Tuesday, May 22, 2007

AIVI recap, Finalists x 2 (05/22)

So I’m crushed, but not surprised that Melinda was off last week. After seeing those hometown vignettes, it’s not hard to believe that Melinda lacked the support that Jordin and Blake have. Did you see the 10,000+ people in Glendale, AZ for Jordin? And the not one, but two different rallies for Blake (one in Bothell and one in Seattle w/ Sir Mix-A-Lot)?

I’m not surprised because this has happened before. Someone listed all the people out at #3 from season one and Melinda is definitely the strongest to go at this point. The list was Nikki McKibbin (Tamyra Gray had already been eliminated at #4), Kimberly Locke, Jasmine Trias (LaToya London had already been eliminated), Vonzell Solomon and Elliott Yamin (Chris Daughtry had already been eliminated). I think that it’s a close one between Tamyra and Melinda not winning their respective seasons, but Kelly Clarkson has been a pretty good original American Idol. You’d be hard pressed to say that the eventual winner (Jordin or Blake) is/will be better than her.

I just really wished it would’ve been a Jordin/Melinda finale. I like Blake, but vocally, I would’ve preferred Melinda there.

Tonight was at the Kodak Theater and Randy decided to break out his Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band jacket. Paula looked horrible. Rumor had it that she broke her nose after tripping over her dog. Simon wore a jacket, but couldn’t resist showing his cleavage. Ryan on the other hand, dressed pretty nicely. Although I can’t help comparing him to the hosts on Dancing With The Stars (Tom Bergeron and Samantha Harris) and they are 100% better and more entertaining than him. Even though Samantha has the lowest, huskiest voice of the three of them.

They had a coin flip to see who would perform first. Blake won and had the right to choose to go first or second. He asked Jordin if she wanted to go first and she didn’t care, so he said he’d go first. Like in football, if I had the choice, I’d have deferred and gone second, which would’ve also meant going last and closing the show. But it didn’t seem tactical to Blake at all, which is pretty cool. I think at this point, they are competitive, but not calculating. And I think that’s cool too.

Blake starts it off with his second go around of Bon Jovi’s “You Give Love A Bad Name.” He changes it up a little. The drummer was featured once again. Still a great performance, but it did lack the shock value of when he first did it (since you knew what was coming). I really enjoy listening to him beat box, but I find myself asking myself if I’d actually buy a CD of him? Maybe I’d download a song here or there (thanks for the iTunes cards TAP!), but may not commit to a whole CD. Randy gave him a 10 out of 10 for the beat box, but the singing was just a’ight. Paula said he outdid himself. Simon said he was not the best singer, but was the best performer.

Jordin chose “Fighter” by Christina Aguilera as her free choice song. I could totally hear her recording this one and her being an R&B artist. She has such a big voice. And, again, I can’t believe she’s only 17. Randy called her voice stellar. Paula thought it would be the best finale ever and the first 2 performances proved it. Simon thought it was great she chose a younger song (I agree), but called it shrieky in the middle. He gave Round One to Blake.

Blake chose Maroon 5’s “She Will Be Loved” as his free choice song. He rocked the green and brown argyle for this song. Didn’t really hit his falsetto notes very well. I think he needs to be upbeat for me to listen to him. Otherwise it comes off as boring and dull. Randy called it a great song and very nice vocal. Paula said it sounded great. Simon thought it was good and safe, but not as good as the first song/performance. He wondered why he picked that song because it didn’t have much impact. Especially for the finale. I kinda agree. He needed to do another dancing/beat boxing song. Shoulda, coulda, woulda…

Jordin’s repeat song was Martina McBride’s “A Broken Wing,” but she probably only chose this one because she couldn’t possibly sing “I (Who Have Nothing)” for the third time and do it two weeks in a row! She really has a great voice. Can’t say that enough. Randy called her the most talented 17 year old he’s ever encountered (I’m surprised he didn’t drop any names of previous 17 year olds he’s worked with). He also called it better than the original. Simon simply stated, now THAT was good. Round Two to Jordin.

The last song for both of the contestants was an original song that was the winning entry of a songwriters contest done by American Idol. Turns out it was done by Jeff Peabody and Scott Krippayne. Krippayne has 7 albums/cassettes on Amazon.com. So much for finding new talent. The song was a “saccharine” power ballad entitled, “This Is My Now.” Good for Jordin, potentially disastrous for Blake.

Blake’s rendition was predictably uninspired. He’s better off mixing things up and Blake-izing songs. No such luck with this one. He was reduced to a few CRich bounces in the middle of it, but it didn’t work. Randy said the song just didn’t suit this voice. Simon called it all a little odd. It wasn’t a bad song, but it just wasn’t one that he’d sing. To Blake’s credit, he did nothing to bad mouth the song. This was an unfair advantage for Jordin. I really would’ve like to have heard Melinda sing this one. Or Sanjaya. Or Antonella, just to see what she’d wear up there. Maybe Jared Cotter would’ve done his face grab to this song. Who knows?

