Wednesday, March 29, 2006

AIV recap, Finalists x 10 (03/28)

Whew, finally only an hour. But we had my buddy Stuart over for dinner tonight, so this one may be brief, as I’m getting a late start on the recap.

Tonight they’re singing songs of the 21st century. And I’m also putting their odds to win, according to Sportsbook.com.

01 – Lisa, Because Of You (Kelly Clarkson) 15-1
Interesting. Singing a song of a former American Idol contestant. It’s like in the movie Scream 3 where they are making a movie of the events that happened in the first Scream. Very convoluted, to say the least. Stu said she looks like a young Toni Braxton. Anyone remember when Jason Kidd was a rookie and the Dallas Mavericks had the Triple J Ranch, made up of Jason, Jamal Mashburn and Jimmy Jackson? Supposedly Toni Braxton came between Jason and Jimmy and Jason gave the Mavs an ultimatum, him or me. In 96-97, the Mavs got rid of both of them, Jim to the Nets and Jason to the Suns. Randy thought Lisa’s version of the song was okay, but really not that good. Paula said that if she was going to sing such a current song, she should’ve given it a twist. Simon said the song was too big for her voice and parts of it were painful. It’s unfortunate because Lisa is a very good singer, but she hasn’t found any songs that 1) show off her voice or 2) endear you to her. It’s a shame because she is so talented but probably won’t last much longer. She may be gone tomorrow night. She’ll be in the bottom 3 for sure. All of the criticism and stress being in the bottom 3 seems to be getting to her too. I honestly think that if she’s not going to win, she should get voted off sooner rather than later for her well being.

02 – Kellie, Suds In The Bucket (Sara Evans) 8-1
Fun song. Kinda boring though. Kellie wore a cute pink bustier/camisole thingy. She had a little trouble with the low notes (see, my wife is back to help me!). One positive was there was a Kristy Swanson sighting. What happened to Kristy Swanson? I thought she’d make it kinda big after her Buffy the Vampire Slayer role, but never really did. She did The Program and Higher Learning, but then has clearly been in lesser roles in other movies (Dude, Where’s My Car? And Big Daddy). Although the Big Daddy role was hilarious, especially when she dumps Adam Sandler for the old guy. She claims that the guy has a five year plan. Sandler retorts, what is it? Don’t die? Ah, funny stuff. Randy liked Kellie going back to her country roots but didn’t think the song was exciting enough for her voice. Paula said she was way better than that song choice. Simon called it a gimmicky, rodeo, lasso song. She has not been too strong as of late, but I still think that she has a pretty strong fan base. I don’t think Kellie will win, but I do think that her personality will keep her in the competition longer than just her vocals would.

03 – Ace, Drops Of Jupiter (Train) 12-1
Smoldering. Ace does have that bad habit of emoting some of the lyrics literally, like when he pointed to his scar during that line in the song. And the stare into the camera is beginning to bug me. It’s like he’s trying to peer hard to see one of those 3D pictures. Although I wouldn’t know because I can’t see those things. I’ve tried and tried and tried and I just can’t. Randy said he didn’t sing it very well and that the song lacked a soul vibe (like ‘NSync). Paula asked about the scar and said that one day he’ll have to tell her about it. That comment sparked some snickering by Randy and Simon because they were obviously referring to her alleged affair with Corey Clark from a few years back. Simon said it wasn’t that great of a vocal and seemed quite karaoke. Ace is really falling in my book. Kinda like how Anwar fell off for me last year. Both made a big splash, then ended in a whimper. Did you hear that sound? That was all the people jumping off Ace’s bandwagon…

04 – Taylor, Trouble (Ray LaMontagne) 5-1
No suit tonight. And no dancing. Taylor wore a leather jacket, print tee and jeans. I think I like the old Taylor who “suits up” like Barney (Neil Patrick Harris/Doogie Howser) on “How I Met Your Mother.” My wife (did I mention she’s back?) enjoyed the song. I was excited because in the midst of a George Huff sighting, there was an Amanda Avila sighting! They put George Huff’s name under him, but how could they leave her out. I know she wasn’t exactly a finalist last year, but this is Amanda Avila we’re talking about. Randy said it wasn’t a great song and he didn’t get to show off (I think he was talking about his dancing). Paula said it was nice to see him just stand behind a mike and sing. Simon said he liked the song and the vocals were excellent. But his outfit was very Clay Aiken. Like it was out of a pop school. Remember when Clay wore that red leather jacket a few years back? This wasn’t as bad, but I think Taylor needs to go back to his suits. He should be fine tomorrow night. The Soul Patrol should live to sing another day.

05 – Mandisa, Wanna Praise You (Mary Mary) 11-2
Did you catch that she was “wearing” a beanie in her back pocket, a la Ace? I thought there was something missing tonight. Either the song was too fast or she was too loud for the band or she was pitchy. I didn’t enjoy it one bit. Randy didn’t understand the song choice. Paula called it a new religion and there were 40 million people joining the Church of Mandisa. How clever. Not. Simon called it a bit indulgent. I wasn’t feeling her tonight at all. She should be safe tomorrow, but I wouldn’t be surprised to see her in the bottom 3.

06 – Chris, What If (Creed) 8-5
In the pre-song interview Ryan clarified that last week Chris’ “I Walk The Line” was actually inspired by the group Live. See this link (http://tv.yahoo.com/news/ap/20060324/114324156000.html). Chris kinda backpedaled and said, yes, it was Live’s version done differently. This really bugged me about Chris. I think it’s because I was impressed at how he changed the song up last week. But I was impressed because he gave no indication that it was “inspired” by another version. Chris knew he was doing Live’s version. I think that he should’ve given them credit in his vignette with Barry or when he was accepting the praise from the judges. To admit it after the fact and after he had been called out on the Internet really chaps my hide. I was just about to become a fan of Chris’ then this happens. Fool me once Chris, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. He looked rather angry during this song. He did wear the tan leather Monday Night Football jacket though. Kristin thinks he has such a narrow range for his songs though and can’t see herself listening to a whole CD of his. Randy liked the song choice, although he pointed out that he was sharp for most of the song. Paula said something, but I tuned her out. Simon called it indulgent and that Creed would not be seen dead on this show. He went on to further contradict himself by saying he can’t keep doing this week after week. This was after praising him last week for being the only contestant to never compromise who he is. I think Chris needs to keep doing the rock thing. If he changes it up, he risks his integrity for not compromising and also he risks a bad performance doing something he may not be comfortable with. I say keep doing what you’re doing, but give credit where credit is due. He will not be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. Guaranteed.

07 – Katharine, The Voice Within (Christina Aguilera) 3-1
When my wife first saw what she was wearing, she said she looked like a superhero. I almost woke the kids up because I was laughing so hard. Katharine really doesn’t dress that well, but I like her best anyway. Randy said it was a good song choice, but she sang it just like the record. Paula said she was at her best and Christina would feel honored. Simon called her the best tonight (but that wasn’t too hard at this point) and that it was almost as good as Christina. I think Katharine will be safe tomorrow night.

08 – Bucky, Real Good Man (Tim McGraw) 60-1
The odds say Bucky’s next to leave. He did dress very country tonight. And he did a little “right leg shimmy while dragging the left leg” move. Is that the country version of the “holding your leg and jumping over it with the other leg” hip hop thing? Randy liked his country better than his last 2 week’s efforts. Paula said he needs to be careful with his diction. Simon agreed because he couldn’t understand a word he said during the song. He said if it was a paid concert, he’d have left. Again, Bucky seems like a nice guy, but he needs to go. It’s guaranteed that he’s in the bottom 2 and should be gone tomorrow night.

09 – Paris, Work It Out (Beyonce) 12-1
She may be a good bet at 12-1. I had a bad Janay Castine flashback from last year when she did Buck Wild by Mary J. Blige. It’s a good thing Paris didn’t have the Parkinson’s shakes that Janay had. Paris’ outfit was a little reminiscent of some ‘80s groups like Salt ‘N Pepa or TLC. Medallion earrings and a medallion on the end of a necklace that would make Flavor Flav proud. Randy called her fearless and it was the best performance of the night. Paula said those weren’t kid moves up there and that she may get a call from the Pussycat Dolls for an audition. Simon called it precocious and it looked like a little girl trying to be Beyonce. Paris has an amazing voice, but Simon’s critique is consistent of what I’ve thought of her all along. Listen. Paris doesn’t need this competition. As a matter of fact, if she doesn’t win and gets to go to any label she wants, it may suit her better.

