Wednesday, March 12, 2008

AI7 recap, Finalists x 12 (03/11)

So, it’s the finals now and there’s a new set and the band is up in the “penthouse” (actually it looks like they’re up in the rafters) and there is a “mosh pit” in front of the judges. I know I say this every week, but Ryan Seacrest really is annoying. I really, really can’t stand him. I wish that they could replace him and Paula. How great would the show be if half the “talent” was credible, funny, witty and not annoying? Simon is by far the best and most honest (sometimes brutally so) judge. Randy at least knows his music and can relate that to the viewers.

So it’s Lennon/McCarthy soundbook week. They have more #1s than any other songwriter in history. Unfortunately, I don’t know a whole lot of Beatles songs, which will disappoint my Auntie Lois (who is the biggest Beatles fan ever; only to be rivaled by her mark as the #1 Eric Byrnes fan out there). I only know some of the more popular hits that EVERYONE knows, so I apologize in advance if I’m missing the point on some of these songs.

01 – Syesha Mercado, Got To Get You Into My Life

Found out she attends Florida International University (FIU), which was the school that got into that embarrassing brawl with Miami in football a few years back. Syesha looks good and sings well, but I really don’t see her standing out in the crowd. She’s no different than any other singer. She doesn’t separate herself from the pack. Randy said she was pitchy to start, but it was a nice arrangement, albeit the Earth, Wind and Fire arrangement. EWF is my wife’s favorite band and we saw them at the United Center while we were in Chicago. That was a good time. Paula said she found her zone midway through the song. Simon thought it was better than alright (as Randy called it), but she looked very nervous and needs to get over that. My wife

Kristin thinks that Syesha wasn’t nervous, she just can’t dance (much like Whitney Houston who can sing, but not dance). I think she’s safe tomorrow night, but won’t go much farther in the competition.

02 – Chikezie, She’s A Woman

Found out he used to work security at LAX. Chikezie rocked the green and grey argyle vest (complete with a green wristband watch) tonight and he reminds me of both Ice Cube and Chi McBride (the principal from “Boston Public”). Chikezie started the song sitting on the steps with guys playing the banjo, violin and tambourine. Was this in “Deliverance?” The crowd LOVED it. He really had them going. I thought it was pretty good, at the very least very inspired. Randy said he was thoroughly entertained, he loved the arrangement and he smashed it (who knew he had that falsetto?). Paula said the greater the risk, the greater the reward. Then she said the reward paid off. What? You mean the RISK paid off, Paula. Oh my goodness I wish they had someone intelligent in between Randy and Simon. It was cute and funny for the first few seasons, but it’s just painful to listen to now. Simon was surprised to agree with the other two. He called it terrific, then Ryan proceeded to make a fool of himself by running and jumping around the stage with Chikezie. I thought Chikezie really left it all on the stage tonight and is absolutely safe for tomorrow and is climbing up the contender list. My wife Kristin (who came home late after playing Bunko tonight) said he nailed it.

03 – Ramiele Malubay, In My Life

She chose this song for all of her close friends who have left the show already. I like Ramiele, but she’s not helping herself out in this competition. She’s got a great big voice and is more talented than Jasmine Trias, yet I don’t think she’s going to last as long (Jasmine finished 3rd in season three). Plus, Jasmine had the whole state of Hawaii (plus pinays and pinoys on the mainland) voting for her. I heard they set up ad hoc phone in centers in Hawaii where volunteers would show up and continuously vote for her. I loved Ramiele’s ‘80s prom dress though. So I call on a bunch of Vietnamese doctors and Ramiele’s outfit and performance reminded me of a Vietnamese variety show singer. Don’t know how to explain it, but there you go. Randy said it was kinda pretty, but kinda pretty boring. Paula started by saying she looked lovely tonight, which is the kiss of death (KOD) from Paula. She then said she played it safe and was holding back. Simon was bored to tears and called it a dreary song choice. He went on to say it was forgettable and he expects better from her. My wife Kristin agrees. She’s holding back. If she holds back anymore, she’ll be off the show soon. I think she’ll be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. And regardless of if she goes or not, she’ll be in tears. That much is for sure.