When Jordin’s turn came to close out the show, she knocked it out of the park. She sang it well, and sobbed a bit at the end, which was reminiscent of when Kelly Clarkson injected her exuberance into her winning song, “A Moment Like This.” My wife Kristin hasn’t watched the show yet (she’s putting our son Jared to sleep right now), but I’ve got money on her crying after this performance. (I would’ve lost! But she was distracted because of all the gratuitous shots of Constantine in the audience. She was annoyed because he looked so smug.) Randy called her the best singer tonight. Paula said she looked over at Jordin’s parents and saw how proud they were of her. Simon said that when he said she didn’t deserve to be in the finale last week, he was wrong. And that she wiped the floor with Blake on the last song.

I thought after last week that Jordin was hands down going to blow Blake away. But then when I heard the crowd for him after his first song, I thought that he may have a chance. Then after all was said and done, Jordin will win going away. I know that they don’t disclose the votes, but I don’t think this will be close.

Going back to Melinda, I feel bad for her that she didn’t win the competition, but as we’ve seen in the past, you don’t have to win the competition to have a successful career. Look at how well Chris Daughtry is doing. And how well Clay Aiken did. And Justin Guarini … is helping host the American Idol thing on the TV Guide Channel with Kimberly Caldwell. I’m happy for Melinda because this competition got her out of the background and into the forefront to sing. She will get a record contract and do well. I haven’t seen her exit interview yet, but will watch it on TiVo later. My wife Kristin and I will also miss LaKisha. She was great on her exit interview (American Idol Extra). She is the only contestant to state that she is not a celebrity, as most of the other non-winners seem to forget. That she’s just plain old Kiki. She was real down to earth. I won’t miss her singing, but I will miss her great perspective.

And lastly, my obsession with Dancing With The Stars lives on. I haven’t seen the other seasons (this is season 4), but the finale with Apolo Anton Ohno, Laila Ali and Joey Fatone was spectacular. Apolo and his partner look professional. Joey is on the heavier side, but it’s amazing how light on his feet he is. I know he’s got the N*Sync dancing in his background, but he still had to learn all the steps and did very well. Laila had some obstacles to overcome (she’s admittedly a “big girl”) but she also looked very elegant out there. And she’s engaged to former Chicago Bear/SF 49er/USC Trojan Curtis Conway. I’m pretty much hooked on this show now and I’m guessing there will be a season 5. And I’m guessing celebs and pseudo-celebs are trying to line up the gig right now!

So that’s it for this season. Thanks to Mike Rico once again for filling in when I wasn’t able to do some of the recaps and thanks to all of you for reading these things. I’ve got to admit these were hard to churn out this year. IF they come back next year, I imagine they won’t be as structured. Just bullet points to be less time-consuming. We’ll see.

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

AIVI recap, Finalists x 3 (05/15)

So it’s the you pick, judges pick and producers pick night. Clive Davis used to be involved in this but I guess not this year. It also features a trip to each finalists’ hometown, which is totally cool for them.

The first songs are the judge’s choice.

01 – Jordin, Wishing On A Star (Rose Royce)
I don’t know who Rose Royce is, but I thought this song sounded very ‘80s-ish, like it could’ve been sung by Brenda K Starr or Mercedes or one of those other R&B ‘80s girls. Then I found out that The Cover Girls covered this song in 1992, which is close enough to that ‘80s vibe. I liked this song. Found out on Wikipedia (don’t you LOVE Wikipedia?) that Rose Royce didn’t really hit it big with this song, but they also did “Car Wash” and “Love Don’t Live Here Anymore.” Randy said it was a very good vocal and that the run at the end was hot. Paula called it a beautiful job (you could tell early on that she was out of it tonight and would offer zero productive comments). Simon, who picked the song, said she sang it beautifully, but didn’t like the jazz arrangement.

02 – Blake, Roxanne (The Police)
Paula picked this song and it was given to him by the mayor of Bothell, WA, who looked like he was 25 years old. Whenever I hear this song, I immediately think of Eddie Murphy singing it in the jail cell in “48 Hours.” How classic is that movie? They, of course, ruined it with “Another 48 Hours,” but are sequels ever as good as the originals? Except for maybe “The Godfather, Part II” which wasn’t better, but equally as brilliant. No beat box for Blake in this song, which was a good thing because it wouldn’t have worked with this song. Randy called it a great performance. Paula said he did her proud and Simon called it good, but not as good as the original.