10 – Elliott, I Don’t Want To Be (Gavin DeGraw) 15-1
First off, I love this song. It’s the theme song to “One Tree Hill,” one of my favorite shows. He totally did a different arrangement, which was refreshing. I still like the original version, but he jazzed it up a bit and it worked for me. For this competition. He still looked like Eminem with his military coat over his hoodie though. And he is probably a worse offender than Ace in acting out his lyrics, especially when it comes to “seeing” something in the song. This one was his hand over his eyes as he was “tired of looking around.” Randy said this boy can sing. Paula loved the arrangement and called him “one funky white boy.” Simon chimed in with great song, terrible arrangement, good vocal, hideous dancing. I didn’t mind the dancing. I don’t think Elliott will win, but he is so needed in this competition. Just kidding, that’s just what Paula says all the time. Elliott should be safe tomorrow night.

That’s it for tonight. Not a particularly strong night. It’ll be interesting to see who is in the bottom 3 with Bucky and Lisa. Maybe Kellie? Maybe Mandisa? Maybe Ace?

Lastly, the reason that Kevin Covais lasted so long is the following website (http://www.votefortheworst.com/). They “champion” the contestant who they think is the worst and encourage people to vote for them. Now that Kevin’s gone, they’re pushing Kellie Pickler. I’d think they’d pick Bucky, but I don’t run the website…

Wednesday, March 22, 2006

AIV recap, Finalists x 11 (03/21)

Another two hours. It’s killing me. A few quick notes before I get to the singers. The Reality channel (yes, they actually have a channel devoted to Reality TV now) is running American Idol Extra and last week was the first show. They interview the person voted off and they have ex-AIers doing work. Matt Rogers does interviews and he is awesome. He has found his niche. He is full of personality and wit. He interviewed some of the celebrities who were at the show and one was Tori Spelling. He asked her “who her horse” was, and I thought this was kind of amusing because I’ve always said that Tori Spelling has a horse face. Mikaela also did a bit. She wasn’t too annoying and is very comfortable in front of the camera.

They also gave a “what are they doing now” feature on former Idols and we found out that Kimberly Locke is a model for Lane Bryant, Justin Guarini just released a jazz album, Josh Gracin is touring and Amy Adams has a part in Joseph and His Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat. I didn’t really enjoy the interview part with Melissa McGhee, so I fast forwarded through most of her stuff. It’s an hour show and it really could be 30 minutes.

Also, last night I Googled my name. Have you ever done that? It’s kinda fun. You should try it. Not many links directly to me, but I did find out that URA is a common abbreviation for “you are a,” as in URA moron. Or URA funny guy. Or worse. Most of the matches were to myspace pages. And URA also stands for Undergraduate Research Assistant.

Okay, getting into tonight, I just have to let you know that I’m flying without a net tonight. My wife is traveling for business (but she’s in Hawaii, so don’t be too sad for her), so she’s not here to spellcheck, nor be my ears or veto some material. It’s pretty funny that I write these things because I don’t know music. I don’t know notes or meters or in pitch or out of pitch. I don’t know octaves from a cappellas. If I can tell that you’re out of tune, that means you’re bad. Real bad. So, it may be crass, my grammar may be bad (I can never get the its or it’s thing right) and my hearing may be off. But the bottom line is, I miss my wife.

Tonight the songs are from the ‘50s and Barry Manilow is the guest song coach. They flew the kids to Las Vegas (where he is doing a show) to work with him. He has a Greatest Songs of the Fifties out right now (my mom just got it), so he’s a perfect accompaniment to this week. Barry cropped his ‘do a bit now and he looks like Siegfried. Or is it Roy? I wish he still had his ‘70s hair. I think he’d still be able to pull it off today. And Barry was amazing as the coach. His insights were great and his knowledge of music and performing was cool.

01 – Mandisa, I Don’t Hurt Anymore (Dinah Washington)
Barry told her that he can come work with him if this doesn’t work out for her. That’s a pretty good compliment. She curled her hair tonight and looked a bit like Patti LaBelle. Did a good job with the song and had a BIG ending. Randy said he was speechless and it was a classy way to start the night. Paula said it took her back to the ‘50s and called her a thoroughbred. Simon said she was blossoming. Called it a sexy performance and that he loved it.

02 – Bucky Covington, Oh Boy (Buddy Holly)
I think Bucky is a nice guy, but I really can’t understand him half the time when he’s singing. I thought it was a boring, uninspired performance. Randy said his mic technique was good and it was a good choice of songs. Paula said he had fun on stage. Simon called it nothing more than a pointless karaoke version of the song. A “so what” performance. I have to agree. At this point in the competition, just having fun is not going to cut it. I think Bucky is in the bottom 2 tomorrow night and may be gone.

03 – Paris Bennett, Fever (Peggy Lee)
Barry called the depth and power in her voice shocking. She has a big voice but the song was a bit too subdued for my taste. I think she looked very classy tonight though, with her yellow dress and hairdo. Randy said she blew it out of the box. Paula called her phenomenal, her vocals were impeccable and she dressed the part. Simon called her voice perfect for that kind of song. I think Paris is a very talented singer, but I don’t think that she is going to win. And she will feel disrespected when she loses. I think she still gets a record deal out of this though. I mean with her connections, how does she not have a record deal right now anyway?

04 – Chris Daughtry, I Walk The Line (Johnny Cash)
Barry said that he has a good handle on who he is. Came out in all black, a la Johnny Cash. I haven’t been the biggest fan of Chris, but I thought this performance rocked. I thought he had great control of his voice and really did a great job. I don’t know Johnny Cash that well (I still need to see “Walk the Line”) but I did hear something about him consistently singing a key too low. But that was how he did it. Randy called it a great alternative version. Paula called him so true to who he is and that he should already be touring. Simon called his performance and enormous difference. Completely opposite of Bucky. And that he’s the one person who has refused to compromise who he is to suit the genre. I think Chris, vocally and talentwise, should win this competition, but I don’t think he will. I think he may be the most successful of all the competitors once this is all said and done, but I don’t think he’ll win. He may come in second, which may actually be better for him, because then he can sign with whatever record company he wants. Whatever happens, he’ll make it. And I’ll be happy for him.

05 – Katharine McPhee, Come Rain or Come Shine (Ella Fitzgerald)
Get me some Tylenol because I’ve got a McPheever! She looked a bit like Sandra Bullock tonight. My mom said she looked like Jaclyn Smith with Sally Field’s smile. I’ve seen her followers referred to as The Kat Pack and their symbol for her looks like this “=^.^=” Very clever. Did a wonderful job with this song. And had a strut going during the song. I just love her personality. She’s kooky at times and very genuine with her emotions up on stage. I really think that she’s the favorite to win. She’s got a spot on voice and she seems to have a huge following. The applause after her song was done was deafening and prolonged. Randy said wow and said she has her own dawg pound (but to be correct, it would be a Kat Pack). He said she had a tough song but she worked it out. It’s funny how singers get praised for singing hard songs and how they get bashed for doing simple 4 chord songs (see Ayla’s last performance). It’s almost like a gymnastics or diving competition where you get more points for the level of difficulty. Paula said they all love her and only she could pull off a song like that. Simon said tonight she turned into a star. Her popularity parallels Kelly Clarkson’s at the same point in the competition.

06 – Taylor Hicks, Not Fade Away (Buddy Holly)
My man Taylor rocked the powder blue suit with white sneakers tonight. He looked like the guy who decided to go to the prom at the last second and this was the only tux that was left. The only thing missing was the ruffles on his shirt. But I’m not capping on Taylor. I love me some Taylor Hicks. Although my manager’s former manager thinks he’s destined to be playing in Branson someday. Not that that is a bad thing. They come by the busload to Branson every day. He danced tonight, but he didn’t do the crazy 360 turns like last week. I call that the “Turning Man” in the same vein as the “Running Man.” Randy said he was having a blast. The song wasn’t challenging vocally, but he worked it out. Paula said they should tape him and make an exercise video out of his performances. Simon called it a complete mess. I don’t think it was a mess. Taylor’s been better, but I think he’s got a pretty solid following. I expect him to make it to the final four, if not farther.

