Tuesday, March 27, 2007

AIVI recap, Finalists x 10 (03/27)

Wow. Stephanie goes earlier than we thought. I’d say that I’m surprised, but really, she wasn’t going to win. I guess the only bummer for her is that she probably won’t get to tour with the final 10. But maybe that’s a good thing.

Gwen Stefani night, as the contestants are singing No Doubt songs and also music that inspired her. Can’t figure out who she looks like tonight (she’s always changing her look). Maybe a blonde Jennifer Love Hewitt? Remember when she was the hottest thing on the planet and when FOX was planning their “Summer of Love?” Believe me, I was one of those smitten by “Love” (allegedly the name those close to her would call her). I thought she was great on “Party of Five” and even watched her ill-fated spin-off “Time of Your Life,” which starred Jennifer Garner and Johnathon (yes, that’s how he spells it) Schaech (he played the lead singer in “That Thing You Do!”). Love hasn’t done much since “Ghost Whisperer,” which I’ve never seen. Her fall was quick. But she was in “The Tuxedo” with Jackie Chan. Does that count for anything?

01 – LaKisha Jones, Last Dance (Donna Summer)

Looks like she shopped at the same store as Stephanie did last week. Hopefully it doesn’t bring the same fate. Decent song and it sounded less like Nell Carter tonight. Song choice was a bit boring and predictable though. Some think that she is limited in her song choices. As good as she is, I really don’t think she’s going to win. But my wife always says, if they’ve gotten this far, they’ve already won. LaKisha will get a recording contract out of this. It just may not be with the American Idol label (whoever that is). Randy liked the uptempo song choice. He loved the boots and called her a fly diva. Paula said she did Donna Summer proud. Simon said he also loved the boots and that they made her look 30 years younger this week (compared to last week). LaKisha should be safe tomorrow.

02 – Chris Sligh, Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic (The Police)

I heard somewhere that Chris tried out twice before for AI and never made it to the judges. Then he and his wife hatched a plan to get him noticed, which included him growing his hair out and looking like a Jack Osbourne-clone. I guess it worked because he’s a finalist now. He does have a bad habit of getting ahead of the music and I wonder where that comes from? Is it because he doesn’t have any formal training? He sounds like he knows music in his post-song interviews. His control is not that of some of the better singers in the competition, but I like his attitude towards the competition. And who doesn’t like a self-deprecating fat guy? Randy said it was a good song choice but he wasn’t on the same tempo as the music. Paula basically called him Jeff Garcia for not staying in the pocket (gotta love those “happy feet” moving down to Tampa Bay) of the song, but vocally it still sat very nice. Simon thought it was a mess, that he was all over the place and that it didn’t feel right. Then the music came on like at the Oscars when the award recipient has overstayed his time in his acceptance speech. Kind of a funny spot. Chris may be vulnerable tomorrow night, as he didn’t blow anyone away.

03 – Gina Glocksen, I’ll Stand By You (The Pretenders)

I think Gina honored Gwen this week by dressing like her, although Gwen’s more famous for her flat tummy, something Gina won’t be pulling off anytime soon. She did wear this funky shiny dress/short skirt thing and fish nets and cool boots. I like Gina’s fashion style. Looks like she should be hanging outside the Vet’s Hall across the street from Watsonville High (sorry, only a few of you will get that one). Randy called her boots fly and said it was one of her best performances ever; a perfect song for her. Paula said she’s improving each week and this week it showed her vulnerability and she soared with her vocals. Simon said it wasn’t one of her best; it was her best. He likes that she knows who she is (vocally, I presume). I thought she was pretty strong tonight and that should buy her another week of not being in the bottom 3. But she’s reaching her ceiling soon. Add the Sanjaya phenomenon and she could be out soon.

04 – Sanjaya Malakar, Bathwater (No Doubt)

Gwen said this was a hard song and said good luck to him, which reading between the lines, she was saying, please don’t butcher one of MY songs. Can’t you choose some artist that inspired me and warble that one instead? Sanjaya pinned his hair up in a Faux-hawk (my wife’s term!) tonight. Kinda looked like Joakim Noah, current Florida basketball player and son of tennis great Yannick Noah. From Sanjaya’s profile, he looked like a Spartan, as in the Michigan State mascot. Randy said he was speechless, which means he had nothing good to say, so instead of skewer him (which would bring pity votes), he just chose to say nothing. Called his hairdo interesting and that he can sing if he puts it out there. Paula says he needs to go for it. Simon said that he presumed that there was not a mirror in his dressing room. Sanjaya tried a smart alec comeback, but failed more miserably than Paula usually does. Simon concluded that it doesn’t really matter what the judges say about him and that he’s in his own universe. Sanjaya’s got so many people voting for him. Every single Indian person is probably dialing him up. He’s got the support of votefortheworst.com and Howard Stern is urging his listeners to vote for him, as a joke on the show. I know that there is a faction of people out there who don’t like the show or are jealous of the show’s success that are voting for Sanjaya to screw the show for allowing him to be a semi-finalist. Those people are sad. If they don’t like the show, don’t watch, but stop messing up MY American Idol. I honestly don’t think that Sanjaya will win. I guarantee he will outlast a few people that deserve to go on farther than him. But he won’t win. And even if he does, it doesn’t matter. So what if he’s the American Idol? You don’t have to buy his CD. Ron Artest has only sold like 343 CDs so far. Will this be Sanjayanara (I shamelessly stole that phrase)? Probably not.

05 – Haley Scarnato, True Colors (Cyndi Lauper)

I’ll tell you this, Haley likes to show us her legs. But I’m not a fan, especially when she gives us the “angry face.” I thought she did okay with this song, but not great. I think she’s gotten better, but she can go any week now and it will be fine with me. Randy said it started rough and got better at the end, but it was just a’ight and it had some pitchy moments. Paula called it a beautiful song and wished she just sang the melody. Simon called it sweet, but forgettable. Said she played it too safe. She should be in the bottom 3 tomorrow, if not gone altogether.

06 – Phil Stacey, Every Breath You Take (The Police)

Phil went with the knit hat today. Don’t know if I like him bald or with the hat. I think neither works for me because when he wears that hat, he looks like a chemo kid. The reason that I grew my sideburns out was because when I used to get my hair cut short and my sideburns were cut across by the top of my ear, if I wore a hat, I’d look like I had no hair. That and the whole 90210 phenomenon. Randy actually kinda liked it because he didn’t push it. Paula called it a good choice and that he shows so much personality when he hits the chorus, but wishes he showed more personality at other parts of the song. Simon thought it was very good and that he finally took it seriously and sang like he wanted to win. He was good, but I wouldn’t rule the bottom 3 out tomorrow night.

