Tuesday, March 30, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 10 (03/30/10)

Wow, 2 for 2 for me so far. Paige really was horrible last week. Rumor’s that she “gave up” and wanted off the show.

So we had a major DVR screw up this week. We had 3 things scheduled to tape and because American Idol was recently added (I missed the first 2 episodes of the auditions and the “Pants on the Ground” audition), it had the least priority (behind “90210” and “Dancing With The Stars”). That being said, we missed the first 5 singers. Saw the capsules at the end, but that doesn’t do the performances justice.

Reading the Idol Chatter blog, it looks like Siobhan didn’t do so well (and took it hard backstage). It looks like they filmed the contestants right as they came off stage, which is odd to me. Casey James did well, as did Big Mike. Didi started crying (shocker) and Tim was Tim. He sang Anita Baker’s “Sweet Love?” Really, Tim?

Now on to the singers that I saw.

06 – Andrew, Forever (Chris Brown)
Wow. Andrew was better tonight than he’s been in a long time. This is what he needs to do. Stay acoustic. He really doesn’t have that strong of a voice, but if he keeps doing what he did tonight, he won’t be on such tenuous ground every Wednesday night. Randy said Andrew is back. Kara said it was one giant leap in the right direction. Simon said it was miles better than the last few weeks. I think this song bought him a few more weeks. And some much needed confidence. He should be safe tomorrow, but watch him go…

07 – Katie, Chain of Fools (Aretha Franklin)
I’m really perplexed by Katie. She has a voice that’s way older than her. But the judges keep wanting her to sound younger. And she’s got a bit of an attitude problem for me. I thought this version was a bit slow. She sang it okay and was pretty much in tune, but it didn’t wow me at all. Randy thought it was a bit disconnected. Ellen thought the vocals were great, but wanted a more current song. Kara thinks she found where she belongs (R&B/pop). Simon called it Star Search-y and thought Kara was wrong in her assessment of her genre. I agree. I think Katie is a “standards” type singer. They keep wanting to make her younger and more current, but I think she’s lost when she tries that. I hope Katie goes soon. Her or Tim.

08 – Lee, Treat Her Like A Lady (Cornelius Brothers)
Man, Lee was good tonight. My wife Kristin thinks this song finally showcased how strong his voice is. I agree with her, as he’s been choosing songs that have not shown off his voice. He was incredibly good tonight. His voice sounds like Creed or Nirvana to me. Randy called him unbelievable and the best he’d heard in weeks. Ellen called it the best of the night. Kara called it amazing (and it was amazing that she didn’t say a-MAZE-ing). Simon said this might be the night his life changed forever. I still don’t think Lee is going to win, but he may sneak up on us like Kris Allen did last year.

09 – Crystal, Midnight Train to Georgia (Gladys Knight & the Pips)
This song reminded us of “Man Vs. Food” as Adam Richman ate at Gladys Knight’s restaurant down in Atlanta. Chicken and waffles. I was a little upset that Crystal gave in to the judges and abandoned her guitar this week. This competition breeds that thinking. That you have to be different and change things up. If you do something well (and Crystal does), I think it’s a risk to mess with it. Luckily Crystal was still good on the piano and her singing is simply effortless. She is, hands down, my favorite singer of the competition. Siobhan is second, but I love me some Crystal. Randy name drops that he’s working on an album with Gladys. Ellen said she’s “never not good.” Kara was so glad that she took that risk. Simon basically slammed Kara and told Crystal to not get away from whom` she really is. I agree with Simon. If you sing well and play guitar well while doing it, do that. Crystal should be safe tomorrow.

10 – Aaron, Ain’t No Sunshine (Bill Withers)
My wife Kristin thought Aaron was better during his rehearsal with Usher. He did okay, but didn’t kill this song. He has been getting better the last few weeks though. Loved his leather zip up hoodie though. Randy thought is was just alright. Ellen joked that he was eleven. Kara liked it, but didn’t like-like it. Simon thought it was a cupcake to Lee’s main course. I agree. But Aaron’s so likeable that he’s most likely safe tomorrow.

I’m not totally qualified for the bottom 3, but here’s my predictions.

Bottom 3: Tim, Didi, Katie

Gone: Tim

And I touched on Dancing With The Stars earlier and will do so again now. Great cast this season. I can’t stand Kate Gosselin. She looks horrible out there too. She made all-around nice guy Tony Dovolani temporarily quit on her. No wonder Jon got out of Dodge… And she rolls her eyes all the time which is annoying. And the big question is, who is watching the 8 kids while she’s extending her 15 minutes of fame? Shannen Doherty was the first one out and did anyone notice her freakishly skinny legs? She looked kinda heavy up top, but has these chicken legs that didn’t fit her torso.

Pamela Anderson was in the bottom 2 and she looked like she was on drugs after each dance, although she is a bit spacey, I think. It’s Nicole Scherzinger’s competition to lose. She’s looked great already and even scored 2 perfect 10s last week. She looks like Kim Kardashian, without the junk in the trunk. Evan Lysachek is good, but has a tough schedule, as he’s in the Ice Skating tour and still has to practice for the show. And his partner is Russian, which probably doesn’t go over well with either of them! He’s had some pretty good looking girlfriends. I think he’s dating Nastia Leukin (Olympic gymnast) right now and previously dated Tanith Belbin (Ice Dancing Olympian).

Buzz Aldrin is going to stay on the show longer than he should because of his popularity (and the fact that he’s 80!). Chad Ochocinco started well, but had a bad week last week. Niecy Nash is hilarious. I’m not a fan of the Bachelor dude (that is my least favorite show of all time; I know A LOT of people watch that show, but it’s worked out once? Twice? I think that it makes a mockery of the institution of marriage, assuming you can meet a total stranger and “make a connection” and eventually get engaged) or the soap opera dude. And lastly one of my favorites is Erin Andrews, the ESPN sideline reporter. Her and Maks make a nice couple.

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 11 (03/23/10)

So I got it right! Lacey went last week! Finally some credibility to these recaps!

On to tonight. Miley Cyrus as a mentor as the contestants sing Billboard #1s. Important week, as the one eliminated won’t be in the top 10 and thus not allowed to go on tour. They talk to Miley in the crowd and she’s sitting by her mom and So You Think You Can Dance judge Adam Shenkman.

01 – Lee DeWyze, The Letter (Box Tops)
My son Jared stayed up for the first few singers and his comment on Lee was that he looked like a mini Adam Richman (from Man V. Food on the Travel Channel). We LOVE Man V. Food in our house. Lee was a little more relaxed up on the stage tonight, but added a “thank you” at the end of his performance (which always bugs me). Randy said he knocked it out of the box. Ellen called him her favorite pen. Kara said he raised the bar for himself and over-enunciated treMENdous. I really hate it when she does that. Simon called him corny, conceded that he sounded good, but said he wasn’t a contemporary artist. I think Lee should be safe tomorrow night. Still has a great tone to his voice, but is usually pitchy in spots.

02 – Paige Miles, Against All Odds (Phil Collins)
This song has been sung quite a bit by past Idol contestants. Paige was incredibly flat during this song. It was an ’80s song and she kinda dressed a bit ‘80s with her stretch pants. I wish her top had shoulder pads and she wore a scrunchy. That would’ve been tight. Randy called it honestly terrible, adding nothing about it was great. Ellen complimented her that she didn’t fall down (she was wearing extremely high heels), then turned the singing critique over to Kara & Simon. Kara called it the worst vocal she’s heard from her and possibly the worst of the season. Kara & Simon also mentioned that they thought she stopped competing. Paige is in big time trouble tomorrow, as she was horrible tonight and has not been good at all this season.

03 – Tim Urban, Crazy Little Thing Called Love (Queen)
Really, Tim? Really? This version sounded like something you’d hear on the Lido Deck on the Love Boat (Pacific Princess). Tim has been incredibly horrible week in and week out. Very consistent in that regard. Randy said the dopest (did I spell that right?) thing he did was the slide, but it was boring vocals and sounded like bad karaoke. Ellen thought it was an audition for High School Musical (and my son agreed that he looked like Troy Bolton). Kara went on to add that he looked like Zac Efron in Hairspray. And she also dropped the hammer on him by saying he wasn’t established enough to play to the fans like he did. Ouch. Simon thought the slide was good because it took the attention away from his singing. He went on to say it was pointless and silly. That being said, Tim will probably be safe again tomorrow night. He’s the current posterboy for Vote for the Worst. I know Tim got called back after they kicked a guy off the top 24. Was Tim the first person they called? Or the first one who accepted the invite back onto the show?