07 – Lisa Tucker, Why Do Fools Fall In Love? (Frankie Lymon & the Teenagers)
First off, I feel real bad for Lisa. I can’t believe she was in the bottom 2 last week. But my wife thinks it’s because she has no following. She’s from Anaheim. Not from some small town where EVERYONE in the student body is voting maniacally for her (see John Stevens). Or from a state where people are manning phone in stations to vote for her (see Jasmine Trias, who by the way, was at the show tonight). I think that she is very talented, but I think she’s going to go away sooner rather than later. She did look like the Mexican or Italian flag tonight with her green top, red shirt and white shorts. My mom called her a young Natalie Cole (now do you see where I get my look-a-like talents?). Randy called it a good song choice, but it wasn’t the dopest (that probably isn’t a word, but I spelled it the best I could). Paula was glad she went back to her youthfulness. Simon called it okay, but said he felt like he was trapped in a high school musical. Which is a funny comment because there is a Disney original movie out right now called “High School Musical.” We taped it for Jared and he loves it. He can even sing along with some of the songs. It’s kinda like a modern version of Grease. If you have kids that like music, they’ll like this one. Anyway, Lisa will probably be in the bottom 3 tomorrow night. Unfortunately.

08 – Kevin Covais, When I Fall In Love (Nat King Cole)
I’m getting pretty annoyed with the fact that Kevin is still on this show, but I won’t be completely out of my mind until Bucky is off. Then for every time Kevin stays and someone else is voted off, my level of hatred will grow. Exponentially. He sang the song in an “aw shucks” manner, singing with his right hand in his pocket the whole time. He very well could’ve been singing an Alanis Morrisette song (“Hand In My Pocket,” get it?). His performance really reminded me of a Broadway musical. Like he was walking in the park, then just broke into song. Needless to say, this was not an Idol-winning performance. But he has a huge following and will be back next week. Randy said he did a pretty good job. Paula said he has more moxie (interpretation, he sucks, but he has the guts to come out every week and suck in front of millions of people) than a lot of people. Simon said it wasn’t the best version of the song he’s ever heard, but that his audience will love it. Kevin’s a nice kid, but he needs to go. Like yesterday.

09 – Elliott Yamin, Teach Me Tonight (Al Jarreau)
I loved Al Jarreau’s Moonlighting theme song. Anyway, Elliott rocked the untucked shirt and tie tonight like he was in Boyz II Men. And he added a goatee that made him look a bit like D.B. Sweeney. You know, the guy who played Shoeless Joe Jackson in Eight Men Out and the guy in The Cutting Edge (the ice skating movie with Moira Kelly). And there was a Lindsey Cardinale sighting. Did they bring back all of the former Idols? I wouldn’t mind seeing Ryan Starr again. Randy said this was the hardest song to sing with all of the chord changes and that he worked it out (again the level of difficulty thing). Paula said it gave her goose bumps. Simon called it fantastic. I think that Elliott is at his best doing the chord changes. I have a feeling he’ll be around for a little while longer but Kevin may last longer. Which would be a shame.

10 – Kellie Pickler, Walkin’ After Midnight (Patsy Cline)
Barry kept telling her that she needs to sing the song like the words mean something. I like Kellie, but after the intro, I don’t think she accomplished it. I don’t think she got the mood of the song. It was too upbeat and not desperate enough. If she was in the studio, they’d have her keep doing it over and over again because this did not capture the essence of the lyrics. That being said, I like Kellie and think that her personality will take her farther than her vocals should. Randy called it a great song choice and that her country pop performance was back. Paula said she wasn’t a minx, but rather a tigress (huh?). Simon said she was great and welcome back (from last week’s debacle). She should be safe tomorrow night.

11 – Ace Young, In The Still Of The Night (The Five Satins)
Jazzy rendition of this standard. Ace got a little dressy tonight, as he wore a button down shirt instead of a t-shirt. I liked it. And he had a nice falsetto at the end. But it’s funny because when they do the recap with the phone numbers at the end of the show, it video they show is from the dress rehearsal and not the live competition. I know this because Ace ended his song with his arms outstretched tonight, but in the recap he was grabbing the mic. And Katharine’s dress was way more revealing in the recap than in her live performance. Randy said that Ace is back and he enjoyed the fresh version. Paula said there were 34 signs asking Ace to marry them and called tonight’s performance his sexiest and sultriest to date. Simon said it wasn’t the best vocal tonight, but he won’t be in the bottom 3 tomorrow. I think Ace is safe and I used to think he would be in the top 4 but last week’s vote was a shock. Maybe it was just a wake up call to his voters.

Not a bad night tonight. I think the bottom 3 will be Bucky, Lisa and either Kevin or Elliott. I think Bucky or Kevin should be gone, but it could be Lisa.

Wednesday, March 15, 2006

AIV recap, Finalists x 12 (03/14)

Two hours tonight. Brutal.

Stevie Wonder night. Is it me or does he look like Barry Bonds?

01 – Ace, Do I Do
I’m not implying anything, but did anyone else notice how much Ace was touching Stevie during their time together? Ace may not be gay, but his boyfriend might be. Ace was not very good tonight. Very nervous. Didn’t change the song up much. He’ll make it through by his looks, although he may start to lose the female vote if he keeps the ultra-sensitive stuff up. Maybe he was so macho that he took estrogen to become more in touch with himself. And his brother was in the audience. That dude looks like a Cro-Magnon man. Like he could be on the comic strip B.C. Randy said it started off no good and it was a hard song, with all the changes. Paula totally disagreed (big surprise). Simon said he’s lucky because the audience is easily pleased and it was not a great vocal and a bit manic. I tend to agree. He’ll be safe for tomorrow night though.

02 – Kellie, Blame It On The Sun
Being a good old country girl, Kellie was not familiar with Stevie Wonder. And I think it’s really hard to sing a song if you’re just learning it that week. If you don’t know how the song was originally sung, it’s hard to change it up and make it your own. Looked really nice in her black dress and red shoes. I think she looks better with straight hair though. This song was way too slow for her. Did she forget the words at one point? She really does better with high energy songs. The slow song took away her performance moves. I think Kellie also looks like the girl from My Two Dads. You remember that sitcom with Greg Evigan and Paul Reiser as her two dads (Staci Keanan). Her mother passed away and didn’t know/reveal which one was her dad, so they raised her together. Kellie looks more like her on a later show, Step By Step. The modern day Brady Bunch with Suzanne Somers and Patrick Duffy as the parents with 3 kids each, living together under one roof. Anyway, Randy called it a very interesting song choice and the key was low. Paula said she was nervous and out of her comfort zone. Simon said everything went wrong and it was so boring. I agree, but people are voting not only for her performances but also for her intros and interviews after. Seacrest has so much fun with her because you never know what will come out of her mouth. She was talking about her fake eyelashes tonight that looked like tarantulas. Just funny stuff. Even though she wasn’t great tonight, she should be safe tomorrow night.

03 – Elliott, Knocks Me Off My Feet
Stevie is Elliott’s idol and he teared up a bit when he sat on the piano bench with him. That was a nice moment. Elliott’s voice really fit this song, but he didn’t knock me off my feet with it. Maybe it was his Dumb and Dumber haircut that put me off. Randy said it wasn’t his best performance and it’s hard to bring something new to such an old song. Paula said it was okay to cry. Simon called it the best so far, but he didn’t have the wow factor, nor showed any originality. Elliott should be fine tomorrow night.