04 – Jason Castro, If I Fell

With his long dreads, Jason looks androgynous. We find out that he’s a student at Texas A&M and declared a music minor last year, which happened to be the only class he failed. Also found out that he’s from Columbia. My wife Kristin said Renel Lewis (morning DJ on KISS-FM and stadium announcer for the Giants) thinks he looks like a young John Travolta. Look at the eyes, I can see that one. He plays the guitar for this one again. I liken him to this year’s Blake Lewis. Blake used to grab the song, put it on his computer, strip it down and build it back up. Jason grabs songs and totally folks it out. I’m really not a fan of his and can’t recognize brilliance when he delivers it. I think he’ll go far though because he’s very likable and the chicks dig him. Randy liked it, but didn’t love it. He didn’t like the switches in the melody. Paula disagreed, which I think she does sometimes (alright all the time) to get the crowd behind her, which is totally self-serving and she should be ashamed. She did say that he’s better off because he doesn’t have to do the riffs and runs that others depend on. Simon said last week was incredible, but tonight reminded him of a student in his bedroom at midnight. I can see that. Like the guitar guy in “Animal House” when John Belushi takes his guitar and smashes it. I Wikipedia-ed that song and it’s called “I Gave My Love A Cherry,” and it was sung in the movie by ‘70s singer/songwriter Stephen Bishop (who did, among other things, “It Might Be You” from the “Tootsie” soundtrack). I’m sure Jason is safe tomorrow night, but I don’t think he’s going to win it all.

05 – Carly Smithson, Come Together

Gee, Carly tells us she’s from Ireland. And did you know that when the Steelers won the Super Bowl that Jerome Bettis was from Detroit? We get it Carly. You’re Irish. You work at an Irish pub. I think Carly’s a phenomenal singer, but she just bugs the hell out of me. Maybe it’s because she’s Irish and not American. Maybe it’s her evil tattoo. Maybe it’s because she’s really a pro (she had a pretty good size contract until the studio that signed her went belly up). Maybe it’s because she sings with a “gotta go pee” posture. Although I think she is head and shoulders the #1 female talent left. Randy said she was strong and confident and had a stellar performance. Paula said it was like already watching a star (is that because Carly was a star before?). Simon said week after week she’s been choosing the wrong song … until now. He also compared her to Kelly Clarkson’s first week in the finals. That’s pretty good company. She’s safe tomorrow night and may be coasting to the final 4 or better.

06 – David Cook, Eleanor Rigby

We find out David was a bartender at a bar in Tulsa, OK where he sometimes performed with his band. I don’t know this song, but he rocked it. He looked a bit naked up there without his guitar though. Randy said (contrary to popular opinion) you can definitely rock out on Idol. Paula called him the darkhorse and added that he’s a thoroughbred. Simon called it brilliant and if it remains a contest of talent instead of popularity, David can win. I think he’s definitely safe this week and could be gaining on frontrunner David Archuleta. I don’t think David Cook will win, but he’s making a wonderful showing so far.

07 – Brooke White, Let It Be

Brooke is musically talented as she’s previously played the guitar on stage and now she plays the piano. I think it’s good that she plays instruments because she really can’t move while she’s singing. I’d say that she can’t walk and chew gum, but that doesn’t really make any sense because she’s singing while she’s playing an instrument. So I’ll just say I’m glad she’s playing an instrument. She played it straight tonight. No runs or riffs, which isn’t her strong point anyway. She’s got a real nice tone to her voice. She’s got a musical purity that is refreshing. She was totally overwhelmed in the moment tonight. I thought it was weird that she kept looking into the camera while she was singing, but my wife Kristin thought it was because she was trying to not lose it while she was singing. She was so emotional tonight like she was so taken aback that she was singing this song on that stage with that piano. Randy said it wasn’t her strongest, but it was a heartfelt performance. Paula said she found her niche. Simon called it one of the best of the night and it was a brilliant choice of song. He called it believable. I think Brooke’s bought herself some more time on this show. I may have to take back the comment that she’s just not the worst girl. She was definitely in the top 3 girls tonight.