07 – Melinda Doolittle, Heaven Knows (Donna Summer)

Who knew that Donna Summer and The Police had such an influence on Gwen Stefani? Melinda went back to the ‘70s with a blue psychedelic top, but she always wears a high belt, which accentuates her short torso. I still like her though, even though she doesn’t have a neck either. My buddy Leroy texted me during her performance to ask my wife if “no neckitis” was a real disease? Randy called her a pro because she was living the words. Called her the bomb again. We had a Sabrina Sloan sighting in the crowd. Paula said she had charisma from the word go. Said she was so joyful and that she tells a story and does it in spades. Simon said, vocally, as usual, she was outstanding, but hated the outfit. She is good. She is nice and sweet. If she doesn’t win, I’ll be disappointed, but not crushed. She’ll still make it as a solo singer. And she’ll do well. People like her. She should be safe. I’m guessing she’ll be safe until the finale.

08 – Blake Lewis, Love Song (The Cure)

I was like, I know this song! But it’s way slower. And dreary. Blake looked stoned again and wore a sweater with a zipper on one side that looked like he should be in the show Sprockets (would you like to touch my monkey?). No beat box this time. Randy said it wasn’t the perfect song choice, but he made the most of it and that he liked it a lot. Paula loved what he did with it. She appreciates that he takes risks and loves that he is original. Simon called him definitely the strongest guy in the competition, but said he’s in the Chris Daughtry zone, doing his own thing. Meaning he has to be careful to not be too indulgent and boring. I think Blake has a pretty good following and should be safe tomorrow night.

09 – Jordin Sparks, Hey Baby! (No Doubt)

Jordin wore a Wizard of Oz, Dorothy-inspired outfit tonight, with the red checkered top and skirt. All she needed was a picnic basket with Toto peeking out. I think this song was a little tough for her to get all the words out at times, but she still gave a decent performance. After reading this, my wife disagreed. She thought Jordin was awesome and thought Gwen was also impressed, especially with her comment about not knowing the song to be so musical. She may be in the finale or top 3. Randy called this song a very risky thing to do, but she can sing anything and that she’ll be a great recording artist. Paula called her adorable and hip. Simon called her the most improved singer. He was glad to see her much younger and more confident. His only problem was that this song could be a bit copycat-ish. Jordin should be safe tomorrow and she really looks like she could be battling with LaKisha and Blake for the top 2 (along with Melinda).

10 – Chris Richardson, Don’t Speak (No Doubt)

I have to say, Gwen was refreshingly honest in all her intros. She gave praise where it was deserved and didn’t hold back on her hesitations. She said she’s seen CRich before and knew of his “vocal Olympics thing.” Classic. Going back to the boy band reference that my wife always gives with him, I think he’d have been better suited for “Making the Band,” instead of American Idol. Whatever happened to O-Town? And Eden’s Crush? I watched a bunch of “Popstars” when they had a marathon on MTV back in 2001 (pre-kids!). Well, I have to agree with my wife, I don’t think that I could possibly listen to too many songs by CRich. Randy called it very interesting and liked his flava. Paula just kept saying “you’re good.” Simon called this a much better choice of songs, but he wasn’t crazy about his vocals. And there was an AJ Tabaldo sighting. I’m not crazy about CRich anymore either. He may be in the bottom 3 again tomorrow.

I only voted for Melinda, Blake and Jordin tonight. DialIdol.com has Haley, Sligh and Jordin as its Bottom 3. I think the bottom 3 should be Haley, Sanjaya and CRich, with Haley going. I really think Sanjaya should be gone, but we know that’s not going to happen.

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

AIVI recap, Finalists x 11 (03/20)

So, Brandon went home. I wish it was Sanjaya, but he’s becoming kinda funny now. It’s painful, yes, but it’s like a train wreck. You gotta watch.

This week is British Invasion Week. I think that they were trying to get Paul McCartney and do a Beatles Week, but 1) I think Paul is watching his estranged wife with the prosthetic leg try to dance (http://abc.go.com/primetime/dancingwiththestars/fantasydancing/index) and 2) doesn’t Michael Jackson own all the Beatles songs?

Anyway, Peter Noone of Herman’s Hermits and Lulu are the guest mentors. I think Peter Noone looks like someone, but I can’t put a finger on whom it is. Peter Cetera? Stefan Edburg? A blond Mickey Dolenz? And one of the Herman’s Hermits pics looked oddly like “A Clockwork Orange.” Lulu on the other hand looked like a cross between Olivia Newton-John and Shirley Jones.

On to the singers…

01 – Haley, Tell Him (Billie Davis)

I understand that this song was really an American song by The Exciters, but was covered by Billie Davis in the UK but never released here. I kept thinking that I’ve heard this song in some movie and show and finally it hit me when she was done. This song was all over Ally McBeal. I’ve gone on and on about that show in previous years, so I won’t delve more into it now, but I will be getting those DVDs once they make it to the US. I’ve seen them on eBay from China, but don’t think they’ll play in my Region DVD player. Back to Haley. What the heck was she wearing tonight? A halter top/camisole? And short shorts? I thought she was doing a commercial for Jello (watch it wiggle, see it jiggle…). She was pitchy in parts and looked like she was going to give a few of the audience members lap dances. And how many shots of her back were we “treated” to? It’s like the producers wanted us to know that she wasn’t wearing a bra. I got it after the first shot, thank you. Randy called it the perfect song for her and said she was back in the competition. Paula said she has this girlish quality to her (well I hope she does!). It would’ve been funny if she said the same thing about Sanjaya. Simon called her a naughty little thing. Called the song fun, young, but a little shrieky. Others were worse tonight. I think that she could be in the bottom 3, but don’t think she’ll go tomorrow night.