04 – Mandisa, Don’t You Worry About a Thing
Her “dogs” were barking so she had Seacrest take off her shoes before the performance. It was a real Al Bundy-type moment. I really like Mandisa, but (as a colleague in the Northwest so cleverly suggested) if this doesn’t work out for her, she can gain employment by performing at the end of games that are already decided. That reminds me of my time at the Bulls. Our entertainment guy would always play “Whoomp! There It Is” when the game was basically over. He was pretty gutsy at times because he brought it out during some close games. We always won them, but I’d always feel safer when I heard that song at home games. And then after Michael retired (for the second, but not final time) they hardly played that song at all. Anyway, Mandisa was very good during some parts of this song and flat in others. Randy said she wasn’t as great as last week, but was the best so far. Paula reiterated Stevie’s assessment that she can sing anything. Simon said now we have a competition because she was the best so far.

05 – Bucky, Superstition
Again, like Kellie, he didn’t know Stevie songs. I think he sang it to get through it and really didn’t do anything special with it. Did wear his hair down tonight and Simon called it Jessica Simpson hair. And his dancing was atrocious. Randy said it was definitely the best song choice for him and even though it wasn’t the greatest vocal, he enjoyed it. Paula enjoyed hearing him do Stevie in his country style. Simon called it one of his best performances (did his others suck that bad?) I think Bucky’s on the bubble tomorrow.

06 – Melissa, Lately
Her intro showed her messing up the words in front of Stevie (and getting a little put off that she messed up). Then she did it again during the live performance. I’m not a fan of Melissa’s and this did nothing to endear me to her anymore. I think that she struggled at times with her voice. Randy mentioned right off that she forgot the lyrics and that she was flat and sharp at times, but she ended strong. He praised her pipes. Paula said she should wear dresses more often (how insightful). Simon called it her best performance so far. He went so far as to call it edgy and contemporary. I didn’t see it at all. I’m hoping she’s off the show soon.

07 – Lisa, Signed, Sealed, Delivered, I’m Yours
Finally we hear an up tempo song from her. I honestly think, in this genre, a ballad would’ve been better for her. She did wear a big belt though. Something that looked like it was from Bongo or Contempo Casuals. Or Wet Seal. Or Forever 21. Not that I shop at any of those places. Randy said the end was hot. Paula said she was a little nervous tonight but liked that she took chances. Simon called it one of the best performances tonight. He loved it. It was a younger, hipper performance for her, compared to the “older” songs of weeks past. I think Lisa will go very far in this competition. She may not win, but I think she should be in the top 2 girls (along with Katharine).

08 – Kevin, Part-Time Lover
Can someone tell me how this kid is still in the competition? Tonight’s performance was almost an anti-Idol performance. It was like (although he is being totally serious) he was mocking the whole competition. Like a bad Saturday Night Live skit. Or like how Mr. Bean as a youngster would perform. And the scary part is, he’s buying into all the hype. He’s actually getting cocky. He does have a better voice than John Stevens, but Finchy never got cocky. He’s a nice kid and all, but he’s got to go pretty soon. If he lasts 3 more weeks, I’ll be okay with it (just as long as Melissa and Bucky go before him). Randy said he sang it good and in tune. Is that the kind of comments that a real American Idol should be getting? Paula called the song a hard song to sing and keep in tune and he did both. Well, whoop dee do. Simon finally got real and called it appalling. Then Kevin said he didn’t expect much out of Simon. Man that was arrogant. I’m beginning to hate this kid now.

09 – Katharine, Until You Come Back To Me
I wasn’t really digging her look tonight. Her eye shadow was a bit much and her dress was kinda funky. But I really dig Katharine. Her voice was unbelievable tonight. And her personality is really cool. Randy called her off the chain. That was hot. Paula said her voice pierces through the heart (I think that’s a good thing). Simon said you’re good and she reminded him (vocally) of Kelly Clarkson. That is a real good comparison in my book. She should be safe tomorrow night. I think she’ll be in the final 4, if not final 2.

10 – Taylor, Living For The City
Man, Taylor dresses so old. And he cannot dance a lick, but honestly, that’s the beauty of it. It’s like Jennifer Love Hewitt’s character in Party of Five (Sarah Reeves). She couldn’t dance, but still did. Taylor did some kind of dancing 360 turn, a few times, and it was pretty cool. Almost like in Can’t Buy Me Love, when Patrick Dempsey’s character did the African Anteater Ritual Dance (which, by the way, Paula Abdul was a choreographer for that movie). Randy called it a hot performance. Paula called him a fun performer. Simon likened him to every dad who ever got drunk at a wedding and danced. I was laughing so hard at his dancing. I really like Taylor. I don’t know if he’ll win this whole thing, but he will be famous after it’s all said and done.

11 – Paris, All I Do
She did a great job with this song. It really fit her vocals. There is no denying her talent, but I don’t think she’s going to win. I don’t think she’s as likable as some of the others. Maybe it has to do with the fact that she reminds me of Fantasia. Randy called her unbelievable tonight and she did it effortlessly. Paula called her a seasoned veteran. Simon called her so confident. Paris should be safe tomorrow night. Don’t get me wrong about her. I like her, just not as much as some of the others.

12 – Chris, Higher Ground
I really think Chris cheated on this one. Like he found a loophole. He admitted that he knew that the Red Hot Chili Peppers remade this song. Chris may not have done an exact version of the Chili Peppers, but it sounded a whole lot more like them than Stevie. I think it went against the whole spirit of the night. I like Chris, but I really can’t ever get into him. He’s too much of a rocker for my taste. I don’t think that he is going to win, but he will definitely get a recording contract out of this. Randy said that every week he figures out a way to make it his own and that he always works it out. Paula sits back and enjoys him every week. Simon said this was the only real world performance. I really think Chris is going to make it, just not as the American Idol.

You know what kind of surprised me was some of the songs that they didn’t pick. Like “You Are The Sunshine Of My Life” and “Ribbons In The Sky” and “That Girl” and “Isn’t She Lovely” and “I Just Called To Say I Love You.”

I think the bottom 3 should be Melissa, Kevin and Bucky.

For those of you who are sometimes waiting for this to be forwarded to you, you can always check on-line at http://airecaps.blogspot.com. I usually send them out and post them all at once and it’s usually around 11pm to midnight every Tuesday.

Wednesday, March 08, 2006

AIV recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 8 (03/08)

Got back from the program just when AI was finishing, so this hopefully won’t come out too late into the night. One observation about Seacrest is that he looks like a mini-Josh Duhamel, especially in the suit he wore tonight. And I think that Melissa McGhee looks like Molly Shannon.

01 – Gedeon McKinney, When A Man Loves A Woman (Percy Sledge)
Gedeon talks slowly and measures his words like Avery Johnson. Over-emphasizing every painstaking syllable. But he wore a pink shirt with a black jacket tonight. Gotta love that Prevacid product placement. I know that we got out of the DTC campaigns, but the subtleness of this advertising is pure genius. To get a 30mg capsule plug on AI, the most watched show on the planet is brilliant. Only the Watsonville people may get this one, but I think that Gedeon looks like Derek Mio. Gedeon did a good job with the song, but I’m really not a fan of his. He’s way too confident and it borders on outright cockiness. Randy thought it was alright and called him the old soul in the competition, which is funny because he’s only 17 and there are a few contestants that are in their late 20s. Paula stated that throwback is his style. Very insightful. At least she wasn’t heavily medicated like she was in the results show last week. Simon called him quite odd, but in a good way. But he also called the performance cabaret and over the top. I think Gedeon’s safe, but he can exit stage right at any time as far as I’m concerned.

02 – Chris Daughtry, some rock song by some rock band/singer
His interesting fact was that he had the Seacrest ‘do going but his hairline started receding, so he vowed if it got to that point, he’d shave his head. And he did. I actually like the cue ball look on him. It adds to his rocker image. Chris was wearing a shirt that looked like it came off the hood of a Firebird. We think his voice reminds us of someone. Maybe a Rock-ish Hootie? Is that possible? Can Hootie’s top 40 voice be done in pure rock? Chris is growing on me. He’s got a very distinct voice, but the problem I have with him is that I never know the songs that he sings. And it’s hard for me to really get into him if I can’t recognize his songs. Randy claimed again (this is getting to be his line) that he’s glad that Chris knows who he is and sings songs that are true to his voice and character. Randy loved it. Rock on. Paula called him an amazing artist and said no matter what happens in this competition, he’ll still be selling out stadiums. I think that’s Paula-speak for, “I think you’re really good, but you won’t win because you’re not as pretty as Ace.” But as Tony Hawk said, “who is?” Simon called Chris’ song choice “indulgent” and the song was boring. Said he needs to be more broad in his song choices and he still needs to entertain. I think that sums up my point about not knowing his songs. I still think Chris should be in the finals and in the last 4 guys, along with Ace, Taylor and Elliott.

