocker, Jessica/Carrie=country) can adapt to the themes that I think they will throw at them.

That’s it for now and I still miss my wife…

AI4 recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 10 (02/28)

AI4 recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 10 (02/28)

Okay, just so you know. I don’t “recap” the results (AKA announce the loser) show. But I usually comment on it in the recap for the next week, as I will do now.

Melinda Lira being the first off. She was absolutely stunned. She was very pitchy in her performance, but did get compliments on how she may have the best voice in the show. She complained that she wasn’t a focus of the audition shows and no one got to know her. That argument holds a little bit of water, but then my wife pointed out that Kelly Clarkson didn’t get no run (my words, not hers) in AI the Original either. America didn’t get to know her until she crept up on the competition and won the thing. I think that Melinda was thinking that she was safe because of the terrible performance that the other girl (Janay) she was up there with had given. Janay was the one who I described as having Tourette’s-like motions, then went on to describe autism (Rain Man reference). So it wasn’t bad enough that I was making fun of one affliction, but compounded the error by making fun of a completely different condition. So, if it hasn’t totally been decided if I’m going north or south when it’s all said and done, I’ll cement the decision with this comment. I could’ve also said that she was making Parkinson’s movements. So there, now I’m going on a Fast Pass to Hell. I guess if you’re going to go, there’s no use in waiting. Speaking of Parkinson’s, was anyone else frightened to death when Muhammad Ali was carrying that torch in the ’96 Olympics in Atlanta? Now it’s time for my athlete/famous person pseudo-apology. You know, the “I didn’t mean to offend anyone, but if I did, I’m sorry” one. Believe me, if you have to start out with “I didn’t mean to offend anyone…” you’ve sufficiently offended someone. Probably a lot of someones. So I guess I take back the apology because I really knew that I’d be offending people.

Jared Yates was no surprise in getting the boot. It was brutal when Seacrest asked Simon if he had any constructive advice for him and Simon blankly stared ahead and simply said, “no.” I don’t think that Jared even finished his song. I can’t wait for the time when a contestant says, “no Ryan, I just lost. I’m emotional and I can’t sing right now.” Oh wait that DID happen when Christina Christian got eliminated in the first season and was “sick” for the results show.

Sarah Mather was bad. Glad she got the boot.

Judd Harris had the best attitude of all the ones voted off. He said, “it is what it is.” He really wasn’t much of a singer as an entertainer though. My buddy Mikey really despised him and thought that he belonged on a float or something with all of that dancing around. Mike was going to post a comment on the blog (http://airecaps.blogspot.com) but it was making him register then it didn’t work out. I’d love for any of you to post comments on there, as long as it’s not a long and arduous process…

I gotta tell you, that results show was crazy. Seacrest was pulling a Jim Gray and being real mean to the kids as they got voted off. He was almost smug about it. Almost felt like he was enjoying giving the bad news. Not empathetic at all. I think that this group of 24 (now 20) are much closer and they’ve formed more friendships than the past seasons. Partly because last year, it was 4 groups of 8 and they voted 2 through each week (plus one wild card that America picked and 1 each from the judges). There were tears like mad last week and Wednesday night should be no different.

My wife commented that the judges shouldn’t really be assessing the results show with “it just wasn’t good enough” but rather “the competition is stiff.” I really think that the remaining 20 are all about where we were in the final 6 last season. I couldn’t say final 12 because Finchy, JPL and Leah LaBelle were all finalists and none of them can hold a torch to even the 4 that were already eliminated.

On to tonight. Just a note, the girls seemed way more relaxed tonight compared to last week. Sorry this is late, but my wife is traveling for work right now. So, not only do you not get her comments, but I also don’t have my “ear for music” with me and I was helping my mom put our son to sleep and consequently missed the first half of the show. It was TiVo-ed, so I watched it all, but I’m starting a half an hour later. It may be even later tomorrow night… I miss my wife :(

01 – Mario Vazquez, I Love Music? (artist unknown)
Mario was wearing a fedora, a white one to compliment (?) his white blazer. All this over a yellow t-shirt with jeans and some cool sneaks. Good performance, but he does give a cheesy smile to the camera sometimes. He’s still one of my favorites though. Randy said he’s got it going on, but wants to hear more with his voice. Paula said it was good, but she, too, is looking for more. Simon said that he looks like he’s been doing this for years and doesn’t really need their advice. I voted for Mario tonight. I’m looking forward to better things from him in the competition.