04 – Aaron Kelly, I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing (Aerosmith)
I really liked the movie Armageddon, even though it was sappy and predictable, etc. I don’t mind Ben Affleck and like Liv Tyler. Met Bruce Willis once at a Bulls game. Seemed like a nice guy. First movie I saw Will Patton in. Loved him in Remember The Titans as coach Ned Yost. Anyway, I have to tell you that my wife Kristin thinks I didn’t give Aaron any credit last week. She thought he was real good and turned it around last week. And he kept the momentum going this week, as he was very good tonight too. He’s so young (16) that he could be on the Disney Channel right now. It seems as though everyone who acts on the Disney Channel also sings. Demi Lovato, Selena Gomez, the Jonas Brothers, Miley Cyrus. Even Emily Osment and Mitchel Musso have songs out. Randy didn’t think it was a perfect performance, but he was thankful that he was good, compared to the 2 before him. Ellen joked about him being in the 3rd grade. Kara finally started acknowledging Ellen’s comments and agreed with her that it was a great song choice. Simon thinks he has a zero chance of going home tomorrow. Given how bad some of the others were, Aaron should be safe tomorrow. And if he keeps improving, he may go even further.

05 – Crystal Bowersox, Me and Bobby McGee (Janis Joplin)
Pretty obvious song choice, but how can you fault her for choosing it. I love Crystal’s voice and stage presence. The judges asked her about not playing the guitar and she hinted that she had a surprise for them next week (should she move on; like she won’t). I think it would be a mistake for her to ditch her guitar. She actually plays it and doesn’t just use it like a prop as others have done in the past. Although she may surprise me next week, which would be cool. I’ve sung the praises for Crystal from the get go and I won’t stop now. She should be in the final 2 with Siobhan. Randy called her a star. Ellen wanted her to take in all the applause and respond to the crowd. Simon told her not to change a thing. Crystal’s safe tomorrow. Guaranteed.

06 – Michael Lynche, When A Man Loves A Woman (Percy Sledge)
All Michael needed was the half mask to complete his Phantom of the Opera look. I must say that I like Michael doing the ballads because he doesn’t bounce all around the stage like he does with faster songs. I thought he was pretty good tonight. Randy didn’t think it was his best vocal, but like him as an R&B soul dude. Ellen thought it was a safe choice. Kara called it technically good, but boring and lounge-y. Simon called it over-indulgent too. Regardless, Big Mike should be safe tomorrow.

07 – Andrew Garcia, I Heard It Through the Grapevine (Marvin Gaye)
So Andrew is now officially a one-trick pony. This version was atrocious. Or as Kara would say, aTROcious. Miley’s idea of putting down the guitar seemed to backfire on him. At least when he was playing the guitar, Andrew wasn’t prancing all over the stage making sign language signs that accompanied the lyrics of the song. He looked like Horatio Sanz doing an American Idol parody on Saturday Night Live. And his accent when singing reminded me of Manny Pacquiao singing on one of the late night shows (even though Andrew’s is a Mexican accent and not a Filipino one). Randy said it wasn’t good and it was the wrong song choice. Ellen didn’t think it was good enough to sway voters on the fence with him. Kara thinks he’s still chasing that moment he had in Hollywood and it’s messing with his head. Simon thought they might have over-rated that moment and that he sucked the soul out of that song. Andrew is in serious trouble tomorrow night.

08 – Katie Stevens, Big Girls Don’t Cry (Fergie)
My wife Kristin thought Katie was pitchy throughout the whole song. I think Katie’s deal is that she has this deep voice that you wouldn’t expect to come from a 17 year old girl. But that’s her only thing. And she doesn’t sing contemporary songs well. Older songs are in her wheelhouse, but it seems odd for a 17 year old girl to sing those older songs. Randy liked that she listened to the judges. Ellen called it her best performance so far. Kara called her pop with R&B leanings. And that she had mad pitch issues, which is a funny statement because usually when they talk about “mad” things, it’s a good thing. Like mad writing skills. But in this case it meant that she had some real bad pitch issues. Simon compared her outfit from tonight to the one from a few weeks ago to chalk and cheese. Which may be British for apples and oranges. Katie should be safe tomorrow, but I hope she’s in the bottom 3 just to give her undue grief.

09 – Casey James, The Power of Love (Huey Lewis & the News)
Casey opens his meeting with Miley by saying he’s a huge fan of … her dad’s. Pretty funny moment. I thought this sounded almost exactly (and unoriginally) like the original. Thought it was a bit of an odd choice of songs. He sang it well though, but it wasn’t earthshattering. Randy was not a fan of the song choice. Ellen thought it was the best vocal of the night. Kara thought he was ready (right now) to make an album. Simon thought he sounded like he was in an ‘80s cover band. I tend to agree with Simon on this one. He’ll definitely be safe tomorrow.

10 – Didi Benami, You’re No Good (Linda Ronstadt)
Wasn’t this song sung in reference to Jerry Brown? Didi’s outfit tonight looked like something from a gal in Austin Powers. I actually thought the big round gold thing on her belt was a gold medallion hung around her neck. Randy thought she was pitchy. Ellen didn’t get the song choice. Kara felt like she was playing a character. Simon didn’t think it sounded like her. I think Didi should be safe tomorrow.

11 – Siobhan Magnus, Superstition (Stevie Wonder)
Siobhan came out in the faux-hawk and wore it better than former Idol contestant Sanjaya. She had a real ‘80s look to her. Thought the song was good, but not great. Hit a big note at the end again (that’s becoming her thing). Randy called her fearless. Ellen asked for “more, please.” Kara thinks Siobhan is more comfortable on stage than anywhere else in her life (my wife Kristin adds, like Michael Jackson). Simon thinks it’s time to mix up her screams. Siobhan should be safe tomorrow.

Top 3: Crystal, Siobhan, Aaron

Bottom 3: Paige, Tim, Andrew

Off tomorrow: Paige

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

AIIX recap, Finalists x 12 (03/16/10)

Thanks again to the great job Jim Rutter did last week, although he might have been better served going this week with it being Rolling Stones week. A few thoughts from last week. I cannot believe that Lilly Scott is gone. I didn’t really get her, but she was WAY more talented than most of the others (except Crystal & Siobhan). And even Alex Lambert going was a bit of a surprise. He was pretty good the last few weeks after his initial performance. I was not surprised that Todrick and Katelyn were gone.

And I must say, this HAS to be the weakest top 12 I’ve ever seen (to go along with the weakest top 24 ever too).

And a few notes on Jim’s recap.
• Appreciated his “stylized vocalization” vs “pitchy” observation on Lee.
• Loved the “David” from Eight Is Enough comment. Grant Goodeve, if I remember correctly. Better a “David” haircut than a “Nicholas,” Adam Rich bowl cut though…
• Don’t think I didn’t catch the UC Berkeley dig, Jim…
• And my wife Kristin also noticed the Kara in Simon’s lap thing going on. It almost seemed as though she was intentionally sitting away from Ellen. Which was weird. And also it seemed like she was disregarding Ellen’s comments because she would never acknowledge them.
• Todrick bugged me in how he obliterated all the arrangements in the songs that he did. It felt as if he was doing that to cover up vocal insufficiencies.

On to tonight. Why is there no Guitar Hero or Rock Band for The Rolling Stones? They haven’t reached the sell out point yet? Why not? If they’re letting American Idol have a theme week on them, why not the Guitar Hero deal too?

01 – Michael Lynche, Miss You
Personally, I’m a little tired of Michael. Liked him in Hollywood, but I’ve quickly soured on him. I think he’s too much of a showman and I think he’s overly confident and can’t take criticism well. We did get a little glimpse into why he quit football (his mother’s passing took it away from him), but seriously, why can’t he go back and try again? It’s not like he’s not in good shape. He’s a personal trainer. You can’t teach bulk like that. I think he’d be a great nose tackle that sang well on the side. Going first on a night with 12 singers is a supreme disadvantage unless you slay it. I though Michael was okay, but he did get a little pitchy when he was moving around so much. Makes you appreciate Mick Jagger even more. Mick is all over that stage and doesn’t miss a bit singing. On top of the fact that all he probably does is smoke and do drugs too. Randy, however, thought he slayed it. Simon called his dancing corny. After 3 positive comments, Michael didn’t take Simon’s take very well. Per usual. I think Big Mike is safe tomorrow night.