08 – David Hernandez, I Saw Her Standing There

So he mentions that he’s a student at Arizona State and that he recently got fired from his job at a pizza bistro. So that’s what they’re calling gay strip bars now … pizza bistros? Remind me not to go to any of the pizza bistros in Tempe. David had an ‘80s look going on with the skinny tie and vest. I was trying to figure out the look and thought maybe The Stray Cats, but then I googled them and saw that Brian Setzer actually wore tank tops and neckerchiefs. So swing and a miss on that one. Maybe it was a Farmer Ted look from Sixteen Candles? Or Duckie from Pretty In Pink? Or maybe a Square Pegs look? Anyway, I hated this performance. I think David should go soon. If not this week, then soon. Randy said he has a big voice, but it was too overdone. Paula said she loves his voice but he overdid it with too many runs. Simon said no, no, no. It was corny and verging on desperate. Is this really last year’s Rudy Cardenas in disguise? I think David’s in the bottom 3 tomorrow.

09 – Amanda Overmyer, You Can’t Do That

Amanda reminds me of a glam rocker. Like David Lee Roth, especially with those black and white striped pants and scarves. The thing I like about Amanda is that she’s the anti-Idol, although she seemed to enjoy herself more tonight than in previous nights. She did pretty good with this song considering she’s never heard it before last week. I say last week because Asia’h Epperson was on Renel Lewis this morning (according to my wife Kristin) and Asia’h said that the contestants work on 3 songs a week (one for the current week, a group song and one for the following week). Asia’h said that the song she was working on for tonight was barely recognizable until she hit the chorus, so it may have been better she was voted off last week. Asia’h also thought she was at a disadvantage going first (which I totally agree with; when there are this many people still left, you can be forgotten very easily going first). And lastly, the contestants don’t know the singing order until they get to the studio for the show. Randy said something about a true mark of great songs and think it meant that even though Amanda rocked it out, she did well with it. Paula said something that I didn’t listen to. Simon said it wasn’t as good as last week, but that she’s a breath of fresh air to have in the competition. I think Amanda’s safe tomorrow.

10 – Michael Johns, Across The Universe

He’s a struggling musician so he’s done a number of jobs, like manual labor and coaching tennis. I wonder if there are tennis coaches for the Wii? My wife Kristin got me a Wii for my birthday/Christmas and we love it. We’ve been trying for awhile and just become “pros” in the Wii Sports tennis game. And we’re embarrassed to say that we have tennis elbow from it. And I just found out that people have been creating celebrity Miis (characters that you can create; most people make it look like themselves) and posting the instructions online. I found a site that has some and since my son is totally into Star Wars right now, we made Darth Vader, Anakin Skywalker, Chewbacca, The Emporer and we plan on making Darth Maul and either Queen Amidala or Princess Leia too! But they have President Bush, Michael Jackson and others too. People have too much time on their hands. Back to Michael Johns (the Aussie, which annoys me about him too, but less than Carly). He sang with the mike stand tonight which was less dancing which equals better for me since he’s not doing the hopping around. I think he’s got a pretty good voice, but then he did the “thank you” at the end of his performance again. As you know, that bugs me. Randy said it wasn’t his best performance. He could’ve taken some liberties with it and he called it sleepy. Paula disagreed again and said he has a quiet confidence. Simon said he should’ve done what Carly did. But what was funny was that he didn’t know her name. He asked (out loud) what the Irish girl’s name was! Way to serve up some humble pie Simon! I think Michael’s still safe tomorrow. He was in the middle tonight.