02 – CRich, Don’t Let The Sun Catch You Crying (Gerry & The Pacemakers)

My wife’s complaint about CRich is that he’s got a boy band sound to him and can’t imagine listening to a whole CD of his (but that’s why iTunes is so great!). And he always does those darn runs all the time. But he was better about controlling that tonight. Randy said it was another great performance and every note was in tune (probably because he left out some of the runs). Paula said the arrangement and acoustics were sexy and charming. Simon called it his best performance so far, that his control was excellent but was still a little nasally at parts. I think CRich is safe at this point, but don’t put him ahead of either Blake or Sligh in this competition.

03 – Stephanie, You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me (Dusty Springfield)

I think someone else had sung this in previous years, but don’t know who. Stephanie came out wearing a necklace and matching earrings that looked like my son Jared made in his pre-Kindergarten class. This song sounds a lot like “Hopelessly Devoted To You” in the beginning. My wife called it a very old fashioned arrangement. By the way, this is the first time this year that we’ve sat down and watched it together. Between travel for both of us and our kids and her being sick over the last several weeks, it’s been crazy. It was nice having her by my side though (and we’ll celebrate our 7th anniversary this weekend, which is even nicer). Randy called it not her best and pitchy. Paula complimented her contemporary look. Simon said she was losing her edge, losing her soul and that she was becoming too old. Other than that she was fine. I think she’s in jeopardy tomorrow night. And Jordin Sparks has surpassed her for 3rd best girl and is quickly moving up to challenge LaKisha for the right to go mano-a-mano with Melinda.

04 – Blake, Time Of The Season (The Zombies)

The thing that I love about Blake is that he’s just Blake. All the time. Loved his Caddyshack, Judge Smails-inspired outfit tonight. My sister-in-law mentioned that he looks stoned every time he performs. So I looked for that tonight and she’s right. My wife says that he doesn’t have the strongest voice, but he is such a good entertainer. I appreciate the fact that he really needs to know his music to constantly change the arrangements to “Blake-ize” all the songs. Randy called it cool, vibey and edgy and said he made it real current. Paula said he really raised the bar and she felt like she was at a concert. Simon called it a million times better than last week and thanked him for keeping the melody in tact. Blake “Blake-izes” everything, but it’s in a good way. I like him. He should be safe tomorrow night.

05 – LaKisha, Diamonds Are Forever (Shirley Bassey)

I thought this was a boring song, but she sings everything so well. And it allowed her to wear an elegant green dress and a ton of bling. She must’ve felt like she was at the Oscars. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite (this is getting to be a signature line for him) and it was just a’ight. Paula said she picked the right song, but then again, when has she openly disagreed with a song choice. I honestly think Paula does this just to get the audience’s applause, which is sad. Simon called it too old and it was like seeing her in 50 years. LaKisha took the criticism well. It probably should be her and Melinda in the finale, but Jordin will go kicking and screaming to the end.

06 – Phil, Tobacco Road (Nashville Teens)

Looks like Phil took a class at the Bo Bice School of Singing With the Mic Stand. My wife said his voice got lost in the music at parts. I’m very apathetic towards Phil. I don’t hate him, but I don’t like him either. That’s like the worst thing in a competition like this. Randy said it was pretty good and that he usually ends his songs with a good upper register. Paula said it was a good choice of song, although some parts were pitchy. Simon wasn’t crazy about it and that he had no grit in his voice (which is what the song needed). Then Phil catered to the crowd asking if they liked it. Were they going to boo? Points off for that maneuver. Phil could be in the bottom 3 again tomorrow.

07 – Jordin, I Who Have Nothing (Shirley Bassey)

Jordin came out with straightened hair and a very classy, slimming black dress. My wife called her voice amazing (especially for a 17 year old) and commented that she really sings with passion. And she would’ve cried if her daughter sang like that. Get ready, because our 17 month old Kacey is already singing along to some of The Wiggles’ songs! Randy said this song was a very tall order but she gave a great performance. Paula called her range great and that age didn’t matter. If you can sing, you can sing. Simon said she sang it beautifully, but that it was so gloomy. Jordin’s improvement from week to week has been astonishing. Again, I feel bad for her because she could’ve probably won previous years but is really up against it this year with Melinda and LaKisha blocking her way. So far AI has been a showcase for her obvious talent though. She’ll be fine after this is over.

08 – Sanjaya, You Really Got Me (The Kinks)

I don’t know what to say about this performance. He kinda looked like Milli. Or was it Vanilli? But they kept showing that poor girl Ashley who was crying throughout the performance. It was like a ‘60s Beatles performance where the girls were crying in the audience because they were so in awe of the music. Or who knows why they were crying. Maybe Ashley was crying because Sanjaya is so bad. Maybe she was crying because Sanjaya’s still in the competition and thinks it’s cruel because he really thinks he belongs. Maybe she was crying because Sanjaya still being in the competition is just a big joke and he’s the only one not in on it. You had to love the “Team Sanjaya” shirts that his family was wearing though. Although they were pretty tight shirts and his sister’s shirt had “Team” on it and I think “Sanjaya” was underneath that but it was kinda hidden. His mom’s shirt saying “momjaya” was pretty clever. Randy praised him for coming out of his shell. I can’t remember what Paula said. And Simon wisely deferred and only commented that the little girl’s (Ashley) face says it all. Seriously though, is there enough money out there to pay for all the therapy Ashley will need after she gets teased tomorrow at school? The sad part is that they showed her crying in Melinda’s performance too. She may have cried for every singer but the producers only chose to show us her crying for Sanjaya. He is brutal. But I’m not going to do anything irrational like I’ve heard many of you say you’re going to do (ie, quit watching the show because he’s still on). Sanjaya happens every year (Kevin Covais, John Stevens). Someone always lasts longer than he should. But usually that person doesn’t win. And usually that person lasts longer than others but those people wouldn’t have won either. So, please keep watching and either take a break when Sanjaya is singing or just laugh. He may be in the bottom 3 tomorrow, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he made it through again.

09 – Gina, Paint It Black (The Rolling Stones)

Gina came out in the ‘80s inspired Pat Benetar shirt tonight. And it looks like she got a haircut. I think she looks like someone. Marlo Thomas, maybe? And what was up with the cut aways to Forest Whitaker on the drums? Randy said he still likes the edge and the vibe but it was just a’ight for him. Paula called it miles better than last week. Simon crushed her by saying there were moments of complete torture and that it was style over content. My wife added that her pitch problems happened because she doesn’t have a strong enough voice to accommodate movement when she’s singing and gets out of breath at times. Gina may be on the bubble tomorrow night, but I think she should be okay. She’s reaching the point where she is going to be outclassed vocally soon though.