02 – Didi Benami, Playing With Fire
I am having a tough time placing Didi because I know she really looks like someone, but I can’t put my finger on it. A blonde Jessica Biel? Judy Greer? Didi came out tonight dressed by either Anthropologie or Urban Outfitters. Take your pick, but she had a great look tonight. I really like her voice, as it has a real contemporary feel to it. Like those indie artists that sing off tempo or have odd phrasing on purpose (like Megan from last year). This song completely showcased her voice and showed that she has a much stronger voice than she’s shown in the past. Randy called her on fire. Ellen joked that she turned “fire” into a 2 syllable word and called it “gr-eat.” Kara liked her intensity tonight. Simon called it a solid, but not brilliant performance. I think Didi should be safe tomorrow. Plus she’s the hottest girl left in the top 12. That’s gotta count for something.

03 – Casey James, It’s All Over Now
So it came to me last week. Casey James looks exactly like Zach Braff (JD from Scrubs) if Braff had long blonde hair. That had been bugging me for awhile and I was supremely happy with myself when I figured that out. If I could figure out how to put pictures into the body of an e-mail (I know I’m lame), I’d prove it to you. Casey was good tonight, with his country-infused version. Randy loved it. Ellen made a funny, alluding to her being a lesbian, but calling herself a blonde instead. Pretty funny moment. Kara liked his blues/soul version and called it his best performance since they met (when he took his shirt off). Simon said that he needed to do more than just sit in the middle of the big stage with his electric guitar. What do you want Simon? Some corny dancing like Big Mike? I think Simon’s comment was rubbish and Casey is safe tomorrow. Guaranteed. He’s probably good to top 4, at least.

04 – Lacey Brown, Ruby Tuesday
My wife Kristin thought she has a Fleetwood Mac-type voice. I actually think her voice is somewhat like the lead singer to Sixpence None The Richer, which is funny because she sang their song a few weeks ago. I’m not a huge fan of Lacey’s. I think she has a Disney Channel type voice. She sings all of her songs too slow too. Bugs me. Randy was pleasantly surprised. Ellen thought it was weird that she sat for the fast part of the song and stood and walked for the slow parts. Maybe she has performance dyslexia? Kara thought she could do better. Simon hit it on the head when he said she performs like an actress. Maybe it has to do with the fact that she got so close last year and didn’t make it to the semis. She’s probably been overthinking everything since then. And it comes off rehearsed and not genuine. I think Lacey’s in trouble tomorrow night.

05 – Andrew Garcia, Gimme Shelter
Man, Andrew was not good tonight. Consistently flat throughout the whole song. Talk about peaking too soon. Poor guy had his “moment” in Hollywood with “Straight Up.” Can’t blame him for doing that when he did because if he didn’t do it then (and saved it for later), he may have not made it through to the top 24. It’s kind of like the lawyer (Matt Damon’s character) in The Rainmaker. He knocked it out of the park in his first case, then quit because he knew he could never make it that big again. Nor could he live up to that again. Randy called it pitchy everywhere. Ellen thought it was his best performance yet, which it might have been. But that’s not saying much. Kara didn’t think he connected with the song. Being a songwriter, Kara really listens to the lyrics. Maybe too much sometimes, but I can’t blame her, as that’s what she does. Simon thought he gave it 100%, but suspects it was better in rehearsal than live tonight. I think Andrew’s on the bubble tomorrow night. Unfortunately, I like him, but I think he may be going soon unless he has another “moment.”

06 – Katie Stevens, Wild Horses
Katie reminds my wife Kristin of Tatiana from last season. The Drama Queen from Puerto Rico that kept singing all the time when the judges wanted her to stop. Did anyone notice that she spat at the camera during the song? I hope those people in the front row had their ponchos on. I wonder if they knew they were sitting in the Splash Zone? My feelings about Katie are that she has a very nice voice, but that she sings the words and doesn’t know what she’s singing about. I’ve never felt like she connected with any of her songs. Chalk it up to her youth? Randy thought she sang it well. Kara said she’s never technically perfect, but she’s moving in the right direction. Simon thought it was the first week that she chose a strong song. I think Katie’s safe tomorrow, but she can’t last much longer if she doesn’t improve.

07 – Tim Urban, Under My Thumb
Not only does Tim Urban look like Michael J. Fox, but during the Oscars when they did the tribute to John Hughes, they flashed a scene from “Some Kind of Wonderful,” and Tim really looked like a young Eric Stoltz. He also kinda looks like a brunette version of Sterling Knight (we watch WAY too much Disney Channel; if you know who Sterling Knight is, so do you!). Tim played this song to a reggae beat. He really has not impressed me one bit during this competition. But he’s a good looking guy and probably has a lot of girls voting for him, in addition to the pity votes he gets for getting destroyed by the judges every week. He is the current poster boy for “Vote For The Worst.” Randy didn’t get it. Ellen thought she was at a resort drinking a pina colada. Kara applauded him for doing something so different with the song. Simon didn’t think it worked either. All this being said, I just have a feeling that Tim’s safe tomorrow.

08 – Siobhan Magnus, Paint It Black
I really like Siobhan. Totally unique. Great sense of style. Knows who she is. Plays to that. Her prom dress with boots outfit tonight reminded me of a front woman for an ‘80s girl band. Go-Gos or Bananarama or The Bangles. I’m a huge fan of ‘80s music, so the previous statement was meant as a compliment (if you were confused). She really does remind me of Adam Lambert from last year, in that they both knew who they were and never wavered from that. And I dig the notes she hits. Randy said that was hot. Ellen says she stands out. Kara had flashbacks to Adam Lambert (in truth, I said she reminded me of Adam to my wife Kristin during the song). Simon called hers the standout performance of the night. Siobhan has crazy vocals. And she’s been consistently good. Completely safe tomorrow. If not, I’ll stop watching. Siobhan and Crystal are the only 2 contestants that I look forward to hearing every week. And they haven’t disappointed yet.

09 – Lee DeWyze, Beast of Burden
I’ve always thought that Lee has a Dave Matthews/Hootie and the Blowfish sound to him, but I realized tonight that I thought he sounded like John Mellencamp (nee, John Cougar and John Cougar Mellencamp). Randy thinks he sounds like Rob Thomas and Dave Matthews. Ellen thought it was almost there, like a hospital gown. Kara thinks he’s growing faster than anyone and he wasn’t as pitchy this week. Simon thought it was a safe, forgettable song. I agree with all of them. I love the tone of Lee’s voice. But also agree that he’s been playing it safe. He really has a “I can’t believe I’m here” confidence (or lack thereof) to him. I don’t want him to get cocky, but I think a little confidence and the belief that he belongs up on that stage will go a long way for his performances. Lee should be safe tomorrow.

10 – Paige Mills, Honky Tonk Woman
Interesting outfit tonight. Reminded me of Shelly Long in “Troop Beverly Hills.” My wife Kristin thought it looked like the original Banana Republic stuff. Nice call on her part. This song got her into her wheelhouse at points. Randy thought she did alright with it. Ellen said she has a star quality. Kara said she’s back. Simon thought it was great, given that she had laryngitis during the week (he just found out about that). I don’t know about Paige. I think she’s okay and will last a few more weeks, but I don’t see her cracking the top 5.

11 – Aaron Kelly, Angie
Very interesting “Astro Boy” hair style tonight. Aaron was way better tonight than last week. Randy said he was born to sing. Ellen asked if he was trying to copy her hair and said his performance was 2nd to Siobhan’s. Simon thought he 100% picked the right song. I apologize, but I was a bit bored at this point and anxiously awaiting Crystal to get up on stage. Still, I think Aaron should be safe tomorrow.

12 – Crystal Bowersox, You Can’t Always Get What You Want
I just dig Crystal. She’s so polished up there. Although I’m not ready to crown her just yet, as I think Siobhan is up there too. Randy said it wasn’t her best, but she didn’t disappoint. Ellen thought she was singing with ease and added a little personality tonight. Kara called her comfortable up on stage. Simon thinks this is the first week that she was beaten (by Siobhan). Crystal should be safe tomorrow. I’d be very disappointed if it wasn’t her and Siobhan head-to-head in the finals.

Top 2: Siobhan, Crystal

Bottom 3: Lacey, Andrew, Tim

Off tomorrow: Lacey

Thursday, March 11, 2010

AIIX recap, Semi-finalists x 8, Guys (03/10/10)

Hey all y’all, Jim Rutter here, giving our man Jason Ura a well-deserved break. It is a bit long, so get the fresh cup of coffee and have at it.



So, the pre-show promos told us that the Top 8 guys would be “leaving it all on the stage” and faux-host Ryan Seacrest claimed they would be “ready to deliver”. That didn’t happen tonight, but overall I thought this was one of the better, or at least in terms of quality, “deeper” sets of the current season. There were a couple of poor, but not “awful” efforts. Note: If it were not for TiVo, I would not have been able to write this recap because I would not have been able to miss Modern Family, which makes me laugh every week. “Recommended viewing”, which I can’t always say for American Idol.