11 – Kristy Lee Cook, Eight Days A Week

Kristy tries to do a country version of this song. She looked good out there in her ripped jeans and sparkly top, but this song was a complete mess. It was too fast and reminded me of a bad county fair version. Like she was on tour with the One-ders in “That Thing You Do.” She still could’ve done a country version of this that wasn’t arranged the way it was tonight. Unless people were listening with their eyes instead of ears, she’s definitely in the bottom 2 tomorrow and probably gone. Randy said there were parts he liked but she tried to force the runs too much. Paula just came out and said she didn’t enjoy it (what happened to the, “you look great tonight”?!). She said that she took the advise too much to heart (I think Simon said country was her thing) and she just didn’t get it tonight. Simon called it horrendous, like Dolly Parton on helium. He said it was very brave, but a foolish thing to do. And I never put it together that her and rocker David have the same last name. Maybe because it’s the first night they’ve performed together. But I’m guessing they’re not related.

12 – David Archuleta, We Can Work It Out

Boy did David flop tonight. I think he got more nervous after listening to his pre-song video because he was talking about how he didn’t like older jazz music growing up (his mother is from Honduras and likes salsa dancing and his father is a Jazz musician, maybe Morman, as they live in Utah and there are like 4 or 5 kids in the family) and wasn’t too sure about picking a Beatles song. As it was, he did the Stevie Wonder version of it. I felt bad for David tonight because he did an upbeat song to Simon’s request (he faulted him for always singing ballads) and he forgot some of the words. Missing the words aside (and he did sort of let is show that he missed some of the words), he still did a decent job on the upbeat song. This bodes well for the next time he ventures into a faster song, as long as he’s comfortable with it and remembers the words! He knew it wasn’t his best and stood up there like he was in front of a firing squad. Randy said it wasn’t on point and it wasn’t his vibe. Paula said it wasn’t his best week (really?), but he’s still a frontrunner. But she also told him not to let it show on his face when he forgets the words. Simon called it a mess and that he expects greatness every week from here on out. I’m still a HUGE Archuleta fan. My wife Kristin voted for him tonight (multiple times) so that he won’t be voted off. He still is the frontrunner though. Hopefully his odds go down on sportsbook.com because he was 2-3 to win it all today, which means you have to bet $30 to win $20.

Bottom 3 – David Hernandez, Kristy Lee Cook, Syesha/Ramiele

Top 3 – Chikezie, David Cook, Brooke

And on a final note (sorry this is so long by the way), I’ll be out the next two weeks (my national sales meeting in Vegas next week, followed by a trip to Disneyland for Jared’s spring break). But, as you know, you’ll be in good hands, Mike Rico has agreed to recap for the next two weeks. Thanks Mike.

Wednesday, March 05, 2008

AI7 recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 8 (03/05)

So it’s ‘80s night for the women tonight. But first a few comments on last night. Jim Rutter can’t believe I missed the “he had me at hello” line for David Cook. I guess I went down looking with the bat on my shoulder on that one. And he also reminds me that I need to note when Simon says, “lll-uved it,” and not “loved it,” since it’s ultra fem when he utters that line. And lastly he thought David Cook is destined to make an album of rocked up ‘80s covers. But the sad part is, I’d probably be first in line to buy that!

01 – Asia’h Epperson, I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Whitney Houston)

How bad was this outfit Asia’h was wearing? Pink top and lavender pants? Those pants reminded me of the saddle pants the girls used to wear in the ‘80s. The ones that showed the camel toe, er, moose knuckle, er, forget it TMTH. I’ve said too much… I thought Asia’h didn’t really change this up much, but there’s always that Whitney quandary. Her songs are sung so distinctly by her that it’s hard to change it up. And if you sing it the same, you won’t sing it better. It’s only been 7 years. You’d think the kids would realize that by now. The funny thing about Whitney is that I saw a clip of a concert of hers once and I think she was singing one of her numerous ballads, but she changed it up. In a subsequent interview she said that she liked doing that (changing it up) because it gave the public a different way to hear the song. Maybe it was a way she’d have preferred to sing it, but the producers had her sing it a different way. So it got me to thinking. How can you make a song that you already own, your own? Randy dropped the obligatory “I recorded that song” and said it was a tall order, but that it was hot. Paula said she nailed it. Simon was not so enthusiastic. Called it a 2nd rate Whitney, but she is good enough for the top 12. We’ll see. I like Asia’h because she’s got a great story (her father passed away right before her audition) and she’s fun. She should be safe tomorrow night.