10 – Chris Sligh, She’s Not There (The Zombies)

Chris came out through the crowd tonight, reminiscent of when a football team enters the stadium through the student section. That’s usually a motivation thing for a big game. He didn’t really get it right because he wasn’t interacting with the crowd and that came across to the judges. But then he mentioned that he was worried about the camera and not tripping because he’s chubby. Then gave that hearty laugh, which I’m a big fan of. Liked his paisley shirt tonight and was glad he rocked the glasses again. Last week when he didn’t wear the glasses he looked like a Care Bear, with the big chubby face and tiny eyes. The direct opposite of Japanese cartoons where the eyes are so big (and so opposite of real Japanese people’s eyes!). Loved the Fro Patro signs. Randy called it like a concert. Paula wished her worked the audience more. Simon called it a good choice of song and a lot better than last week. I think Chris is safe tomorrow and should be in the final 2 guys with Blake. Where that leaves them I have no idea. Maybe 4th and 5th?

11- Melinda, As Long As He Needs Me (Shirley Bassey)

A third Shirley Bassey song. I’m embarrassed to admit that I have no idea who Shirley Bassey is. I Googled her and found out that she had two James Bond songs (Diamonds Are Forever and Moonraker). And was born to a Nigerian father (a seaman) and English mother. And she’s a Dame. They showed Ashley crying again during this performance. Nice work, FOX. Randy said they saved the best vocal for last. Paula called her in her own league. Simon said it was very boring to start but the second part was absolutely sensational with impeccable vocals. And he asked if she’s really this nice. I haven’t hidden my feelings for Melinda. She’s my American Idol 6. I’ll be very surprised if she doesn’t win.

All in all, probably the best night yet, with some very strong performances and no real stinkers (well, my wife reminded me of Sanjaya, but I think I’ve blocked it out from my memory already). I voted for Blake, Jordin, Sligh and Melinda tonight.

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

AIVI recap, Finalists x 12 (03/13)

These first few recaps are tough. Two hours is a lot of singing when the singers aren’t all good. Seacrest comes out in a 3 piece suit, but it’s grey with earth tones for the shirt and tie. Did Al Davis dress him?

Tonight is the music and career of Diana Ross, who also serves as the guest mentor. As they are showing her old pics, she looked a lot like Michael Jackson, if he stayed black and kept his original nose. She mentioned in the intro that she felt like a parent to these kids and I wondered if she had kids. Little did I know that she had 5, one of them being a “Love Child” with Berry Gordy (actress Rhonda Ross Kendrick). Actress Tracee Ellis Ross (“Girlfriends”) is also her daughter.

Okay onto the singers. And I put their pre-show odds to win it all, courtesy of sportsbook.com (yes, you can bet on this; I won on Taylor Hicks last year at 5 to 1).

01 – Brandon, You Can’t Hurry Love (40-1)

Loved his paint pallet shirt. Must’ve shopped at Sherman Williams this week. I think he has a good voice, but he has no real charisma. And he forgot the words!! If this was Hollywood, he would have been immediately excused. Randy said he reverted back to a background singer, but his last 2 notes were good. Paula said it’s not easy and nerves play a big part of it. She didn’t want to focus on what he did wrong (forgetting the words), but the many things he does right. Simon called it a complete letdown, a predictable arrangement and he has no star quality. I like Brandon but I agree with Simon. He belongs in the background. Melinda has overcome those 10 feet to become a lead singer. He belongs 10 feet back singing backup.

02 – Melinda, Home (3-2)

Okay, I’ve discussed who she looks like and Jayna Nakashima said that she looks like D.W., Arthur’s sister (it’s a kids’ cartoon). I’m going one step further by saying she looks like her, but with Dorothy the Dinosaur’s body (no neck, hardly a torso). Diana said she gave her goose bumps when she sang. Melinda did wear a classy silver dress tonight, but her belt was at her bustline and it accentuated her short torso. Funny looking notwithstanding, Melinda is still my favorite. Great voice. Great story (being the meek, timid background singer). I don’t think she’s as timid as they’re playing her up to be, but I’m still one of her biggest fans. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite performance for her, but she was still real, real strong. Melinda’s performance and ensuing tears when she heard the crowd roar made Paula cry too. Simon asked her why she was crying and Melinda replied that she’s never heard such a noise for her. She can’t fake that. I was moved. Didn’t cry, but I felt the emotion. Simon went on to say that she made a very boring song fantastic. Called her a young Gladys Knight. Paula described her feelings as an out of body experience. I really, really like Melinda. I hope she wins, but she’s already won. There is a recording contract for her whether it comes from American Idol or some other producer.

03 – Chris Sligh, Endless Love (6-1)

Chris said that he and Diana had similar hair. That was funny. When he went over his arrangement with her, you could tell she didn’t like it (but she didn’t shoot it down like Queen did to Ace last year). She told him to find the melody and hold on to it. He came out sans the glasses and it looked kinda weird with his beady little eyes among all the hair. His version sounded like a fast remix of a slow song. Christina Aguilera has a fast version of “Reflection” that this reminded me of. And it also had a Coldplay vibe to it (not that I’m really current enough to know Coldplay). It was a weird remix, but I still think that Chris has a smoove voice. Randy bagged on the Coldplay copycat and called it a mess. Paula said he had to worry about trying ultra hard to be ultra hip. Simon said he murdered the arrangement and that even the boos were light. It was odd because this song is supposed to be a love song, yet he sang it without a lot of emotion. The guys are in an odd place, especially Sligh and Blake because they have to make songs their own, but they run a fine line between making it their own and butchering the original. Sometimes the judges send mixed signals. Sometimes it’s you didn’t make it your own. Other times is it doesn’t matter how you sing it, just sing it well. Whatever. Chris should be safe tomorrow.

04 – Gina, Love Child (25-1)

As I mentioned before this song was in reference to the “love child” that Diana had with Berry Gordy (who also is the father of Rockwell, nice ‘80s reference). What was Gina wearing tonight? What was up with those pants? They weren’t jeans, right? Were they leather? Or pleather? What was up with that tribal necklace? Did she miss some notes? I still like Gina though. She’s not going to win, but she deserves to stay longer than most of the guys and Haley. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite performance, that there was no excitement. Paula said she’s much better than how she did tonight. Simon said he can’t say much about it. It wasn’t terrible, but it also wasn’t fantastic. He liked that she stayed in her image, but it was a forgettable, middle of the pack performance. Middle of the pack should keep her around to next week though.