First up…



LEE DEWYZE: “Fireflies” – Owl City



Lee, dressed in “dormitory chic”, came out fast-strumming his guitar a la ??? (pretty sorry statement that I just had to “google” to be reminded of the name of last year’s nondescript winner, Kris Allen.)



Does this Dewyze fellow really want it badly enough? He did seem a little more into it tonight. I mean, he does have a certain “Dave Mathews” quality to him, but at some point we have to agree on what is “stylized vocalization” versus “pitchy”. I thought Lee was the latter. He ended a capella and the finish was sort of a “mini-moment” for him.

Randy said “Wow! Wow!” which with RJ can mean good or bad. “Sweater Man” called it a strange song choice, but liked that Lee made it his own, worked it out. Whatever.

Ellen liked that he made it a little “rock”, but cited a couple of pitch problems. Thinks he is “adorable” (Somebody please buy that woman a thesaurus!) and that people are talking to her that have crushes on him. Okay…
Kara thought Lee looked confident tonight. She had been waiting for him to step up and show “star” quality. She called it a “solid job”, that he improved on the original song with his “production value”.

Simon didn’t think it was a “moment”, likes him for the Top 12, but thinks he can do better. I can’t believe the money they have been paying Cowell! He makes me want to channel Arrested Development and yell “C’MON!”



ALEX LAMBERT: “Trouble” – Ray LaMontagne (apparently some Maine folk singer I don't know)



When I watch this kid perform, I am in “trouble”. “Droopy Dog” has more energy and stage presence. He bores me, but then again, so did Roy Orbison and Roy’s perfect voice made his career.



Randy liked it, but wasn’t “wow-ed”

Ellen seemed to “boo” Randy and said Alex was a “mushy banana” that was ripening so fast, constantly getting better. She loves his innocence, thinks he is sweet and vulnerable (none of which are qualities I look for in a major pop star, but that is just me). I think she is being overly “De-generous” in her praise. Ellen hopes he doesn’t become a “cocky banana”, because according to her, “no one likes that” (which of course isn’t true) That kid J.D Fortune, who became the INXS lead singer after his Rockstar INXS participation, was a “cocky banana” and it scored him a pretty sweet gig!)


Kara thinks “the only thing standing in the way of your winning is you right now!” C’MON!

Still, she thinks he is “stiff up there” and “not letting go”. She wanted just him with his guitar, “in the moment” (whatever that means)

Simon thought Alex was too caught up in trying to deliver the performance, that he should try to relax by envisioning Randy Jackson in a bikini (uh….okay…) Wants him to stop staring down the lens/camera. Thinks he has a good, distinct voice.

TIM URBAN: “Hallelujah” – Jeff Buckley version or something

Tim Urban – Lord, what a name – must be the long-lost love child of “Tim” McGraw and Keith “Urban”. But you know, the guy jumped back into the fray with a very decent performance tonight. The guy’s hairstyle is somewhat reminiscent of that of the oldest brother “David” on Eight is Enough.



Randy thought he walked in pretty big shoes, but did a pretty good job!

Ellen felt compelled to run down and give Tim a congratulatory bear- hug. She thought it was “fantastic”. Not sure about that, but he did seem like he belonged in the competition for once.
Kara admitted she thought Urban would be going home weeks ago, but now thinks he is “kind of in it” and at the “top of the toys”. Tim looks stunned by the positives.

Simon took credit for Tim’s improved performance and said he was “very, very smart with the song” and that it was by far his best performance to date.



I agree and really appreciate that “Timbo” didn’t scratch the nation’s chalkboard as he did with his painful rendition of One Republic’s "Apologize" a while back.

ANDREW GARCIA: “Genie in a Bottle” - Christina Aguilera



I sort of like Andrew, but as a long-time supermarket checkout wannabe, I keep wanting to “scan” the guy’s neck! Also, what is with the ridiculously long “wallet chain” Andrew was sporting tonight. Was he worried someone was going to rob him on stage? I am not into the thick-rimmed “Hokey Gokey” glasses, but hey, to each his own.



The judges have given him too much credit for his admittedly excellent version of Paula’s "Straight Up". He said he was “going back to his roots”, but this effort simply… sucked. It was sung way too high (in register?) for my taste. Maybe it is this guy’s ultimate destiny and niche to sing “unplugged” versions of chick dance songs. Who knows? His star is fading fast.



Randy thought the song was a good idea, but that it didn’t quite work and was a little pitchy.

Ellen thought it was a great song choice, but said “the genie came out of the bottle” a little too late.
Kara thinks he peaked too early (with “Straight Up”) and has been chasing it ever since. She was “disappointed”.

Simon thought Andrew was “desperate”, “uncomfortable” and “kind of going backwards.”



Andrew then pandered to fans at home – which was smart on his part.


CASEY JAMES: “You’ll Think of Me” – Keith Urban



Count me as a big fan of CJ. Of all the contestants, he is the one guy I would actually buy a ticket to see perform a full concert. Dude certainly has the look and his presence and attitude are singularly non-annoying. Tonight his voice reminded me of a more upbeat UC Berkeley non-graduate Adam Duritz of Counting Crows, which is a good thing.



Did I ever mention that Cindi and I got free tickets to a Kelly Clarkson show at the Shoreline Amphitheater in 2006 and were so disappointed we actually left early (in fairness, partially because the acoustics were laughably horrendous!)



Back to The Talented Mr. James……

Randy thought it was too “safe”, wanted more of an edgy, Stevie Ray (Vaughn) style.

Ellen thought it was “great”. Enough said. Wow, I agreed with Ellen?
Kara said it was “a move in the right direction” and that she was kinda back on the “Casey Train” (at first I thought she said back on the “Crazy Train”, which trust me, she has been on all along – see her emotional melt-down after Big Mike’s show-closing number).

Simon thought it was “sincere”, but not memorable, calling it Casey’s second-best performance, but adding that he didn’t love the song choice. Put a fork in Simon. I can’t even listen to him anymore – and what is scarier, he is probably the best of the judges. The juvenile elbowing and “leaning” toward Kara had me ready to start channel-surfing.


AARON KELLY: “I’m Already There” - Lonestar



Nice kid, sure. But I am thinking “big arrow down” here. There is no freakin’ way this kid deserves to be a finalist contender. Immediately off key/pitchy and the song seemed forced and too big for him – he even seemed to be challenged for air during the performance. Was trying too hard to hold notes and his voice seemed to be cracking. Just too young and dorky. Little Aaron Kelly aka “Archuleta 2.0” is amazing in his ability to make David A. actually seem almost cool in comparison. He is sort of this season’s Anthony Federov or Kevin Covais.



Randy, however, thought it was “really good” and “a job well done”.

Ellen liked Aaron’s confidence, but said it was “not terrific” and agreed with me that it was too much song for him.
Kara loved that he gave it his all, but didn’t think it was relevant since he is a young kid and couldn’t relate to the song’s content

Simon immediately and rather rudely cut Kara off and insinuated that she was smoking crack (figuratively), that it was the right type of song. He didn’t think it was a great vocal, but he felt it showed emotion. Simon is truly a bull in a judges’ shop. Tool.



TODRICK HALL: “Somebody To Love” - Queen



Slight “arrow up” on Todrick. The opening falsetto bugged me (for a second I thought he was going to go all “Minnie Ripperton” on us!), but I have to admit, the man can really sing. I wasn’t wild about the arrangement, but it sort of worked. The over-the-top Gospel-style background singers were borderline ridiculous – reminded me of the doo-wop-ing Motown back-up singers in Little Shop of Horrors – except that they were intended to provide comedy to that show. Todrick, on the other hand, had his gals backing him for real and it only came across to the audience as comedic. Oh, and I kind of liked his wardrobe/look (for him, not me).



Randy says “Todrick is back!” Believes it was one of the best vocals by a man in weeks.

Ellen called it “brave” and commended him.
Kara said it was really good singing, but that it was so dramatic she almost laughed.

Simon sees his as more of a “Broadway” singer (which is probably true, but hey Queen songs are often highly theatrical), but admitted Todrick sang well and made an effort to perform, adding that this “may have saved him” (also true)


“BIG MIKE” LYNCHE: “This Woman’s Work” – Kate Bush/Maxwell



I immediately did a double take when I recognized the start of the song. Who can forget the hauntingly beautiful Kate Bush original version that was featured so fittingly in 1988’s She’s Having a Baby (one of the all-time great 80s scenes is when a hormonal Elizabeth McGovern screams at Kevin Bacon “I’ll have to BURN THE SHEETS!” after Alec Baldwin’s character bedded some skanky broad.) Anyway, that has to be one of the more memorably “relevant” movie songs.