02 – Kady Malloy, Who Wants To Live Forever (Queen)

Katherine McPhee sang this two years ago on Queen night. How can I even start to compare Kady to Katherine? So I won’t. As you probably know (or remember since I talked in depth about this a few years ago), this song was from the movie “Highlander.” If you’ve never seen that movie, do yourself a favor and put it in your Netflix queue (am I being presumptuous in that you all are Netflix members?). It’s a little gory (we’re talking swordsmen and only dying if your head gets cut off), but a good movie. Kady did the “thank you” to the studio audience when she finished her song. I love it (not) when the contestants do that. Paris Bennett was infamous for that. Although hers was more of a “then kew.” Randy called it an interesting song choice and that she hit the big notes well (but not the softer ones). Paula called it her best performance and disagreed with Randy (how shocking!) by saying she has magic in her tender notes. Simon called it better than last week but she has a massive lack of personality. And I can see what he’s saying. They called her a Stepford Wife, but I think she’s more like an Austin Powers fembot. I think Kady is vulnerable tomorrow and will most likely be one of the two off.

03 – Amanda Overmyer, I Hate Myself For Loving You (Joan Jett)

My wife Kristin thought this was a good song for her. She was much better than last week. But she’s shown her hand already. I really don’t expect anything different from her than I’ve already seen so far. She has the same stage presence (which kind of reminds me of Bo Bice from a few years back) and sings everything the same. Her fiancé and brother were there tonight. I wish her mom was back. Amanda’s actually kinda pretty (she inherited much of her mother’s features), but she’s like that/those Goth chick(s) in high school. They may have been good looking, but it was hard to tell under all that mascara, makeup and black clothing. Randy said that’s the Amanda we like and love. He always mentions the bluesy rocker. Paula called her face beautiful and that she’s found her niche. Like she didn’t know her niche before, Paula? Simon thought it was fantastic and that she absolutely nailed it. Seacrest asked why she doesn’t smile or even looked down during the compliments and I think her reason is that she’s genuinely embarrassed to be on this show. She’s a rocker that’s sort of selling out to be on this pop show. But if this is the means to an end (record deal), then she can put up with it. I think she’s safe tomorrow, but will have to keep producing to avoid an early exit from the final 12.

04 – Carly Smithson, I Drove All Night (Cyndi Lauper)

So this was a Cyndi Lauper song (1989), but Celine Dion (arguably) made it more popular. This song was originally penned for Roy Orbison, but his version wasn’t released until 1992, three years after Lauper’s and four years after his death (thanks Wikipedia). Carly looks a lot better with makeup and styled hair. I still don’t love her, but she really can sing. Her performance was acceptable for me tonight. Randy loved it and called it another great performance. Paula called her a dependable dog. What happened to her pocket references? Simon is continually tough on Carly saying she didn’t choose the right song, which my wife Kristin agrees with. This was a copycat Celine Dion performance. She really does need to pick a song where she can showcase her voice because it is one of the strongest of the competitors. Carly is safe tomorrow and I think she will last a long time in the finals. And it still does bug me that she’s not American. Like the illegal aliens winning the lottery. Where’s the justice?