05 – Sanjaya, Ain’t No Mountain High Enough (30-1)

Is he still in this competition? Well, www.votefortheworst.com has adopted him as their poster boy and I guess Howard Stern was urging his listeners to vote for him tonight to keep him in the competition. And DialIdol.com has him currently in 3rd. I don’t think he’s leaving us tomorrow. With his hair like it was tonight, he kinda looked like Mario Van Peeples. My buddy Leroy thought he looked like Stoney Jackson from the Beat It video. I thought they were going “boy, girl, boy, girl,” but I guess they broke the pattern here. Poor Sanjaya. He has such a weak, timid voice. Seriously, what did they see in him to put him through? I think the Stepmom version of this song was better than his. Randy didn’t even know what to say. It wasn’t very good and thank god for the background singers. They really overshadowed him. How bad is that? Paula said he had the sweetest soul and he sang on pitch, but he needs to grab the audience. And she added that he looked adorable. How insightful! That’s why she makes the big bucks. Simon said Diana was going to freak when she heard that. But he was nice and said he’s brave. Unfortunately, we’ll probably have to put up with him for another week or so. Jim Rutter said it wouldn’t surprise him if Jacko and Eldra “El” DeBarge had spent some time together at Neverland Ranch, with Sanjaya as a result. And Jim also has WAY too much knowledge of El DeBarge songs. But then again, I probably know way too much about The Jets too…

06 – Haley, Missing You (100-1)

I can’t believe that Haley is still in and Sabrina is out. Haley reminds me a bit of Rachel Ray, but not really. And I’ve heard this from a few people but Haley reminded them of a darker Gloria Estefan. What was up with the bottom of her dress tonight? Was it a sash that fell? And how could you not notice the Dream Catcher earrings? She was a mess tonight. She forgot the words. She broke down when the judges gave their comments. She really reminds me of a cabaret/wedding singer. Can you tell she’s not my fave? Randy said she gave it a valiant effort but the pitch was all over the place. Paula started out by saying she looked lovely (kiss of death), but she forgot her words and the pitch was not good. She was about to breakdown and Simon said that he didn’t think it was that bad. And that she had a real presence up there. Honestly, I think he did what he claims he never does and that was to patronize her. Had he really given it to her like she deserved, she would’ve broken down and cried. I think she’s awful. I hope she’s gone tomorrow, but I’ll let suffer through another week of her if it means Sanjaya is gone.

07 – Phil, I’m Gonna Make You Love Me (40-1)

My wife calls him Stacey Phil, as in close your eyes when he sings and you’ll imagine a woman with a husky voice (like Cher). June Yasuhara called him Pee Wee Herman (it’s the eyes). His skull is shaped like ex-Warrior Tyrone Hill, who incidentally, was unofficially named to the all-ugly NBA team (along with Sam Cassell, Nick Van Exel, Popeye Jones and Gheorghe Muresan, although the Muresan was a cheap shot because he suffered from a pituitary disorder (I think it was termed Gigantism and was the same condition that Andre the Giant had)). Imagine if Tyrone Hill played Powder. Now you see Phil Stacey. Randy called his performance boring, but his vocals were hot. Paula said he needed to be more uptempo but the vocals were strong. Simon thought he chose the right tempo and that it was just OK. He has a tendency to shout his words, but he was better than last week. I don’t think Simon likes Phil. One last shot at Phil. He reminds me of a mannequin. Especially those creepy ones at Marshall Fields in Chicago. No one may relate to that, but I had to get it off my chest.

08 – LaKisha (Kiki), God Bless The Child (5-2)

My wife calls her voice Nell Carter-ish. I can’t get “Gimme a break, I sure deserve it” out of my mind now. I don’t have much to say about LaKisha. I think she’s in a two-horse race with Melinda, but my allegiance is to Melinda, so I’m biased. I wouldn’t be angry if LaKisha won over Melinda. I don’t think LaKisha will win, but I do think she’ll also get a recording contract when it’s all said and done. Randy called it the perfect song choice. It was an unbelievable vocal, she didn’t overdo it and it was sensational. Paula called her a beautiful performer and her heart really comes through when she performs. Simon said you’ve either got it or you don’t, and she’s got it. Said her and Melinda are in a league of their own. If it’s not those 2 in the finale, something is wrong.

09 – Blake, You Keep Me Hanging On (6-1)

What was up with Blake’s get up tonight? He looked like Taco, doing Puttin’ On The Ritz. He was just missing the top hat and cane. The strobe lights were really bugging me during his performance. Liked the popping and locking. He must’ve bought that VHS of Darrin’s Dance Grooves (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0301152/). I think Blake looks like Steve Zahn (Lenny in “That Thing You Do!”). Randy told him to not worry about Blake-izing every song. Let the classics be the classics. That’s tough advice though, as I explained before. Paula said that he could have a hit with that version. Simon didn’t get it at all. He didn’t sound as good as we’ve heard him before, but he’ll be fine. I think he tried thinking out of the box and it didn’t work out that well this week. At least he’s popular and will probably be safe to show us his brilliance once again. I think it’s between him and Chris Sligh to be the last guy standing, but it may be for 4th place.

10 – Stephanie, Love Hangover (10-1)

Diana said that she had star quality. She wore a funky paisley dress that kinda reminded me of a kimono, but not really. Performance was okay but it she didn’t really nail it. The judges commented on that. Randy said that she forgot the words, but it was a perfect choice for her. Paula was waiting for the uptempo part but it never came. And that she should strive for better. Simon called it a strange arrangement, like it was a song intro and she didn’t close well. He added that she was totally upstaged by Melinda and LaKisha tonight. She’ll hang around, but she is in danger of eventually being forgotten.

11 – Chris Richardson, The Boss (10-1)

Is it me or does he look like Turtle from Entourage? I don’t really watch that show (we don’t get HBO anymore), but I’ve seen ads. CRich had an odd outfit on tonight, with the white blazer, colored shirt and white tie, with jeans and white shoes. It reminded me of a cruiseship performance. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite performance but the runs he connected on were hot, but half were good and half were bad. Paula said he nailed it, bringing the song up to date and that his vocals were great. Simon called his vocals dreadful. He said take the dance and personality out of it and it was horrible. I’m in between Simon and Paula. I like this guy, but not as much as Blake and Sligh.