02 – Anwar Robinson, What’s Going On (Marvin Gaye)
The music teacher came out with a camouflage jacket on. I almost didn’t see him up there. Okay stop booing, that wasn’t THAT bad of a joke. Nice upbeat performance. I like Anwar. I voted for him tonight. Randy said that he worked it out and had great control of his voice. Paula said the stepped it up and that he has amazing tone to his voice. She also called him technically, the best vocalist of the competition. Simon said he sounded fantastic. I don’t have to tell you this. I’m a fan of his. Which I can’t really say about…

03 – Joseph Murena, Let’s Stay Together (Al Green)
First off, he’s got a five-head. Bigger than a forehead. It’s a five-head. Like Christina Ricci. Or Tyra Banks. Joe reminds me of a young Armand Assante. Or like TAPer Eugenio Gabella. Take your pick. Joe comes out in a pleated tux shirt that is open almost to his naval. Big lapels and a black blazer. Was he singing at the local piano bar after the competition? I thought it was very “lounge-y.” Randy said he was waiting for one note or run to distinguish him, but it never came. Paula said it was a classy performance and better than last week (did he suck that bad last week?). Simon said that it reminded him of a song in a Portuguese night club in ’74. Basically, it didn’t differentiate him in the competition, which is what AI is all about. I did not vote for Joseph tonight. Shocker.

04 – David Brown, title unknown (Stevie Wonder)
All I could focus on was the Yankees bling watch that he had on. I liked the kid from the auditions, but he hasn’t done much to move me in the last few weeks. The song was inaudible at the beginning and then it seemed like he was screaming at parts in the middle. Randy said it was better than last week, but still pitchy. Paula hopes that the best is yet to come. Simon said that he’s left the sparkle behind that they saw in the auditions. He could be on the bubble on Wednesday.

05 – Constantine Maroulis, Light Your Candle? (unknown)
Gosh I know this song. Anyway, Constantine does his best rocker performance, which is wearing a little thin on me. He places screams in there at times which makes me think that he may actually need some Preparation H (which leads to the question, what happened to Preparations A-G?). He also gives his signature “open one side of his jacket” move. That’s up there with the George Huff towel throw as far as I’m concerned. And how many bracelets does Constantine have on? I see the yellow “Live Strong” one, but then there are others. I was a Jamba Juice the other day and one of the workers had 6 different color bracelets on. That’s great that she was supportive of all of those causes, but you know what? Pick one and go with it. Randy said that he was much better than last week but was still a bit pitchy. I’m guessing that the eventual AI4 winner will not be described as “pitchy.” The competition is too great for a “pitchy” singer to win. Paula said that he owned the stage. Simon said that he doesn’t think that he’s a good singer and he wonders if the crowd is cheering for his voice or his theatrics? I think he’s on the bubble Wednesday too. If Constantine is eliminated now, it will save him the embarrassment of having to sing a Motown song when that theme inevitably comes up. So he’s got that going for him.

06 – Scott Savol, song title unknown (Luther Vandross)
What happened to Seacrest saying the title of the song before the contestant sings it? Scott comes out with those smoke tinted shades and a large shirt with a double button collar. Looks good. Comes out with the Abe Lincoln beard. He sure does have a sweet sounding voice. Randy said it was alright, but he hasn’t lived up to what they heard in his auditions yet. Paula said that he brought it on and was on pitch. Simon agreed with Paula. I think Scott is on the fence for Wednesday too. My cousin Stacy said Scott looks like the guy from Full Metal Jacket. Upon further review, that guy was Vincent D’Onofrio and the character’s name was Private Gomer Pyle/Leonard Lawrence. Vincent gained 70 pounds for the part. DeNiro gained 60 to play Jake LaMotta in Raging Bull. You may know D’Onofrio from his role in Law & Order: Criminal Intent or even earlier in his career as Lily Taylor’s boyfriend/husband in Mystic Pizza.