03 – Kevin Covais, Vincent (Starry Starry Night) (Don McLean)
I think this is who sang this song. And it’s the American Pie Don McLean, not the former hoopster from UCLA and various NBA teams who actually got busted for using steroids. But if you look at his body, he was using them wrong! Maybe he thought just taking them would make you stronger and didn’t read the fine print that you have to still work out to get stronger. Actually, this song was on one of the Ally McBeal soundtracks. I won’t go on a long tangent on how much I liked this show, but I am anxiously awaiting its release on DVD. At least the first 2 or 3 seasons. My wife will never let me forget that when we first started dating (it was over the phone because I was in Chicago and she was in San Jose), she couldn’t call me when Ally McBeal was on because I’d be distracted or just tell her I’d call her back when the show was over. Looking back, TiVo would’ve solved that. Bygones. Kevin actually reminds me of a young John Cage though. Or he looks like an altar boy. My manager’s husband said that the Chicken Little reference was pretty close, but to be more correct, Kevin looks like Egghead, Jr from the Foghorn Leghorn cartoons. My wife thinks that Kevin has a good voice, but it’s not one that she’d like to hear on the radio and she wouldn’t buy a CD of his. Or buy an iTune of his. Randy called it an interesting, weird song. Paula had nothing but love for him and appreciated his sincere performance. Simon said he’d get the granny vote and the song was very juvenile. Especially when comparing him to the other 16-17 year olds (Lisa, Paris and Gedeon). I think Kevin’s a nice kid, but I think it’s time for him to go. He’s got a better voice than John Stevens and he’s not approaching that status for me yet.

04 – Bucky Covington, Wave on Wave (Pat Green)
I think this is who sang this. Not a country fan and Bucky is totally country. Got to meet his brother, Rocky. My wife said he’d actually make a good looking girl, with those puppy dog eyes. Maybe he should compete with the girls and Kinnik could compete with the guys and we could call it a day. Randy said it was a great song for him and he liked it. Paula called him unpretentious and likes his raw, untapped talent (is that a compliment?). Simon said it wasn’t exceptional. It was OK and that’s not good enough at this point. I think Bucky’s nice, but he can go at anytime now and I’d be good with it.

05 – Will Makar, How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved By You) (James Taylor)
It’s so funny because my manager Cindi and I were just talking about how when she hears this song, it always reminds her of the movie American Pie (this was the song that Chris Klein and Mena Suvari sang together at the singing competition). And I had to add that one of my favorite lines in that movie was a very subtle one. But I appreciate it nonetheless. When Chris Klein is just getting to know Mena Suvari when he first joins the choir, he mentions how there are all these stereotypes, like how everyone only thinks he’s this kick ass lacrosse player, but what people don’t realize is that he plays football too. I don’t know why I think that is so funny, but I do. Anyway, back to Will. I really like Will. He’s got a pretty good voice, especially since it doesn’t look like that voice should come out of his mouth (kinda like Clay Aiken). This rendition was okay, but the judges grilled him. Randy was particularly disgusted, saying it really wasn’t good for him and it was a bad karaoke version. Paula totally disagreed because she’s a fan of his (I don’t know if she’s the judge I’d want to have in my corner). Simon called it utterly average. I think Will may be gone tomorrow night. I don’t think he deserves to, but he didn’t wow anyone tonight.

06 – Taylor Hicks, Takin’ It To The Streets (The Doobie Brothers)
I said that Taylor looks like Michael McDonald’s love child and now he goes and sings one of his songs. Taylor wore a tan corduroy, Monday Night Football, Football Hall of Fame-type blazer. Soul Patrol! Taylor’s energy and gyrations up on stage were somewhat distracting, but not really. I just love his emotions and unbridled passion for song. He’s so unaffected by his movements. I think it adds to the performance too. He’s just so likeable, which is what this competition is all about. Randy called it a great song choice and was wondering about the arm wind up move. Paula called it her favorite performance of his and was blown away. Simon laughed and said he single-handedly killed the music video industry and that it was a performance best suited for the radio. But it stood out. You know how you bag on people and say that you’ve got a face for radio? Well, I’m a fan of The Sports Guy (http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/simmons/index). He’s a Boston guy who a real funny writer. (That previous sentence is a typo, but when my wife was proofing this for me (she looks for typos and “okays” the content, so that I don’t embarrass her), she asked, “what are you, Chinese?!”) He writes for ESPN.com’s Page 2 now. He’s way into sports, sports betting, gambling, video games, reality TV, etc. Anyway, I heard him on The Jim Rome Show (radio) last year and my first thought was, this guy has a voice for the Internet. Meaning he sounded like Arnold Horshack. I’ve seen what he looks like and how he writes and his voice just didn’t match any of it. It was quite a disconnect for me. Taylor should be safe tomorrow night and will probably be in the final 2 guys. Maybe the final 4 overall. We’ll see. He’s so fun.

07 – Elliott Yamin, Heaven (Bryan Adams)
It was interesting to hear that he’s lost 90% of his hearing in his right ear. It’s amazing that he sings so well. Unfortunately this song tonight was pitchy in parts and a total weak effort. Especially on the heels of last week’s stellar outing. My manager’s husband reminded me of others that Elliott looks like. To quote him (which would only do it justice), “The University of Notre Dame Department of Athletics called and demanded that American Idol return Elliott Yamin immediately so he can resume his duties as the school’s Leprechaun mascot! Of course, this may be impossible due to the suit SNL’s Jim Breuer has filed asking Elliott to cease and desist from trying to bring back his mid-90s character “Goat Boy” baaaaah-ck.” Priceless. Randy called Elliott’s performance hot. Paula called it phenomenal and amazing. Simon called it a cop out. He felt for the first time there was a disconnect to the song and felt that Elliott appeared uncomfortable singing it. I had to agree with Simon. I don’t think Elliott should be doing Bryan Adams songs. Maybe Chris, but Elliott has such a smoother voice than the gravelly Bryan Adams. And by the way, Adams was 9 during the Summer of ’69. I think Elliott is safe tomorrow night and is one of the best 4 guys.

08 – Ace Young, Butterflies (Michael Jackson)
I really didn’t know this song. This was off Jacko’s 2000 album (can we really call them albums anymore?) “Invincible.” My wife thought he sang in falsetto too long at the beginning of the song. Almost fingernails-on-the-blackboard too long. But did anyone really notice? I mean he wore the beanie this time (and it matched his undershirt). He had an ace of spades on his shirt. Still did a good job with the song though. He’s doing the smoldering look into the camera, but it’s not Constantine-annoying yet. Randy praised him for his falsetto. Paula called it better than the original artist. Simon didn’t really like it, but said that Ace made it work. Who are we kidding? He’s breezing into the finals and will probably be in the final 4, if not 2.

The bottom 4 should be Kevin, Will, Bucky and Gedeon. I’m hoping the bottom 2 are Kevin and Bucky, but I have a feeling Will is gone.

Like always, I love to hear your comments back after you watch the show and read the recap…

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

AIV recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 8 (03/07)

Whew, now that Brenna and Heather are gone, we only need to get rid of Kinnik and Melissa and we’ll be good.

01 – Paris Bennett, Conga (Miami Sound Machine)
They included a little known fact in each intro this week and Paris’ was that she is a tomboy. Grew up with a bunch of brothers and cousins and loves wrestling and football. She was okay tonight. Vocally, she was okay (but pitchy in parts) and I thought the arrangement was boring. And there was dancing. I’m not a fan of too much distracting movement on the stage. I think she’s fine for now, but song choices like this may get her when the competition gets hotter. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite song choice. Paula prefers her uptempo songs, but was surprised by what she chose melodically. Simon called it vocally okay, but people like her and she’ll sail thru to the finals.