12 – Jordin, If We Hold On Together (10-1)

Wore a nice prom dress tonight. I know that I said she looks like Mike Rico’s wife, but tonight she looked like someone else. Then it hit me. Callie O’Malley! From Grey’s Anatomy! Randy was so very impressed with her. Said she made it a 3 girl race. Paula called her a natural gift and a breath of fresh air (she says that a lot and it never means the same thing). Simon called it a little gooey, but he totally agreed that it was a very, very good vocal. I like Jordin a lot but still think she’s not in Melinda and LaKisha’s league. She could eventually jumpfrog Stephanie for third though. And that would be impressive.

I voted for Melinda, Chris Sligh, Blake and Jordin tonight. The bottom 3 should be Sanjaya, Haley and Brandon, but it will probably be Haley, Brandon and Phil or Gina. I think Haley or Brandon will be gone.

Until next week. And I appreciate comments back, so keep ‘em coming or start sending them back. Like last year, I’m posting these on Blogger.com again (http://airecaps.blogspot.com/). Feel free to pass along the e-mails or direct others to the blog. Everything for the last few years is posted on the website. And I apologize for any grammatical mistakes, as my wife is not here (she’s in Hawaii for work) to proofread.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

AIVI recap, Semi-Finalists, Gals x 8 (03/07)

Seacrest keeps plugging the “most important, ground breaking Idol project yet.” I think they’re having a songwriting contest for the winner to sing. How groundbreaking. Not.

Let’s get into it.

01 – Jordin Sparks, Heartbreaker (Pat Benetar)

Her “secret” is that she loves football. No, really? Let’s see. Her dad played at ASU and in the NFL. She lives in Glendale, AZ which is home to the Cardinals and the BCS Championship game. I bet her brother wishes that he had her size. Jordin really started the night off well. It was a fun, snappy tune. Nice twist on the Pat Benetar standard. Randy started off by saying it was such a different show when the women go. Called her song hot. Interjecting here, I think that the producers are probably kicking themselves for making this format bring out 6 guys and 6 girls. If they performed together, or were mixed I’d imagine that it might be 8 girls and 4 guys. Although it’s probably gonna be Melinda and LaKisha in a dead heat, Ruben vs. Clay style. Paula loved her energy and said she’s getting better each week. Simon was not as enthusiastic as the others and called the song manic and shrieky (I know it’s not a word, but I’m doing my best to spell it) in parts. Said it wasn’t her strongest performance but 100% deserves to be here next week. I agree. I like her. She should be safe tomorrow night, but the fact that Antonella seems bulletproof means probably Jordin, Gina or Sabrina will go home tomorrow (along with Haley).

02 – Sabrina Sloan, Don’t Let Go (En Vogue)

Her surprise is that she wanted to be the next Katie Couric. Her old videos don’t even look like her. Maybe it was her hair being jet black, but she looked darker in those videos too. It’s almost like she did a Michael Jackson lighten the skin job. Is that her original nose too? She’s a very pretty girl though and wore one of those purposely wrinkled dresses. My wife has a shirt like that. It’s great for traveling because they fold down to like a 3” by 3” square. And they can be dressy. Sabrina shows off her big voice tonight. Did a little dancing during the song too. Randy said it wasn’t his favorite performance, but it was still solid. Paula said the one thing consistent about her is that she can sing. Simon said her performance was lacking emotion and came off as a little robotic. Called it a hotel/resort performance. I think it was a little better than that. The interesting thing is that DialIdol.com (http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp) has her in the bottom 2 (along with Haley). I think it would be a shame if she got voted off in favor of Antonella staying.

03 – Antonella Barba, Put Your Records On (Corinne Bailey Rae)

What we didn’t know about Antonella is that she has played the violin since she was 5 and still teaches it when she comes home from school for summer. I don’t really know Corinne Bailey Rae that well, other than I’ve seen her CD at Starbucks. Is that really good for your career? To have your CD at Starbucks? Just asking. Antonella came out in a black jumpsuit/dress thing with big boots. She looked like a fembot from Austin Powers. Or a stylish flight attendant. You choose. I’ve noticed that Antonella has a fast vibrato that wasn’t really evident in her auditions. Although it could be the nerves at this point. How nervous would you be if you sucked in front of 30+ million people each week? Randy called it still pitchy and an okay performance. Paula called it the right song choice and heard the magic in the higher range. Simon broke it down real simple. She’s gone as far as she can go. He just wishes she could sing better. Don’t we all? Although Antonella’s attitude really puts me off. She seems bored and apathetic at times. Very self-absorbed. She should be gone tomorrow, but then again, she should’ve been history the last 2 weeks, based on performance.

04 – Haley Scarnato, If My Heart Had Wings (Faith Hill)

Haley reveals that she was a gymnast in her youth. I wonder if she had to sleep in a little box to keep her from growing, like how they torture those young calves in order to make veal? What’s funny about gymnasts is that their height is all relative. When you’re watching the Olympics, you see one gymnast who towers over the others, but in actuality, she’s 5’2”. The reverse is true with basketball players. Someone once asked me in my years at the Bulls if I was surprised at how big any one player was. My answer was the opposite. I was surprised to see how big Steve Kerr was. He used to look puny on TV, but seeing him in real life, I realized that he’s still 6’3”. Speaking of the Bulls, Haley looked like a Luvabull (Bulls’ dance team) tonight with her red top and black pants. Randy thought it was an interesting song choice. He was not jumping up and down. The song had no pizzazz. No “yo.” Paula said it wasn’t her favorite song, but she sang it well and looked good (Paula’s kiss of death). Simon called it just horrible. He called it very high school musical (but I take offense to that because High School Musical had better numbers and singers) and piled on by saying that he didn’t even know her name. Poor Haley didn’t take the criticism well. I think that she’s very cabaret and if she’s not going home tomorrow, I’ll be very shocked.