07 – Travis Tucker, All Night Long (All Night) (Lionel Richie)
Can’t forget the song title in the parenthesis. I really like Travis. He comes out all G’ed up in a yellow shirt that is unbuttoned and a wife beater underneath. His voice was shaking a bit at the beginning, probably because he knew how much dancing he was going to be doing while singing the song. He does the snake, the Usher moonwalk and the New Edition slide. I was waiting for a Running Man and a transition to a Reebok… But seriously, he gave a pretty good performance. Randy gave him “big ups” for coming back from last week. Paula said ditto and was proud of him. Simon said he’s not the best singer, but a born performer. Travis looks like someone. Like and NBA player. I was thinking Steve Smith, but Steve has a longer, thinner face. Travis will not win the competition. He’s not a strong enough singer. But he will last until the final 12 and, because of his charisma and showmanship, maybe the top 6. He could’ve been top 4 last year, but not this year. I voted for Travis tonight.

08 – Nikko Smith, Let’s Get It On (Marvin Gaye)
Nikko is smooth, like his father taking a grounder up the middle. He comes out in all black (blazer, pants, shirt). Big belt buckle. No fedora tonight. Really got into the song. Good performance. Randy said that no matter what song you sing, you need to sing the song. It made more sense when he said it. Paula was so taken by the performance, that she couldn’t speak. That was a good thing. Simon said it was a 1000% improvement, but his only downside is that he looks like Bobby Brown. No Simon, actually, he looks like Ozzie Smith. For future reference, when I refer to Nikko’s dad, I’ll just write Ozzie. Are we clear on this? For the record, Ozzy Osbourne is spelled with a “y” and not an “ie.” Back to the Bobby Brown reference. What really went on when he left New Edition? Was it a good move or not? He did refer to himself (or was it Whitney that referred to him?) as the “King of Soul.” Remember when Bobby did the little rap interlude during “Every Little Step?” How cool was that? When I first got that tape (this was before CDs were in) it had the first song as “Cruel Prelude” and I thought it was going to be song about the car (Prelude). Then I figured out that it was just the instrumental intro to “Don’t Be Cruel.” Nice. This was a great album by the way. Don’t Be Cruel. My Prerogative. Roni. Rock Wit’cha. Every Little Step. Ralph Tresvant was the voice of New Edition and his solo venture was weak compared to Bobby Brown’s. And then remember the ill-fated Bell Biv Devoe? Everyone knew Michael Bivins couldn’t sing. I was a huge New Edition fan and got all the tapes (including Johnny Gill). I think my favorite was NE Heartbreak, when they sounded so grown up. Then again, compared to Candy Girl & Popcorn Love, anything would sound more grown up. And remember Iesha from ABC (Another Bad Creation)? Okay, back to Nikko. He’s good. He should make it to the finals. I voted for Nikko.

09 – Anthony Federov, I Want To Know What Love Is (Foreigner)
Love Foreigner. One of the rockers needs to sing “Juke Box Hero.” How classic would that be? Anthony came out with jeans that looked like a piranha had just gotten a hold of them. But this kid can sing. He has such a pure voice and gave a powerful performance. It was nice too, as he acknowledged the girls upon completion of his performance. Randy said he didn’t know what to think when the song first started but he worked it out. Paula said that he raised his game (get a new phrase) and he kicked it into a different gear (see previous parenthetical statement). Simon called it a fantastic job. He’s been called the Clay Aiken and he’s handling it well, saying that he hopes to achieve what Clay has by the end of the competition. Nice kid. He should make the finals. I voted for Anthony.

10 – Bo Bice, don’t know, don’t care (Allman Brothers Band)
Bo came out in all brown. Maybe this was the UPS uniform in the ‘70s? Very Jim Morrison-like. Very rocker-ish. A lot of theatrics. A lot of hair flying around. I know people like Bo. I get that. He’s just not my cup of tea. For one, he looks way too old. He is such a rocker that I don’t know if he’ll be able to conform for all the themes that they are going to throw at him. Randy loved it. Paula said he’s the real deal. Simon said that his performance blew the others away, like Fantasia or LaToya from last year. I just don’t see it.

So, I think the final 6 for the guys will be: Mario, Anwar, Bo, Anthony, Travis, Nikko

I hope you don’t mind these. It’s been described by Connie Carillo as a “running commentary in my head.” Which is totally accurate. No one knows that better than my wife. I write as I would talk (or as I think). That’s just the way it comes out. It’s disjointed at times and sometimes you have to figure out when I’m done with a tangent. So, I apologize in advance for those little things. They will happen. I do this in real life too. I’ll be thinking about something in my head, then talk about it, not realizing that the person receiving it (usually my wife) is not privy to the thoughts in my head. She’s used to it by now. I miss my wife. :(

That’s it for now. Back in 24 hours or so.