03 – Melinda, I Believe In You and Me (Whitney Houston)
This was an interesting choice by Randy because the hard and fast rule is that you never, ever pick a Whitney Houston song. But he chose to challenge her tonight. This was also an interesting Whitney choice because it was when Whitney was in her “soundtrack” phase (see also “The Bodyguard” and “Waiting To Exhale”). Her first two albums were masterpieces (“Whitney Houston” and “Whitney”) but then she hasn’t really matched those efforts to date. So, I guess what I’m getting at is that this song wasn’t a pure Whitney song. It was more gospel-based (from a remake of “The Bishop’s Wife”) and thus maybe easier to sing. Regardless, Melinda changed it up enough to own it. It was a smokier version and the a cappella/falsetto part at the end was real cool. Randy wanted to throw her a curveball and she blew it out the box. Paula called her fantastic. Simon said it was a very difficult song, but it was her best performance in the last 4 weeks. And gave round 1 to Melinda.

04 – Jordin, She Works Hard For The Money (Donna Summer)
This was the producers’ choice and I will say this again and again. I can’t believe she’s only 17. She really sang this song well and really the only week she’s been off was the Bon Jovi week. Randy said that she can work it out for any song. I’m going to start to not write what Paula said anymore because all she kept saying was “fantastic.” Simon called it a very good performance.

05 – Blake, This Love (Maroon 5)
When I heard this song, I immediately thought to myself, “beat box alert.” And he didn’t disappoint. This song is pretty annoying, but it’s in Blake’s element. He did a cool version and danced and beat box/scratched it up pretty well. Randy said it was a good vibe for him. Simon said it sounded very comfortable and he preferred it to his first song.

06 – Melinda, Nutbush City Limits (Ike and Tina Turner)
I think the producers were forcing the Tina Turner angle on this one a bit. But, as usual, Melinda delivered. Randy called it another great star performance. Paula again stated the obvious by saying she looked like she had a blast. Simon said that he loved that side of Melinda.

07 – Jordin, I Who Have Nothing (Shirley Bassey, among others)
This started the contestants’ choice of songs. She redid this song from British Invasion night. She might have sung this better tonight than earlier. I still can’t believe that she’s only 17. She has such a powerful voice and this rendition was chilling, almost haunting. Very good. Randy called it another great performance and her best of the night. Simon said she sang it very well, but complained about a 17 year old singing a 60 year old song. I’m getting the feeling that he likes Jordin, but wants Melinda to win. Personally, I don’t really care who wins, but I would like to see a Melinda-Jordin finale. A Melinda-Blake finale would be okay too, just as long as Melinda is in the finale.

08 – Blake, When I Get You Alone (Robin Thicke)
His intro showed him beat boxing and scratching with Sir Mix A Lot. That was a sweet thing to see. This song was interesting because it was a cover of a song by Alan Thicke’s son and it had a sample of Beethoven’s Fifth in it. He did have a little scratching at the end. I’m glad that he incorporated it tonight because he didn’t overuse it. Randy called it cool, but liked the Maroon 5 better. Simon said he really liked it, especially since he doesn’t play it safe, he takes risks and looks like he’s having fun.

09 – Melinda, I’m A Woman (Peggy Lee)
She wore a cool 3 piece suit that she basically turned into a 2 piece suit because she dropped the jacket with the quickness. I liked that she featured the background singers during the song. Randy liked seeing the range and said it was hot again. Simon said that she consistently, week after week brought it and deserves a spot in the finals.

I am unabashedly in support of Melinda. I’m okay with Jordin winning too, but my money is on Melinda. I can guarantee this though. Blake will be in the bottom 3 tomorrow and Melinda will be in the top 3.

And on my new obsession, Dancing With The Stars (DWTS), I’m hoping that Apolo Anton Ohno wins. Their semi-finals was VERY good. Two perfects for Joey Fatone (who I also like and can see winning) and Laila Ali (who can also win). Apolo got dinged for a “raunchy” version of the cha cha with his partner, Julianne. The thing I like about Apolo is that he matches his partner’s steps. The other celebs feature their partner a bit more, but he is there step by step with Julianne. And she’s a cute little thing too. She’s only 18 and looks like Paris Hilton (but not trashy). Her choreography is very creative, maybe a bit too creative for Len, the stuffy judge. Ian Ziering is okay, but I think that he is clearly 4th out of the 4. His partner, Cheryl Burke, is the two-time defending champ though (with Drew Lachey and Emmitt Smith). Laila had Muhammad Ali on last week and it was a transcendent moment. How much of an icon is The Greatest? His Parkinson’s is so tragic because he used to be so full of energy. Anyway, we’re totally hooked on that show now.