05 – Kristy Lee Cook, Faithfully (Journey)

I love Journey. My first favorite song ever was “Don’t Stop Believin’.” They had an Atari 2600 video game about Journey, although I don’t remember Randy being in the video game. The graphics weren’t that good back then, but I don’t remember a fat brotha being in it. This song has one of those “’80s Lyric Quiz” lines in it. “They say that the road ain’t no place to start a family…” Why not have a Journey night on AI? Can’t Randy pull some strings to make that happen? Anyway, Kristy put a country twang to this, but has anyone else noticed her super red tongue? My wife Kristin always points this out. Does she suck on a lollipop before going out there? Randy called it a great song. Paula said it would be a hit for her in country music. Simon called her forgettable. Kristy’s a pretty girl, but I think she’s in the bottom 3 tomorrow and possibly gone.

06 – Ramiele Malubay, Against All Odds (Phil Collins)

Ramiele is funny because she totally dresses ‘80s in real life. Her haircut, clothes, etc. Not that I mind. I love the ‘80s. It’s my high school’s 20th class reunion this year and I’ve gone back to gel in my hair to prepare for it. I used to use a ton of Dep back in the day and now I’m using L.A. Looks. Is that bad for the ozone? But my hair never moves. I was using the Aussie spray gel but when my hair was getting longer it was wearing out by lunch. I know you all needed to know this. So you’re welcome. Ramiele really made this arrangement different. I didn’t love it, but she really has a big voice. I realize her being tiny accentuates this, but I like her nonetheless. And this song is funny as I always used to think the name of it was “Take A Look At Me Now.” Randy called it another big song and that she had a pretty good vocal, but she needs to just go for it. Paula said she has an innocent, pure voice. Simon called it very old fashioned and predictable. I think she’s safe tomorrow and Seacrest will rig it for her to stay on because she makes him feel tall.

07 – Brooke White, Love Is A Battlefield (Pat Benetar)

Everytime she sings she’s sitting down. Whether it be last week playing the guitar or this week sitting on the edge of the stage. And every time that happens, my wife Kristin says, “Joe lies” like in “Say Anything…” It makes me laugh every time. Because this is totally a Lili Taylor type song. I felt like I was at a coffeehouse and that there was a poet coming up to the stage next. Like in “She’s All That” when Rachel Leigh Cook took Freddie Prinze, Jr to that performance. Or like in “So I Married An Axe Murderer” when Mike Myers is doing his poetry. Have you seen “So I Married An Axe Murderer?” If not, add it to your Netflix queue after “Highlander.” Mike Myers isn’t way over the top in it and it has a pretty good soundtrack. Randy liked that Brooke sang it with only a guitar accompanying her. Paula called it a very wise choice, but wished she would’ve used the band more. Simon thought it worked purely without the band. My wife Kristin thinks she has a very nice tone to her voice. The USA Today guy thought this was the best performance of the night. I think Brooke is an okay singer (and she changed this song up well tonight), but I really think it’s just that she’s not the worst so far. The gals are weaker than the guys and she’s struggling to keep her head above water. I think she’s safe tomorrow but will be one of the first ones to go in the finals.

08 – Syesha Mercado, Saving All My Love For You (Whitney Houston)

I like Syesha, but can’t someone tell her that you can’t out-Whitney, Whitney? This song was clearly too big for her and it was a 2nd rate Whitney performance. She didn’t change it much. But she looked cute in her shorts suit. Almost like she was on “America’s Next Top Model.” They were pressed for time so Randy called it good. Paula called it sophisticated and Simon called it a bit predictable but good. I think this was the first song that I heard of Whitney’s. Her first album (with this on it, along with “You Give Good Love,” “How Will I Know,” “Greatest Love Of All” and “All At Once”) was unbelievable, especially for a debut album. Anyway, I think Syesha is safe tomorrow and is one of the frontrunners for the girls (along with Carly, Asia’h and Ramiele).