02 – Lisa Tucker, Here’s Where I Stand (Tiffany Taylor; Camp Soundtrack)
I had not heard this song before. I thought it was an older song, but then found out it was from Camp, a Fame-meets-Meatballs movie about a songwriter who works at a musical camp for young performers. Actually sounds like an interesting movie. It may make my queue on Netflix. Lisa’s little known fact (LKF) is that she loves Jimi Hendrix and learned to play the electric guitar because of him. She came out with the straight hair tonight, which made her look like her mom’s sister. I don’t know if her mom looks young enough to be her sister or if Lisa looks older and mature enough to be her mom’s sister. Either way, I think all parties involved are glad that she looks like her mom and not her bald, present day Michael Warren-looking father. You know Michael Warren. Played hoops at UCLA, but is probably best known for his portrayal of Bobby Hill on “Hill Street Blues.” Lisa wore a dress tonight that had a pattern on it that looked like a cornfield in Iowa after the aliens did their work on it. She’s so petite, like Jasmine Trias was a few years back. Didn’t know the song, but she sang it well. She’s got a big voice and tremendous performance skills, but I have yet to be completely wowed by her. I still think she’ll breeze thru to the finals, but it will take some better performances once the competition tightens up. Randy still called her song choice old and wanted to hear a song with more runs in it. Paula called her a seasoned performer but wants a song that we can get into. Simon called her super talented, but it sounds like her mum is choosing her songs.

03 – Melissa McGhee, What About Love (Heart)
Her LKF is that she’s a car freak. She came out with a total ‘80s look. Kinda Goth with the make up and earrings. Barracuda-washed jeans. A black leather mini shirt. Looked like the “fat man in a little coat” routine that Chris Farley made so famous. I like this song, but I think it’s been sung before in the competition (Carrie, last year?). And it has definitely been sung better. Randy called it a good song choice. Paula said she’s been improving every week and that she’s a powerhouse. Simon said her last note booked her ticket home and that he thought she shouted the song. Melissa should be gone Thursday night.

04 – Kinnik Sky, some Alicia Keys song
LKF: she loves chitlins (hog intestines), which is short for chitterlings. I really think she’s a female impersonator. I could see Tracy Morgan doing a Saturday Night Live skit portraying her. She really would make a handsome man. Again, I think Alicia Keys songs should be outlawed in this competition because they are stylized and hard to mix up and make it your own. Honestly, the person(s) who are helping them choose the songs should stop them and ask them to reconsider their choice. Kinnik did start a fashion show for UPS though. She’s one of three to wear brown tonight. It’s almost as if it was Project Runway where different designers were designing different outfits for the female UPS drivers. Randy said she loved the song choice. Said she started out amazing, but got sharp and didn’t nail it. Paula said she looked amazing (and you know when Paula goes immediately to the looks, you sucked), but was not on pitch. Simon got straight to it and said she messed it up and also booked her ticket home. Maybe she can get in the same row as Melissa. They should both be gone the night after next.

05 – Katharine McPhee, that “you better think/freedom” song
Before Kinnik’s performance, Ryan interviewed Katharine to squash the rumors that she was 1) going to quit the show and 2) was pregnant! Craziness. Someone did say that she reminded her of a chubby Katie Holmes. Her LKF was that she attended the same Boston Conservatory that Constantine did. And Seacrest gave her the “McPheeVer” moniker. Katharine sang well, performed well, shook her booty up on stage. She’s full-figured, but in a she-carries-it-well way. I really enjoy her reactions of unbridled giddiness after she’s done with her songs. She mentioned that she didn’t have much fun singing her song (ballad) last week and wanted to have fun again. Mission accomplished. Randy said to the dawg pound that they have a hot one. Paula said it was good to see her having fun again and that she has amazing control of her voice. Simon called it a risk, but she pulled it off effortlessly. I really like Katharine. I think she’s got an amazing voice and a fun, carefree, goofy personality. She should go far.

06 – Ayla Brown, Unwritten (Natasha Bedingfield)
Again with the brown. She looked like an Amazon genie tonight. And she wore clamdigger pants that Sway would’ve had to cuff. Didn’t know the song. Started slow, but she picked it up and sang it well. She wanted to change it up and sing a fun song instead of a ballad. If she makes it through (I think she’ll be in the bottom 3, but don’t think she’ll go), I think she should go back to the ballads. Randy said the song was okay but it wasn’t a singer’s song because of its 5 note range. Paula said she likes her because she fights the fight every week. Whatever that means. Simon thought it was pretty good, just not fantastic. I really hope that Ayla makes it through to the finals. I think she’s (to take a March Madness term) on the bubble.

07 – Mandisa, I’m Every Woman (Chaka Khan)
Her LKF was that she sucked her thumb until she was 24. And she wore a brown Afghan. And how many denim trees did they have to cut down to make those pants? Did she do the Chaka Khan version or the Whitney Houston/Bodyguard version? I couldn’t tell. Randy called it the best vocal by a female this season. Paula said she took the song and owned it. Loved the arrangement and she sang her butt off. Whoa there. Let’s not go overboard. She did not sing her butt off. It’s still there. Simon said all the other girls are going to hate her because she made everyone else look ordinary. She was in a different league tonight. Mandisa finally sang a song that suited her. Those other rock songs weren’t her. She was in her element tonight. She’s very strong. She should go very far.

08 – Kellie Pickler, I’m The Only One (Melissa Etheridge)
Country-ed out Melissa’s rock song. It really worked for her. She looked more comfortable up on the stage tonight. She is so likeable. Her naivety seems genuine and I think the voting public is falling in love with her. Randy said she’s consistent every week and loved how she turned country into rock. Paula said she’s adorable and everyone is in love with her. She also mentioned her point and looking into the camera. I noticed it too, but it hasn’t annoyed me yet. Simon called her a naughty little minx, which completely confused her. And he said he thinks he prefers her to last year’s winner (called by some Carrie Underwhelm). She doesn’t have the best voice, but she’s got that likeability that may trump better voices. And she just had salmon for the first time last week. She should be safe to the finals.

I think the bottom 2 should be Kinnik and Melissa, with either Ayla or Paris rounding out the bottom 3.

There may or may not be a recap tomorrow night because I have a program for work and it depends on how late I get back and when I get done viewing it. But I can already tell you that Kevin should be off.

Thursday, March 02, 2006

AIV recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 10 (03/01)

So the gals weren’t overly great last night. Some were downright offensive. I’m not that hopeful for the guys tonight because they are top-heavy. They have a few real good ones and some stinkers.

01 – Taylor Hicks, Easy (The Commodores)

The only funny part about Taylor’s intro was that he called his beanie/ski cap a “toboggan.” Never heard it called that before. Then again, I had never heard a soft drink referred to as a “pop” before I was out in Ohio. And they call any soft drink in Atlanta a “Coke.” They’ll ask you want a Coke? And if you say yes, they ask what kind? Funny stuff. He didn’t blow us away tonight, but I really still like Taylor. Although his “whoo’s” are kinda Tourette’s-like. I guess we’re just lucky that they are Ric Flair “whoo’s” and not cuss words. My wife didn’t know if he was trying to change the song up or was flat and Randy verified that he was pitchy. Paula still loved his enthusiasm. Not her favorite song, but he is still one of her favorites. Simon didn’t think the song worked. You know I forgot to mention Taylor’s harmonica riff when he was walking to his chair during the one on one’s to be named to the final 24. I’ve heard so many positive comments from people about that. I’m banking that Taylor will bring it better next week. And he must be the happiest person on the face of the earth. Not that that is a bad thing.

02 – Elliott Yamin, Moody’s Mood for Love (James Moody)

First off, in addition to the whole Seth Green, Adam Sandler, Eminem thing, Elliott reminds me of an elf. I had no idea what this song was, but man, did Elliott sing it well. He was silky smooth and buttery and all of that. It was surprising. I think he’s in it for the long haul. Randy said he has a natural amazing gift and gave him a standing O. Paula complimented him because it was a difficult song to sing (with all the scats and runs). Simon called it a great performance and that he’s grown in confidence. I was thoroughly impressed tonight.

03 – Ace Young, If I’m Not Made For You (?), Daniel Redding (?)