In a million years, I would never have guessed “Big Mike” would do that tune. Points for the serious surprise element. I thought it was a tad “karaoke” and his falsetto a bit much, but the XXXL-sized note he held onto for about an hour near the end was quite impressive.



I was reminded by Wikipedia that the Maxwell cover of "This Woman's Work" was used on the July 22, 2009 episode of So You Think You Can Dance, (Jason just loves it when I can tie AI in with a reality dance show) as a backdrop to a contemporary dance choreographed by Tyce Diorio with the subject of breast cancer as the story line, danced by ballerina Melissa Sandvig and contemporary dancer Ade Obayomi. Both dancers and Diorio received strong and emotional praise from judges Nigel Lythgoe, Mary Murphy, Mia Michaels, and special guest, of all people……. Ellen DeGeneres. Full disclosure: Believe it or not I saw that dance number and indeed it was incredibly moving.



So, yes, given this young man’s recent foray into fatherhood and having to balance that emotional experience with this competition, it was a brilliant song choice. That notwithstanding….I still have trouble taking this cat too seriously as a finalist to become “the next American Idol”. I have trouble getting over his sheer mass. “Big Mike” makes me want to put my hands up, wiggle me some arm fat, and shout “Hercules! Hercules! Hercules!” with The Klumps from The Nutty Professor! I admit I like the big fella (the way I liked affable former UW lineman Matt Rogers from Season Three), but he is simply way too big to have his performances keep you from focusing on his physical enormity. “Big Mike” is a GNC store manager’s wet dream, but with that new child in his life, he needs to tone down the workouts and go cold turkey on the protein shakes.

Randy thought it was “crazy”, and HOT!

Ellen kept it simple: “Oh my God, so beautiful!”
Kara got all teary, saying it was “so relevant” (which admittedly it was) and recognizing the respect it showed for Mike’s wife. The poor woman almost lost it at the judges’ table.

Simon said that it was “needed” and that “Big Mike” nailed it 100%, producing the best performance of the live shows.



They liked it a bit better than I did, but Mike gets credit due for a strong shot across the bow.

---------------------------

Top “Moment” of the Evening: Well, for me personally, it was the awesome preview for Iron Man II – Imax (May 7th!), which may be the first ad I haven’t fast-forwarded through in the seven seasons I have been watching Idol. But seriously, it has to be “Big Mike” with his “long & strong” note.

Impressive Performances: Casey, Big Mike



Helped themselves: Tim, Todrick, Big Mike



Kept Himself in the Game: Casey

Hurt themselves: Andrew, Aaron, Lee



Could Be On Their Way Home: Aaron, Andrew



Should Be On Their Way Home: Aaron, Alex

Tuesday, March 09, 2010

AIIX recap, Semi-finalists x 8, Gals (03/09/10)

So, we’re back on schedule with the gals going first. I was 2 for 4 last week, predicting Jermaine Sellers and Haeley Vaughn would be off. Not totally surprised by John Park going, but somewhat surprised that Michelle Delamore was let go. Park, John (as the Koreans would call him) still has the love that Shania Twain gave him to put in is back pocket. Sounds priceless, like a MasterCard commercial.

01 – Katie Stevens, Breakaway (Kelly Clarkson)
I think this song did nothing for Katie’s voice. I get that she tried to pick a younger song, but she was pitchy and came off as amateur. She’s like the girl that can’t say no. Randy wanted a bigger song. Ellen wanted a younger song. I’m surprised they didn’t recommend the Sara Bareilles song (“Love Song”) that they always recommend to a contestant to sound younger. Randy said it paled in comparison to the original. Ellen liked that she took a younger song, but didn’t feel like she connected to it. Kara said she has a great voice, but she doesn’t know who she is an artist. And that her voice is years older than her. Simon echoed the “haven’t worked out what type of artist you are” sentiment. I think if you cut Katie’s hair, she would look like Brandon Call, JT from “Step By Step.” I think Katie’s in trouble on Thursday night.

02 – Siobhan Magnus, House of the Rising Sun (The Animals)
Loved Siobhan’s top tonight, as it had a Japanese obi-esk feeling to it. One of my favorite ties is from a line called Kanajo and it has a part of an obi in it. Siobhan started a cappella and rocked it. You can’t deny her voice. She didn’t have that “note” like last week, but I think she’s a close second to Crystal right now. Randy said he’s surprised by her every week. And he also joked that the judges have all these suggestions for her every week and she never pays attention to them. Ellen gushed, “you are why I love music.” Kara loved the a cappella start. Simon, however, was under impressed. Not only does Siobhan look like Ally Sheedy with Demi Lovato’s smile, but I also think she has a little of Dana Delany (in Desperate Housewives) in her. She’s safe on Thursday and I think she’ll be in the final 2 with Crystal.

03 – Lacey Brown, The Story (Brandi Carlile)
Lacey definitely has her own style and threw it all in your face this week, with the leopard print sweater over a neon orange/pink top and lime green nails. To go with the Annie Lennox hair too. It’s all a little bit much for me. And I am not a fan of her voice. She’s got a real weird tone to me. Randy thought it was her best performance in a long time. Ellen thought the song was something written for her. Simon didn’t love the song, but said Lacey sang it real well. She was praised so much tonight that I think she may be in trouble on Thursday.

04 – Katelyn Epperly, I Feel the Earth Move (Carole King)
I don’t know why, but I feel like Katelyn looks like a PTA mom. Or a somewhat younger version of one. And that hair screams of Meg Ryan in “When Harry Met Sally.” I thought this song was pretty karaoke. I get that she played the keyboards, but they seemed more like a prop than something that added to the song. Randy didn’t feel the vibe and said it felt “put on.” Ellen said that was not the song to wow people with. Kara didn’t feel like she was competing up there. Simon likened it to request night at a restaurant that she was working at. I think Katelyn may have reached her ceiling in this competition. Vocally and performance-wise, she’s overmatched, but that doesn’t mean she’ll go home on Thursday.

05 – Didi Benami, Rhiannon (Fleetwood Mac)
Didi has the same voice as Megan Joy, but better. Just think if Megan Joy (with her looks) had Didi’s voice. She may have gone to the final 4 last season (I think she made it to the final 9). I really liked this song tonight. And I think Didi looks like she should be on one of those shows on the WB right now (90210 or Gossip Girl or One Tree Hill). Randy said she was a whole lot better than last week. Ellen quipped, “Yes, indeedy, Didi,” which was pretty funny. Kara called it one of her favorite moments of the season so far. Simon called her head and shoulders above everything else tonight. And called her “wow moment” the whole performance. I think Didi should be safe tomorrow. And I also think she looks a bit like Laura Prepon from “That ‘70s Show.”

06 – Paige Miles, Smile (Charlie Chaplin)
Paige looked very uncomfortable up there tonight and kind of out of her element. She said that it was an emotional song for her (because Michael Jackson covered it and she was a huge MJ fan) and that her emotions got the best of her up there. Randy said it didn’t work for him. Ellen called it sad and heavy instead of inspiring and uplifting. Kara called it all wrong. Simon thought it was a horrible choice of song and the arrangement was awful. Paige has a pretty good voice, but she has underwhelmed so far. I think she’s in big trouble Thursday night.

07 – Crystal Bowersox, Give Me One Reason (Tracy Chapman)
When I first heard this song choice, I thought, “how predictable.” But then Crystal came out and totally rocked it. Played the electric guitar and just killed it. She reminds me (performance-wise) of Bo Bice. Both real good singers that probably didn’t want to go the AI route, but their circumstances led them to this show. So I read somewhere that her illness last week that hospitalized her was considered “diabetic complications.” Again, she’s a dead ringer for Julia Stiles, but crossed with Jason Castro (dreds). Randy said he loved that. Ellen said she needs new adjectives for Crystal. Simon said she’s definitely in the top 12 and that she’s the one to beat. They’ve practically crowned her the champion already after only 3 weeks. I agree with their assessment, but it’s hard to keep that momentum going from so early on. Ask David Archuleta about that. 100% safe on Thursday though.