Bottom 2 – Kady, Kristy

Top 2 – Carly, Brooke

Tuesday, March 04, 2008

AI7 recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 8 (03/04)

THIS … is YOUR AI recap. How annoying is Ryan Seacrest? So it’s ‘80s week this week (playing after the ‘60s and ‘70s weeks). I LOVE ‘80s music, but it really wasn’t known for great vocals (which is the strength of this competition). It was more about the show, the synthesizers, the outfits, the alternative stuff, etc. Don’t really know how tonight will turn out. It’s all about song choice tonight.

And the contestants tell us about their embarrassing moment, which I’ll spare all of you because they were all lame.

01 – Luke Menard, Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go (Wham!)

Funny, I always thought the words went, “wake me up before you go GIRL.” Did I really like Wham! back in the day? Careless Whisper was okay, Freedom was pretty good (especially with that video shot in China after they opened it up to the world). Luke kinda looked like George Michael with the stubbly beard. Anyway, Luke sang this in usual falsetto. I think he’s one of the weakest of the guys remaining. Randy said it started off pitchy, but he kinda got it together at the end and it was a little corny. Paula drops the “I choreographed the George Michael tour” bomb, a la Randy. Simon didn’t like it and called it a bit girlie. He most certainly will be in the bottom 2 on Thursday and should be off the show.

02 – David Archuleta, Another Day in Paradise (Phil Collins)

David starts off playing the piano (which he only plays for about 20 seconds; nice set change!) then abandons it for the second verse. I think my wife’s only complaint about him is that he breathes loudly. But the thing we love about this kid is his honesty. And his pure, unadulterated adolescence. This may not be his best performance, but it’s still better than almost all of the other performances by the others. Randy thought it was good. Paula said even though he was imperfect, he was still perfect. Simon said it wasn’t as good as last week and he needs to lighten up a little. He thought the song was a bit depressing, but David said, very honestly, that he liked the message of the song. This kid is the real deal. He should win it all, but even if he doesn’t, he’s a winner. He’ll make it big. Obviously he’s safe on Thursday.

03 – Danny Noriega, Tainted Love (Soft Cell)

I think this song is on EVERY “Greatest Hits of the ‘80s” disc. Almost so much so that I cringe every time I hear it. Way different arrangement, but it was, according to the USA Today guy, “overly showy and flamboyant.” Yup. This kid actually has a pretty good voice, but his showmanship (or lack thereof) gets in the way of it. When I saw his jacket though, I thought he was going to do “Billie Jean” or “Bad.” Randy thought it started rough but liked what he did with it at the end. And praised his “mad attitude.” Paula called him a bright light in the competition. She also called him “sensitive” and “spicy.” What she should have said was, “call 911 because you’re on fire!” Simon thought it was horrible, absolutely useless and hated the arrangement. Danny gave him the single antler back, which was priceless. He should be in the bottom 3 and maybe bottom 2 on Thursday but somehow I think he stays. Votefortheworst.com has him as its poster boy and those votes go a long way this early in the competition. Look how far it took Sanjaya last year…

04 – David Hernandez, It’s All Coming Back To Me Now (Meat Loaf)

So if you hadn’t heard the 411 on David, it’s been circulating on votefortheworst.com, but finally AP did a story on him today. Supposedly he’s been working as a stripper in a gay bar in Phoenix. It will be interesting to see if American Idol acknowledges this or disqualifies him. They let Frenchie go because of an affiliation with an adult website but they did let Antonella Barba get voted off after some racy pictures surfaced of her on the Internet. And they did drop Ebony from last year because of her work on a lingerie football game. So we’ll see. My wife Kristin thought he was really pitchy through the song tonight (and that he has vampire teeth). Maybe his performance will be his undoing and then AI won’t have to do anything. Or maybe they just rig it and let him go as if he was in the bottom 2. This song is funny because most people know it as the Celine Dion song, but she sang it in 1996. This was actually from Meat Loaf. I had no idea who Celine Dion was until she did that duet with Clive Griffin on the “Sleepless in Seattle” soundtrack (When I Fall In Love). Then she became this megastar who had her own show in Vegas. Kristin and I actually saw her in concert at the United Center (yes, I’m admitting I went to a Celine Dion concert; but that’s not my funniest concert experience. Ask me about The Jets concert sometime…) and she’s actually very manly in her movements. She had a great opening act of a guy who did musical impersonations. Think a French Danny Ganz. Back to David. He belted out some notes, which usually draws a reaction from the audience, but some singers do that for effect and it usually makes them feel like they have a better performance than they really did. Was that totally confusing? Randy called it a nice song choice, but he had some pitch problems. Paula said he has some of the best vocals of the group. Simon said it wasn’t as good as last week, but he’s 100% secured a spot in the finals (top 12). Maybe. I think he could be in the bottom 4 tomorrow because it’s pretty tough right now. Everyone is pretty talented.