05 – Stephanie Edwards, Sweet Thing (Rufus and Chaka)

What we didn’t know about her is that when she was growing up, she would only perform in front of her parents. I like this song, but I remember it more from Mary J. Blige than from Chaka. Stephanie’s dress was nice, but it looked like a jersey from NFL Europe. In addition to looking like Tisha Campbell, my wife also thinks she looks like a cross between LaToya London and Fantasia. Randy gave her an A for a valiant effort, but when he hears that song, he hears Chaka and it’s hard to compare to that. Paula called her darn near flawless, but then contradicted herself (when does she not?) by warning her to watch falling behind the music. Simon called her one of the best, but said she has a tendency to copycat. I feel bad for Stephanie because I think that she is very talented but it really is a two-horse race right now. If Stephanie was in a different year, she could probably win. DialIdol has her in the bottom 3. Based on her performances and talent she should be safe tomorrow, but you never know.

06 – LaKisha Jones, I Have Nothing (Whitney Houston)

LaKisha is terrified of animals. But she’s not terrified of singing Whitney songs. She’s got a huge voice and she sang effortlessly tonight. Came out in a simple black dress. Came off as classy, compared to her salmon mishap last week. This song in particular is an interesting song because I think it was originally done by Dolly Parton. And I think it was playing in the background during the movie (The Bodyguard, not to be confused with My Bodyguard starring Christopher Makepeace, who also “starred” in Meatballs). Dolly’s song and Whitney’s interpretation are completely different. You wouldn’t even know it was the same song. Randy said it wasn’t her best, but it was another great performance. Paula said she’s already made us love her and she just needs to work on becoming the next American Idol. Simon lauded her passion, talent and believability. And also added that she looked beautiful tonight. She’s safe.

07 – Gina Glocksen, Call Me When You’re Sober (Amy Lee and Evanescence)

She let us in on her lucky charms (troll, pickle and pillow). She really played up the rocker chick tonight, which really hasn’t been represented in the competition since Ryan Starr in season one. Randy said there were some pitch problems, but finally saw the real Gina. Paula said it was more who she imagined her being but be careful to not oversing, but the style suits her the best. Simon noted that it was the first time she looked comfortable up there. She tended to scream a bit but called her a breath of fresh air. I like her. The contest needs her to be in the final 12. And she will outlast a few of the guys if she makes the final 12. I really think that Gina is playing with the house’s money at this point. I think she knows she can’t win but wants to stay as long as America lets her. DialIdol has her in 3rd, so hopefully she’s still around after tomorrow.

08 – Melinda Doolittle, I’m A Woman (Peggy Lee)

We learn that she’s a bit OCD, having to give equality to things she does (step on a crack with one foot, need to also do it with the other, etc). Chris Jackson (also known as Mahmoud Abdul Rauf in the NBA) was famous (or was it infamous) for playing with Tourette’s Syndrome and also for not facing the American flag during the National Anthem (he reasoned that the flag stood for tyranny), but I remember reading an article about him once that highlighted his OCD too. Like how he would have to do things perfectly before he could move on to something else. His shirt needed to be tucked in the right way. He had to make free throws without hitting the rim and swishing through just right to make the right snapping sound. I think he shot over 95% from the free throw line one season. Back to Melinda. How good is she? I love how she walked down the stage today to give props to the background singers too. I’ll be very disappointed if she doesn’t win this thing. LaKisha will give her a good fight, but I think Melinda will be the runaway winner. Randy called it the hottest one of the night and added that she’s a consummate pro. Paula asked her if she ever thought she’d be up on that stage getting the adulation of the masses. Simon called her a little tiger, because he thought she was a pussycat. He noted that he could tell that she was actually enjoying every moment of the competition. She’s my favorite to win it all.

I think Haley is out for sure. Antonella deserves to be out, but I don’t think she will be. That means either Jordin, Sabrina, Gina or Stephanie will be gone and unfairly so. My guess is that it will be Haley and either Sabrina or Stephanie.

AIVI recap, Semi-Finalists, Guys x 8 (03/06)

I’m glad to be back and I once again thank Mike Rico for doing the recaps while I was on my Pat Riley/Roger Clemens-like sabbatical. You know, let Mike do the heavy lifting when there were 24, then 20 singers and ease my way back in when there are 16 (spread over 2 nights) and then be ready for the final 12. It’s like pre-season football. Play one series and the get the heck out of the game before you get hurt. Just kidding Mike. You did great and I hope you’re still available in a pinch should something come up during the season…

Tonight is “What’s Your Secret” night. Really an odd intro, but I guess it’s fresh. And they can’t do theme nights until they get to the final 12, so I guess they get a pass.

01 – Blake Lewis, All Mixed Up (311)

Blake’s thing America probably didn’t know was that he loves improv comedy. Although his fictional character didn’t really bowl me over. I don’t really know 311, but I did see them in concert once in Chicago. There was some kind of Wicked Tour and they had a ton of bands play at the United Center. Concert went on all day because 311 was there along with Chumbawamba (Tub Thumping), Everclear (before they sold out to make movie songs), Sarah McLachlan (she was an odd fit because her songs are so depressing), Duran Duran (they just had Ordinary World out) and the headliner was The Cure. Anyway, back to Blake. Wore a shirt with a skull on it and it showed his forearms which were all tatted up. Got to beatbox a little. Not familiar with the song, but I still enjoy his performances. Randy said he likes him because this is the first year that the singers are singing current songs and he loved it. Paula didn’t know the song, but she was interested in it (which was a good thing). Simon laughed that he didn’t understand a single word that he sang, but gave him props for keeping it current. Blake should be safe for Thursday. He’s original. He’s hip. He’s got that beatbox thing. People like him. I like him. Blake Lewis Can’t Lose.

02 – Sanjaya Malakar, Waiting On The World To Change (John Mayer)

Sanjaya started out saying that people might be surprised to know that he can dance hula. I was about as surprised as I was to learn that the kid from “Who’s The Boss?” came out of the closet. You mean you weren’t already out? Sanjaya came out, I’m guessing as a tribute to his sister, with straightened hair. Seriously, he looked like one of the Milli Vanilli guys. Rob or Fab? Or does it matter? And is one of them dead now? I always thought that a Milli Vanilli night would be funny. The contestant would sing off stage and Milli Vanilli would lip sync them on stage. Maybe not. And were those caterpillars or eyebrows above Sanjaya’s eyes? I still like the kid and think he has a soothing voice, but he’s so darn boring. Randy said that he was special the first time they saw him but he has yet to show that again. My question is, then why did they put him through to the final 24? Paula said there is still a sincerity in his voice, but he needs to raise his game. Simon said he was not as ghastly as last week, but it was not a good vocal. Then wondered aloud about his Paula hair style. Seacrest was kinda funny when he bagged on Paula’s hair extensions. Sanjaya really must go at this point. He probably should’ve gone in favor of AJ last week. But then again, the guys are so weak right now I don’t really care if he stays over any of the other ones. It’s pretty much assured that a girl is going to win this year.