I apologize. I missed the name of this song. Maybe I was too excited to hear Ace perform. My palms get all sweaty and I get nervous like a little school girl before he performs and gazes into the camera. Maybe he’s singing to me. Oops. Did I just type that? That was supposed to be a conversation in my head only. But seriously, I am very secure in my manhood (although my wife may start to wonder now), but how pretty of a man is Ace? TiVos across America are going to break because so many women (and maybe some men) will be replaying Ace’s performances over and over and over again. His intro explained the beanie in his back pocket superstition. Randy was glad that he chose that song because he’s a sensitive singer and hit the falsetto thing. He claims that Ace sings better than he leads on. Whatever that means. Paula called it another good week and also praised the falsetto. Simon thought he struggled with the song. Eh, Ace won’t be on thin ice for a long time. As long as he doesn’t sing anything heinously wrong, he’s safe to the final 4.

04 – Gedeon McKinney, A Change Is Gonna Come (Sam Cooke)

Let’s get this out of the way. Gedeon needs to smile more. Gedeon sang the song well, but it’s such an old song. He’s got a big voice and is supremely confident though. His confidence puts me off a bit. At the end of his performance, you could hear Mandisa say “that boy can sing!” Randy called him a great natural performer. Paula called him unique, which is funny because over the course of the season, she’ll call every single person unique. Simon called him authentic and said that Gedeon really fits in that era of singers. I could see that. I could see him on American Hot Wax or playing Sam Cooke on an episode of “American Dreams.” The jury is now out on Gedeon for me. I think he’s a good singer, but I’m not digging his confidence at this point.

05 – Kevin Covais, I Heard It Through the Grapevine (Marvin Gaye)

I’m really conflicted on Kevin. He’s a nice kid and very likeable, but c’mon, he’s not your next American Idol. The judges (well, Randy and Paula) fawned over him, but the reality is, they have such low expectations for him that anything he does is okay with them. Will sang very well later in the show and the judges didn’t praise him. Kevin didn’t really even sing this song that well. His performance looked like a bobblehead up on stage. Like his feet were stuck in glue or gum. And he moved like that hula girl that you’d put on the dashboard of your car. It’s almost like the gals, judges (except for Simon) and audience were laughing at him and not with him. Randy really enjoyed the performance and said “my boy can blow.” Paula called him infectious and when she looked around, everyone was smiling. Simon called Kevin likeable, but if he heard that song on the radio, he’d turn it off. I totally agree with Simon. People are being influenced by the singer and not the song sometimes. Nice kid. He’ll be safe tomorrow night, but shouldn’t last too much past that.

06 – Jose “Sway” Penala, Overjoyed (Stevie Wonder)

You’ve got to give it to Sway for busting out the white leather Member’s Only jacket. Gone was the pimp fedora (which was a good move). He shoulda gone with the Kangol hat last week. Is Kangol hat redundant? That reminds me of when I was first riding along with my old partner Kim Bui, who is Vietnamese. I was showing her where some doctors were and I said “there is Doctor Bac Si Nguyen.” She started giggling and I asked her why? I had just called him Doctor Doctor Nguyen, as Bac Si is Vietnamese for Doctor, and not his first name! I don’t know why, but Stevie Wonder songs seem really popular on American Idol. I guess it depends on which song you sing because gals shouldn’t pick any Whitney Houston or Mariah Carey songs, but the guys seem to pick a lot of Stevie. Are his songs easier to sing? Are there just a lot of them to choose from? I see the gals picking Celine Dion a lot too. Anyway, all this text was just to delay the bad write up on Sway. It was sad. The gals were giving him the “golf clap” after he was done. Like they were clapping because it was the polite thing to do. Randy said it wasn’t as good as last week and that the song was hard to make it his own. Paula called him disconnected and not in the zone. Simon called it “how not to do well,” pure karaoke and zero originality. I think Sway’s gone tomorrow night, but for the record, I think he’s WAY more talented than Kevin, but just not as popular.

07 – Will Makar, Lady (Kenny Rogers)

I think that Will looks like Logan Lerman, who played Bobby in the now cancelled WB show “Jack & Bobby.” I mentioned this show last year as one of my favorites, but it never found its audience and the plug was pulled. It was a brilliantly written show though. I won’t go on and on about it, but I was really sad to see it go. Anyway, in his intro he was mentioning how cool it was to meet Justin Guarini. Really? I hope America doesn’t hold that comment against him. Will showed a very nice voice during this song. I thought it was a bit subdued, but my wife loved it. And she was very upset (livid, almost) that the judges praised Kevin’s shoddy (at best) performance and didn’t praise Will’s. He did show a different side of his voice. One that many didn’t know he had. Randy called it just alright. Paula said he had a nice tone to his voice and he controlled it nice, but it was a safe song choice. Simon called it an audition for Cats. Then Seacrest molested him on stage. Poor kid. I think that he should be okay tomorrow night, but we’ll see. He definitely is the best of the youngsters (Will, Kevin and David).

08 – Bucky Covington, The Thunder Rolls (Garth Brooks)

Not a country fan. Because of that didn’t know if he changed up the song. If he sang it well or not. I can’t connect with Bucky. I hope he’s gone soon. Randy praised him for the Dirty South and said he knows exactly who he is. Paula said he’s finding his place in the competition. Simon called him a support singer for the bigger stars. I couldn’t agree any more. Nice guy, but there is no way he wins this competition.

09 – David Radford, The Way You Look Tonight (Frank Sinatra)

And various other artists. My favorite version of this song is the one on the Father of the Bride soundtrack. There’s a version on My Best Friend’s Wedding too, but it’s not as good as the Father of the Bride one. And David’s version was probably the worst ever. He’s a total throwback to the Rat Pack, but he was totally nervous tonight and I really didn’t feel it. If he lasts past tomorrow night, he will officially become my John Stevens. Why do they put a crooner through every year? They never make it. They stay longer than they should. Really, would you buy a CD by David Radford? His intro story about forgetting his belt and having to use his mom’s car phone charger was pretty funny though. Randy said he was bored and listened to the band more. Paula said she’s seen him perform better with other songs. Simon said he lacked charisma and confidence and that the band was too much to accompany him on this song. He’s a good looking kid and it would disappoint me, but not surprise me if he made it past tomorrow. He should be gone though.

10 – Chris Daughtry, Hemorrhage (Fuel)

I guess this was a great performance. I’m just not that much of a rocker and really can’t appreciate his performance. He sounded good, but I’m not familiar with the song and don’t know how it stacked up against the original. Chris reminds me a bit of TAPer Neil Robbins. Maybe it’s just the bald head. Everytime Chris performs though, it seems like a lot of screaming. Like Sam Kennison. Randy loved it. Said he’s right where he’s supposed to be. Paula called it amazing and a magic moment. Simon called it the only performance that would stand up in the real world. I guess he was good tonight. I’ve got to think he’s pretty safe tomorrow.

Overall, it wasn’t a great night. I think Chris, Elliott and Will were good. Taylor, Ace and Gedeon were worthy of praise. Sway, Kevin, David and Bucky were all worthy of bottom feeder performances in my book. If I had to pick my final 6 guys, it would be Ace, Taylor, Elliott, Chris, Gedeon and Will.

AIV recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 10 (03/01)

So the gals weren’t overly great last night. Some were downright offensive. I’m not that hopeful for the guys tonight because they are top-heavy. They have a few real good ones and some stinkers.

01 – Taylor Hicks, Easy (The Commodores)

The only funny part about Taylor’s intro was that he called his beanie/ski cap a “toboggan.” Never heard it called that before. Then again, I had never heard a soft drink referred to as a “pop” before I was out in Ohio. And they call any soft drink in Atlanta a “Coke.” They’ll ask you want a Coke? And if you say yes, they ask what kind? Funny stuff. He didn’t blow us away tonight, but I really still like Taylor. Although his “whoo’s” are kinda Tourette’s-like. I guess we’re just lucky that they are Ric Flair “whoo’s” and not cuss words. My wife didn’t know if he was trying to change the song up or was flat and Randy verified that he was pitchy. Paula still loved his enthusiasm. Not her favorite song, but he is still one of her favorites. Simon didn’t think the song worked. You know I forgot to mention Taylor’s harmonica riff when he was walking to his chair during the one on one’s to be named to the final 24. I’ve heard so many positive comments from people about that. I’m banking that Taylor will bring it better next week. And he must be the happiest person on the face of the earth. Not that that is a bad thing.