08 – Lilly Scott, Falls to Pieces (Patsy Cline)
My wife Kristin always thinks of Madonna singing “Santa Baby” when Lilly sings. And that album “A Very Special Christmas” is my favorite holiday CD of all time. Hands down. The Pretenders’ version of “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas” is my favorite holiday song, although Whitney Houston’s “Do You Hear What I Hear?” and the Eurythmics’ “Winter Wonderland” are close. Back to Lilly. Do you think wardrobe has fun with her? She definitely has her own style, but in a way that fits her. Not like Lacey. And is Lilly harkening back to Betty Boop with her voice? Randy called it well done. Ellen loves her originality. Kara thought she made Patsy Cline feel current. Simon called her very brave for her risky song choice. I just don’t get Lilly. Not at all. She’s going to go way farther than I want her to in this competition. She won’t win, but it pains me to hear her every week. But she’s definitely better than most of the others.

A lot has been said about how good this top 24 is. But not by me. I think this is the weakest top 24 in recent history. I was wondering when they’d run out of talent for this show. I think this is the year. No one blows me away, but I do like Crystal and Siobhan. But that’s it. I like Andrew too, but he has to get back to his “Straight Up” performance.

I’ll post bottom 2s tomorrow.

Thursday, March 04, 2010

AIIX recap, Semi-finalists x 10, Gals (03/03/10)

Thanks again to Mike Rico for filling in last night. I was supposed to have dinner with a cousin who was going to be in from out of town, but he cancelled at the last minute. But since Mike had agreed to recap, I sat back and was entertained. Plus, I know he’s got a following too and I want to have him write this season, as he claims it’s his last go round (and maybe mine too).

A few things from last night. I know the guys had to go a day earlier, but I don’t think the time change affected them that much. Meaning, I don’t think an extra day would’ve made them sound any better. After watching the gals tonight, there is no way a guy is going to win this thing. I wouldn’t be surprised if the final 4 are all girls. Seriously. Here are my quick $0.02 on the guys.
• Used to like Michael Lynche, but can’t stand his facial expressions/how he performs.
• Loved the short track reference on John Park.
• Surprised at how Kara reacted to Casey James. But love the song choice, as it’s the theme song for one of my favorite shows, “One Tree Hill.” They had an homage to John Hughes and the ‘80s on a show a few weeks back. Packed with visual gags from all the ‘80s movies. Loved it.
• Alex Lambert was better last night, but I still have a hard time watching/listening to him.
• Todrick needs to just sing and stop chopping songs up. It worked for Blake Lewis, but that’s it.
• Jermaine bugs me. Seems too old for the competition and has a chip on his shoulder.
• Poor Andrew has to live up to the “Straight Up” rendition. I thought he was good last night. Co-worker’s husband had a great line from last week. Since they called Casey “Eye Candy,” it would’ve been hilarious if Andrew referred to himself as “Eye Fiber.”
• I think Simon was using reverse psychology by not killing Tim Urban. And did anyone notice that Seacrest called him “Jim?”
• Lee’s performance summed up the guys. May have been the best of the night, but it was pitchy at times. Real nice tone to his voice (sounds like The Dave Matthews Band? Or Daughtry?). And nice call on Jay Cutler.

01 – Crystal Bowersox, Long As I Can See The Light (Creedence Clearwater Revival)
So I guess the buzz on the gals is that if Crystal Bowersox was unable to perform, she would’ve been automatically eliminated from the show. Still don’t know what went on, but it seems as though she was hospitalized. Judges really emphasized how well she did and stuff. Maybe overly, but she was good tonight. The thing people didn’t know about her is that she has a twin brother. Who is a square. She really reminds me of a grungy Julia Stiles. For some reason, I remember Julia dancing in a lot of her movies (10 Things I Hate About You, Save the Last Dance, O), much like I remember Julia Roberts singing in a lot of her movies (Mystic Pizza, Pretty Woman, My Best Friend’s Wedding). Yeah, that was random. So, back to Crystal. I think she has a real pure voice. And she’s got that real folksy vibe to her. She’s got some sympathy building now too. I think she’s safe to the top 12 and a real frontrunner. Randy called her true to herself. Ellen called her a pure, raw, natural talent. Kara said she recovered from last week and hit a new level. Simon said she didn’t play the sympathy thing, likened her to Kelly Clarkson (taking the competition by the neck in the 2nd week) and called her vocals incredible. So I guess he liked it too. He kept pimping her throughout the night too. I hope he’s not jinxing her!

02 – Haeley Vaughn, The Climb (Miley Cyrus)
Her secret is that she makes headbands and other accessories. But during the piece she also came over as immature and too young. And her body glitter annoys me too. I thought Haeley was quite pitchy during this song, which means she must’ve been really pitchy if I can hear it and acknowledge it. I’m without my wife Kristin tonight, as she’s traveling for work. She’s usually my ears, as I’m probably tone deafer than Mike. Since this song is by Miley Cyrus (from the “Hannah Montana Movie,” which we saw and actually liked), I’ve always wondered how a current pop star would do on this show. Let’s say Miley Cyrus dressed in disguise and tried out for the show. How would she do? I’d be very interested to see if she made it through and the journey of her making it. Randy said the song didn’t work for him, calling it excruciating and so pitchy. Ellen told her to keep smiling, but that she didn’t connect with the song. Kara said she needs another year to strengthen her voice. Simon called it a complete and utter mess and that in theory the song should’ve worked. Maybe she’ll be safe because of his criticism. And she’s the poster girl on “Vote For The Worst,” along with Tim Urban. Haeley seems like a nice girl, but she’s way over her head in this competition. I hope they put her out of her (and our) misery tomorrow night.

03 – Lacey Brown, Kiss Me (Sixpence None The Richer)
Love this song. Main song in “She’s All That” with Rachael Leigh Cook (and Freddie Prinze, Jr). Cute movie. And I think it’s funny that Rachael Leigh Cook was on “Dawson’s Creek” as a girl hired to play Joey Potter (Katie Holmes’ character) in the movie Dawson was shooting while they were in college. This is such an upbeat, get up and dance song. And Big Mike was doing just that. He was working it out off the stage. He’s so big that when he does something, you notice it. Lacey really does have a unique tone to her voice, but her version was definitely not better than the original, but she did change it up a little. Randy called it a good song choice, but said he was looking for the little TV with the words coming across because it sounded “karaoke.” Ellen called her adorable (I think that’s becoming her pet word, which means you stunk). Kara liked her tone, but said she needs to step it up. And sounded like she was suggesting that she sing “Shiny Happy People” next week. Simon called her marginally better than last week, but slammed her saying that if she does what they suggest to her (Kara suggested this song last week), she may move on, but that she is not out to showcase her talent and actually try to win. He pimps Crystal again here, saying there’s a massive, massive difference between the two. I think Lacey is in trouble tomorrow night.

04 – Katie Stevens, Put Your Records On (Corrine Bailey Rae)
I think if you give Katie a bowl cut, she’ll look like Jimmy Connors. Think about that one. Her “talent,” if you can call it that, is that she can say “give me a kiss” in 6 different languages. I’m a bit torn on Katie because she has such a rich, deep voice, which is pleasing to me. But then she’s 17 and she seems a bit precocious and reminds me a bit of Diana DiGarmo, in that it seems as though she’s been singing and performing and been told that’s she’s a great singer since she’s been like 5 years old. Kind of like a Jon Benet Ramsey pageant girl, but as a singer. Randy liked her upper register. Ellen said she has a great voice, but wants to hear something younger that “she wouldn’t hear at her dentist’s office.” Kara and Simon were both frustrated because she has a great voice but singing the wrong songs. They keep telling her to sing a younger song, but I think Katie’s got an older, more mature voice. And singing a younger song may not suit her voice. It may suit her age, but I don’t think it will go well if she sings a song by a younger person just because that person is younger. A few years back, Ayla Brown was 1 week away from the final 10 (or 12?) when she sang “Unwritten” by Natasha Bedingfeld. That song was younger, like Ayla, but it didn’t suit her. Ayla, by the way, went on to play basketball at Boston College (I think she’s a senior now) and her dad is Scott Brown, the new senator in Massachusetts. He’s the guy who leveled the playing field for the Republicans in that the Democrats can’t filibuster anymore. With such a high profile right now, I wouldn’t be surprised if Scott Brown is the Republican candidate for President in 2012. Back to Katie. I think she’s safe tomorrow night, but I think the judges are killing her. I think she’s singing better than their comments. She’s a definite contradiction though.