03 – Sundance Head, Jeremy (Pearl Jam)

Sundance had a little fun with the secret thing, saying that he’s thin in real life but puts on the fat suit to sing so that America won’t recognize him in public as he’s thin. He looked like he was dressed by Randy Jackson tonight, with the big button down shirt, opened down to the navel. Sported the Mohawk a la Blake too. What annoyed me was the “thank you” at the end of the song. It wasn’t “than kew” like Paris last year, but the fact that he was thanking the crowd for their obligatory applause was kind of annoying. Randy like his southern rock on a Pearl Jam song. Paula said midway through the song his Sundance kicked in (does that mean he sucked in the beginning?). Simon didn’t like it as much as last week. Called it indulgent and like a generic bar singer. I did think he was shouting at times during the song. What really amazes me is how short Sundance is. Seacrest towers over him. He must be like 5’3” and 275 pounds.

04 – Chris Richardson, Tonight I Wanna Cry (Keith Urban)

C-Rich’s revelation is that he was 40 pounds heavier in college and played football. Isn’t Google a great thing? I Googled “Chris Richardson football” and found out that he played at Christopher Newport University in Newport News, VA and played QB and LB. They showed his number as 22 and I was thinking that he was a RB (Emmitt Smith wore #22) or defensive back. But in the back of my mind I knew that Doug Flutie wore #22 at Boston College (then in the NFL, short for the No Fun League, he had to change to #2 because QBs can only wear numbers 1-19). So anyway, Chris was good tonight. I didn’t know the song, but I thought he pulled it off. Randy said he put his own twist on the Keith Urban (who I hear is a country hottie) song and that he’s in it to win it. Paula said he picked a great song and adapted it well. Simon said it was good, but he was not jumping out of his chair. He also called it cutesy, but that he sold it. I like C-Rich. He should be bulletproof on Thursday.

05 – Jared Cotter, If You Really Love Me (Stevie Wonder)

Jared’s secret is that he played DII hoops in college. See, I knew he looked like a baller. He played at Five Towns College in Long Island. His intro showed him missing a dunk on the playground. I think he kinda looks like Carlos Boozer, but better looking. Jared came out with an argyle sweater, an homage to Kobe Bryant, who may have gotten that look from Motownphilly BoyzIIMen. I really like Jared, even though he mugs to the camera like Constantine. But it’s WAY less irritating. Randy worried when he heard he was doing a Stevie joint, but said it was real good. Paula wanted him to color up the way he sings (Paula critical? And of a good looking guy nonetheless? Is hell freezing over?). Simon called it not original, but said he’s popular so he should be safe. He was disappointed, because there was no wow factor. I think Jared is safe on Thursday, but I may be wrong.

06 – Brandon Rogers, I Just Want To Celebrate (Rare Earth)

Brandon’s secret is that he’s a classically trained piano player. I thought this song was by Lenny Kravitz, but I was wrong. Brandon came out with a white Member’s Only-type jacket and also a white belt, fashionable on the PGA Tour right now, most notably by Jesper Parnevik and Aaron Baddeley. Randy thought it was solid, but messed up at the end. Paula called it phenomenal (there we go, she’s back not making sense). Simon said he didn’t represent himself well and that he’s nervous for him on Thursday. I think Simon likes Brandon and thinks he’s a talented singer, but his song choices so far have been poor. I think he’s vulnerable on Thursday.

07 – Phil Stacey, I Need You (LeAnn Rimes)

Phil’s “bet you didn’t know” was that he had hair before. Long hair. He’d probably look less menacing with hair. Had a real odd look today. Like he was going to the race track. Hey, who do you like in the fourth? The five horse? There was a movie called “Let It Ride” that starred Richard Dreyfuss. He is a degenerate gambler whose wife (Terri Garr) is on the verge of leaving him because he wastes all his time and money at the track. He finally has a day every gambler dreams of where he hits every race and “lets it ride” on every ensuing race. He wins a bundle. Kinda funny movie. Robbie Coltrane (Hagrid in the Harry Potter movies) has a small part too. Back to Phil. Didn’t think it was that good tonight. Odd song choice and not a great vocal. Randy called it an interesting song choice and that he reminds him of Steve Perry (Randy had to get a name drop in there), but that he was pitchy in his lower register. Which reminds me of Steve Perry. How could he be so successful as the voice of Journey, then just flop as a solo artist? The only hits that I remember him having was Oh Sherrie and Foolish Heart, which can be mistaken for each other at times. I guess it’s happened before (artists not making it solo), but whouda known? Paula called it an odd song choice and that his lower part of register was not good. Simon didn’t get it at all. I think Phil may be in danger on Thursday.

08 – Chris Sligh, Wanna Be Loved (DC Talk)

Said he had short hair for a very long time, then went on to say that it’s his real hair and not a perm. I hear that the song is from a Christian pop band. Not really familiar with it. But I think that he has a real nice voice to listen to. My only problem with him is that he sings songs that not everyone knows and I think that you run the risk of people not connecting with it. That being said, I still think he’s a shoe-in for the final 12. Randy said that although it was not his favorite song choice, he still got the vocal prize for the night. Paula said it wasn’t her favorite performance. Simon said he still has a lot of potential. I think that Chris is a very funny guy and his singing is pretty good too. I think that he will be in the final 3 guys with Blake and Chris Richardson, but none of the 3 compare to Melinda, LaKisha and Stephanie.

As an aside, I jeard today that Jenry got stagefrigjt in Jollywood and got booted. He vowed to come back strong next year and re-audition tjougj. Looking forward to tjat, as are most of the females watcjing. I’d say tjis is the last Jenry mention, but I can’t do tjat. If tjere is anytjing consistent about these recaps, it’s tjat I love to beat a dead jorse.

So, based on performance, Sanjaya and Phil should go, but realistically, it could be Brandon and Phil. I’m still not impressed with Sundance either. I think that Chris x 2 and Blake are safe and Jared is probably safe, but I’ve been wrong before.