02 – Elliott Yamin, Moody’s Mood for Love (James Moody)

First off, in addition to the whole Seth Green, Adam Sandler, Eminem thing, Elliott reminds me of an elf. I had no idea what this song was, but man, did Elliott sing it well. He was silky smooth and buttery and all of that. It was surprising. I think he’s in it for the long haul. Randy said he has a natural amazing gift and gave him a standing O. Paula complimented him because it was a difficult song to sing (with all the scats and runs). Simon called it a great performance and that he’s grown in confidence. I was thoroughly impressed tonight.

03 – Ace Young, If I’m Not Made For You (?), Daniel Redding (?)

I apologize. I missed the name of this song. Maybe I was too excited to hear Ace perform. My palms get all sweaty and I get nervous like a little school girl before he performs and gazes into the camera. Maybe he’s singing to me. Oops. Did I just type that? That was supposed to be a conversation in my head only. But seriously, I am very secure in my manhood (although my wife may start to wonder now), but how pretty of a man is Ace? TiVos across America are going to break because so many women (and maybe some men) will be replaying Ace’s performances over and over and over again. His intro explained the beanie in his back pocket superstition. Randy was glad that he chose that song because he’s a sensitive singer and hit the falsetto thing. He claims that Ace sings better than he leads on. Whatever that means. Paula called it another good week and also praised the falsetto. Simon thought he struggled with the song. Eh, Ace won’t be on thin ice for a long time. As long as he doesn’t sing anything heinously wrong, he’s safe to the final 4.

04 – Gedeon McKinney, A Change Is Gonna Come (Sam Cooke)

Let’s get this out of the way. Gedeon needs to smile more. Gedeon sang the song well, but it’s such an old song. He’s got a big voice and is supremely confident though. His confidence puts me off a bit. At the end of his performance, you could hear Mandisa say “that boy can sing!” Randy called him a great natural performer. Paula called him unique, which is funny because over the course of the season, she’ll call every single person unique. Simon called him authentic and said that Gedeon really fits in that era of singers. I could see that. I could see him on American Hot Wax or playing Sam Cooke on an episode of “American Dreams.” The jury is now out on Gedeon for me. I think he’s a good singer, but I’m not digging his confidence at this point.

05 – Kevin Covais, I Heard It Through the Grapevine (Marvin Gaye)

I’m really conflicted on Kevin. He’s a nice kid and very likeable, but c’mon, he’s not your next American Idol. The judges (well, Randy and Paula) fawned over him, but the reality is, they have such low expectations for him that anything he does is okay with them. Will sang very well later in the show and the judges didn’t praise him. Kevin didn’t really even sing this song that well. His performance looked like a bobblehead up on stage. Like his feet were stuck in glue or gum. And he moved like that hula girl that you’d put on the dashboard of your car. It’s almost like the gals, judges (except for Simon) and audience were laughing at him and not with him. Randy really enjoyed the performance and said “my boy can blow.” Paula called him infectious and when she looked around, everyone was smiling. Simon called Kevin likeable, but if he heard that song on the radio, he’d turn it off. I totally agree with Simon. People are being influenced by the singer and not the song sometimes. Nice kid. He’ll be safe tomorrow night, but shouldn’t last too much past that.

06 – Jose “Sway” Penala, Overjoyed (Stevie Wonder)

You’ve got to give it to Sway for busting out the white leather Member’s Only jacket. Gone was the pimp fedora (which was a good move). He shoulda gone with the Kangol hat last week. Is Kangol hat redundant? That reminds me of when I was first riding along with my old partner Kim Bui, who is Vietnamese. I was showing her where some doctors were and I said “there is Doctor Bac Si Nguyen.” She started giggling and I asked her why? I had just called him Doctor Doctor Nguyen, as Bac Si is Vietnamese for Doctor, and not his first name! I don’t know why, but Stevie Wonder songs seem really popular on American Idol. I guess it depends on which song you sing because gals shouldn’t pick any Whitney Houston or Mariah Carey songs, but the guys seem to pick a lot of Stevie. Are his songs easier to sing? Are there just a lot of them to choose from? I see the gals picking Celine Dion a lot too. Anyway, all this text was just to delay the bad write up on Sway. It was sad. The gals were giving him the “golf clap” after he was done. Like they were clapping because it was the polite thing to do. Randy said it wasn’t as good as last week and that the song was hard to make it his own. Paula called him disconnected and not in the zone. Simon called it “how not to do well,” pure karaoke and zero originality. I think Sway’s gone tomorrow night, but for the record, I think he’s WAY more talented than Kevin, but just not as popular.

07 – Will Makar, Lady (Kenny Rogers)

I think that Will looks like Logan Lerman, who played Bobby in the now cancelled WB show “Jack & Bobby.” I mentioned this show last year as one of my favorites, but it never found its audience and the plug was pulled. It was a brilliantly written show though. I won’t go on and on about it, but I was really sad to see it go. Anyway, in his intro he was mentioning how cool it was to meet Justin Guarini. Really? I hope America doesn’t hold that comment against him. Will showed a very nice voice during this song. I thought it was a bit subdued, but my wife loved it. And she was very upset (livid, almost) that the judges praised Kevin’s shoddy (at best) performance and didn’t praise Will’s. He did show a different side of his voice. One that many didn’t know he had. Randy called it just alright. Paula said he had a nice tone to his voice and he controlled it nice, but it was a safe song choice. Simon called it an audition for Cats. Then Seacrest molested him on stage. Poor kid. I think that he should be okay tomorrow night, but we’ll see. He definitely is the best of the youngsters (Will, Kevin and David).

08 – Bucky Covington, The Thunder Rolls (Garth Brooks)

Not a country fan. Because of that didn’t know if he changed up the song. If he sang it well or not. I can’t connect with Bucky. I hope he’s gone soon. Randy praised him for the Dirty South and said he knows exactly who he is. Paula said he’s finding his place in the competition. Simon called him a support singer for the bigger stars. I couldn’t agree any more. Nice guy, but there is no way he wins this competition.

09 – David Radford, The Way You Look Tonight (Frank Sinatra)

And various other artists. My favorite version of this song is the one on the Father of the Bride soundtrack. There’s a version on My Best Friend’s Wedding too, but it’s not as good as the Father of the Bride one. And David’s version was probably the worst ever. He’s a total throwback to the Rat Pack, but he was totally nervous tonight and I really didn’t feel it. If he lasts past tomorrow night, he will officially become my John Stevens. Why do they put a crooner through every year? They never make it. They stay longer than they should. Really, would you buy a CD by David Radford? His intro story about forgetting his belt and having to use his mom’s car phone charger was pretty funny though. Randy said he was bored and listened to the band more. Paula said she’s seen him perform better with other songs. Simon said he lacked charisma and confidence and that the band was too much to accompany him on this song. He’s a good looking kid and it would disappoint me, but not surprise me if he made it past tomorrow. He should be gone though.

10 – Chris Daughtry, Hemorrhage (Fuel)

I guess this was a great performance. I’m just not that much of a rocker and really can’t appreciate his performance. He sounded good, but I’m not familiar with the song and don’t know how it stacked up against the original. Chris reminds me a bit of TAPer Neil Robbins. Maybe it’s just the bald head. Everytime Chris performs though, it seems like a lot of screaming. Like Sam Kennison. Randy loved it. Said he’s right where he’s supposed to be. Paula called it amazing and a magic moment. Simon called it the only performance that would stand up in the real world. I guess he was good tonight. I’ve got to think he’s pretty safe tomorrow.

Overall, it wasn’t a great night. I think Chris, Elliott and Will were good. Taylor, Ace and Gedeon were worthy of praise. Sway, Kevin, David and Bucky were all worthy of bottom feeder performances in my book. If I had to pick my final 6 guys, it would be Ace, Taylor, Elliott, Chris, Gedeon and Will.