05 – Didi Benami, Lean on Me (Bill Withers)
Didi’s secret is that she was the mascot for her middle school, until she worked her way up to becoming a full-time cheerleader. Didi really is Megan Joy without the whole sleeve tattoo. Didi has such a different voice (although much like Megan’s!). It’s kind of annoying, but not that much because she’s good looking like Megan. Randy said it was the wrong song choice. Ellen said she loved her voice. Kara said it wasn’t good, that it felt karaoke and lost her uniqueness. Simon called it screeching and said she wasted an opportunity. This almost brought Didi to tears and she couldn’t even respond to a question that Seacrest asked her. Didi’s definitely in trouble tomorrow, but I have a feeling she might be safe.

06 – Michelle Delamore, With Arms Wide Open (Creed)
Loved Michelle’s outfit tonight. Very retro, Madonna-ish Borderline/Lucky Star-like. This version of the Creed song was not good to me. Pitchy at times. But I think people will remember how good a singer she is and not judge by this performance. They called her Alicia Keys predictable last week so she wanted to change it up. Randy thought her outfit was hot and dope (I love how he’s trying, single-handedly, to keep this word alive), but didn’t do enough with the song and felt it fell flat. Ellen said it almost worked. Kara called it her favorite performance of hers. Not technically perfect, but it felt believable. Simon agreed with Kara, then proceeded to point Vera Wang out in the audience. I think Michelle is safe tomorrow and should cruise into the top 12. I think she’s a contender too.

07 – Lilly Scott, A Change Is Gonna Come (Sam Cooke)
Lilly’s secret is that she plays a multitude of instruments. I just don’t get Lilly. She has such strange phrasing. I think some people will love her. I’m just not one of them. Randy said she worked it out and it was his favorite of the night. Ellen said she’s got “it.” Kara said she had her first “moment.” Simon said it was good, but he wasn’t as crazy about it as the other 3. I’m with Simon on this one. She will definitely be safe tomorrow, but I’m just not a fan. It’s American Idol, not Indie Idol…

08 – Katelyn Epperly, The Scientist (Coldplay)
Her deal is that she is studying to become a recording engineer. Man, this song was boring. Randy acknowledged it was way slow, but liked it. Ellen mentioned that they’ve seen her on the guitar before, but then forgot she was on the piano! But explained that she made the mistake because she fell asleep because the song was so slow! Kara said Katelyn has an incredible instrument (I think she’s referring to her voice), but she’s all over the place. Simon thought it was a smart choice of song, but said she becomes corny when she performs. I think Katelyn is safe tomorrow. I missed her Sandy from Grease look.

09 – Paige Miles, Walk Away (Kelly Clarkson)
Paige likes to color, and used a third person reference describing it. Love that. Paige has a great voice, but her eyes freak me out. She really had fun up there, but that was a little turn off for Kara, who helped write the song. She said if she was connecting with the song, she wouldn’t be smiling when saying “walk away.” Simon said she failed to choose the right song. Randy and Ellen both liked it. I think Paige has one of the strongest voices in the competition. Definitely better than any of the guys. She just has other gals to contend with. She should be safe tomorrow and cruise into the final 12.

10 – Siobhan Magnus, Think (Aretha Franklin)
Her secret is that she had a Mohawk recently. Her look is much better now. And I again have to give kudos to my wife Kristin for nailing her Ally Sheedy with Demi Lovato’s smile comment. I think Siobhan is going to win this thing. She has a crazy, big voice evidenced by “the note” that she held at the end of this song. And she’s got her own style already. Very ‘80s-ish, like Molly Ringwald in “Pretty in Pink.” Randy called her bold and fearless. Also added dope and slayed it. Ellen got off a nice Snuggie joke. Kara couldn’t get over that note and Simon called her such a strange person again (but in a good way). Siobhan is my pick to win it all. Her or Crystal.

So this is a tough one. I was 0 for 4 last week. But here are my fearless predictions anyway.

Off for the guys: Tim Urban and Jermaine Sellers.
Off for the gals: Haeley Vaughn and Lacey Brown.

Wednesday, March 03, 2010

AIIX recap, Semi-finalists x 10, Guys (03/02/10)

Hi all

Mike Rico, here, subbing in today for the man, the myth, the legend. I told Jason I’m good for one more year as a pinch hitter. I’m like Manny Mota hanging on for one more season and one more pinch hit... Some random thoughts so far on the season… The addition of Ellen was something I looked forward to as I’m a fan of hers. To me she is the female equivalent of David Letterman without the edge and Letterman was my favorite when he did the Late Night show when I was growing up. I’ve noticed that Dave’s and Ellen’s moms look almost exactly alike… Anyway, my wife tivos her show and will play it as she winds down for bed. I’ll get sucked in oftentimes. Jason was right in that it was a bit awkward blending her in on the first week, but she is getting her sea legs and had some funny comments this week… I think Kara now offers the best advice to contestants week in and week out since the second half of last year. She’s pretty good at pinpointing the issues with the singers. Didn’t like her at first, but her critiques have been pretty right on- she can be annoying though. Didn’t need to see her try to top bikini girl on last year’s finale. That was lame…

On to the show- a sudden illness to Crystal Bowersox on the ladies’ side has led to a change in scheduling as the girls were suppossed to perform first. Not sure what the nature of the illness is, but we have had sick contestants before without schedule changes, so this will be interesting… We’ll hear the guys tonight as they hope to reveal interesting tidbits in the intros that people may not know about them…

01 Michael Lynche, 26; This Is A Man’s World, James Brown.

Big Mike went to a performing arts high school. He was into theater, but also played football. Did Fame have a football team? Does Juilliard? Michael should have auditioned for a role in Glee, the Fox show about show choir… We have the AI football combine here as he says his max in the bench is 505 and in a funny visual, he curls sixteen year old Aaron Kelly like he’s a 30 pound bar bell. Mike doesn’t even break a sweat, but I seem to remember that we saw his sweaty pits in Hollywood. Keep the arms down, Mike. Looks like he could have made a decent defensive tackle in the college if he wanted… Tonight, he sings a selection from the Godfather of Soul.

Ellen says she likes his song choices so far in the competition. Simon says he grew from a pussycat into a tiger. The Dawg gave him a standing ovation.

I like Michael- it would be hard not to like him. I thought the judges went a little overboard as I didn’t like the arrangement of the song- it sounded kind of loungey- but I’m not going to dwell on it. He stylized it and I’m glad to see him without the guitar. It’s an odd sight as he holds the guitar really low, but I think it would probably look like he was playing the ukulele if he held it any higher. He’s a stone cold lock to move on.


02 John Park, 21; Gravity, John Mayer
We learn that John is part of an acappella group at Northwestern. My favorite name for an acappella group is “Acafellas” in a bit from the TV show, Glee. Oh, boy, I’m going to pimp Glee early and often. Seriously, Glee is the best show going right now. Too many great things about it to list, so do yourself a favor and rent or buy the Season 1 DVD to get current when it comes back in a few weeks… In the clip, we find out that English is John’s second language- he was born in America, then his parents moved back to Korea and then came back to the US in the 4th grade, where he learned English. My pet theory is I think his parents were trying to get him in Korea’s short track speed skating program, but he was too tall…He talks about last week’s performance- he says he tried too hard and concedes that he picked the wrong song last week. He’ll give it a shot this week with a John Mayer song.

Randy said he didn’t bring anything new; he wasn’t special. Simon said it was nothing to get excited about. He doesn’t seem believable to him. Ellen says more soul is needed and Kara said it was way better than last week. However, there’s a lack of connection.

I like John and want him to do well in the competition. I thought last week was a disaster for him. He definitely picks a better song this time, but it’s still only a minor improvement. I agree with Kara, he needs to find a way to connect with the audience. He may very well be gone this week.


03 Casey James, 27; I Don’t Want To Be, Gavin DeGraw

Casey shares the fact that his family didn’t watch much TV growing up. This was due to the fact that lighting struck his house when he was 7 and the family decided that their TV wouldn’t be replaced. Got to admit, it would have to take a lot more than that for me to give up the idiot box. Lightning, floods, locusts… these things could not break up my love affair with commercial programming. I really have to question their commitment to the greatest medium ever broadcasted. Who needs TV now, Casey James?

Ellen says you can’t go wrong with this song. She said he had some stiffness and wants him to perform more to the audience. Randy loves the guitar playing and could see him playing this type of music. Simon says it felt like someone trying to be a rock star. His biggest fan, Kara, said he took two steps backwards.

I remember Casey was almost a borderline call in auditions. He looked the part, but gave a lethargic performance. They sent him through, but with the condition that he bring some excitement. Looks like he did enough of that through Hollywood… Casey has an interesting vibrato, not too distracting. He sounds to me like a light-weight Eddie Vedder from Pearl Jam. He’s okay for me. I agree with Kara that he took a step back tonight as his lack of charisma or inability to connect with the audience is holding him back.