Wednesday, May 02, 2007

AIVI recap lite, Finalists x 6B (05/01)

Just a mini recap this morning. Or a recap lite, if you will.

First off, I thought Idol Gives Back was a great thing last week. They’ve raised over $70 million so far. Although, I don’t mind AI helping raise money, I’d like to see them donate a TON of money too. I don’t think matching all of the donations is necessary, but a substantial amount wouldn’t be out of the question, seeing how much FOX, etc makes off this show. News Corp was going to give $0.10 per vote for the first 50 million votes. $5 million isn’t a bad donation. They said that their major sponsors gave undisclosed amounts. Why not disclose? Anyway, they are taking donations up to May 31, but if you really wanted to donate after that, I don’t think they’ll turn your money away. And yes, we did give a little.

I didn’t watch the whole two-hour show last week (we TiVoed it), but I did see Carrie Underwood (how do you think Gina Glocksen felt after hearing that version of “I’ll Stand By You?”) and Mama Cass, er Kelly Clarkson. I thought the Josh Groban with the kids thing was cool. Annie Lennox looked good for her age. I saw Blondie a few years back on a free DirecTV concert and she looked old and heavy. I’ll have to watch the whole benefit again to catch the whole effect.

Jon Bon Jovi night. He’s kinda sold out as of late. He owns the Philadelphia Soul, an Arena League football team and is way overexposed from that. I think they got a contract with NBC to start and they might be on ESPN now. John Elway was the same way. After he divorced his wife, I think he needed to feel appreciated and be in the spotlight. TAP helped that, as he was a spokesperson for Prevacid for a bit. And he also owned the Denver/Colorado AFL team. Didn’t Bon Jovi play at a Super Bowl recently? Still, his rock songs are pretty classic.

Thought Jordin would be the frontrunner because of her Pat Benetar performance earlier in the competition, but she struggled mightily. How old did it make Bon Jovi feel when Jordin kept talking about how her mother would be so jealous that she was singing with him?

I thought Phil was okay. Same as always. Good voice. Nice guy. Scary looking. Not an original voice. He’s really on borrowed time on this show. It’s like he called the front desk for a late checkout and they accommodated it. He should be gone tonight.

Didn’t know the song that LaKisha sang but that probably worked to her advantage. She blew this song out, probably because it wasn’t a rock song. Was it enough to keep her in? Maybe to next week, but then she’s probably gone. Third place is her ceiling, but she’ll be fighting Blake for that.

Speaking of Blake, THIS was the performance I’ve been waiting for all year. Honestly, it was this song that motivated me to write something this morning. Because I’m not your classic rocker, this song was cool for me. It might have been hard for Bon Jovi to see this done to his song, but he allowed him to do it (unlike Queen with Ace Young last year) and it totally worked. Like Simon said, probably half loved it and half hated it. I was in the “loved it” category. His beatboxing and sound effects are so cool. He should team up with the dude from Police Academy and do a whole CD without instruments.

I thought Chris was okay. I really think he’s almost out. He kinda R&Bed the song up, but not really. It was like N*Sync singing Bon Jovi. Doesn’t really work.

Melinda continues to shine. She said “I’m so bad at rock,” but then sings spot on. And adds a little Tina Turner to it. If she’s not the frontrunner again, I’ll lose faith in this show. She’s really reminiscent of Kelly Clarkson in the first year. Kelly never had a bad night. That doesn’t make you an American Idol because because consistency doesn’t make you a star. It just means you can navigate through the different genres that they throw at you. But, Melinda’s voice is so good and her personality is such (like Kelly’s) that I really think she should win going away.

Bottom 3 should be Phil, CRich and LaKisha, but don’t be surprised to see Jordin down there after last night’s debacle. Blake could sneak down there too. I only think that Melinda is safe.

On a different note, does anyone watch “Dancing With The Stars?” We just started watching last week, but it’s tough to fit it in with everything else we tape. On Monday alone, we’re taping “How I Met Your Mother,” “The Class” (which is done for the season already) and “Two And A Half Men.” I had “Studio 60” taping but they are on permanent hiatis right now. I absolutely love DWTS. It’s not the stars. It’s not the skimpy costumes the women wear (although that doesn’t hurt). It’s not even the dancing. It’s how much fun the celebs are having. There is so much pressure on AI because this is the singers’ shot at stardom. But the stars have already made it. There is a genuine camaraderie going on. And it’s cool to see how hard they work and train to look somewhat competent on the dance floor. And Carrie Ann Inaba is hot. I think she looks like a Japanese Jennifer Lopez. She’s Paula, but meaningful. And the hosts are good too. Tom Bergeron is pretty good. But that girl has such a husky voice. How did she get a speaking part? No, I won’t be recapping DWTS, but just wanted to throw it out there that we’re watching.