05 – Michael Johns, Don’t You Forget About Me (Simple Minds)

So, this guy is kinda bugging me now. He seems a bit out of his skin up there with no band. He dances like a guy who can’t dance and does that effeminate hop. It’s painful to watch actually. I think it wouldn’t be as pronounced if he had a band on the stage with him, but when he’s up there alone, it’s weird. He really didn’t do much with the song. But I think the brain, the princess, the jock, the criminal and the basketcase liked it. There have always been rumors of a sequel to the Breakfast Club, but nothing’s ever materialized. Much like Fletch Lives. They might as well make sequels to all the ‘80s teen angst movies. With the same casts. Those are movies I’d find time to watch. Randy mistakenly thought this was an INXS song, as he said Michael “went home for ‘80s week” and compared him to the late Michael Hutchence. Paula said this song defined who he is and Michael has a strength in the low range. Simon liked it, but didn’t love it. He compared him to Carly, in that he’s a good singer but hasn’t found the song to push him over the top yet. The ladies love the Aussie, so he should be safe on Thursday.

06 – David Cook, Hello (Lionel Richie)

Okay, I’ve done a 360 on David now. I like him again. I really liked this version of “Hello.” “Hello” reminds me of 8th grade dances in garages, where all they played were slow songs. This song was good back then, but what I really remember was that cool music video of the song. My wife Kristin thinks David’s got a Daughtry vibe to him. He’s much more the true rocker than Robbie Carrico ever would dream to be. Randy called it a slightly evil rendition of the extremely pop version. Paula said that she is always in for a surprise when he takes the stage. Simon called it a very brave thing to do, but he loved it. It was unpredictable and it worked. I couldn’t agree more. David should cruise into the top 12 and should make it to the top 5 or 6.

07 – Jason Castro, Hallelujah (Leonard Cohen)

I didn’t know this song (I wondered if it was a Queen song) but I think he did a pretty good job with it. Jason’s definitely a unique talent. I think it bugs me a bit because he looks like a girl with his pretty eyes and long hair. And he makes some funky faces when he sings. Overall I know the chicks dig him and he’ll be safe on Thursday. Randy said it was a great degree of difficulty and gave him props for it. Paula said he made it sound effortless and his phrasing makes him great. Simon called it absolutely brilliant and that he keeps getting better and better and better. I still haven’t heard a performance that I totally loved of Jason’s and still think he pales in comparison to David Archuleta. But Jason will 100% be safe on Thursday.

08 – Chikezie, All The Woman I Need (Luther Vandross)

My buddy Leroy says Chikezie looks like a dead ringer for former Buckeye running back and current criminal, Maurice Clarett. I think Chikezie raids the Boyz II Men closet every week, as he was in motownphilly mode tonight. This was a Luther song, but I mostly remember it as a Whitney song (circa 1990). Randy said it was an interesting song choice but he did a good job with it. Paula said the vocals sounded good tonight (for all the boys). Simon called it more cabaret than last week. I think he’s still pretty good. He may be on the bubble on Thursday. But he should be in the final 12.

Bottom three – Luke, Danny, David Hernandez

Top three – David Cook, David Archuleta, Jason Castro