04 Alex Lambert, 19; Everybody Knows, John Legend

Alex was the super-nervous kid from last week. In the video, he talks about his lack of experience performing. Talking to the camera, he seems like he could be a character from Friday Night Lights. He also says he shares that he made up his own language in the sixth grade, which helps him with the melodies of the songs he sings. He breaks off a sample and his made up language kinda sounds like garbled Spanish. Whatever works…

Simon said it was a million times better, but needs to develop a killer instinct. Ellen made me laugh when she said that there is a great voice under that mullet. Karen says he has a great tone and that everyone wishes they had that kind of voice.

Alex amazes me with that voice (especially the tone) he has; that voice coming from the body is a strange sight for me. This kid shouldn’t have to worry about a regular 9 to 5 job with those pipes, no matter what happens here… It’s a confidence issue for him right now… He looks more comfortable behind his guitar and is able to give a more relaxed performance. It may be hard for him to perform, but I will be rooting for him to do well.

05 Todrick Hall, 24; What’s Love Got To Do With It, Tina Turner

We learn that Todrick grew up as a young performer. He was a soldier in the nutcracker and was the Jackie Robinson of his school/studio by being the first African-American to play the character of Fritz. He talks about last week’s performance and how he will try to tone down the dancing and be more about the singing.

Randy said it was a great song that doesn’t need to be reworked. Didn’t like it. Just sing the song, says the Dawg. Simon thinks he should just move, not dance when he sings. Ellen said he picked a hard song to sing and it just didn’t feel current, while Kara asks what has happened to Todrick?

Liked this guy a lot in the auditions. I think naturally, he’s more of an R&B performer, which is often not as immediately accessible to the AI demographic. He does need to pick better songs. There’s no reason why his dance skills should detract from his performances. The bigger problem, as alluded to by the judges, is that he’s picking signature songs and doing too much to them. Everyone knows the formula on AI- take a song and rework it in your style. Todrick needs to figure out how to make the formula work for him, whether it’s song choice and/or style. I hope he figures it out soon.

06 Jermaine Sellers, 27; What’s Going On, Marvin Gaye

In the intro, Jermaine announces to the world that he rocks the onesies, while frolicking in a pajama jumpsuit usually rocked by toddlers. Yeah, that wasn’t contrived… The other part of the piece is that he uses a steam mask to help open up his vocals. … Tonight, he tackles a classic from Marvin Gaye. Good luck.

Ellen says Jermaine has a great style, but the song didn’t work for her. Kara thought he was doing too much. She advised him to look at the lyrics of the song- it felt forced to her. Too many tricks vocally. Simon is frustrated with him as he watering down the songs (referring to last week as well) from the emotional impact of the original recordings.

Not a fan of this guy or other “look at me” singers who want to vocally trick out every song they sing. His style is jazzy and it sounded like Al Jarreau sings Marvin Gaye. (But I love “Mornin’” and “We’re In This Love Together” from Jazzy Al.) I’m also deducting points for his played out faux hawk which is distracting. He then asked the panel what he should sing, which is weak. Simon says the problem is that he probably won’t be there next week. Zing! You still got it, Simon. I agree the guy has skills, but so far they haven’t served the song or the audience. Connect with the song and entertain us! He’s in my bottom three this week.


07 Andrew Garcia, 24; You Give Me Something, James Morrison

My man showed us that he is a semi-retired breakdancer who is also hella out of shape. After just one session on the cardboard, he was huffing and puffing like he just finished a 10K. The editors of that piece will win an Emmy next year by cutting in it a way that we never had to see Andrew’s butt crack. No money wasted here on blurry pixels… His performance last week was a bit of a letdown, so he’s hoping to rebound here with a song from the soulful James Morrison.

The Dawg said it was pitchy and all over the place. Didn’t like it. Ellen liked it a lot and is still a huge fan. She made me laugh when she said she was still going to get a tattoo of his name on her neck. Both Ellen and Kara agree that it is tough for him to top the “Straight Up” audition. Simon says he’s frustrated, because he hasn’t picked the right song in two weeks.

I told Jason during auditions that I was excited about my pick-to-click, AKA, The Great Brown Hope. His reworking of “Straight Up” by Paula Abdul electrified the Mexican-American electorate as well as neck tat connoisseurs everywhere. Not sure why, but my cultural pride only swells up behind Mexican AI contestants and boxers. (I also claim Manny Pacquiao, because my wife is a quarter Filipino.) I want Andrew to come out singing in a white robe with the Mexican and American flags intertwined on the back. Jason says he’s the Mexican Danny Gokey and I agree. The glasses are big and bold and the singing is smooth. That also sounds like a recipe for enjoying a good lager… As far as the performance, I liked it, but agreed that everyone is sitting around waiting for a sequel worthy of his first audition. I hope it comes and comes soon, but I’m biased.

08 Aaron Kelly, 16; My Girl, Temptations

We see that Aaron loves photography as we get a look at the baby of the season. Aaron now occupies the throne that Kevin Covais, Sanjaya, and David Archuleta have kept warm in previous seasons. Being the youngest kid who can sing a little bit will usually get you far in the competition… As an aside, I was one of those wretched souls who watched “I’m a Celebrity, Get Me Out of Here!” where Sanjaya was a contestant. After watching it, Sanjaya came out looking a lot better than he did when he was flailing about on American Idol. He was a likeable and game competitor who wasn’t afraid of any challenge or situation in the jungle and he did well on the show. In fact, I am now more of a freak for admitting that I watched that show than Sanjaya was at the end of his AI run… Back to Aaron, not really a fan of his, but I’ll keep an open mind…

Randy said the first half was brilliant, second half got a little funky. Kara really liked it- a country twang with a nice vibrato. He knows who he is and is getting better. Simon had the opposite take- he didn’t like the song, saying he isn’t current and he still needs to figure out what type of singer he wants to be.

Yeah, have to agree with Simon here. His point was that you couldn’t project this type of performance to something you would hear on today’s radio and I agree. He sang it okay, but it was kind of shaky and pretty forgettable. Aaron’s probably not my cup of tea, but he should be safe for a while.


09 Tim Urban, 20; Come On Get Higher, Matt Nathanson
It looks like Tim comes from a large family- he has four brothers and five sisters. He says in the intro that it was hard to digest last weeks’ feedback from the judges, but he took his medicine and he’s ready for this week… Not familiar with the song or the artist he uses this week.

Randy said it was very karaoke, had some pitch problems. Ellen said he should try acting and he has no charisma. Sounds brutal on paper, but somehow it doesn’t sound as mean when it comes from Ellen’s mouth. Kara liked the song choice, but said he didn’t make it his own. Simon was the contrarian here- he said it was a marked improvement. He said Tim listened to the criticism and picked a more relevant song than most others tonight. Maybe Tim brought some big numbers last week and Simon is hedging bets.

It’s difficult for me to believe that this guy made it through all the rounds to get this far. He’s not a good singer/performer- last week’s performance was so painful that we had to forward it halfway through. He’s better this week, but that’s not saying much. I agree with Ellen, get an agent and try acting.

10 Lee DeWyze, 23; Lips Of An Angel, Hinder
We learn in the intro that Lee went to continuation school. Lee says he was a nice guy who made some bad decisions. He’s a good singer and I’ve got no jokes about continuation schools, so I’m going to keep it classy in here… He sings another obscure song (to me) and he does a good job of it.

Randy called his singing guitarless a bold move. The Dawg is a huge fan, but says he has pitch problems, but he liked it. Ellen said his passion and intensity really came through. Simon says vocally, Lee is head and shoulders above everyone on the men’s side. He just needs to believe in himself. A confidence issue… Kara thought it was great and can hear his voice on the radio right now.

I like Lee and the tone of his voice. I have to admit after all these years of watching AI that I can’t really pick up on pitch problems. I guess that makes me tone deaf and pitch deaf, an awesome combination to be recapping American Idol. If I can pick up your pitch problems, then it’s most definitely a problem. Lee reminds me of Jay Cutler, the quarterback for the Chicago Bears. If Lee had Tim Urban’s hair and no chin, he would be a dead ringer for Cutler… My hope is that Lee finds a song he can connect with and turn into a contender. Should make it into the final 12 easily.

It looks a little bleak for the guys’ side right now. Contenders emerge over the season as they become more comfortable in the competition, so it may be likely someone hiding in the shadows will make a run. For now, it looks like the girls are going to have to save the day with a good show.

Deserves to be in the bottom 3: Tim Urban, Jermaine Sellers, John Park

Best guess: John Park, Jermaine Sellers, Todrick Hall

So long!